Metropolitan Police's policy over live facial recognition ‘unlawful'
The Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) has said the UK's biggest police force's rules and safeguards over using the tool 'fall short' and could have a 'chilling effect' on individuals' rights when used at protests.
The concerns come as the Met is set to deploy LFR, which captures people's faces in real-time CCTV cameras, at this year's Notting Hill Carnival over the August bank holiday weekend.
Metropolitan Police commissioner Sir Mark Rowley has already sought to reassure campaign groups that the technology will be used without bias.
The EHRC has been given permission to intervene in an upcoming judicial review over LFR, brought by privacy campaigner Big Brother Watch director Silkie Carlo and anti-knife crime community worker Shaun Thompson.
They are seeking the legal challenge claiming Mr Thompson was 'grossly mistreated' after LFR wrongly identified him as a criminal last year.
EHRC chief executive John Kirkpatrick said the technology, when used responsibly, can help combat serious crime and keep people safe, but the biometric data being processed is 'deeply personal'.
'The law is clear: everyone has the right to privacy, to freedom of expression and to freedom of assembly. These rights are vital for any democratic society,' he said.
'As such, there must be clear rules which guarantee that live facial recognition technology is used only where necessary, proportionate and constrained by appropriate safeguards.
'We believe that the Metropolitan Police's current policy falls short of this standard. The Met, and other forces using this technology, need to ensure they deploy it in ways which are consistent with the law and with human rights.'
The watchdog said it believes the Met's policy is 'unlawful' because it is 'incompatible' with Articles 8, right to privacy, 10, freedom of expression, and 11, freedom of assembly and association of the European Convention on Human Rights.
Big Brother Watch interim director Rebecca Vincent said the involvement of EHRC in the judicial review was hugely welcome in the 'landmark legal challenge'.
'The rapid proliferation of invasive live facial recognition technology without any legislation governing its use is one of the most pressing human rights concerns in the UK today,' she said.
'Live facial recognition surveillance turns our faces into barcodes and makes us a nation of suspects who, as we've seen in Shaun's case, can be falsely accused, grossly mistreated and forced to prove our innocence to authorities.'
'Given this crucial ongoing legal action, the Home Office and police's investment in this dangerous and discriminatory technology is wholly inappropriate and must stop.'
It comes as Home Secretary Yvette Cooper defended plans to expand LFR across the country to catch 'high-harm' offenders last week.
Last month, the Metropolitan Police announced plans to expand its use of the technology across the capital.
Police bosses said LFR will now be used up to 10 times per week across five days, up from the current four times per week across two days.
The Metropolitan Police has been contacted for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
27 minutes ago
- The Sun
‘Beep if you think Starmer's a w***er' sign removed by police after constant honking
POLICE removed a banner saying 'beep if you think Keir Starmer is a w**ker' after constant honking from motorists created a noise nuisance for neighbours. Locals said the sign created the 'loudest dual carriageway in Britain' before a patrolling officer was alerted to it. 2 2 It was put up on the A4 Portway in Bristol on Wednesday, while a second banner read: 'Stop the boats.' Local resident Mike Turner commented: 'It's louder than The Rolling Stones at the moment. "I think it's a sign!' Another wrote: 'Loudest dual carriageway in Britain'. It is understood there were no official noise complaints to the police. There was one call pointing out that the signs were put up. An Avon and Somerset Police spokesman said: 'A patrolling officer was alerted to two signs on overbridges on the busy A4 Portway on Wednesday 20 August. 'Due to the potential they could result in a distraction to drivers, as well as a nuisance to nearby residents, they were removed.'
Daily Mail
27 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Hotels braced for a wave of protests: Up to 30 targeted as residents turn up heat to follow Epping precedent
A wave of protests are set to sweep the country this weekend targeting migrant hotels. Anti-immigration campaigners are looking to ride on the back of this week's landmark judgment that saw the High Court order the removal of migrants from a hotel in Epping, Essex. Protests at up to 30 hotels are believed to be planned as communities seek to replicate the ruling for The Bell Hotel, which, pending an appeal, must be closed within weeks. The hotel had been at the centre of protests after an asylum seeker living there was charged with sexually assaulting a teenage girl, which he denies. Hotels in Cannock, Chichester and Tamworth are among those expected to be targeted by demonstrations, with anti-racism groups already organising counter-protests in 15 locations across the three-day Bank Holiday weekend. They are prepared to turn up tonight in the likes of Bournemouth, Portsmouth, Leicester, Leeds, Orpington, Perth, Aberdeen and Altrincham. Reform UK leader Nigel Farage has used Epping as a rallying cry, saying: 'Let's hold peaceful protests outside hotels and put pressure on councils to go to court to try to get illegal immigrants out.' On Tuesday, a judge granted a temporary injunction against migrants being housed at The Bell Hotel after Epping Forest council argued that it was necessary for 'the safety of nearby residents' and to reduce the threat of 'violent protests'. As it tried, unsuccessfully, to intervene in the case at the eleventh hour, the Home Office argued that granting Epping's application 'runs the risk of acting as an impetus for further violent protests'. The ruling threatens to collapse Labour's asylum system as protesters take to the streets and councils across the country prepare to hit the Home Office with copycat litigation over the use of hotels in their areas. Tory leader Kemi Badenoch has written to all Conservative councils pledging support for any legal action, while Reform UK's leaders have encouraged people to protest at their local asylum hotels. But anti-racism groups have warned the ruling sets a 'dangerous precedent', with Stand Up To Racism saying that it will 'embolden the far-Right to call more protests outside hotels housing refugees'. Labour grandee Lord Falconer urged the Home Office to appeal against the Epping judgment on Thursday as he admitted the ruling 'causes great problems' for the Government. The peer, who served as justice secretary under Sir Tony Blair and as Sir Keir Starmer's shadow attorney general, said it 'gives rise to the expectation that some asylum hotels can be closed'. Lord Falconer said the ruling presents Labour with a 'very troublesome issue, namely does demonstrations outside these hotels lead to it being more likely that they will be closed'. Urging the Government 'very strongly' to appeal, he told Radio 4's Today programme: 'It puts the courts and the politicians in a difficult position. 'There should be clarity on that and the authority in relation to that can only come from the Court of Appeal.' The Home Office still could not say whether or not it plans to appeal on Thursday. But pressure was mounting on the Government as all Tory councillors were sent a draft motion, produced by the Conservative Research Department and the Conservative Councillors' Association, 'strongly urging' them to follow Epping's example. It included instructions on how to influence their local authorities. Stevenage became the latest Labour-run council to say it would consider taking legal action over an asylum hotel in the Hertfordshire borough as the internal revolt grew. The council had already warned a Novotel hotel it must stop housing asylum seekers or face planning enforcement action, and on Thursday said it was 'actively investigating alleged breaches' as it considered legal action similar to Epping's. Ministers were scrambling to find contingency plans to house migrants, with officials looking at houses in multiple occupation (HMOs), empty tower blocks, disused teacher training colleges and old student accommodation as alternatives. The asylum minister, Dame Angela Eagle, told the Commons home affairs committee in June that the Government had shifted its focus from old military barracks to smaller locations such as tower blocks. However, the Guardian reported officials are still considering placing people removed from hotels in the RAF Wethersfield base in Essex and Napier Barracks in Kent. Meanwhile, it was also reported that asylum accommodation contractors working for the Home Office have contacted property specialists, seeking 5,000 residential units in towns and cities to house migrants. But a Government minister could not answer when quizzed on where asylum seekers should go instead of hotels on Thursday. Asked 'where will they go?', schools minister Catherine McKinnell said: 'Well, I mean, that's a big question.'
Times
an hour ago
- Times
Double killer could be deported back to Scotland from US
A double killer is facing deportation back to Scotland after he was detained by agents from America's ICE immigration service. Phillip Harkins, 46, originally from Greenock, shot a man dead with an assault rifle during a botched drug deal in Florida in 1999. After fleeing back to the UK, Harkins then crashed a car into a taxi and killed its 62-year-old passenger, Jean O'Neill, also of Greenock. Harkins was jailed for five years for causing O'Neill's death by dangerous driving, but was extradited to America despite his 14-year court battle against the decision and sent to prison for second-degree murder. He was due to be released from jail next week but was detained just before his release date. US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officials in Florida have revealed he is back in custody and facing a deportation court hearing. This week a source at Florida's justice department said: 'Phillip Harkins is … detained at Baker County detention facility under a court order. He was detained towards the end of his prison sentence.' The ICE agency is a frequent subject of controversy regarding its enforcement practices, particularly involving arrests and deportations. US activists have claimed immigrants at the detention centre where Harkins is being held are experiencing abuse including lack of adequate hygiene and food. Harkins shot 22-year-old Joshua Hayes in the head at close range during a drug deal in Jacksonville, Florida, in 1999. After his arrest for murder, he jumped bail and returned to Greenock to stay with his grandmother Annie Harkins, who has since died. He told her he had returned for a holiday. Despite being a fugitive, he managed to get a job in the accounts department of a Glasgow company. At the time of his arrest in 2003 over O'Neill's death, Scottish police discovered there was an international arrest warrant in his name and alerted the FBI, who began extradition proceedings. Three months after Harkins's release from prison in March 2006, he was rearrested and the home secretary at the time, John Reid, ordered that he be extradited. Harkins then launched a series of appeals that lasted another 11 years. The killer claimed sending him back to face justice in the US would breach his human rights. The case went all the way to the European Court and became the UK's longest ever extradition court battle. The lengthy pre-Brexit legal process angered the prime minister, David Cameron, who said British laws were too often being overturned by unelected judges in Strasbourg. Harkins was finally extradited in 2017 after US prosecutors assured the British authorities they would not seek the death penalty if he was convicted. In 2018 he admitted guilt over the death of Joshua Hayes. He was sentenced to 25 years for second degree murder, with credit for time served dating back to killing O'Neill in 2003. He could be returned to Scotland if Ice succeed in removing him from the US. At the time of Hayes's murder, his mother, Patricia Gallagher, said: 'Josh was my oldest. So, yeah, it's hard. Josh has got grandchildren now but he'll never know. He's got a son that never got a chance to know him.'
