Maharashtra ATS Challenges Mumbai Train Blasts Acquittals In Top Court
Chief Justice BR Gavai will lead a three-judge bench alongside Justices K Vinod Chandran and NV Anjaria to examine the appeal. The urgent listing came after Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, representing the Maharashtra ATS, emphasized the matter's gravity and requested expedited proceedings.
The Bombay High Court's recent verdict completely overturned the trial court's 2009 judgment that had imposed death sentences on five accused individuals and life imprisonment on seven others. The original convictions stemmed from their alleged involvement in orchestrating and executing the coordinated bomb attacks that targeted Mumbai's Western Railway network on July 11, 2006.
Justices Anil Kilor and Shyam Chandak, forming the division bench, delivered a scathing assessment of the prosecution's case, declaring that investigators had "utterly failed" to establish guilt beyond reasonable doubt. The court expressed difficulty in believing that the accused had actually committed the crimes they were charged with.
The High Court raised serious concerns about the investigation methods employed, specifically highlighting allegations of torture against ATS officials. The judges observed that investigators appeared to be operating under intense pressure to produce quick results following the attacks, potentially compromising the integrity of the evidence-gathering process.
This judicial criticism deals a devastating blow to the Maharashtra Anti-Terrorism Squad's investigation, which had maintained strong connections between the accused and the banned Students' Islamic Movement of India. The ATS had built its case around claims that the suspects had collaborated with Pakistani operatives from Lashkar-e-Taiba to orchestrate the deadly attack.
The tragic incident remains etched in Mumbai's collective memory as one of the most horrific terrorist strikes in Indian history. Within a terrifying eleven-minute span, seven explosive devices detonated across the Western Railway's suburban train network, claiming 189 innocent lives and leaving more than 800 people injured. The coordinated nature of the attacks and their impact on ordinary commuters made this one of the deadliest terror incidents the country has witnessed.
The acquittal verdict has sparked significant debate about the quality of terrorism investigations and the pressure law enforcement agencies face to deliver swift justice in high-profile cases. Legal experts have noted that the High Court's observations about torture allegations and investigative shortcomings raise broader questions about procedural safeguards in terrorism prosecutions.
As the Supreme Court prepares to examine this contentious appeal, the outcome will likely have far-reaching implications for how terrorism cases are investigated and prosecuted in India. The hearing represents a crucial moment for both the victims' families, who have waited nearly two decades for justice, and the legal system's credibility in handling complex terrorism cases.
The case's journey through various judicial levels reflects the challenges inherent in prosecuting terrorism-related offenses while maintaining due process standards and ensuring that convictions are based on solid, untainted evidence rather than investigative pressure or public sentiment.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hans India
26 minutes ago
- Hans India
Renukaswamy murder case: SC hearing on bail plea of Darshan adjourned to tomorrow
Bengaluru: In a significant turn in the sensational Renukaswamy murder case, the Supreme Court has adjourned the hearing on the Karnataka government's plea challenging Kannada actor Darshan's bail to July 24, effectively granting the actor two more days of relief. Darshan, who was arrested in connection with the brutal murder of Renukaswamy, is currently out on bail granted by the Karnataka High Court. The state government moved the Supreme Court questioning the High Court's decision to grant bail to the popular actor. The petition was scheduled to be heard today but was deferred after Darshan's senior counsel Siddharth Dave requested more time. Speaking to the media, Dave explained, 'Senior advocate Kapil Sibal was to appear for Darshan, but he had to attend to another matter today. I received this case only last night, so it was not possible to prepare arguments overnight. Therefore, I requested an adjournment of one or two days, which the Supreme Court accepted. The matter will now be heard on Thursday, July 24.' Dave added that he would not be arguing about the grounds for Darshan's arrest but would focus on the merits of the bail itself. Legal experts believe the Supreme Court's observations could have a crucial impact on the actor's fate. Earlier, the Supreme Court had questioned why Darshan's bail should not be cancelled and observed that the High Court had not exercised sufficient caution while granting it. If the apex court cancels the bail, Darshan could face re-arrest, which would severely disrupt the production of his upcoming film Devil. In total, 17 people have been granted bail in the Renukaswamy murder case, including prime accused Pavithra Gowda (A1) and Darshan (A2). The Karnataka government has specifically sought the cancellation of bail for seven of the accused, including Darshan and Pavithra. As the high-profile case continues to grab headlines, all eyes are now on the Supreme Court's next move. A final decision on the bail plea is expected when the matter comes up again this Thursday.
Hans India
26 minutes ago
- Hans India
State bans use of sirens during VIP movement: DGP issues strict order
Bengaluru: In a significant move aimed at enhancing public safety and curbing noise pollution, Karnataka's Director General and Inspector General of Police (DG & IGP) Dr. M.A. Saleem has issued an official order banning the use of sirens during the movement of VIPs across the state. The order, issued on Sunday, states that the use of sirens not only creates unnecessary disturbance on public roads but also potentially exposes the route of VIPs to unauthorized individuals, thereby increasing the risk to their security. Considering this, the DGP has directed that sirens must not be used for VIP convoys or movement. The directive also highlights that sudden use of sirens on public roads can inconvenience other motorists and may lead to accidents, especially when vehicles are forced to make abrupt movements to make way. The order recommends that any urgent coordination during VIP travel should be conducted through wireless communication channels rather than sirens. According to the guidelines laid down in the order, only emergency service vehicles such as ambulances, police vehicles, and fire brigades may use sirens, and only in genuine emergency situations. The DGP further emphasised that as per Supreme Court directives, no vehicle other than emergency services is permitted to use sirens. Even police vehicles are restricted from using sirens unless responding to an emergency. Violation of this rule will attract legal action under Section 190(2) of the Motor Vehicles Act, which could result in a fine along with up to three months of imprisonment. This decisive step by the Karnataka Police aims to ensure safer roads, reduce noise pollution, and maintain the secrecy and security of VIP movements.
Mint
26 minutes ago
- Mint
Indian techie, working for Amazon, brutally beaten and stripped in racist attack in Dublin; gory details emerge
An Indian man in his 40s was hospitalised following a brutal and racially motivated assault in Tallaght, a suburb of Dublin, late on Saturday evening. The victim, who had arrived in Ireland only three weeks prior and is reported to work for Amazon, was viciously attacked by a group of teenage males after being falsely accused of inappropriate conduct near a children's playground. The incident occurred at approximately 6 pm on Parkhill Road, where the man was subjected to severe physical violence, including having his trousers forcibly removed. Witnesses found him bleeding heavily from multiple injuries to his face, arms, and legs before rushing him to Tallaght University Hospital for emergency treatment. The man, who has not been named publicly, was reportedly attacked by a group of 15–16-year-olds who not only punched and kicked him but slammed his head into a lamppost three times, according to eyewitness accounts. 'He was a gentle man and he was stripped, he was attacked,' said local resident Jennifer Murray, who rushed to his aid. 'He told us what happened, that they punched him in the head first. He had about an inch and a half gash above his eyebrow, and then about an inch above his other eyebrow.' 'Then they took his head and rammed it into a lamppost three times. Then they all punched him and kicked him, and they stripped his shoes, off his trousers, off his underwear off. They took his phone and they took his money, and then they left him for dead,' she told The Journal. According to Murray, the man was bleeding heavily and appeared to be in severe shock. 'His legs were completely saturated in blood. The blood had actually congealed so much we had to cut his jacket off to check for wounds on his chest,' she added. 'This was pure racism, leading to innocent people being attacked.' The Gardaí, Ireland Police, confirmed they were alerted to the attack and have launched an investigation into the incident. A spokesperson stated, "Gardaí in Tallaght were alerted to an incident at Parkhill Road, Tallaght, Dublin 24 on the evening of Saturday, July 19, at approximately 6 pm. Gardaí attended the scene and a male, aged in his 40s, was taken to Tallaght University Hospital with injuries. Investigations are ongoing." Authorities have emphasised that the allegations of misconduct that sparked the assault are entirely unfounded. These false claims, originally spread by the attackers and subsequently amplified by far-right and anti-immigrant groups online, have been dismissed by police. Local leaders have voiced their concern over the incident, highlighting the broader issue of rising xenophobia and racist violence in Ireland. Fine Gael councillor Baby Pereppadan, after meeting the victim post-hospitalisation, described the man as deeply traumatised and called for increased Garda patrols in the area. He remarked, 'He couldn't speak much because of the shock he was in. He is not taking any visitors at the moment. Small incidents like these are happening frequently in Tallaght.' The Indian community in Ireland has expressed profound unease in the aftermath of the assault and is urging the Irish government to take urgent steps to engage with immigrant and minority groups to address safety concerns. Meanwhile, a protest organised by anti-racism and pro-migrant organisations is scheduled for July 26 to denounce such hate crimes and demand justice for the victim. The Indian Ambassador to Ireland, Akhilesh Mishra, has also condemned the attack, calling for the swift prosecution of those responsible. 'How can an ALLEGED' assault cause such horrible injury and bleeding? Aghast at the insensitivity & obfuscation of RTE [Ireland's national media outlet] Hope the perpetrators are brought to justice,' he posted on X.
