Former Presbyterian minister reveals his congregation spied on him as dossier of complaints lies for three years
An Ex-Presbyterian minister has revealed that members of his own congregation spied on him.
The minister says he suffered a breakdown after discovering members of his flock tracked him over living arrangements dispute.
A surveillance rota was drawn up because of a belief he was not staying in a manse after a request to live in his own home was refused by the church.
According to a letter from the Information Commissioner's Office (ICO), the minister was being 'covertly monitored' for 'insurance purposes'.
That story broke after it was revealed that a dossier alleging inappropriate behaviour within the Presbyterian Church is still on the desk of an independent regulator — three years after it was submitted.
Former Alliance Leader Lord Alderdice says he is deeply frustrated that the dossier hasn't been reviewed.
The dossier was sent to the Charity Commission expressing concerns on the legitimacy of the church's charity status due to its alleged ill-treatment of some of those working for the church.
Ciarán Dunbar is joined by Sunday Life reporter Angela Davison.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Belfast Telegraph
12 hours ago
- Belfast Telegraph
‘I loved those kids as if they were mine': Childminder ‘broken' by Fermanagh shooting tragedy
Jenny Bowles also spoke of how the community has been 'broken' by the suspected triple murder and attempted suicide near Maguiresbridge. Vanessa Whyte (45) died along with her children James (14) and 13-year-old Sara. Last night hundreds gathered for a vigil in memory of the three. People wrapped their arms around each other at the event, which was organised by a community group and held at the local primary school that James and Sara once attended. First Minister Michelle O'Neill was among the crowd. Also present was Ms Bowles, who was childminder for James and Sara for eight years from when they were about three months old each. She said the tragedy has left the community shattered. 'Our family — we're just devastated,' she told the Belfast Telegraph. 'James and Sara were just like our own children. We treated them like our own family and they both were very fond of my own two boys, Jordan and Adam. 'James looked to Jordan and Adam as his brothers. They were his role models. 'Vanessa was such a lovely person, very hard-working and a very strong person. 'To describe her, she was just so lovely. James and Sara were great. They loved the outdoors. 'James loved machinery, especially the harvester at this time of the year. Sara loved the animals on the farm. 'They were big into their sports, and I know when we had James at our house he loved the football.' The shooting happened at a house near Maguiresbridge on Wednesday morning. Vanessa and Sara were pronounced dead at the scene. James died a short time later in the South West Acute Hospital from the injuries he sustained. A man remains in a critical condition at the Royal Victoria Hospital in Belfast. Describing her reaction to the tragedy, Ms Bowles added: 'I just went into complete shock. I couldn't even find the words to tell my husband. We are just heartbroken. 'Sara and James were just part of our family. They loved outdoors, and they would have rather been out helping and working, rather than sitting in, playing with toys. James absolutely loved getting out to help my husband in the workshop and making wee things out there or tidying up. 'They were just an exceptional family. Vanessa was just exceptional in every way, and so were the children. 'To describe the community, I would say... broken. 'James had really wanted to get to Enniskillen Royal Grammar School too, because Jordan and Adam had gone there, and he achieved that.' She also told how James had become an Arsenal supporter, because her own two sons were. Jenny added that the local community has been 'amazing' in the unity they've shown and praised the fact all denominations have been able to 'come together under some tragic circumstances'. Multiple clergy led the large crowds in prayer at the vigil, including Rev Rodney Beacom, a local Presbyterian minister; Passionist priest Brian D'Arcy, and the Church of Ireland's Rev Lindsey Farrell. A two-minute silence was held, with a poem read by the vice chairperson of Maguiresbridge Development Association, Sonya Smith. She recited: 'How do we go on? After the unthinkable happens, how can we carry the burden of knowing? The world can be cruel and dangerous, the future so unpredictable.' Also in attendance at the vigil was the local MP Pat Cullen, former MP Michelle Gildernew, and MLAs Aine Murphy, Jemma Dolan and Deborah Erskine. Agriculture Minister Andrew Muir was also there. Ms Whyte had worked for his department, and had recently been promoted to the most senior government vet within Co Fermanagh. Watch: DUP Leader Gavin Robinson pays respects to mother and children killed in Fermanagh shooting She had also formerly been part of the Maguiresbridge Running Club. Yesterday evening, some of its members remembered her as being 'full of life' and 'very determined'. 'Just for someone so ordinary, so hardworking, the soul of the community and of so many different clubs and in a cross-community capacity — she didn't deserve that,' one member said. Another said that the running club's route often takes them past the family's house, noting that 'it will never be the same' each time they pass it now. Many people stayed after the vigil for hours, queuing to sign the book of condolences that has been set up for members of the public to pay their respects to Ms Whyte and her children. Members of all ages from St Mary's Maguiresbridge Gaelic football club, and Lisbellaw Hurling Club, of which all three shooting victims were 'active and beloved' members, walked together to the vigil from the local GAA pitch. St Mary's described Sara as 'a joy to be around and always had a smile on her face'. The club said that James, who was captain of the under-14 team this year, 'was the heartbeat of our team and he had the confidence to be vocal and show leadership to younger team members'. They said that Ms Whyte 'had a passion for our games that encompassed everything good about the GAA showing dedication, sportsmanship, and camaraderie, and it was clear to see how Vanessa instilled these same values in her children'. James and Sara both attended Enniskillen Royal, and the school announced that it will be open all of next week for any of its students or other young people that need help and support.
Scottish Sun
a day ago
- Scottish Sun
Shamed Gregg Wallace says ‘I'm no groper, sex pest or flasher,' as tearful star refuses to accept blame for BBC sacking
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) FORMER MasterChef host Gregg Wallace has pleaded his innocence, telling The Sun in a tearful interview: 'I'm not a groper, a sex pest or a flasher.' The 60-year-old, sacked by the BBC after a probe into allegations of bad behaviour, said he wanted to clear his name but is 'not looking to play the victim'. 12 In a tearful interview with The Sun, former MasterChef host Gregg Wallace has pleaded his innocence Credit: Dan Charity 12 Wallace says he has been unfairly bracketed with sex offenders Jimmy Savile and Huw Edwards Credit: Dan Charity 12 Gregg has also backed axed co-host John Torode, saying: 'he's not a racist' Wallace says he has been unfairly bracketed with sex offenders Jimmy Savile and Huw Edwards, adding: 'That's so horrific.' The ex-MasterChef host spoke out in his first interview since the BBC sacked him following complaints from multiple women over several years. He says: 'There's so much that I want to say, and so much that I want to put right, if I can. 'I'm not saying I'm not guilty of stuff, but so much has been perceived incorrectly. Things that really hurt me and hurt my family.' Wallace — who has not been paid for this interview — adds from his home in Kent: 'I'm not a groper. People think I've been taking my trousers down and exposing myself — I am not a flasher. 'People think I'm a sex pest. I am not. I am not sexist or a misogynist, or any of it. 'There never were any accusations of sexual harassment. 'I have seen myself written about in the same sentence as Jimmy Savile and Huw Edwards, paedophiles and sex offenders. That is just so, so horrific.' He adds from his sitting room, dotted with photos of wife Anna and six-year-old son Sid: 'I have learnt a lot about myself over the past eight months or so, and I'm still learning. 'I know I have said things that offended people, that weren't socially acceptable and perhaps they felt too intimidated or nervous to say anything at the time. 'We'll never work with him again', blast BBC as Gregg Wallace report reveals 'substantial' allegations over 19 YEARS 'I understand that now — and to anyone I have hurt, I am so sorry. 'I don't expect anyone to have any sympathy with me but I don't think I am a wrong 'un.' During our interview, Wallace flips between anger and remorse, and bursts into tears when talking about the fall-out for his family. He also backs axed MasterChef co-host John Torode, saying: 'He's not a racist.' The report into Wallace's conduct, from law firm Lewis Silkin, saw 45 of 83 complaints upheld. In total, 41 people complained. I've worked with around 4,000 people - cast, crew, production - which means 0.5 per cent of people found fault with me Gregg Wallace But he says: 'I've worked with around 4,000 people — cast, crew, production — which means 0.5 per cent of people found fault with me. 'That means in a room of 200 people, one person complained about my knob joke. It sounds a lot, but you have to consider that I don't work in an office.' However, Wallace does accept that this 0.5 per cent is too many. The timeline of allegations does not make for pretty reading. 12 The ex-MasterChef host, 60, was sacked by the BBC following complaints from multiple women over several years Credit: Dan Charity 12 I'm not a groper, a sex pest or a flasher, said Gregg in his first interview since his axe Credit: Dan Charity 12 During the chat, Wallace flipped between anger and remorse, and even bursted into tears Credit: Dan Charity One of the worst, which was upheld, was that he groped a woman. Wallace claims he was attempting to flirt, recalling: 'It was 15 years ago. Me, drunk, at a party, with my hand on a girl's bum. 'This girl told me about an affair she was having with a married man who was part of the Conservative government. I can't remember who it was. 'She gave me her phone number. I considered that to be intimacy. I was single at the time . . . well, I was dating, but I wasn't married. Now, even in the report, it says, 'Gregg believes this contact to be consensual'. So, listen, drag me out into the marketplace and stone me now.' 'Jovial and crude' Wallace is also keen to point out that he isn't a flasher. The moment he paraded around the MasterChef studio with a sock on his willy has been heavily reported. He says: 'Yes, that's one of the three upheld, the one with a sock on. Can I clarify what that is though? That was 18 years ago. The studio is shut, there's no contestants.' He said outside his dressing-room door was a sofa with four of his mates from the show on it, including Monica Galetti. He went on: 'I was getting changed to go to a black tie event, a charity event. I put my bow tie on and my shirt. It's only them outside the door. I put the sock on, opened the door, went, 'Wahey!' and shut the door again. 'The people interviewed were either amused or bemused. Nobody was distressed.' He takes a dimmer view of other allegations, including claims he dropped his trousers in front of a lady named as Alice by a BBC News investigation. He rages: 'That really damaged me. In the investigation, it says this person's story is simply not credible.' Wallace accepts he regularly got changed in front of people, and showed off his six-pack. One of the main threads of the upheld accusations is the use of sexualised or inappropriate language. He accepts all of these - and blames his background. It was 15 years ago. Me, drunk, at a party, with my hand on a girl's bum Gregg Wallace Wallace insists: 'I'm a green-grocer from Peckham. 'I thrived in Covent Garden's Fruit and Veg Market. 'In that environment that is jovial and crude. It is learned behaviour. 'And that's exactly the persona I brought into the workplace. Nobody ever asked me to change. 'MasterChef was a big hit. They gave me Celebrity MasterChef. That's a big hit. They gave me Professional MasterChef. It's a big hit. They gave me Eat Well for Less. They gave me Inside the Factory. I've got five returnable series. 'They're all big hits, and every day I'm giving them what I think they want. It's jokes, it's banter. 'It's relaxing virtually everybody I work with and we're getting good interaction with them.' 12 Gregg, above with The Sun's Clemmie Moodie, says he's been scared to go out since the scandal broke Credit: Dan Charity 12 Wallace pictured at his home in Kent with wife Anna Credit: Dan Charity 12 He accepts the upheld accusations of use of sexualised or inappropriate language, blaming his background Credit: Dan Charity In January Wallace was formally diagnosed with autism, and he admits he is 'learning every day' about it. He sticks by his awkward claim that his refusal to wear underwear was down to that. Devastated by backlash Wallace says: 'I never wear pants', before raising his short- covered leg as if to demonstrate. 'I'm not wearing socks either.' I tell him to keep his leg down. Bemused he adds: 'Somehow everybody has sexualised this as well. It's not sexualised. It's hypersensitivity — that happens with autism.' Autism charities have dropped him, with some saying it is not 'a hall-pass for bad behaviour'. Wallace understands but has been devastated by the backlash. Having spent two-and-a-half hours with him, I believe he is severely on the spectrum. He repeatedly tells me off for interrupting — fair enough — and he is adamant we start the interview his way, which sees him nervously reading scribbled-down thoughts from scraps of paper. I arrived at his home not expecting to like him but left liking him. He peppers every conversation with slightly painful jokes, including: 'What do you call a judge with no thumbs? Justice Fingers!' Another sees him making a curled-finger hand gesture, asking: 'What is this? A microwave!' I know I am odd. I know I struggle to read people. I know people find me weird. Autism is a disability, a registered disability Gregg Wallace I'm still none the wiser. He is like a schoolboy desperate to please without being malicious. I previously wrote about a bruising encounter on a journalists' special of MasterChef in 2014 in which I'd accused him of making me feel deeply uncomfortable. I read out some of my criticism, saying I felt he 'gas-lit' me. Wallace appears confused as he asks me what that means. He replies after a beat: 'I'm sorry if I made you feel uncomfortable. "We were playing pantomime roles, I was playing up to it. I had no idea you felt that way, I honestly struggle to read people. 'I know I am odd. I know I struggle to read people. I know people find me weird. Autism is a disability, a registered disability. Just because you can't see it doesn't mean it's not real.' One of the claims that hurt him most — and saw him trolled mercilessly — was when Sir Rod Stewart publicly said he had bullied his wife Penny Lancaster on Celebrity MasterChef four years ago. He says it was not upheld, adding: 'It was us having a disagreement over whether an orchid should stay in a bowl of soup.' Sighing, he goes on: 'I'm actually a Rod Stewart fan. I've been to see him twice. So that hurt me. Somebody like that carries a lot of weight. But there was no bullying and no harassing.' 12 Wallace, who was formally diagnosed with autism in January, says he is 'learning every day' about it Credit: Dan Charity DAVIE WON'T MIX WITH LIKES OF ME By Clemmie Moodie BBC Director-General Tim Davie failed to get in touch with Gregg Wallace after his sacking, he claims. Wallace also hit out at the decision to pay off disgraced newsreader Huw Edwards. And he accused the organisation of being out of touch with working-class people. He said: 'I haven't heard from Tim at all. 'I think people like Tim were told that if they worked hard at school, they wouldn't have to mix with people like me. 'The BBC right now, absolutely everybody's been to Guatemala and nobody's been to Lewisham. 'I don't have an uncle who works for the BBC who's doing me any favours. They gave me big shows and they were all a success. So it was a massive shock to me in 2018 to find that what I was doing could cause problems.' Wallace was dismissed by production firm Banijay and did not receive a pay-out. While not disputing this, he is angry they paid off Edwards. He added: 'Huw Edwards received a £200,000 pay off after he was arrested — I didn't get so much as a pat on the back and a tenner. 'I'm not complaining, I'm pointing out a fact. I'm not looking to play the victim.' There was also a 2018 complaint from his time on BBC One's Impossible Celebrities, where he told a female employee she was 'very bright and very pretty' and was 'rude' to the show's production runners. He says: 'I asked for a healthy lunch and they gave me a packaged sandwich I didn't want so I was a bit cross.' Another complaint referred to him asking a model what she ate in a day to stay so thin. The BBC sent him on a course which was, he claims, like 'telling someone with a heart condition to go and fix their own heart rate'. I'm scared' He adds: 'They told me about how to interact with young people. 'My problem was that I saw myself the same as them, but they weren't perceiving me the same as them. They saw me as a position of authority. So I was being too familiar and I was told I shouldn't try to talk to them about what they might be doing at the weekend or where they're going on holiday because I might be forcing them to converse with me on personal details that they might not want to give. 'And I didn't know I was autistic at the time. So all that did was just confuse the living daylights out of me. So from that point on, I just stopped talking to young people because I realised that I was working in a complaints culture. 'And if I could get in serious trouble for telling a girl she was attractive, what would happen if I went out drinking with people and said something political or sexual? 'So I just stopped talking to young people. In fact, I stopped socialising on MasterChef. It just panicked me.' From then on, there was only one allegation of inappropriate behaviour. Wallace has, he says, spent the past seven years 'hiding behind my sofa reading history books'. My biggest, biggest regret is that I ever went anywhere near a television studio - I was doing just fine as a greengrocer Gregg Wallace Since the scandal broke, he says he has been scared to go out 'in case people, who think I'm a sex pest, abuse me in the street'. He went on: 'The first time I went to the gym afterwards I was shaking. I have been so scared. I go out now in a disguise — a baseball cap and sunglasses, I don't want people to see me. I'm scared.' Wallace also admits a level of guilt for what happened to his Aussie co-star John, who had an allegation of racism upheld against him during the investigation. He storms: 'I've known John for 30 years and he is not a racist. 'And as evidence of that, I'll show you the incredible diversity of the people that he has championed, MasterChef winners, over the years. There is no way that man is a racist. No way. And my sympathies go out to John because I don't want anybody to go through what I've been through.' Following the investigation, Wallace unfollowed John and his wife Lisa Faulkner on social media. He says: 'We never really did get on that well. 'We're two very, very different characters. But we made bloody good telly together for 20 years.' Wallace says that the only positive from this is getting to spend more time with his non-verbal autistic son Sid. He admits he wished he had stayed in his former profession instead of embarking on a TV career. He says: 'My biggest, biggest regret is that I ever went anywhere near a television studio — I was doing just fine as a greengrocer." 12 Wallace also admits a level of guilt for what happened to his Aussie co-star John Credit: BBC 12 Wallace says that the only positive from this scandal is getting to spend more time with his non-verbal autistic son Sid Credit: Rex
Metro
a day ago
- Metro
E-bike rider who knocked down pensioner is chased down by hero bystanders
To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video An e-bike rider was caught red-handed after crashing into a woman and leaving her bleeding on the road. Grandmother Margaret Scaldwell was left fighting for her life after ex-footballer Kian Monks, 22, crashed into her in Wigan as she was crossing the road. Ms Scaldwell was in a coma for weeks with life-changing injuries after Monks sped at her with a powerful electric dirt bike on August 1, 2023. Monks, then aged 19 and who only had a provisional licence, was caught by an angry mob that chased after the bloodied rider as he cowered in a nearby alleyway. He has now been given a 22-month prison sentence at Bolton Crown Court after pleading guilty to a host of driving offences, including failing to stop at the scene to help Ms Scaldwell. Ms Scaldwell, then in her 60s, said the crash left her 'no longer living' and she is 'just existing' after the crash robbed her of being an 'independent lady who always had a smile on my face.' Following the crash, she struggles to eat as she lost her teeth and has to sleep in her lounge downstairs as she cannot climb stairs. The crash happened as the ex-Wigan Athletic player sped through Orell Road with a Talaria Sting electric motorbike with a friend sitting behind him. He was speeding at 40mph in a 30mph zone. CCTV footage shows Ms Scaldwell suddenly stopping in her tracks as she is about to cross the residential road. But the speed of the e-bike left her no chance to escape from the head-on crash. The grandmother was sent flying through the air for several metres and hit her head on the pavement. Ms Scaldwell broke her leg, bones in both arms and her pelvis, and had several broken ribs and suffered severe facial injuries. Monks and his friend, Joel Pilling, fled the scene, but bystanders chased Monks and began filming him. He is seen leaning against the wall without his shoes with blood pouring down his face as the bystanders surround and restrain him. He says before getting up and trying to leave: 'I wasn't driving, it wasn't me. I've hit my head. I've hurt my head and my jaw.' Pilling, who was 20 at the time and owned the bike but had no licence, later turned himself in at a police station. Ms Scaldwell said in a statement after the sentencing: 'These men's selfishness have ruined my life. 'Before the collision I was an independent lady and always had a smile on my face. 'Now my life is dehumanising, reduced to a long list of hospital appointments with no end in sight and I can no longer walk wash or feed myself. 'No sentence will bring back my health. But I will not let them beat me as I am determined to recover the best I can.' Monks was jailed for two years and three months over causing serious injury by dangerous driving, dangerous driving and driving with no licence or insurance. He was banned from driving for four years, and he was also found guilty of failing to stop at the scene, failing to report a crash and failing to provide a specimen following a serious collision. Pilling was given a 22-month prison sentence, suspended for two years, for causing serious injury by dangerous driving, dangerous driving, and driving with no licence or insurance. He was also ordered to do 250 hours of unpaid work and banned from behind the wheel for two years. Detective Constable Steve Pennington from our Serious Collision Investigation Unit said: 'This was a shocking incident where two individuals recklessly rode an e-bike through one of Wigan's busiest areas with complete disregard for public safety. More Trending 'Their dangerous driving resulted in a horrific collision with a grandmother who was simply crossing the road. She suffered life-changing injuries and spent weeks in a coma – it's nothing short of miraculous that she survived. 'This incident highlights the severe consequences of operating e-bikes illegally on our roads. These aren't toys – they're powerful vehicles that require proper licensing, safety equipment, and responsible handling. 'Riding without these essentials isn't just breaking the law, it's putting lives at risk.' Electric motorbikes like the Talaria Sting model are legal on the UK roads, but they are considered motor vehicles, so riders need a licence and insurance. Pedal e-bikes are also legal – although controversial – as long as the bike is propelled with pedals and the speed is limited to 15.5mph. Riders' minimum age is 14. Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at webnews@ For more stories like this, check our news page. MORE: Bus roof torn off after it crashed into bridge leaving passenger fighting for life in Eccles MORE: Family pays tribute to man, 58, killed in M60 motorbike crash MORE: Officer at centre of Manchester Airport 'assault' says Taser push on mother's face 'justified'
