Appeals Court rules DOGE can access sensitive federal data
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit ruled in a 2-1 decision that unions looking to bar DOGE from accessing sensitive data at the Treasury Department, Office of Personnel Management and Department of Education were unlikely to succeed on the merits as they argued that the move would be a violation of federal privacy laws.
In March, U.S. District Judge Deborah Boardman prevented DOGE from accessing troves of personal data at the three agencies of around 2 million plaintiffs.
A month later, in April, a panel of judges on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 4th Circuit issued a pause, in a 2-1 ruling, on Boardman's decision to lessen the DOGE's access to personal data.
Five union organizations, including the National Federation of Federal Employees and the American Federation of Teachers, along with six Americans, sued the three agencies over DOGE's access to personal data.
Judge Julius N. Richardson, an appointee of President Trump, and Judge G. Steven Agee, a former President George W. Bush appointee, were in the majority. Judge Robert B. King, an appointee of former President Clinton, dissented.
'Contrary to the panel majority, the district court did exactly what it was obliged to do. Specifically, in its thorough and cogent Opinion, the district court separately assessed the plaintiffs' likelihood of success on the contested merits issues — i.e., whether the plaintiffs possess Article III standing to pursue their APA claim, whether there was a final agency action for purposes of APA jurisdiction, whether the APA claim is otherwise precluded by the existence of an adequate remedy under the Privacy Act, and whether the Privacy Act's need-to-know exception renders lawful the disclosure of personally identifiable information to DOGE,' King wrote in his dissent.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indianapolis Star
17 minutes ago
- Indianapolis Star
The EPA wants to rollback climate regulations. Here's how Hoosiers can have a say.
Hoosiers have limited time to voice their opinions as the U.S. EPA prepares to roll back rules meant to curb the effects of greenhouse gas emissions. The announcement in Indianapolis last month to rescind a major climate rule was one of the Trump administration's many pushes to deregulate major greenhouse gas polluters — in this case, the transportation industry. And with a rich history of auto manufacturing, Indiana stands to benefit, according to a statement made by U.S. Rep. Jim Baird during the announcement. Meanwhile, Americans will become more vulnerable, said Shannon Anderson, the director of advocacy at Earth Charter Indiana. While greenhouse gas emissions are not directly toxic to human health, they are the driver behind human-caused climate change, which is exacerbating the frequency and intensity of natural disasters across the globe. 'People sometimes feel like climate change is a problem that's coming later, but we're starting to experience it now,' Anderson said. She pointed to extreme heat events and increased flooding across the continent. Sam Carpenter, the executive director of the Hoosier Environmental Council, warned denial of climate science is bad for individual Hoosiers, communities, and the economy. The EPA has regulated greenhouse gases for over 15 years, but now the agency wants to quash a 2009 ruling that anchors its ability to fight climate change. The agency will no longer regulate greenhouse gas emissions from power plants or oil and gas operations. And all greenhouse gas standards for new motor vehicles and motor vehicle engines will be repealed, according to the EPA. Before the ruling is finalized, the public has until Sept. 15, 2025, to submit comments on the proposal. Indiana's greenhouse gas emissions — which come from compounds like carbon and methane — are hefty compared to similar states. Indiana releases the most energy-related greenhouse gases per capita in the Midwest and eighth in the nation, according to the HEC. About 21 percent of Indiana's total emissions come from the state's transportation sector. But as a desire to mitigate climate change impacted consumer choice and federal policy, like the Inflation Reduction Act, Indiana became a leader in electric vehicle manufacturing. Related industries now employ over 240,000 Hoosiers. The repeal of greenhouse gas emission standards could reduce the incentives helping Indiana pursue electric vehicles and battery manufacturing. 'We were starting to get a foothold in the U.S. under the Inflation Reduction Act, and Indiana has benefited mightily from those investments,' said Carpenter of HEC, nodding to the state's push toward clean energy. 'That's all being kind of pushed away through the current stance of denial on climate change. And so, it really has impacts on our health, on our communities, and in our economy.' Despite the agency's new stance on regulating greenhouse gases, 74 percent of Americans think that carbon dioxide should be regulated as a pollutant, according to the Yale Program on Climate Change Communication. Anderson thinks the EPA will soon have to face the masses during the required public comment period, where the agency must consider input before the ruling is finalized. 'We know there are so many Americans who stand with us on this issue, and it won't even take all of them to speak out on this, but as many as possible that are willing to just take a minute to write a public comment, to send a message to their legislators, that can be tremendously powerful,' Anderson said. The EPA is "going to have to acknowledge that they are flying in the face of overwhelming public consensus.' The public can submit written comments to the EPA through an online portal, email or by mail. Earth Charter Indiana also created a toolkit to help Hoosiers find out how to comment and contact their elected officials. Comments are due Sept. 15, 2025. IndyStar's environmental reporting project is made possible through the generous support of the nonprofit Nina Mason Pulliam Charitable Trust.
NBC News
43 minutes ago
- NBC News
How Trump's EO on retirement accounts comes with high returns and risks
President Donald Trump signed an executive order allowing Americans to invest their retirement savings in private equity, cryptocurrency and real estate, among other alternatives. NBC News' Emily Lorsch explains how the new options for Americans come with lucrative returns at high risks.
New York Post
44 minutes ago
- New York Post
Don Trump Jr. jokes Mamdani will be ‘great' because he will force people to wake up to ‘ridiculous experiment' of socialism
Donald Trump Jr. quipped Wednesday that New York City mayoral frontrunner Zohran Mamdani will actually be 'great' if he wins — because it'll force Americans to wake up to the 'ridiculous experiment' of socialism gripping the country. The first son warned that the champagne socialist's proposed tax hikes on the Big Apple's millionaires and major corporations would only spell 'serious trouble' for the city because it would spark a mass exodus of high earners who could pay for his freebie-filled agenda. 'Mamdani, if he wins, he's going to be great for the rest of the country in the future because New York City is going to go through some really hard times, and people are going to stop playing with this ridiculous experiment of communism and socialism that has not worked anywhere else in the world,' Trump Jr. told Fox News' 'Fox & Friends.' Advertisement Donald Trump Jr. warned Zohran Mamdani's proposed tax hikes on millionaires would spell 'serious trouble' for New York City given it'll spark a mass exodus of high earners who'll pay for his freebie-filled agenda. Fox News President Trump's son laid into Mamdani's campaign promises of a 2% tax hike on millionaires and a 4.5% increase on corporations, saying it'll drive away those who fund the majority of the city's subsidy programs. 'The reality is no one wants to pay that much,' he said, adding the wealth would uproot to other states like Florida or Texas if Mamdani's tax-the-rich plan comes to fruition. Advertisement 'This is really sad for actual New Yorkers and middle-class New Yorkers… the wealthiest people, they can move very easily. They can work from wherever. 'They are the vast majority of the tax base that funds all of these subsidy programs in New York City. You lose 10 to 15,000 of those ultra high net worth individuals, this city is in serious trouble, and no amount of free stuff being promised is going to actually help it,' he continued. Mamdani this week kicked off a weeklong rage tour during which he slammed Trump for enacting policies that he claims are 'dire threats' to New Yorkers. Gregory P. Mango 'It's a shame.' Advertisement Meanwhile, his brother, Eric Trump, noted that New York City was the 'epitome of capitalism' across the world. 'The guy is coming out and actively saying that he wants to shut down capitalism,' he said. 'I mean, it's the antithesis of what New York City is. The guy is holy, holy scary. And I think it's a disastrous thing for the state, which has already had an exodus of people out of it,' Eric added of Mamdani's tax plan. Their criticism came just as Mamdani kicked off a weeklong rage tour during which he slammed Trump for enacting policies that he claims are 'dire threats' to New Yorkers. Advertisement Mamdani's Trump-hating expedition is expected to tick off all five boroughs by Friday as the lefty insisted, 'We know that there is no borough that will be free from Trump's cruelty.'
