Tuition fee aid for low income families 'worrying'
The Public Accounts Committee (PAC) has published its review into the government's Student Awards Scheme.
It said while the grants had been increased in line with inflation, the income levels to qualify for the full funding had not.
The report said it was "worrying to note" that for a student to receive a full maintenance grant, parents or other contributors "must be earning less than the minimum wage".
That was making higher education "unaffordable" for lower income households, it said.
The report also found that over time the proportion of students from lower income households who were eligible for a full grant "has been reducing".
The PAC made 13 recommendations, which are due to be debated in Tynwald later this month.
The lower end of the grant's income threshold is currently £21,547, a figure the PAC recommended be "uplifted to at least £30,388", with the thresholds adjusted each year in line with inflation.
It has also called for a review into the awards scheme to make sure its policies were aligned with the "educational aims in the Island Plan".
It noted disparities with support available for students studying on the island, who received £2,700 less than those travelling to study away from home.
"The differential appears to be greater than the likely cost of travel," the report said, adding that there were no incentives to study locally.
It called for the education department to review the support provided to put it on an equal footing, with the exception of travel costs, in the future.
Eligibility criteria for support is based on residency, academic achievement and household income.
While currently a person must have 80 UCAS points to qualify, the PAC said alternative options should be considered.
It suggested that including other qualifications at the same level would help to address skills shortages on the island.
Among other recommendations, the PAC called for higher levels of financial support for those with a disability, and a Tynwald review into how incentives could address an island skills gap.
Read more stories from the Isle of Man on the BBC, watch BBC North West Tonight on BBC iPlayer and follow BBC Isle of Man on Facebook and X.
Student pay awards reviewed amid tuition fee rise
Island students to pay same fees as UK residents
Public Accounts Committee Student Awards Report 2024-25
Tynwald - Parliament of the Isle of Man
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indianapolis Star
5 days ago
- Indianapolis Star
Restored Queen Anne home from 1904 features original parquet floors, pocket doors & more
In August 1904, Ada H. Peters purchased a lot in what is now known as New Albany's East Spring Street Historic District. Shortly after taking ownership of the property, she built an 1,800-square-foot, Queen Anne-style home that was rented to Harry E. Borgerding and his family through July 1909. Borgerding was associated with the H. Borgerding Manufacturing Co. on Corydon Pike and later became secretary — and eventually president and treasurer — of the Borgerding Motor Car Co. on Spring Street. His memory lives on through the house he once lived in, now owned by Anne and Matthew Phillips. "It's a Victorian," Anne said, "but it's a craftsman and Victorian cross (from) the beginning of the 20th century. Almost everything in here is very simple; it's not that frilly, Victorian (aesthetic) — and I think that's why it was preserved." The home still boasts several original features, such as woodwork that has never been painted or stripped. This includes the staircase, which led the Phillips family to purchase the home in 2017. "I guess the staircase is what sold me on the house," Anne recalled, adding that she grew up in old homes and is accustomed to their quirks and oddities. "It had good bones, but cosmetically, (there was) a lot to do." Superficial changes were made throughout, but the kitchen required a complete overhaul, as critical updates were needed to keep it functional. Anne explains that the microwave was falling apart, and the oven would start steaming whenever the temperature exceeded 375 degrees. "We didn't change the layout," Anne said, "but we did take it down … to the studs." The room features new electrical, plumbing, cabinetry, and appliances, but Anne kept the home's character beadboard cabinetry — painted a cool, dark green Sherwin Williams hue called Messenger Bag — features latches that mimic the original ones upstairs. The home's original milk door is still intact, though it's now used to store keys. "We don't try to restore; we try to enhance," Anne said. "(With) the kitchen, I wanted it to feel like (it was always) part of the house." Though the house became a single-family home in the 1980s, signs of its past remain. "There are numbers on the doors because those were the rooms," Anne said, adding that their primary bedroom once held another kitchen — and the old gas line is still visible. Their bedroom is room number one, and room two is a guest room. Room three is Matthew's office, which holds pieces of a different past. "He's definitely into the 80s, and he's got all his things," Anne said, noting the Ms. Pac-Man and Mortal Kombat arcade games, which sit below framed pop art. Opposite the games, neon Pac-Man lights adorn the wall just above the bookcase, which holds dozens of books and other knickknacks reminiscent of the period. "It's a little more midcentury," Anne said, "(but) I think it all still flows and works together." When the Phillipses first moved in, the attic was unfinished and filled with decades' worth of other people's belongings. "We completely redid it because in 2020," Anne said, "when I shifted to work from home." The room is accessible only through a door in the second-floor bathroom, which opens to a small set of stairs and up to Anne's office. The banister, she says, is both practical and sentimental. "This is a noodle pin that was my great-grandmother's," she explained, adding that Matthew whittled it to create a functional piece for their home. Up the stairs, Anne's office furniture sits on wood flooring that boasts a unique look. "It's not stained," Anne said, explaining that its appearance is the result of previous high-heat damage. "It was cleaned up, and with the sanding and the poly, it looks like tortoise shell." One side of the attic is lined with seven built-in closets, a feature Anne and Matthew added for storing seasonal clothing, holiday decor, and other occasionally used items. Though it's one of the newer features of the home, it blends in seamlessly, further enhancing the essence of the home's historic charm. "We were just taking the space we have," Anne said, "honoring what it was, and trying to enhance it for modern life." The Philllips home is open for viewing on this year's New Albany Historic Home Tour, held on Sept. 13. Know a house that would make a great Home of the Week? Email writer Lennie Omalza at aloha@ or Lifestyle Editor Kathryn Gregory at kgregory@ WHAT: Presented by New Albany Main Street, this tour features some of New Albany's finest properties in its numerous historic neighborhoods. This self-guided tour offers a unique opportunity to explore interiors not typically open to the public while learning about the stories, styles, and preservation efforts behind each home. WHEN: Saturday, Sept. 13, 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. WHERE: Address of all tour properties will be shared upon ticket purchase. TICKETS: $20 in advance, $25 day of, $5 for students in grades K-12. Purchase tickets online with a credit card at MORE INFORMATION: Visit email info@ or call 812-941-0018. Owners: Anne and Matthew Phillips. Anne is a dietitian and Matthew is the chief technology officer for The Astro Technology Company. Also in the home is the couple's dog, Wilbur. Home: This is a three-bed, one-and-a-half bath, 1,800-square-foot, Queen Anne home in New Albany's East Spring Street Historic District. It was built in 1904. Distinctive elements: Original parquet floors in parlor, living room, and dining room; original pocket doors between parlor and living room and living room and kitchen; original heat vents throughout home; original windows in front of house and box gutters; original woodwork throughout house; original room numbers from when home was a boarding house; original milk cabinet in kitchen; distinct floor in attic from high-heat damage; small ventilation door in attic stairwell that overlooks stair case; handrail in attic stairway crafted from owner's Hungarian great grandmother's noodle pin that her great grandfather whittled; original bead-board storage cabinets in attic stairwell inspired renovation in kitchen, which features added bead-board elements and inspired cabinet latches; Taj Mahal Quartzite kitchen counters and backsplash.
Yahoo
12-08-2025
- Yahoo
Students will want universities to ‘understand context' over grades
School and college leavers will want universities to 'respect and understand' that they faced a 'significant' programme to deflate their GCSE grades following Covid-19, the Ucas chief has said. Jo Saxton, chief executive of the university admissions service, suggested that fewer students who are receiving their post-16 qualification results this summer met the entry requirements for A-level courses two years ago when grading was returned to pre-pandemic levels in England. Dr Saxton, who was chief regulator of England's exams regulator Ofqual from 2021 until 2023, has suggested that there could be 'higher' attainment across this year's A-level cohort as a result. Her comments come as students in England, Wales and Northern Ireland will receive their A-level and Level 3 BTec results on Thursday, with many finding out if they have secured a university place. Last year, more than a quarter (27.8%) of UK A-level entries were awarded an A or A* grade, up from 27.2% in 2023. It was the highest proportion of entries scoring top grades outside the pandemic-affected years of 2020-22. In 2019 – the last year that summer exams were taken before the pandemic – 25.4% of entries were awarded A or A* grades. The Covid-19 pandemic led to an increase in top A-level and GCSE grades in 2020 and 2021, with results based on teacher assessments instead of exams. Professor Alan Smithers, director of the Centre for Education and Employment Research at the University of Buckingham, has suggested that a higher percentage of UK A-level entries awarded top grades – compared with before the pandemic – could become the 'new normal' this summer. During a webinar hosted by the Higher Education Policy Institute think tank, Dr Saxton said: 'This cohort are the first to sit their Level 3 qualifications where they had the pre-pandemic standard reinstated on their GCSEs. 'I think that's just such an important backdrop for this whole cycle, just remembering this is that cohort, that there was a significant national programme to deflate their grades.' Dr Saxton, who was in charge at Ofqual when A-level and GCSE exams were reinstated in England following the pandemic, said she 'lost a lot of sleep' over the action to tackle grade inflation. But she suggested that teenagers told her that they wanted their exams back and they wanted their results to 'carry value'. Dr Saxton said: 'I think they will really be looking to those universities to respect and understand the context in which they've come through.' She said the return to pre-pandemic grading in 2023 meant 'fewer students than in recent years actually met the entry criteria that most schools and colleges would set for progression into A-level subjects'. Provisional exam entries data for England shows that A-level entries decreased by 0.4% from 825,355 last summer to 821,875 this summer, despite a 3.8% increase in the size of the 18-year-old population. Speaking just a few days before students receive their exam results, Dr Saxton added: 'It probably means that there's fractionally higher prior attainment across the cohort. This is me speculating as a former chief regulator.' Dr Saxton said clearing is no longer perceived as a 'bargain basement' for those who are not successful on A-level results day. Clearing is available to students who do not meet the conditions of their offer on A-level results day, as well as those who did not receive any offers. But prospective students who have changed their mind about what or where they wish to study, and also those who have applied outside the normal application window, can also use clearing. On Tuesday, the Ucas chief said: 'Clearing maybe was perceived as a bargain basement – it was for the people who had been unsuccessful. 'But that is definitely not how current applicants perceive it. 'For current applicants it's the mechanism by which they change their mind.' Nearly 22,700 courses with vacancies for undergraduate students living in England were available on the Ucas clearing site as of Wednesday last week – eight days before results day, a PA news agency analysis showed. A sample of 129 of the UK's largest higher education providers showed 17 of the 24 elite Russell Group universities had more than 3,600 courses with vacancies for English residents on clearing. Dr Saxton added: 'It is about students trusting their instincts and going back to their curated playlists, the favourites that they researched, that they've probably visited. 'They're not blindfolded throwing a dart at a dartboard.' Earlier this week, the Education Secretary said 'far too many young' white working-class British students do not get the exam results that they need to allow them to continue on to university. Bridget Phillipson told PA that the Post-16 White Paper and the Schools White Paper, which are both due in the autumn, will focus on turning around these 'thorny and generational challenges'. Dr Saxton said she would like the Government to look at regional disparities in access to and participation in higher education – such as the 'London advantage'. She said: 'More people in all parts of the country should get to benefit from higher education.'
Newsweek
30-07-2025
- Newsweek
Minefields Over Minecraft—Ukraine's Youth Robbed of Childhood Innocence
Things are getting worse in Ukraine these days. The frontline feels like a giant game of Pac-Man as Russians try to gobble up remote agrarian villages where hardscrabble families eke out a desperate living. Here, for children living in these villages, the horror is unimaginable. Miles of newly dug trenches and "dragon teeth," strings of cable connecting pyramidal cement blocks designed to stop tanks and armored vehicles, create a haunting maze across once-prized and meticulously tilled farmlands between villages and towns. For children, red signs and flagging mark field after field mined by the Russians. We crossed these structures carefully, led by local leaders connecting us with the neediest children and families. With schools closed and classes only online, a Ukrainian girl takes part in arts and crafts, here making hand prints in the blue and yellow colors of the national flag, in a program supported by... With schools closed and classes only online, a Ukrainian girl takes part in arts and crafts, here making hand prints in the blue and yellow colors of the national flag, in a program supported by UNICEF and the Howard Buffett Foundation, on January 22, 2025, in Izium, Ukraine. MoreMy recent trip was my twelfth to Ukraine since the war started in 2022. As a co-founder of the nonprofit Common Man for Ukraine, I've been all over the war-ravaged country, providing food, critical hygiene items, and at the holidays, small toys for children. We also provide residential trauma counseling retreats to children whose fathers have been killed in the war. Our volunteer convoys have crisscrossed Ukraine's vast landscape from Lviv to Kyiv, Odessa to Kherson, and on my recent trip, Kharkiv and 16 small villages at the Russian frontline. I've joined our convoys across more than 20,000 miles on unmarked, abandoned roads, highways and dirt paths, providing food to children living in safe houses and orphanages in western and central Ukraine. I've hugged thousands of children hiding from Russian kidnapping and bombing. These children are secreted away in hidden safe houses where brokenhearted mothers and fathers sent them in hopes that these precious children—Ukraine's progeny—would survive the war. In a brief moment of calm, Common Man for Ukraine Co-Founder Susan Mathison (bottom right) sits with children at a safe house in a frontline Ukrainian village in March 2025, after delivering food, clothes, and... In a brief moment of calm, Common Man for Ukraine Co-Founder Susan Mathison (bottom right) sits with children at a safe house in a frontline Ukrainian village in March 2025, after delivering food, clothes, and Beanie Babies. More Photo Courtesy of Common Man for Ukraine Typical now, as we arrived at a frontline village the air alert sirens blared loudly. Our air alert app indicated ongoing threats. We could hear concussive explosions just beyond the tree line to the east. And yet, quietly, calmly, hundreds of mothers, grandmothers, old men and hundreds of children waited for the food we could deliver to them. Food, hygiene items, and toys for the children. Messages of hope, love, and strength from people they will never know. After most of our food had been delivered, I entered the village's abandoned school. Bright walls were painted with bright flowers that no children see. The soggy floor sagged below the gaping hole in the roof. Shelling? Windows were blown out and a curtain flapped languidly in the breeze. A child's tiny blue plastic airplane rested on a once-perfectly painted windowsill, covered now in broken glass. There was no electricity here. And no teaching. The chalkboards were clean and the chairs pulled neatly to each desk. And, in a corner, a brightly colored booklet caught my eye. A comic book. Simple enough, in Ukrainian, and, ironically now, a USAID logo at the bottom. A partnership between the U.S. government and the Ukrainian children's agency. I flipped through the book. The pictures told the story of these children's terror. I gasped. With this March 2025 humanitarian supply convoy to Ukraine's frontline villages, nonprofit Common Man for Ukraine has delivered more than 4 million pounds of food to the children of war. Their 13th convoy is planned... With this March 2025 humanitarian supply convoy to Ukraine's frontline villages, nonprofit Common Man for Ukraine has delivered more than 4 million pounds of food to the children of war. Their 13th convoy is planned for August. More Photo Courtesy of Common Man for Ukraine Tiny drawings showed the bear with the bomb hidden gently inside the bear's fluffy tummy, ready to kill the child who ignored the warning. Another image showed an unexploded ammunition and mine in a pile of leaves, warning kids not to play. "Among the branches, fallen leaves, and under the snow in Ukraine, it is difficult to notice a strike." What child has not aimlessly kicked up a rustling pile of fun? For Ukrainian children, it might cost them a leg or a life. The comic book that Susan Mathison found on a recent trip to Ukraine. The comic book that Susan Mathison found on a recent trip to Ukraine. Photo Courtesy of Common Man for Ukraine Another page showed red and white triangles, explaining that this means the ground around them is mined. A child running, carefree in an open field of grass? Not in Ukraine, it says. The Russians have mined the fields that once hosted your games and your family's livelihood. Simple drawings, a comic book. For the youngest child to understand. To try to survive. To remember every second of the day. Air alerts. Bombing. Teddy bears with bombs. Fields designed to kill. The terror felt by Ukrainian children. Children who struggle to make sense of the senseless. These children, the ones that survive, the ones that we hope will live in a free and independent Ukraine, will need our help for decades to come. We've begun the work already, delivering thousands of tons of aid, providing trauma counseling, and reminding Ukrainians young and old, that Americans cannot and will not give up on them. Common Man for Ukraine, a nonprofit that is moving mountains in Ukraine, proves that everyday Americans care. We'll return for our thirteenth convoy in August. Every child deserves a comic book with a happy ending. Susan Mathison co-founded the New England-based grassroots nonprofit in 2022, serves as president of her local Habitat for Humanity chapter, and retired after a 30-year career at the USDA Forest Service. The views expressed in this article are the writer's own.
