Starmer says welfare reform vote will go ahead despite mounting Labour revolt
The Prime Minister said the Commons vote would go ahead on Tuesday as planned despite 120 Labour MPs publicly backing a move to block the legislation.
Sir Keir said his party was elected 'to change that which is broken' and the welfare system 'doesn't work for anyone'.
Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer said the vote would go ahead as planned (Ben Stansall/PA)
Insisting the Universal Credit and Personal Independence Payment Bill would not be pulled in the face of the mounting rebellion, Sir Keir told LBC: 'There'll be a vote on Tuesday, we're going to make sure we reform the welfare system.'
The legislation plans to restrict eligibility for the personal independence payment, the main disability payment in England, and limit the sickness-related element of universal credit, with the aim of getting more people back into work and saving up to £5 billion a year.
Existing claimants will be given a 13-week phase-out period of financial support, a move seen as a bid to head off opposition.
But the fact so many Labour MPs are prepared to put their names to a 'reasoned amendment', a move which would stop the Bill in its tracks, shows how entrenched the opposition is.
Dame Meg Hillier has led the rebels seeking to block the legislation (Richard Townshend/UK Parliament)
Defending the plans while at the Nato summit in The Hague, Sir Keir said the current system 'traps people in a position where they can't get into work'.
'In fact, it's counterproductive, it works against them getting into work,' he said.
'So we have to reform it, and that is a Labour argument, it's a progressive argument.'
The rebels argue that disabled people have not been properly consulted about the plan and say further analysis is required before making any changes.
Mayor of Greater Manchester Andy Burnham added his voice to the senior figures calling on the Government to reconsider.
He told BBC Newsnight: 'When the PLP (Parliamentary Labour Party) delivers its collective wisdom in such numbers, it is invariably right. And it is right on this.
'I would say to the Government, listen to the PLP.'
His comments came after his London counterpart, Sir Sadiq Khan, said that ministers 'must urgently think again' about the plans.
Labour's First Minister of Wales Baroness Eluned Morgan has also called for a rethink of the plans.
Work and Pensions Secretary Liz Kendall, who has already taken steps to soften the impact of the welfare Bill, has been locked in talks with backbenchers as she seeks to win over those opposed to the measures.
Meanwhile, Kemi Badenoch said the Tories would lend the Government votes to pass the legislation but only if Labour rules out tax rises in the autumn budget as well as reducing unemployment and lowering the welfare budget.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
16 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Angela Rayner says welfare cuts vote will go ahead as Labour rebellion grows
Keir Starmer will push ahead with his plan for a vote on the government's welfare cuts next Tuesday, his deputy said on Wednesday, despite a large and growing rebellion from Labour MPs. Angela Rayner told the Commons the government would not back down on its proposals to cut nearly £5bn from the welfare bill by limiting access to disability payments. With more than 120 Labour MPs now having signed an amendment to put the cuts on hold, ministers are facing a growing possibility of defeat next Tuesday, or of relying on opposition votes to pass the measures. Labour has a majority of 165 MPs in the Commons. But during a session of prime minister's questions during which she was deputising for Starmer, Rayner told MPs the government would not delay or abandon the vote. 'We're investing £1bn into tailored employment support, a right to try to help more people back into work, and ending reassessments for the most severely disabled who will never be able to work,' she said. 'We won't walk away and stand by and abandon millions of people trapped in the failing system left behind by [the shadow chancellor, Mel Stride] and his colleagues.' Pushed by Stride to recommit to a vote on Tuesday, she added: 'I don't know if he listened to what I said … but what I can tell him, and I don't need a script, we will go ahead on Tuesday.' Rayner's message came a day after she and other senior cabinet colleagues mounted a frantic effort to save the bill, calling rebel backbenchers and urging them to vote with the government. Some MPs say they have been threatened with suspension and even de-selection in four years' time if they vote against the bill, while others say party managers have told them they see it as a vote of confidence in the government. Downing Street has denied those claims. The government's lobbying operation had borne little fruit by Wednesday morning, with the number of signatures to the amendment climbing from 108 to 123. They are being led by Meg Hillier, the respected head of the Treasury select committee. The Conservatives appear to have decided not to support the bill. Kemi Badenoch, the Tory leader, set preconditions for supporting it on Tuesday, none of which are likely to be met. Stride told MPs on Wednesday: 'We will help her [Rayner] to get their bill through, if they can commit to actually reducing the welfare bill and getting people off benefits and into work.' He later added: 'The bill will see the number of people on welfare rising for every single year.' Rayner's insistence that the vote would go ahead echoes the message of the prime minister on Tuesday on his way to the Nato summit in The Hague. 'There is a clear moral case, which is: the current system doesn't help those who want to get into work,' he said. 'It traps people. I think it's 1,000 people a day going on to Pip. The additions to Pip each year are the equivalent of a city the size of Leicester. That is not a system that can be left unreformed.'
Daily Record
26 minutes ago
- Daily Record
Keir Starmer to speak to nation after warning 'prepare for war in the UK'
The Prime Minister will take part in meetings at the NATO summit in the Hague. Keir Starmer is to give a press conference today - just a day after a UK Government document warned we must "actively prepare" for war. The Prime Minister will take part in meetings at the NATO summit in the Hague. A National Security Strategy dossier said the years ahead will be a test for the UK and that there will be a need for a WW2 -like spirit in the country. The document said the threat of nuclear weapons will be "more complex than it was even in the Cold War". It went on: "The years ahead will test the United Kingdom... The direction it takes – and the decisions we take – will reverberate through the decades. "We will need agility and courage to succeed, but we should be optimistic. "We remain a resolute country, rich in history, values and in our capabilities. But most of all, there is the determination of the British people themselves. "After all, we do not need to look too far into our history for an example of a whole-of-society effort, motivated by a collective will to keep each other safe. "We can mobilise that spirit again and use it both for our national security and the rebuilding of our country." Labour Defence Secretary John Healey said the Prime Minister trusts that Trump's America would come to the aid of NATO allies. He told Times Radio: "Do I trust President Trump and the US's commitment to Article 5? Yes. "So does our Prime Minister, and he does because in the Oval Office on his visit to the White House, President Trump gave him that commitment in public." Starmer has caused for Israel and Iran to maintain the pause in hostilities. In a conversation with the French and German leaders at on Tuesday, he "reflected on the volatile situation in the Middle East," according to a Downing Street spokeswoman. The leaders agreed that "now was the time for diplomacy and for Iran to come to the negotiating table", the spokeswoman added. It comes as intelligence reports in the US suggested that the American attack on Iran's nuclear programme over the weekend have only set it back by a few months, rather than destroyed it as Donald Trump previously suggested.
Edinburgh Live
29 minutes ago
- Edinburgh Live
Potholes and pavements the big issues in Fountainbridge/Craiglockhart by-election
Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info Voters in Fountainbridge and Craiglockhart will go to the polls tomorrow to elect a new councillor – with candidates concerned about the state of the roads and pavements they will use to get there. The by-election for the ward was called after Labour councillor Val Walker passed away suddenly in April. Polls will open at 7am across the ward, and close at 10pm, and ahead of the vote we contacted the candidates to ask what issues local people were concerned about and how they would tackle them if elected. And almost all raised the issue of potholes and poorly maintained pavements as being on the minds of residents. The council was criticised over 'quick fix' solutions, while one candidate said the state of local pavements was ' a disgrace'. Anti-social behaviour was also a topic that kept coming up, with concerns over. youth violence rising in the wake of the Covid lockdowns. Here are what some of the candidates had to say. Mark Hooley, Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party – 'Get the basics right' Scottish Conservative and Unionist party candidate Mark Hooley, who has lived in the ward for five years, said that potholes, roads and anti-social behaviour were big issues. He said: 'In terms of areas [of concern], it would definitely be the roads. I think that's an issue. In general, the state of the roads, sometimes the council just does a quick-fix job, and then it's not done properly. 'Also, I would want to focus on anti-social behaviour. We've had some issues down by the canal, so I would definitely want to focus on rectifying that.' Mr Hooley, who has lived in the city for nine, says his campaign is all about getting the basics of government right. He said: 'My basic philosophy is that government should do less, but do it better. It's not doing the basics as well as it should. 'I don't think it's surprising that when people get disillusioned from government, and then some more extreme options become more attractive to people because they say, 'oh, regular politicians aren't doing what they should do''. Mr Hooley, who works in senior management at a betting firm and is studying an MSc in journalism at Napier, says he cares deeply about where he lives, and wants to help improve the ward by representing it at the council. He also said that he wanted to be a visible presence in the community if elected, and further that he would want to encourage more civic participation in government. Q Manivannan, Scottish Green Party – A more caring, considerate politics Q Manivannan, a PhD student from India who moved to Scotland four years ago, is representing the Scottish Greens at the by-election. They said that housing and traffic, as well as environmental issues, would be big priorities if they were elected. They continued: 'Let's start with housing. Lots of people in the area, especially in Fountainbridge and Tollcross, are paying sky high rents. 'And in Hutchison and Chesser, lots of what used to be council housing is now let out privately. 'Besides that, residents have talked to me constantly about the road safety aspect of it all. I think traffic calming measures are long overdue. 'But way too many councillors are far too timid about reducing traffic and offering positive alternatives like walking, cycling and public transport.' They said that their experience as a queer member of the Tamil community would help them relate deeply to constituents in the ward if they were elected. They continued: 'This election is not just a chance to elect one of the 63 councillors, but it's also a chance for the people in Fountainbridge/Craiglockhart to say they don't want the same as usual. 'I think people are yearning for a more caring, considerate politics – one that isn't just driven by remediating the worst things happening in society, but rather looking for new ideas and new kinds of people.' In their life before entering politics, they have spent time working for the UCU trade union, as well as working at the United Nations on disability-inclusive responses to Covid-19. They also convene the Green Party's Palestine solidarity group, and said the party's collective nature drew them towards it. Catriona Munro, Scottish Labour – Continuing a legacy For Labour candidate Catriona Munro, the biggest issues she sees in the ward are the state of the roads and the pavements, as well as road safety and the provision of public services. She said: 'The concerns that people have voiced are a lot of issues around the roads, the state of the roads and the state of the pavements. 'It's a problem for all road users, all sorts – pedestrians, cyclists and cars. We need to get better at making sure that these are dealt with.' She also said that she had gotten to know late councillor Walker 'so well' through their shared engagement in arts in the ward. Their connection started over Ms Munro's efforts to save a dance space she used from closure, which Cllr Walker had taken an interest in. Ms Munro, a solicitor, has lived in Edinburgh for almost 30 years, and recently retired from full-time practice. She said: 'I've always wanted to engage in public service of some sort, and I have stood for election before, but I feel that the time has come for me to give something back to my community. 'I would be honoured to be given the opportunity to do so.' Gary Neill, Reform UK – Action on potholes and social housing Gary Neill, originally from Belfast, is the Reform UK candidate for the by-election. He said that potholes would be a focus of his if he became the ward's councillor, continuing: 'Some of the pavements are a disgrace. The roads are absolutely terrible. 'What are [visitors] thinking of a city like Edinburgh, when the council can't even present decent walkways, decent roads for people to drive on.' He also says that he has heard many complaints about crime and housing. On social housing and homelessness, Mr Neill wants to see stronger action from the council, saying: 'It takes anything between two and four years, if you're lucky, to get social housing. 'And the problem is, one, there's not enough. Two, the normal approach is, block book a hotel, block book a bunch of properties from private landlords, block book Airbnbs. 'What's a permanent solution [to homelessness]? Why not use some of the council land and build a prefab village, or a portacabin village? 'One might think, well, that doesn't sound great. But at least if you are allocated a unit, it's yours – you're not moved every six months because the hotel has run out of contract, you're not moved from A to B because of anti-social behaviour.' He's had a wide-ranging background, spending time in the British Army and as a part-time police officer in his younger years before leaving Northern Ireland in 1984 to continue a career in sales, management and project management. Mr Neill, who moved to Edinburgh in 2023, says that his work experience gives him a 'good background' for becoming a councillor. Murray Visentin, SNP – A well-established local face SNP candidate Murray Visentin says that one of the biggest concerns he's heard of in the ward is issues around the Caledonian Brewery redevelopment, in Shandon. While it's not in the Fountainbridge/Craiglockhart ward, he says many local residents are concerned about the parking impact the development – which has two parking spaces for almost 170 units – will have. He also says he's heard that potholes are an issue, as well as anti-social behaviour. He said: 'One thing that has been, even in my Asda, is anti-social behaviour from youths not long after Covid. 'People were stuck in the house for a long time, and the kids felt like they could run amok like they could run amok in their houses. 'And then you've got what people always talk about, which is potholes.' Having spent most of his life in the ward, Murray Visentin says he has a strong tie to the community he's looking to represent. He believes he can serve his local community best by running for council, saying: 'My belief is that local politics can make a difference with people more than national politics. 'It can come across as a negative thing sometimes, but local politics, regardless of party, becomes, 'what can your councillor do for you?' 'And because I know an awful lot of people in the ward, they'll have this local personal contact, and I thought that's probably the best thing I could possibly do for my local community.' Mr Visentin works as a manager at Chesser Asda, and says this brings him people and management skills that would make him well-suited for the job. He presently works as a manager in the warehouse, where he's ended up due to his possessing a forklift license, but has worked as a manager in every part of the store. All candidates A full list of candidates is as follows: Bonnie Prince Bob, Independent Derrick Emms, Independent Lukasz Furmaniak, Scottish Libertarian Party Mark Hooley, Scottish COnservative and Unionist Party Richard Crewe Lucas, Scottish Family Party Q Manivannan, Scottish Green Party Kevin Joseph McKay, Scottish Liberal Democrats Catriona Munro, Scottish Labour Party Gary Neill, Reform UK Mark Rowbotham, Independent Murray Visentin, Scottish National Party Steve Cristopher West, Independent Marc Wilkinson, Independent
