Advocate hopes review of N.B. right-to-information law strengthens legislation
The Liberal government has asked for public submissions on its election promise to modernize legislation governing the public's right to obtain information from provincial departments and agencies.
The Centre for Law and Democracy last year ranked New Brunswick's freedom-to-information system as one of the two worst in Canada, along with Alberta's.
Residents who are denied access to a government document or record can appeal to New Brunswick's information commissioner.
But Toby Mendel, director of the law and democracy centre, said in an interview Tuesday a key weakness is that the information commissioner can only recommend that a department or agency release information. Citizens are then forced into expensive court proceedings when governments don't comply.
Mendel said he hopes New Brunswick will consider an appeal system like Newfoundland and Labrador's, where the onus is on departments and agencies to go to court if they wish to reject the commissioner's recommendations.
'In Newfoundland and Labrador, when the commissioner makes a decision, the public body either has to follow that decision or go to court to contest it … We believe it is a good model for small jurisdictions like New Brunswick,' Mendel said.
The Newfoundland and Labrador model is mentioned in New Brunswick's discussion paper on its existing information legislation. The paper provides questions for the Liberal government to consider, including if some of the exemptions that departments can use to refuse document requests need to be dropped or revised.
The law and democracy centre says exemptions are too numerous and too broad. 'We see a lot of exceptions (to releasing information) that are on the face of it illegitimate,' Mendel said.
New Brunswick's Green Leader David Coon says the province's Right to Information Act has 'degenerated' over the past 15 years.
One of the more problematic changes to the law, Coon said, is the restriction that government records that include 'advice' to a minister can no longer be requested by the public. For example, he said, the work that consultants do for government, or reports to departments, can be interpreted as 'advice' to a minister.
That change, he said, 'has been used extensively to keep lots of documents … a lot of reports, secret.'
Nicole O'Byrne, an associate professor at University of New Brunswick's faculty of law, called the existing access to information system in New Brunswick 'slow and cumbersome,' adding that it can require months to appeal a decision.
Government departments and agencies are often swamped by broad requests for information, which can take long to process, she added. She also suggested that departments and agencies be proactive and release more information without the need for the public to make formal requests to access it.
O'Byrne commended the provincial government for its review. 'Citizens have every right to demand accountability from their elected representatives. This is a fundamental cornerstone of our democracy.'
This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 29, 2025.
— By Michael Tutton in Halifax and Hina Alam in Fredericton.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
15 minutes ago
Where does Carney stand on Canada's 2030 climate targets? It's not clear
Prime Minister Mark Carney is facing mounting pressure to act on climate change amid another near-record-shattering wildfire season and scorching hot summer. But five months after taking Canada's top political job, it's unclear whether he will pursue his Liberal predecessor's deep emissions cuts. Carney will need to make up his mind quickly, as the country is about to face a critical test. Canada has five years to meet or come as close as possible to achieving its international climate commitments. LISTEN | Where does Carney stand on climate targets? (new window) Those legally binding targets require the country to slash carbon pollution and other planet-warming gases by at least 40 per cent below 2005 levels by 2030. It is going to take a really heavy lift at this point, said the country's top climate adviser, Simon Donner, told CBC Radio's The House (new window) . Donner is co-chair of the independent Net Zero Advisory Body, an expert group that provides independent advice to the government on achieving net zero emissions by 2050. What is net-zero? Check out CBC's climate glossary (new window) There's a lot of things in this world that are uncertain at this time, but I think it's a safe prediction … that we will not meet that target, said Serge Dupont, a former deputy minister at Natural Resources Canada. The targets were perhaps overly ambitious to start with.… I think it's still important we make a valiant effort to go as far as we can, but we're not going to meet that target, he said. Environment and Climate Change Minister Julie Dabrusin was not available for an interview. But in a statement, her office said Canada is committed to reaching net-zero emissions by 2050. We strive towards our 2030 and 2035 targets, Keean Nembhard, press secretary for the minister, wrote in a statement. He said the government would provide an update on its emissions reduction plan. Targets slipping out of reach The federal government's January greenhouse gas projections show that Canada will fall short of its climate targets. As the data shows, the country is on pace to miss its interim 2026 target, reducing emissions by only 16 per cent by 2026 — short of the 20 per cent required. Moreover, modelling also shows Canada will miss its 2030 target — potentially even further than currently projected now that the carbon tax is gone. Enlarge image (new window) Source: Environment Canada Photo: CBC All we know that is happening is that we've been removing existing climate policies, Donner said. Removing the federal carbon tax and the requirement for provinces to either use it or have their own was one of Carney's first acts as prime minister. According to one analysis, the measure has been responsible for reducing carbon pollution by less than seven per cent. One group upset with the way the federal government is addressing global warming is Last Generation. The group uses civil disobedience to demand action on climate change. When CBC News caught up with the small group of activists, they were leaving their mark near downtown Ottawa on a summer evening. Members were postering across the University of Ottawa campus in defiance of at least one warning not to do so. We're hoping that this is going to get our name out there and teach people that they can fight the climate crisis directly instead of relying on politicians who have failed us time and time again, said Benjamin Welchner, one of the organizers with Last Generation. The group has taken part in more provocative non-violent civil disobedience, such as graffiti that says Oil Kills in bright pink letters, dousing a Tesla dealership in paint and climbing Montreal's Jacques-Cartier Bridge (new window) . The group, modelled on Britain's Just Stop Oil, has a specific ask: the creation of a national climate disaster agency. Gains offset by fossil fuel industry Amid the view that the world and Canada are not doing enough to reduce their carbon footprint, it's worth noting that 10 years ago, projections for global warming were far worse. In 2015, Canada's emissions were trending to exceed greenhouse gas emission levels for 2005, the baseline year from which Canada measures progress. Canada's electricity sector has led the way in decarbonization, slashing the sector's emissions by half. However, these gains have been offset by considerable increases in oil and gas production. The industry accounts for Canada's largest share of emissions and it has increased by 11 per cent since 2005. How Carney will tackle concerns that fossil fuel companies have not done their fair share remains unclear. But sitting on the table are two unfinished Trudeau-era climate policies — enhanced methane regulations and an oil and gas emissions cap. We haven't seen [the Carney government] prepared to abandon any goals right now, said Oliver Anderson, who was director of communications for former environment minister Steven Guilbeault. Anderson is now the vice president of communications and growth at the water charity AquaAction. We need to see what it is that they are going to change in order to get us to that end still. Carney has signalled an openness to listing a bitumen pipeline as part of the list of projects in the national interest that his government could fast-track. He has been supportive of renewable energy projects as well. His government's major projects legislation, C-5, enables the federal cabinet to approve what they deem to be nation-building projects before a federal environmental assessment or Indigenous consultation is complete. Asked about how a pipeline could impact Canada's emissions goals, Donner, the country's top climate adviser, suggested proponents and governments should avoid backing assets that could become stranded. WATCH | Carney ends the consumer carbon tax: The question we need to ask ourselves is who is that oil being shipped to in the year 2040, in the year 2045, when the world is shifting away from using gasoline and passenger vehicles? Donner said. Others believe we could see a shift with Carney, who, unlike Trudeau, doesn't see climate change as everything policy, according to Shannon Joseph, the chair of Energy for A Secure Future. It was [Trudeau's] economic policy, it was the foreign policy, it was the housing policy, Joseph said. People feel the pinch and so they've changed the priorities, and I think we're going to end up with a better, more measured solution. But Dupont, the former Natural Resources deputy minister, believes the government needs to recalibrate its climate target for a new reality. There's a wider set of issues at play here for Canadians, he said. Those issues, according to Dupont, who is now the head of public policy at the law firm Bennett Jones, include a softening of both economic growth and public support for green policies. The Carney government will eventually have to come clean on how and if it can meet Canada's climate targets. It's legally required to do so under the Canadian Net-Zero Emissions Accountability Act. David Thurton (new window) · CBC News · Senior reporter, Parliamentary Correspondent David Thurton is a senior reporter in CBC's Parliamentary Bureau. He covers daily politics in the nation's capital and specializes in environment and energy policy. Born in Canada but raised in Trinidad and Tobago, he's moved around more times than he can count. He's worked for CBC in several provinces and territories, including Alberta and the Northwest Territories. He can be reached at LinkedIn (new window) Twitter (new window)
National Observer
4 hours ago
- National Observer
Many public servants ran for federal office in last election — only one of them made it
Out of the many federal public servants who ran as candidates in the last federal election, only one was elected: Caroline Desrochers, the Liberal member of Parliament for Trois-Rivières, Que. Originally from Montreal, Desrochers worked at Global Affairs Canada for almost 25 years; her first posting was in Haiti. She later worked for about a decade on Canada-US relations and was posted to New York during US President Donald Trump's first mandate. During that time, she worked on the first round of tariffs and the renegotiation of the North American trade pact. "I always knew one day I would want to do that," Desrochers said of entering politics, adding that she was interested in doing work that felt closer to people. "For me, it was important to have a solid experience to come and do this kind of work." Desrochers ran for the Liberals in the La Prairie riding in 2021 but was defeated by Bloc Québécois candidate Alain Therrien. Desrochers said her experience in dealing with the Americans on steel and aluminum tariffs and her outreach with the US Congress will be valuable in this "consequential" moment. Many public servants ran for federal office in the spring — only one of them made it. She said she's also interested in working on economic development and industry issues, noting the presence of a federal port and a large steel and aluminum industry in her new riding. This is the first time the Trois-Rivières riding has been held by a Liberal since the 1980s. It has been held most recently by Conservative, Bloc and NDP members of Parliament. The Public Service Commission of Canada gave 54 federal public servants permission to run in the recent federal election. Federal government employees who want to run in federal, provincial, territorial or municipal elections need to get permission from the commission, said a commission spokesperson. Before that permission can be granted, the commission has to be satisfied that there are no risks to the political impartiality of the public service. More federal public servants showed interest in running in the recent election than in previous years. The commission received requests from 65 public servants for permission to run in the 2025 campaign — 11 later withdrew their requests. The commission received 29 requests from public servants for permission to run in 2021, and 44 in 2019. The commission granted 38 requests in 2015 and 12 in 2011. The commission says it doesn't have data on the total number of requests filed in those years. While she's keen to work on economic issues and housing — she's now parliamentary secretary to the minister of housing and infrastructure — Desrochers said she also wants to be part of ongoing conversations about modernizing the public service. While Prime Minister Mark Carney promised during the election to "cap," not cut, the size of the public service, most departments and agencies have since been asked to find program spending cuts of up to 15 per cent by 2028-29. A recent report by the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives said the public service could shed almost 60,000 jobs over the next four years as Ottawa looks to cut costs. Desrochers — who worked on transforming Global Affairs Canada before the election — said she believes the public service needs to be trimmed down to make it more efficient. She said that complex processes and multiple levels of bureaucracy are slowing down the work of government. "We owe that to the Canadian public, to be more efficient in how we do things," she said. Reducing the size of the public service will be "a dance" and will "take some coordination," Desrochers said, because people retiring or leaving for other opportunities may not be working in the places where cuts are most needed. Desrochers also said that the ratio of executives to non-executives is "quite high" in some departments and the plan seems to be to cut back in that area as well. The Carney government has struck a new cabinet committee focused on government transformation. Desrochers said she already has started to engage with colleagues on that committee. "It's important that we get it right," she said. "I hope it can be a constructive conversation also with the public service." Desrochers said there will also be a "conversation" if some departments are unable to achieve their targets without cutting essential items and services. She said some departments may be able to cut deeper than others, which could allow other departments to make smaller cuts. Desrochers said her main focus when Parliament returns will be housing, particularly for students. She said she's also working on the new Build Canada Homes initiative promised by the Liberals during the election. Desrochers said the government is exploring options for Build Canada Homes, which could become a separate agency or a unit within Housing, Infrastructure and Communities Canada. "We're going to start doing work right now with what we have already, the programs that we have, and then we're going to see about what's the best governance of it, but our goal is really to not create more layers of bureaucracy and approvals," she said. "This is why you do politics … to work on something that is going to have impact on people. And so, I think to have the privilege of working on that is really, it's really awesome."
National Observer
5 hours ago
- National Observer
Carney maintains positive approval rating despite the summer cooldown: poll
Prime Minister Mark Carney 's popularity may be cooling off in the summer but remains broadly positive, a new poll from Abacus Data suggests. The Carney-led Liberal government's approval rating dipped to 50 per cent in the firm's latest polling, down two percentage points compared to mid-July and the lowest level since March. With 48 per cent viewing Carney favourably and 19 per cent disapproving, the prime minister maintains a positive net approval. That figure is a couple percentage points lower than in Abacus's previous poll. Abacus CEO David Coletto said in a statement accompanying the new poll that Carney's drop in popularity could be tied to a lack of perceived progress on key domestic files and ongoing high-profile international negotiations. Canadians were surveyed in the week after US President Donald Trump levied new 35 per cent tariffs on Canada — seemingly a consequence of failing to secure a new trade deal by the Aug. 1 deadline. Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre, who will attempt to regain a seat in the House of Commons in an Alberta byelection slated for Aug. 18, meanwhile broke even on his approval ratings. At 42 per cent positive and 41 per cent negative, Coletto said the results were Poilievre's "best net rating in months." Trump maintains a largely negative perception among Canadians at a net approval rating of -62. Despite a modest cooldown for the Liberals, political preference has been largely unchanged through the summer. The Abacus poll suggests that if an election were held today, the Liberals would secure 43 per cent of votes from decided voters and Conservatives would land 40 per cent. Those figures are unchanged from mid-July, while the remaining federal parties secured single-digit support from decided voters in the survey. "Support for the governing Liberals remains strong, vote intentions haven't moved, and the desire for change is static," Coletto said. "In short: no new movement, no new momentum." Coletto said that, for now, Canadians are separating frustration on key files from blame on the government, but that could change, particularly as domestic economic issues top voter concerns. Cost of living remains the dominant issue identified by 62 per cent of Canadians, up from 59 per cent in Abacus's previous poll. Dealing with the Trump administration was the second-place priority at 44 per cent, followed by the broader economy, housing affordability and health care to round out the top five. Abacus Data surveyed 1,686 Canadians from July 31 to Aug. 7. A comparable probability-based random sample of the same size would come with a margin error of +/- 2.4 per cent, 19 times out of 20. This report by The Canadian Press was first published Aug. 10, 2025.
