logo
The contrapuntal voice of Africa, Valentin-Yves Mudimbe, has died

The contrapuntal voice of Africa, Valentin-Yves Mudimbe, has died

Mail & Guardian21-05-2025

Valentin-Yves Mudimbe, regarded as the pioneer of postcolonial studies in Africa, never ceased to be a voice of the continent. Photo: Michael Runkel/Robert Harding Heritage/AFP
Modern African discourse did not develop in a vacuum. It developed in a context of contestation. Every African thinker had Europe in the background — West, colonialism, Hegel — a whole European archive of discourse about Africa. When African writers, especially those who were born and subjected to colonialism, try to represent themselves, they have to navigate the pre-existing categories, archive and philosophical and anthropological texts.
So, Léopold Sédar Senghor, writing on Negritude, was in contestation and conversation with the whole tradition of Enlightenment Thought. Chinua Achebe, writing about African culture or writing about the image of Africa or Conrad, was in contestation with ideas of Joseph Conrad in
Heart of Darkness
. Ngugi speaking, about the debate on African language, he is in contestation and conversation with the whole history of denigration of African languages in colonial context.
The intellectual formation of Valentin-Yves Mudimbe, 83, was no different from theirs. Like his peers and predecessors, he was born into, and grew up in the Christian dominated environment where he was trained to be a monk in his homeland, the Democratic Republic of the Congo.
He had been alienated through the colonising mission, which later helped him debunk the colonial system. Later he realises that Christianity is a 'cultural phenomenon that, in Africa, actualises the experience of conflict'. He studied classics in Congo, and did his doctorate in philosophy in Belgium.
Mudimbe is widely regarded as a pioneer of postcolonial studies in Africa. Along with Edward Said, he established a strong hold against the Eurocentric and Western knowledge system. He never ceased to be a voice of Africa, paving the way for the African intellectuals to engage with their own culture while cleaning out built-up assumptions and debris from the gutters.
Mudimbe's seminal work,
The Invention of Africa: Gnosis, Philosophy, and the Order of Knowledge
(1988), garnered significant scholarly attention and placed him alongside Said, whose work inspired subaltern studies.
Both scholars are known for their critiques of Eurocentric discourses and the construction of the 'other'. Their work has had a lasting effect on various fields such as postcolonial studies, African studies and cultural studies.
Mudimbe is preoccupied with the discourse of Africa, and he devoted most of his time to understanding the damages it caused to the continent. His task was not only to challenge the discourse, but to demonstrate and problematise its epistemic foundations. Most importantly, this discourse on Africa is marked by 'incompleteness and inherently biased assumptions'. This discourse of competence is completely based on textual production which is summed up in his own term 'colonial library'.
To Mudimbe, the body of knowledge on Africa is invented by the colonial library and exemplified by primitivist anthropology. Through these primitivist strategies Africa had been denied access into world history or rational domain.
'Colonial Library' as a political project refers to the body of texts and epistemological order which construct Africa as the 'other' and inferior — even more than that, 'a primitive entity'. It is a discursive formation in which a set of representations and texts, thoughts, tropes, concepts, archives and images are foregrounded to generate and to invent Africa.
The main objective of Mudimbe was to Africanise the knowledge system by debunking dichotomies promoted by Western formative discourse or Eurocentrism. His works seek to reconfigure the geography of discourse around Africa, challenging dominant Western narratives and promoting a more nuanced understanding of African identity.
Mudimbe also writes about African images in the paintings and reception of African objects from 15th century to 19th century anthropology. He harshly critiques anthropological discourses for objectifying Africa and perpetuating negative stereotypes. He notes that African images in paintings and the reception of African objects were often distorted, associating Africans with 'savagery' and 'primitiveness'. The tendency was to assimilate the history of native people to a myth.
Mudimbe identifies three stages in the restructuring of Africa as follows. 'Exploitation of land', where colonisers exploited Africa's natural resources; 'domestication of natives', where colonisers imposed their control over African populations; and 'integration of local economic histories', when colonisers integrated African economies into the Western perspective. Because this domesticating system is problematic and characterised by binary oppositions such as traditional versus. modern, oral versus written, agrarian versus urban.
Mudimbe argues that these binary oppositions are misleading and that there is an intermediate space between African tradition and colonial modernity that characterises marginality. This space generates tension between modernity and tradition and is a product of the colonising structure.
Though he borrows from Claude Levi-Strauss and Jean-Paul Sartre, Mudimbe is obsessed with discursive formations and most of his analysis tends to be discursive reading of narratives or ideas. He extensively draws on Michel Foucault's work. Even in his last book in English,
The Scent of the Father,
in which he follows psychoanalysis threads to trace the idea of the 'absent father' in Africa, he brings Foucault into the debate.
He maintains: 'For Africa, to truly escape from the West presupposes an exact appreciation of the price we have to pay to detach ourselves from it; it presupposes knowing to what extent the West, perhaps insidiously, has drawn close to us; it implies a knowledge, in that which permits us to think against the West, of all that remains Western; and a determination of the extent to which our recourse against it is still possibly one of the tricks it directs against us, while it waits for us, immobile and elsewhere.'
Mudimbe warns us about tricky positions that should be taken to be situated on the verge of possessing knowledge. This is an epistemic dilemma all African scholars have to confront.
Mudimbe's work highlights the need for an epistemological paradigm shift to create a new understanding of Africa. The question remains: how can African genesis be created without such a paradigm shift, despite individual efforts?
Ahmet Sait Akcay is a literary critic and African Studies scholar, he is teaching at the Centre for African Studies, University of Cape Town.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Thulani Khumalo is alive, despite claims a Somali syndicate killed him
Thulani Khumalo is alive, despite claims a Somali syndicate killed him

Mail & Guardian

time3 hours ago

  • Mail & Guardian

Thulani Khumalo is alive, despite claims a Somali syndicate killed him

Thulani Khumalo is a South African entrepreneur who operates a spaza shop from his home in Vosloorus. (Facebook) Thulani Khumalo is a South African entrepreneur who operates a spaza shop from his home in Vosloorus. On 3 May last year, Khumalo took to both social and news media to share that his life was in danger, accusing foreign spaza shop owners of attempting to kill him. Around the time of his outcry, accounts known for perpetrating an anti-immigrant narrative online twisted his outcry to proclaim him dead, alleging that he was killed by 'a syndicate of Somalians'. However, as our investigators found, Khumalo is alive, well and 'shocked' at the news of his death, despite doing nothing to dispel the rumours. When Thulani Khumalo took to social media to share how threats were being made on his life, allegedly by foreign spaza shop owners who saw his business as competition, he never imagined that his story would be manipulated to make it seem like he had been killed by 'Somali syndicates' — at least that is what he says. In early May last year, Khumalo shared a message on Facebook, stating that he was being 'hunted down' by a man hired to kill him, all because he tried to be a South African spaza shop owner. Prior to this, Khumalo had posted about how he was trying to Khumalo's message drew widespread support from government officials and the broader public. Political parties, he said, offered him 'protection in terms of security, telling me they would tell the police to patrol this area regularly'. 'They also offered me funding, for example, the MK party, but this never materialised; it was only for that day. Political parties that visited were the ActionSA and the ANC from Ekurhuleni.' The message became popular on X, with some accounts alleging that Khumalo had been killed. Among these are the @Isephara and @joy_zelda accounts, which both stated at different times of the year that Khumalo had been killed by a 'syndicate of Somalians', once on 3 May, about an hour after he claimed that he was being hunted down, and another in August. Both these X accounts regularly post content with anti-foreigner sentiment. Between May and August, Khumalo was interviewed by The X post from the @ISephara account, Khumalo's initial Facebook post and the claim made in August 2024 by @joy_zelda can all be seen here: Speaking to investigative journalist Tabelo Timse, Khumalo alleges that the threats began around March and April last year. This is noteworthy because in March, he posted a picture of himself in what appears to be his spaza shop, including the words ' 'It started when I saw foreign shop owners casually walking up and down the street daily. Some will approach me to ask how much I am willing to sell this shop [for] or how much rent I want. When I refused [to sell or rent], I noticed people hiding down the street at the second school gate,' he said. Khumalo's shop is run out of his garage in a residential area. Hence, in order to verify the threats that he alleges, it would be important to understand the general foot traffic on that street. He added, 'This one time, I saw three guys hiding. Later, I noticed they were walking up the street, so I went inside the house. These three guys robbed someone who looked similar to me — I think I was the target. So, during the robbery, one robber was shot in the foot and he is the one who said they were looking for me. I don't know what happened to that guy.' However, relaying a similar incident to the City Press in June 2024, he claimed that it was his friend who was mistaken for him and shot in the leg. Khumalo says he went to the police but was told to provide proof of the threats before a case could be opened. He never appears to have provided such proof. Khumalo says he had no idea that the threats on Facebook would go viral, despite stating, 'Vosloorus, please make this trend …' He added that he had to deactivate his social media accounts when allegations of his death surfaced. 'I, and those close to me, including my family, never posted anything about my death. We were all shocked when we saw this account posting and my younger brother replied to those posts that I was alive and that this was fake news. But this person just went on and on about my death, even asking for donations,' he said. Khumalo still uses the same Facebook account from which he claimed that he was being hunted down and he has not taken the initiative to clarify the false narrative about his death. He says he sees 'no need' to clarify that he is alive because people can see that he is active on social media. 'This fake news about my death is also putting my life in danger because I am now exposed.' In a country where anti-immigrant sentiment is rife and xenophobic attacks continue to be perpetrated, it is important to clarify when misinformation is being generated and spread, even if the clarification favours a perceived 'enemy'. Khumalo has not been killed by so-called Somalian syndicates. Just as he feared for his safety, he also compromised the safety of competing entrepreneurs, who may have had nothing to do with the threats or his 'death'. Khumalo has missed multiple opportunities to come clean and dispel the rumours about his death — the first when he was interviewed by news media a month after his viral post, and the second which presents itself every time he logs in and posts on his account. Despite not explicitly setting the record straight, criminality against Khumalo cannot be condoned, and we hope that he finds proof to take legal action against those allegedly making threats against his life and business. Tabelo Timse is a freelance journalist and media consultant and a former investigative journalist at the amaBhungane Centre for Investigative Journalism. Yossabel Chetty is a Researcher at the .

'You are rude': McKenzie slams DA MP Jacobs' conduct in parliamentary meetings
'You are rude': McKenzie slams DA MP Jacobs' conduct in parliamentary meetings

The Herald

time10 hours ago

  • The Herald

'You are rude': McKenzie slams DA MP Jacobs' conduct in parliamentary meetings

'Jacobs knows that I haven't breached any act or law, hence he's talking about ethics. My ethics and his are different. We are not dealing with what he feels and what I feel. The act allows me to appoint Eugene Botha,' McKenzie said. 'I've breached no act. The PA is not the first party and certainly will not be the last party to do that. Your party in the Western Cape is riddled. When you say I've done something wrong, quote the act, not your feelings.' McKenzie also addressed Jacobs' conduct during the meeting, referencing a previous committee meeting where Jacobs grilled Safa president Danny Jordaan over his leadership and travel expenses. 'What I will never allow is for this honourable member to speak when I'm speaking. On a personal level, I want him to know that when he showed Danny Jordaan his finger, I will never allow him to do that to me. I respect you; respect me. When you speak, I am obliged to listen, and when I speak, you should listen. You should not come in as you feel. You can only interject with a point of order through the chairperson. 'You are rude. I will never stand for this rudeness of Jacobs.' TimesLIVE

National Foundations notes commencement of national dialogue
National Foundations notes commencement of national dialogue

The Herald

time10 hours ago

  • The Herald

National Foundations notes commencement of national dialogue

A national dialogue preparatory committee set up by the National Foundations has welcomed President Cyril Ramaphosa's announcement on Tuesday of the national dialogue process, a historic chance for South Africans to reclaim their agency. The National Foundations consists of 43 civil society groups and 12 foundations including the Nelson Mandela Foundation, the Tutu Legacy Foundation, the Steve Biko Foundation and the Thabo Mbeki Foundation. 'It is rare in the history of any nation for citizens rather than just their representatives to be given an opportunity to embark on a historical reflection about the state and condition of their nation, and their prospects for the future,' the National Foundations said on Wednesday. The foundations said on April 30 2024, former president Thabo Mbeki, reflecting on 30 years of democracy, made a passionate call for the nation to engage in a dialogue to work a new vision and programme for the next 30 years and beyond. Mbeki then tasked the National Foundations to prepare for the national dialogue. 'Thus the National Foundations became the custodians of the national dialogue from that day.' The foundations set up a committee to commence with preparations for this initiative, expanding the pool of civil society support for the national dialogue. 'In September 2024, the foundations convened a two-day workshop, attended by close to 50 civil society formations ... to set up structures, ranging from content development, planning and organisation, public mobilisation, fundraising, monitoring and evaluation and marketing and communications subcommittees to anchor preparations for the national dialogue in granular detail.' The foundations said around the same time, its preparatory committee began engagements with the emissaries of Ramaphosa, who is empowered by the constitution, to call for an initiative of this magnitude and consequence. 'At those meetings the foundations stressed the importance of the national dialogue to be a citizens-led initiative, rather than a government-run enterprise, to help overcome the chasm that has opened up between government and the governed in our country, as illustrated by the fact that only about 40% of eligible voters in our country bothered to vote in the last national and provincial elections in May 2024.' The foundations said the voter stayaway was a pointer to a massive alienation of the electorate from the democratic project, which ought to be a concern. 'For if the electorate is alienated from the democratic project, what are the implications for the legitimacy for the democratic order. It was thus important that we embarked on an initiative which will result in the citizens reclaiming their agency. 'We are happy that we reached a mutual understanding with the head of state on the essence and approach to the national dialogue.' The National Foundations said it had greed on all the structures that will underpin the execution of the national dialogue. 'We will, in the coming days, elaborate on the process that will unfold towards the preparatory convention for the national dialogue process scheduled to be held on August 15.' TimesLIVE

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store