Wheelchair user misses train and branded ‘rude' by station staff after they refused to get ramp
Anna Landre, 26, had planned to travel to Cambridge from London Liverpool Street on Sunday, but was forced to cancel her plans when station staff were 'too busy' to help her on the train.
She arrived at the station 15 minutes before her train was set to leave at 11am and went to the information desk to let them know which train she was getting and that she would need a ramp.
'Some stations are excellent, and you can arrive like any other non-disabled person five minutes before the train and they're happy, whereas others look at you and say, no, you're not here 30 minutes before, and won't even try,' the PhD student told the Independent.
It got to five minutes before her train was scheduled to leave, and she was told the staff were 'really busy' and would not be able to help her.
Ms Landre remained hopeful that platform or onboard staff would be able to help. However, she was told they did not have any ramp keys and could not assist her.
When a member of staff from Liverpool Street Station eventually arrived to help her, it was too late and she missed the train.
Frustrated, but still hopeful she could get the next train in 30 minutes, Ms Landre went back to the desk to request assistance again.
Passengers with a disability can book assistance before they travel – like buying a ticket in advance, but this fails around a quarter of the time, Caroline Stickland, CEO of Transport for All explained.
An alternative is 'Turn Up and Go', which allows people to simply arrive at the station and ask for assistance.
'Turn Up and Go can be piecemeal. Only 11 per cent of stations are staffed all the time, which can make turning up and going quite challenging,' Ms Stickland added.
A few minutes after Ms Landre missed her train, a member of staff came over to ask if she had pre-booked assistance.
'I explained that I have the right to turn up and go, but he kept explaining that they were very busy and have to help people who are booked first,' Ms Landre said.
'I told him, I know my rights. I know the law. I don't need a lecture on it. He just kept going and I said it again. I'm just waiting for the next train, and he really didn't like that and said I was rude, and he would not help me.'
The member of staff went to his manager, who then told Ms Landre she understood she was rude to a member of staff and was frustrated.
Although Ms Landre agreed that she was frustrated for missing a train, she did not believe she was rude.
Minutes later another manager stepped in with two security guards and Ms Landre claims she was told they would not be providing assistance to her, leaving Ms Landre no option but to cancel her plans and go home.
A Network Rail spokesperson said: 'We are really sorry that Ms Landre had this experience when using our station.
'Our director for the Anglia region, which includes responsibility for Liverpool Street station, spoke with Ms Landre this morning and personally apologised for her experience.
'Our aim is to provide a positive experience for each and every passenger and she should never have been denied assistance to board a train and we know we let her down.'
Network Rail will now be launching an investigation into what went wrong but for Ms Landre, the ordeal has left her feeling anxious to travel.
'I think for most wheelchair users traveling is very anxiety-inducing because the system fails us so frequently. Then we're painted as the irrational, anxious or unreasonable ones for reacting in a very rational way,' she said.
Ms Landre explained she avoids taking trains to work or university because the 'Turn Up and Go' system is 'unreliable'.
'It's such an overlying just burden and cloud over a life that is already challenging because of the additional logistics necessary to live in an inaccessible world,' she said.
Ms Stickland said: 'We all want the freedom to travel when we need to, but disabled people are often blocked from that by inaccessible stations and information.
'We hear about horrific experiences like Anna's every single day, but they are not recorded anywhere official.
'Companies have targets around leaves on the line or how many minutes late trains are, but nobody's measuring how often disabled people are stranded - we are erased from the data.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
42 minutes ago
- BBC News
'Bus fares eat my budget': Under-22s join call for free travel
Young people have told the BBC the "extortionate" cost of bus travel in England means they socialise less and struggle to pay rent. A report by MPs has recommended everyone under the age of 22 should get free bus travel to help them get into work and education - similar to in Department for Transport says it is already spending "£1bn in multi-year funding to improve the reliability and frequency of bus services across the country".But the BBC has heard from people aged 22 and under who say bus fares are too expensive and eat into their food budget. 'I get hungry at college but can't afford snacks' Maisy Moazzenkivi, 18, lives in Coventry with her mum, dad and brother, and travels almost two hours each way to get to college, four days a has a disability bus pass because of her autism, meaning she pays less for travel than her friends. However, she still spends £8 a day on getting to college as her free travel allowance only kicks in after 09:30, half an hour after she needs to be says money she spends on travel eats into what she would otherwise spend on food and snacks throughout the day. "Sometimes, when I finish college I'm really hungry and just want to get a meal deal or something for the way home, but it's so expensive on top of everything. I'm very lucky that I can go home and my family can feed me, but not everyone has that." If bus travel was free, Maisy says she would be able to socialise more, and save for "luxury items". "I know it doesn't sound like a big deal, or an essential item, but one day, I'd love to save for a Juicy Couture tracksuit," she said. 'I don't understand how it's so extortionate' Gracie Moore, 22, lives in Slough and catches the bus every day to and from work, which costs her £120 a month."For someone who is not earning much more than minimum wage, it's quite a big expenditure," says Gracie who works as an administration assistant for a care home says the high cost of travel for young people makes it difficult to navigate having a job and a social costs are "absolutely" a factor which stop her from moving out from her family home, she says."I have less independence this way, but I'm paying so much less."Gracie previously lived in Madrid, where she enjoyed unlimited travel on bus, train, tube, and tram) for only €8 (£6.90) a month with a young person's travel card. "I don't understand how it's so extortionate here when other countries in Europe subsidise it so well," she says. "I just don't know how the price of transport here can be justified." 'Free bus pass would make a big difference' Originally from Nepal, Nikita Upreti, 20, is an international student studying at University College Birmingham. She says the rising price of travel means it is getting "harder" to pay for her bus pass each month. When Nikita first moved to Birmingham in September 2024, a monthly bus pass with a student discount cost her £49. Now, it costs her £53."The student discount is not helping us anymore," she says. Nikita also works 20 hours a week as a waitress. Despite working the maximum amount of hours her university will allow her to while studying, she still struggles to pay her rent while juggling the rising cost of living. She says that free bus travel "would make a big difference" to her life. "I could spend the money I save on groceries and things that would help my education. It would be really helpful."
The Sun
2 hours ago
- The Sun
Summer trains misery with commuters facing ‘wrong soil' hell after clay under tracks dries up
RAIL commuters face 'wrong soil' hell after clay under tracks dried up so much that trains have to go slow. Services between parts of Essex and London will be hit for two to three months. Similar problems have affected the West Country after the driest spring since 1974. Infrastructure manager Network Rail said it had dropped 12,600 tons of ballast to minimise clay shrinkage on the Essex route in the past year. But this had not been enough to solve the problem. It said speed restrictions had been introduced 'to keep everyone moving safely'. One commuter said: 'I've heard of leaves on the line and the wrong type of snow. "Now the delays are due to the wrong type of soil.' Network Rail Anglia and c2c Railway, which run services across the network, apologised for the disruption. Buses will replace Greater Anglia trains for some late evening journeys on Mondays to Thursdays. Watch the shocking moment cow puts Irish Rail services to a HALT during morning rush 1
BBC News
2 hours ago
- BBC News
Weather checks and cost sees changes to Wales' holiday bookings
"A lot of holidaymakers are waiting now for the weather forecast before deciding whether to go on holiday or not."A growing trend of Brits booking getaways last minute, as well as a rise in people taking shorter breaks, is having a mixed impact on Welsh tourism well as the unpredictable weather, saving money is also thought to be a key factor driving this change in behaviour, as well as wanting to get the most from their time away, according to industry means some, such as campsite owners, are seeing a spike in bookings, but those with holiday let properties said this shift in priorities was hitting them hard. "We have seen it growing in the last decade," said Linda Osti, senior lecturer in tourism at Bangor University."As a society we are moving towards this 'I want to have more', so [we] wait to the last minute to see what's better."She also said this meant people keeping a keen eye on the weather forecast before "deciding whether to go on holiday or not". Adam Owen and his partner Nia Evans, from Caernarfon, are good examples of people doing just that, as well as being part of a growing trend of families choosing to stay local."When the weather's nice we just decide, last moment, to come," explained Adam, while enjoying a few days' break with his three children at Riverside Camping just outside their hometown."Although we're only five minutes from the house, it just feels like a break." Riverside Camping is run by Catherine Hummel and her family, and said last-minute getaways for those on a smaller budget brought a real boost."Longer stays are easier because it's less moving about on the field, comings and goings, but the short, last-minute stays, fill in the gaps."It does bring extra trade and we like seeing local trade as much as people from further afield... so it's a real mix." The British Holiday and Homes Park Association said there had been "a discernible shift away from week-long and fortnight-long holidays which has been evident for the past few years".It added: "However, this perhaps simply reflects the way people now use their leisure time, preferring to take shorter breaks but more of them throughout the year and re-charging their batteries on a more regular basis over the four seasons." said the number of people looking in July for a break during the six-week school holiday was up 23% on Holiday Cottages, which has 23,000 properties across the UK, said the gap between when people book and when they go on holiday had fallen by 8% this year. But this trend is hitting many of those running traditional holiday lets hard, according to the Professional Association of Self-Caterers (PASC) UK."People are now booking much shorter holidays which means they are not filling all the weeks, so you've got dead days that you can't fill in a week," according to Nicky Williamson, its lead policy advisor in Wales."The shorter breaks have as much work in them as a longer break - you're still paying for the change overs, you're still paying for the linen. You've still got the same amount of work for a one-night stay as a seven-night stay."PASC said a growing number of shorter breaks made it harder for holiday let operators to achieve occupancy rates of 182 days over the they do not hit this figure, they face paying extra council tax as owners of a second property or holiday Ms Osti said this change to short break, last-minute holidays was being seen across Europe and only looked likely to grow.
