Security crisis at hospitals and clinics sparks fear and protest
A surge in armed attacks and violent crimes at rural hospitals has left healthcare workers fearing for their lives.
Hospitals and clinics – especially those in rural areas or with insufficient security – are becoming the targets of ruthless robbers, with medical staff and patients being the victims.
Recent incidents include an attack by armed criminals on medical practitioners at the Barberton District Hospital in Mpumalanga; a robbery at gunpoint of security guards at Livingstone Hospital in Gqeberha, Eastern Cape; and ongoing attacks – including rape – on nurses at isolated health facilities in Limpopo.
Barberton Hospital protest
This week, hospital employees at Barberton Hospital were picketing outside the gate demanding the government must ensure their safety before they could resume work.
A group of armed people reportedly entered the facility a few days ago and 'threatened nurses and doctors'.
Mpumalanga department of community safety, security and liaison Moeti Mmusi confirmed the incident and said the department has taken steps to ensure the safety of the workers.
'Not a work boycott'
SA Medical Association Trade Union's Mpumalanga representative, Mandla Matshabe, confirmed their members were scared to enter the facility due to safety concerns.
ALSO READ: Two nurses kidnapped for 4 hours and raped in Limpopo clinic attack
The contract of the current security company lapsed and as the new firm was preparing to move in, the criminals hit the hospital and attacked the staff and patients, Matshabe said.
'This is not a work boycott. There is a security threat due to the incident that took place in the early hours of 1 June.
'Workers are willing to perform their duties. The security threat is posed by the handover to a new security company – and I believe there is a security threat throughout the province due to this transition,' said Matshabe.
'In accordance with the Occupational Health and Safety Act, workers asked the employer to ensure their safety at the hospital.'
Healthcare workers' continuous attack
Cyril Mdluli, a provincial secretary of the Democratic Nursing Organisation of South Africa, said: 'We note the continuous attack on health care workers by the community and criminals and call for a strong security system in all health facilities.
'Currently, our securities are not armed. We need to review that decision. Mpumalanga is the only province where security matters are handled at the department of safety and security.
ALSO READ: Chuene Clinic attack: More charges expected against Limpopo suspect as case postponed
'We therefore call for security to be managed by the department of health. Insourcing will increase the security in facilities.'
Mdluli said for security needs to be met, facilities must have proper fencing and lighting. Department of health spokesperson Dumisani Malamule declined to comment.
Rural clinics security concerns
Last month, Zoutnet news reported attacks on nurses working in rural hospitals across Vhembe.
'Nurses are facing a lot of challenges, especially those working in rural clinics and hospitals, where there is no security,' said Fhumulani Mulaudzi from the University of Pretoria.
Democratic Nursing Organisation of South Africa president Simon Hlungwani earlier highlighted a nurse who was raped while on duty in Limpopo and another who was shot dead in Tembisa Hospital.
'We need to come up with clear programmes that we are going to drive to wage the struggle and improve the service,' Hlungwani said.
As one nurse said: 'It pains us to see we are lacking in the very service we are supposed to render to our communities.'
NOW READ: Gauteng health warns of 'silent killer'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
2 days ago
- The Citizen
Security crisis at hospitals and clinics sparks fear and protest
A surge in armed attacks and violent crimes at rural hospitals has left healthcare workers fearing for their lives. Hospitals and clinics – especially those in rural areas or with insufficient security – are becoming the targets of ruthless robbers, with medical staff and patients being the victims. Recent incidents include an attack by armed criminals on medical practitioners at the Barberton District Hospital in Mpumalanga; a robbery at gunpoint of security guards at Livingstone Hospital in Gqeberha, Eastern Cape; and ongoing attacks – including rape – on nurses at isolated health facilities in Limpopo. Barberton Hospital protest This week, hospital employees at Barberton Hospital were picketing outside the gate demanding the government must ensure their safety before they could resume work. A group of armed people reportedly entered the facility a few days ago and 'threatened nurses and doctors'. Mpumalanga department of community safety, security and liaison Moeti Mmusi confirmed the incident and said the department has taken steps to ensure the safety of the workers. 'Not a work boycott' SA Medical Association Trade Union's Mpumalanga representative, Mandla Matshabe, confirmed their members were scared to enter the facility due to safety concerns. ALSO READ: Two nurses kidnapped for 4 hours and raped in Limpopo clinic attack The contract of the current security company lapsed and as the new firm was preparing to move in, the criminals hit the hospital and attacked the staff and patients, Matshabe said. 'This is not a work boycott. There is a security threat due to the incident that took place in the early hours of 1 June. 'Workers are willing to perform their duties. The security threat is posed by the handover to a new security company – and I believe there is a security threat throughout the province due to this transition,' said Matshabe. 'In accordance with the Occupational Health and Safety Act, workers asked the employer to ensure their safety at the hospital.' Healthcare workers' continuous attack Cyril Mdluli, a provincial secretary of the Democratic Nursing Organisation of South Africa, said: 'We note the continuous attack on health care workers by the community and criminals and call for a strong security system in all health facilities. 'Currently, our securities are not armed. We need to review that decision. Mpumalanga is the only province where security matters are handled at the department of safety and security. ALSO READ: Chuene Clinic attack: More charges expected against Limpopo suspect as case postponed 'We therefore call for security to be managed by the department of health. Insourcing will increase the security in facilities.' Mdluli said for security needs to be met, facilities must have proper fencing and lighting. Department of health spokesperson Dumisani Malamule declined to comment. Rural clinics security concerns Last month, Zoutnet news reported attacks on nurses working in rural hospitals across Vhembe. 'Nurses are facing a lot of challenges, especially those working in rural clinics and hospitals, where there is no security,' said Fhumulani Mulaudzi from the University of Pretoria. Democratic Nursing Organisation of South Africa president Simon Hlungwani earlier highlighted a nurse who was raped while on duty in Limpopo and another who was shot dead in Tembisa Hospital. 'We need to come up with clear programmes that we are going to drive to wage the struggle and improve the service,' Hlungwani said. As one nurse said: 'It pains us to see we are lacking in the very service we are supposed to render to our communities.' NOW READ: Gauteng health warns of 'silent killer'
The Citizen
24-04-2025
- The Citizen
Suspicious fires rock Tembisa Hospital during SIU probe
Two fires hit Tembisa Provincial Tertiary Hospital as investigators uncover R3 billion in graft. Amid a Special Investigating Unit's (SIU) probe into corruption at the Tembisa Provincial Tertiary Hospital, the DA has called for a swift investigation into the possibility of arson as two fires ravaged the health institution. In what DA Gauteng shadow Health MEC Jack Bloom has described as 'suspicious', the hospital has twice been hit by a fire – destroying the accident and emergency section over the Easter weekend and the adjacent outpatients' department yesterday. 'Are there tenderpreneurs [entrepreneurs profiting on government tenders] who want to get the contracts for rebuilding the burnt sections?,' asked Bloom. Arson 'This cannot be ruled out as we have criminal syndicates who sabotage the water supply so they can benefit by providing water tankers,' he claimed. He said arson was identified as the cause of the devastating fire at the Charlotte Maxeke Johannesburg Academic Hospital four years ago, 'but no one has been caught'. 'Any foul play at Tembisa Hospital needs to be speedily identified and the culprits apprehended before further fires occur.' Bloom, who has visited the hospital, accompanied by members of the Gauteng legislature health oversight committee, said he saw the extent of the damage. ALSO READ: Health department addresses Tshwane clinic 'medicine shortages' 'In the interim, the accident and emergency section patients will be treated in the old family medicine section. But this should be a temporary measure, as it worsens the hospital's already severe overcrowding,' he said. R3 billion in taxpayer losses Taxpayer losses to Tembisa Hospital corruption networks, have risen to R3 billion, according to the SIU. It was first identified by whistle-blower Babita Deokaran, who was assassinated in a hit-style killing outside her Johannesburg home in 2021. 'Under no circumstances should the dysfunctional Gauteng department of infrastructure development be involved in this project,' said Bloom. 'It is notorious for nonperforming contracts, such as at Charlotte Maxeke Hospital, where fire repairs had to be taken over by the national health department and the Development Bank of South Africa. Compliance issues 'A competent project team should be appointed for Tembisa, working with the private sector to expedite the building work. 'Greater priority should be given to make all public hospitals comply with the Occupational Health and Safety Act. 'None of the 37 hospitals have 100% compliance, with Tembisa only 79% compliant.' ALSO READ: Operations continue at Tembisa hospital after second fire in less than a week Gauteng department of health spokesperson Motalatale Modiba said an investigation into the Tembisa Hospital fires was underway. 'Patients continue to receive care. We appeal to the public for patience, because we are not dealing with a normal situation. 'We also appeal to various organisations to allow space to health workers, to adapt to a new environment and give care to patients. We are willing to account and share information,' said Modiba. A litany of corruption incidents involving the provincial department of health: The Gauteng government spending almost R3 billion on Covid-related personal protective equipment (PPE); Prices inflated by up to 400%; The auditor-general finding 23 unlisted suppliers had delivered PPE to the Gauteng government worth R863 million; In 22 instances, PPE contracts worth R442 million were awarded to suppliers with no previous history of supplying PPE; and In six instances, overpricing led to a potential loss of R182 million. NOW READ: Patients evacuated as fire breaks out at Tembisa Hospital's emergency unit (VIDEO)
The South African
22-04-2025
- The South African
DA vows to push for accountability over Tembisa Hospital fire
The Democratic Alliance (DA) in Gauteng has demanded a speedy investigation and consequences for any identified failures that may have contributed to the fire at Tembisa Hospital in Ekurhuleni. A fire broke out at the hospital's emergency unit on Saturday, 20 April. Fortunately, there were no casualties reported. However, the unit remains closed. The Gauteng Department of Health said, despite the incident, Tembisa Hospital remains operational, and the cause of the fire is under investigation. DA Gauteng spokesperson on health Jack Bloom said they're very grateful that disaster management services were able to prevent a monstrous tragedy by the speedy evacuation of patients. They should be commended. Bloom said unfortunately, there is a history of drawn-out investigations and lack of consequences after previous hospital fires. 'While arson has been identified as the cause of the devastating fire at the Charlotte Maxeke Johannesburg Hospital five years ago, the hospital CEO was not fired despite identified deficiencies in a report by the State Security Agency. There has also been no progress in apprehending the arsonists,' Bloom said. Meanwhile, none of Gauteng's 37 public hospitals comply fully with the Occupational Health and Safety Act, with fire being the biggest risk, the DA also revealed. The party said that this is according to a recent Gauteng Health Department presentation to an oversight committee in the Gauteng Legislature. Sixteen hospitals scored less than 75% OHS compliance, mostly because of missing fire prevention and fire suppression equipment, and lack of fire signage and escape lighting. Notably, Tembisa Hospital only scored 72% OHS compliance, the same as the Charlotte Maxeke Johannesburg Hospital, despite their previous fire. 'Tembisa Hospital has been mismanaged and looted by fishy contracts for years now, and it does not even have a permanent CEO. A top-class CEO is urgently needed to ensure that full services are reinstated, and measures are taken to alleviate the severe overcrowding that will be worsened by the fire. 'The DA in Gauteng will push for full accountability and speedy efforts to fix Tembisa Hospital,' Bloom added. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1. Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X, and Bluesky for the latest news.
