Protesters seek apology from Minister in row over footage claim in strip-search allegation review
The demand follows a
letter from Commissioner Drew Harris to Ceann Comhairle
Verona Murphy last week in which he said there are 'no recording devices in cells when prisoners are being searched'.
Mothers Against Genocide held a sit down demonstration blocking the gates of the Dáil's entrance on 1 April and 11 people were arrested on public order offences.
Subsequently, a number of TDs from People Before Profit told the Dáil that they had been informed that a number of the women involved had been strip-searched.
Speaking a number of weeks later,
Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan stated
that he had asked that footage of the incident be examined and that following a garda review it was determined that the allegations were 'false'.
O'Callaghan therefore urged politicians to be cautious when making claims under Dáil privilege.
In his letter to the Ceann Comhairle, Harris reiterated that a 'comprehensive review' of the allegations had taken place and that all gardaí involved in the searches 'acted at all times professionally, lawfully, and in accordance with established procedures and legislative provision'.
Advertisement
He said the protest and the arrests were recorded by garda bodycams.
There were also recordings reviewed from the garda stations involved, which Harris said 'show nothing that would substantiate any allegations of wrongdoing'.
He added: 'There are no recording devices in cells when prisoners are being searched for obvious requirements for dignity and privacy.'
Harris's statement about a lack of footage in cells where searches take place has prompted Mothers Against Genocide to accuse the Justice Minister of attempting to 'discredit' the group.
In a statement today, Mothers Against Genocide called this 'a grave matter of public interest and trust.'
'We expect the Minister for Justice to issue a public apology for spreading misinformation and for interfering with due process by repeating false statements and defending Garda conduct before investigations had even begun,' the group said.
'Many of those arrested have submitted subject access requests to the Gardaí seeking all footage and information held on them. To date, none of this information has been received.'
Paul Murphy TD said yesterday that O'Callaghan did not disclose the 'crucial information' that there was no footage of what happened within the cells.
'The Minister gave the clear impression that footage had 'revealed' that our claims on strip and cavity searches were false,' Murphy said.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
4 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
As Putin & Trump meet, The Sun goes inside raging battle for key Ukraine city…& the tactics that could decide war's fate
AS Putin and Trump prepare meet for crunch talks in Alaska, The Sun looks into the raging battle for a key Ukrainian city - and the key tactics which could decide the fate of the war. Former intelligence officer and NATO planner Philip Ingram takes a deep dive into the ever-evolving warfare used to combat Putin's army in the brand new weekly series Battle Plans Exposed. 8 Philip Ingram, former intelligence officer and NATO planner, will take an in-depth look at the battlefield as part of the weekly series Credit: The Sun 8 It comes as Putin and Trump meet in Alaska for crunch talks on Friday 8 The new series will analyse the crucial battlefield tactics of the Russia-Ukraine war Credit: Getty 8 The first episode of the eye-opening show, which launches Friday, takes an in-depth look at the crucial city of Pokrovsk. Ingram takes a comprehensive look at why vital drones used by Ukraine have helped them defend the city for such a long time. Watch the brand new series here... The through analysis also delves into how drones have become the "new weapon of war" on the front line - often equipped with incendiary devices or explosives. Dubbed the "gateway to Donetsk" by Russian media, Pokrovsk serves as a major regional transport and rail hub and has immense strategic importance. And as part of the new show, Ingram tells how Putin is suffering over 1,000 casualties per day to capture the city. He also takes a look at the operational, strategic and tactical battles taking place between Russia and Ukraine. The new series comes as Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin are headed to Alaska - with the streets of Anchorage already lined with pro-Ukrainian civilians coming out in force against Russia's war. Trump took to Truth Social shortly before he was due to takeoff from Washington to simply post: "HIGH STAKES!!!" He has already described the summit as being like a chess game this week. Putin's huge team started their journey across to the US earlier today as they sped through the shabby streets of Magadan. The despot is expected to board a jet to Alaska soon and complete the nine-hour trip to the 49th state. Trump will officially greet Putin with peace talks starting at around 8:30pm UK time. Putin has continued to order barbaric attacks on Ukraine just hours before he is expected to be pressured into agreeing to a peace deal. The US President has been adamant the bloodshed in Ukraine must end but a merciless Putin is yet to relent. He continued to launch aerial bombs in Dnipropetrovsk region overnight with his troops edging forwards on the frontline. Ukrainian forces have been forced to evacuate a town in Donetsk as the intense fighting rages on at the hands of Russian sabotage and reconnaissance groups. Putin is expected to ask to keep hold of all the land he has managed to illegally seize since starting the conflict in February 2022. 8 KHERSON, UKRAINE – AUGUST 11: A Ukrainian artillery squad fires on the left bank of the Dnipro River in kherson, Ukraine on August 11, 2025. The Kherson region is now the focus of peace negotiations between US President Donald Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin. (Photo by Fermin Torrano/Anadolu via Getty Images) Credit: Getty 8 Putin's attacks have continued in the days leading to the talks with Trump Credit: Getty 8 Neighbourhoods are still being pummelled by Putin's strikes Credit: Getty The brazen tactics were paired with the Kremlin's "Doomsday Radio" which blurted out strange coded messages as the despot started his travels. The station is known to send out strange messages during tense times for Russia with experts saying it is likely linked to the Kremlin's nuclear defence forces. Today the signals NZHTI 88751 MAREL 5057 6881 and NZHTI 03649 STOKOTON 2751 2830 were broadcasted with no explanation. The same mysterious codes were sounded only six weeks before the start of Putin's illegal invasion of Ukraine. Kyiv launched their own warning shots at Russia as they sent a final message to the Kremlin ahead of the talks. They are believed to have downed Putin's £32 million Su-30SM fighter close to Ukrainian-controlled Snake Island in the Black Sea. Russia was also hit by heavy Ukrainian bombardment on the Olya port in Russia's Astrakhan region. The port has been used to import military goods for Putin's war machine from Iran via the Caspian Sea across the past three years. Ukraine also exploded Syzran Oil Refinery with a major drone swarm which triggered deafening explosions and sparked two major blazes. Russia's defence ministry said it had intercepted 55 Ukrainian drones across multiple regions overnight. Friday's historic peace summit is being held at the Joint Base Elmendorf-Richardson in Anchorage, Alaska. It will be the first meeting between the pair since 2019. A notable absentee from the peace talks is Ukraine's Volodymyr Zelensky. Trump is expected to call up Kyiv's brave wartime leader alongside his European allies following the summit to discuss the progress made. A second meeting is then due to be scheduled which could see Putin and Zelensky meet face-to-face for the first time since the war started. 8 Demonstrators protest in Anchorage, Alaska ahead of Trump's meeting with Putin Credit:
Irish Times
6 hours ago
- Irish Times
Parents of teen killed after being left on roadside by emergency services: ‘They failed Shannon'
In the sittingroom of her home in Dunloy, Co Antrim , a framed photograph of Shannon McQuillan smiles down from the mantelpiece. 'She wanted to be a human rights lawyer,' says Paul McQuillan, looking up at the picture of his daughter. 'She hated injustice, and she was going to try and correct things. 'She wanted to provide justice for people that were being treated the same way she ended up being treated.' A 19-year-old law student at Ulster University, Shannon had been on a night out with her boyfriend, Owen McFerran, when she was knocked down and killed in the early hours of January 20th, 2018, after being left alone at a bus shelter in Magherafelt, Co Derry , by Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI) officers and a Northern Ireland Ambulance Service (NIAS) paramedic and trainee. READ MORE Owen, then 21, suffered life-changing injuries. Earlier this month, following an investigation, the Police Ombudsman for Northern Ireland concluded there had been 'multiple breaches in the duty of care' offered to Shannon and Owen, and that the PSNI response was 'wholly inadequate'. This included failing to 'complete even the most basic checks' in relation to them, to recognise the vulnerability and danger of leaving them alone beside a road, and to safeguard their welfare. 'More should have been done in this case to protect the extremely vulnerable young woman and man from harm,' said the Police Ombudsman's chief executive, Hugh Hume. 'You've been treated as if you don't count,' says Paul, 'because Shannon didn't count [to them]. She may not have counted to them, but she definitely counted to us.' Shannon McQuillan's grave. The 19-year-old was into make-up and had 'the most beautiful ginger hair', her father says. Photograph: Arthur Allison/Pacemaker Press Shannon was one of four children; first came a son, then three girls in three years, each born a year apart, with Shannon in the middle. 'They were very close,' says Paul. 'Shannon was an independent young girl, she liked doing her own thing, and was very easy to get on with, very easy-going.' She was into make-up, had 'the most beautiful ginger hair' and was funny – he laughs, remembering 'some of the one-liners she used to come out with'. 'Our conversations were always having a wee joke at each other, because each one thought they were as quick-witted as the other.' Shannon shared her mother Collette's passion for heavy metal and rock music, and was 'a really caring person,' he emphasises. 'No matter what lengths she had to go to care for somebody or something, she would go to those lengths.' This included saving a kitten and bringing home an injured duck; they still have her pet tortoise, Arthur. 'She was a nice girl, and a good daughter,' says Paul. That evening, Shannon and Owen were going out to a nightclub. According to the Police Ombudsman, they first came into contact with the PSNI and ambulance service at 2am, in a car park in Magherafelt. Shannon had fallen 'a number of times', hit her head and was unconscious, and had visible injuries to her leg. Subsequent tests showed both had high levels of alcohol in their blood. A decision was made to take them to hospital, but the ambulance personnel called police back to the car park after Shannon's behaviour became 'erratic'. Police agreed to follow the ambulance, but shortly before 3am, it pulled into a bus layby on the Moneynick Road in Magherfelt and called again for police assistance. Following a discussion between the emergency services, Shannon and Owen got out of the ambulance 'and were left, alone, at a bus shelter'. Collette had already received a call from the police, asking her to go and meet Shannon and Owen at the hospital. Then, at about 3.30am, Shannon phoned. 'I said, 'Where are you at?'. They hadn't a clue where they were … Owen said: 'The police put us out'.' The ombudsman stated that 'at 3.38am the police received the first of three phone calls about two people walking in the middle of the Moneynick Road. 'Two minutes later, a motorist informed police that he had collided with two people on the same road.' Shannon died at the scene. Paul McQuillan: 'Shannon was an independent young girl, she liked doing her own thing, and was very easy to get on with, very easy-going.' Photograph: Arthur Allison/Pacemaker Press Owen had told Collette he thought they had been left at Logan's Fashions, a well-known shop near Dunloy but about 48km away from their actual location. 'I got in the car and went over to Logan's Fashions and there was no Shannon and Owen. 'I kept trying to contact them, it went to voicemail, so I went back home and kept trying to phone and phone. 'Then at five o'clock in the morning I got a call from a policeman that he was coming to see me. So I knew.' Following the tragedy, one of the three police officers who attended the ambulance received a written warning for gross misconduct, and another was dismissed from the PSNI. This dismissal was set aside on appeal, but the officer died before a hearing could take place. A third officer was disciplined for breaching the PSNI's code of ethics. The ombudsman's office submitted a file to the North's Public Prosecution Service (PPS) for the potential offences of gross negligence, manslaughter and misconduct in public office. The PPS directed no prosecutions. A separate PSNI investigation was carried out into the conduct of ambulance service staff and a police file was submitted to the PPS, but no criminal charges were brought. As a result of the 'wholly inadequate' communication between police officers and ambulance staff, such as failures to pass on key information – including that Shannon had been unconscious, and contradictory accounts of what happened – the ombudsman has recommended a new policy, currently under development, for the PSNI and NIAS for dealing with people who are intoxicated and refuse medical treatment. 'This is definitely positive, if it saves somebody else,' says Paul. Yet 7½ years on from their daughter's death, he and Collette are still searching for answers. 'They should have been sacked for the way they behaved that night,' says Paul. 'They cost my daughter's life, and they're not even man enough to stand up and admit their mistakes.' Collette has taken a civil case against PSNI Chief Constable Jon Boutcher and the NIAS. In the wake of the Police Ombudsman's report, they are calling for the PPS to look again at prosecutions, and for a similar investigation to be conducted into the actions of the NIAS. They have many questions. Why was one of the police officers involved subsequently promoted twice? Why was a patient report form destroyed? Why could the police not have phoned to say they were leaving them in the layby? 'Why did one of the cops say you come from a republican family ... it's trying to discredit the family,' says Paul. 'It's been lies, and cover-ups, the way they've tried to portray it. It just goes to show you, the whole establishment, circles the wagons, the truth, never [comes out].' 'Where was the compassion for Shannon?' asks Collette. 'They didn't take into account the head injury that may have caused that erratic behaviour. 'The police were totally unprofessional, they did not do what they should have done. They failed Shannon in every way. 'Are we just left – that's it, accept it? No, I'll never accept it. There is an injustice and I will fight for justice for my wain [child].' The McQuillans' criticisms were put to the PSNI and the NIAS, and they were offered the opportunity to respond. In a statement, the PSNI said it had nothing to add to its comments following the Police Ombudsman's findings, when Assistant Chief Constable Anthony McNally said: 'Our thoughts are very much with everyone who has been affected by this awful and tragic incident. 'We accept that more could and should have been done by police to prevent the circumstances that preceded Shannon's death and Owen's injuries,' he said. 'For that we are truly sorry. 'We will now take further time to carefully consider the ombudsman's report and assure ourselves that lessons have been learned particularly around the identification of vulnerability, risk assessment and adherence to service policy.' The NIAS said it was 'unable to provide any comment on account of ongoing legal proceedings'. Shannon McQuillan's grave. Photograph: Arthur Allison/Pacemaker Press Collette and Paul still talk to their daughter every day. For Collette, their conversations are on the sofa at home. 'She'd be like me, wee cup of tea and a wee smoke and oh, we'd put the world to rights about homelessness and how can this be, and that's not right.' She keeps in regular contact with Owen. 'He was always part of our family, and he always will be.' Paul goes to Shannon's grave. It is a few minutes' drive away, across the road from the chapel and with a view of the village and the green hills beyond. As he stands there, he thinks, 'You shouldn't be in there, pet.'
Irish Times
6 hours ago
- Irish Times
Far-right Israeli minister taunts jailed Palestinian leader during prison visit
The Palestinian Authority has reacted angrily after footage was released of Israel 's far-right national security minister, Itamar Ben-Gvir, appearing to threaten prominent Palestinian Marwan Barghouti during a visit to his prison cell. 'You will not defeat us, whoever messes with the people of Israel, whoever murders our children and women – we will wipe him out,' Mr Ben-Gvir appears to tell Mr Barghouti. 'You need to know this, it's been like this throughout history.' Mr Barghouti (66) has been incarcerated since 2002 when he was sentenced by Israel to five life sentences plus 40 years after a court convicted him of planning attacks in the occupied West Bank that led to the deaths of five civilians during the second Palestinian Intifada, or uprising. The Palestinian Authority said the comments amounted to 'state terrorism.' READ MORE 'We condemn the raid by extremist minister Itamar Ben-Gvir on the cell of commander Marwan Barghouti, directly threatening him. This is an unprecedented provocation and organised state terrorism,' a statement by the Palestinian foreign ministry read. Israeli media reported that Ben Gvir was visiting Tel Aviv's Gannot prison with Prisons Service Commissioner Kobi Yaakobi "to closely monitor the worsening of the imprisoned terrorists' conditions" — Middle East Eye (@MiddleEastEye) Palestine Liberation Organisation executive committee deputy chair Hussein al-Sheikh also criticised Mr Ben-Gvir's remarks. 'Ben-Gvir's threat against leader Marwan Barghouti in his cell is the peak of the psychological, moral and physical terror used against prisoners, and a grave violation of international and humanitarian treaties and conventions,' he wrote on X. But Mr Ben-Gvir, who has imposed numerous restrictions on Palestinian prisoners since the Hamas attack on Israel on October 7th, 2023, rejected the Palestinian condemnation, saying he would repeat his statements 'again and again without apologising'. He referred to Mr Barghouti as an 'arch-terrorist' and called for his name to be erased, citing a Hebrew curse used for enemies of the Jews. The short video clip marked the first image of Mr Barghouti seen in public in over a decade. He was placed in solitary confinement at the start of the Gaza war . Relatives of Mr Barghouti said they were 'shocked by the changes in Marwan's facial features, from the fatigue and hunger he is in'. His wife, Fadwa, said she didn't recognise him. At the time of his arrest Mr Barghouti was the leader of the Tanzim militia, linked to the Fatah party led by Palestinian president Mahmoud Abbas. Despite his imprisonment, Mr Barghouti has consistently topped opinion polls asking Palestinians who they would vote for in a presidential election, ahead of current Mr Abbas and leaders of Hamas. Although he is a senior member of Fatah, his support cuts across party lines. Palestinians have long sought his release, including through hostage deals, but Israel has so far rejected this. Hamas wants him set free as part of a ceasefire deal with Israel to end the Gaza war.
