
What Suella Braverman's plan for quitting the ECHR gets right
It talks about the erosion of sovereignty over immigration, policing and vast swathes of social policy; the baneful 'living instrument' doctrine that means we have now effectively given a blank cheque to a self-selecting and unaccountable bench to second-guess our democratic process in ever more intrusive ways; the Strasbourg court's arrogation of powers, such as the right to order interim measures never contemplated in 1950; and so on. The paper then goes in detail through the legal machinery of disentanglement, starting with the obvious point that the Convention itself provides for a right to leave on giving six months' notice, and then describing the legislative and administrative processes involved.
But don't be fooled. This may not be exciting reading (Suella is, after all, a lawyer); but the appearance of this document at this time matters a lot.
One very significant point is that the paper in one place meets head-on the arguments lazily trotted out as slam-dunk wins for the case against withdrawal. Does the UK's good reputation depend on ECHR membership? Doubtful. There are plenty of countries not members of regional agreements that are admirably free (think Canada and Australia), not to mention ECHR members that, shall we say, leave something to be desired (stand up, Azerbaijan).
Reform the ECHR from within? We've tried that, and it's had no effect in the areas that matter. Tweak the Human Rights Act? It won't work with the Strasbourg court sitting in the background waiting to pounce. The right of the EU to withdraw police cooperation under the Withdrawal Agreement if we denounce the ECHR? Bring it on, and if need be, call their bluff. They have as much to lose as we have: it's a small risk, and one worth taking.
What of the elephant in the room, the Good Friday Agreement? More awkward, but nothing insuperable here. For one thing, it doesn't actually bar the UK from withdrawing from the ECHR. Instead it talks much more vaguely of the incorporation of ECHR provisions in Ulster law and court remedies to enforce it. If necessary, there must be some political horse-trading here, and in the end, Westminster must be prepared to put its foot down and face down Irish nationalists if necessary in the interest of a common rights regime in the UK.
To this extent, the Braverman document has continued the process of moving ECHR scepticism away from the fringe and placing it firmly in the range of the sayable and even politically plausible. More to the point, it also fills another void. So far, calls to ditch the ECHR have suffered from a similar difficulty to that which faced the Leave movement right up to the 2016 referendum and might well have tipped it into defeat: it has been heavy on criticism but light on practicalities. By laying down in some detail the measures to be taken to remove the ECHR from our law both in form and substance and opening these to debate, this may well reassure electors otherwise wavering.
Looking more widely, today's events could just indicate a subtle shift in political tectonics. Doubts about the way the ECHR is chipping away at the institutions of this country are engaging electors who might previously have shrugged off human rights as something remote and unconcerning. Whenever they read of an undeserving visitor to this country allowed to stay, often at our expense as taxpayers, on the basis of family life here or possible beastliness abroad, they increasingly connect this with the ECHR; so too when, as a harassed commuter or housewife, they find they cannot go about their business because of some demonstration said to be protected by a European right to cause inconvenience to the public.
Nor is it only electors. Teasingly, this morning's Telegraph said that Suella's proposals had cross-party backing not only from key figures on the Tory right (predictable: after all, even Kemi has said she is open to talk of abandoning the Strasbourg regime) and also from Reform, whose position has always been clear, but also from the DUP and even some from blue Labour (no names yet, but an educated guess might light on figures like Jonathan Brash, the free-thinking MP for Hartlepool).
Whisper it quietly, but human rights scepticism is becoming the new mainstream. Defenders of the Strasbourg status quo are shrinking to an increasingly small caucus of senior Labour figures, Tory grandees and a motley collection of urban intellectuals and academics. It's quite possible that within a few years, ECHR enthusiasm will have declined to a niche interest in much the same way as, say, Euroscepticism did twenty years ago. Now that's a change worth contemplating.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Guardian
3 hours ago
- The Guardian
Von der Leyen to meet Trump in Scotland as EU and US close in on trade deal
The EU appears to be on the verge of signing a trade deal with Donald Trump after the European Commission president, Ursula von der Leyen, announced she would meet the US president on Sunday during his four-day trip to Scotland. Trump landed in Scotland on Friday evening before the opening of his new golf course in Aberdeenshire. He said he was also planning to meet the British prime minister, Keir Starmer, on Saturday. The European Commission said von der Leyen's visit would be at Trump's invitation. Ireland's taoiseach, Micheál Martin, said on Friday a deal would 'hopefully be signed off before the weekend is over'. After getting off Air Force One, Trump described von der Leyen as a 'highly respected woman', said there was a 'good 50-50 chance' for a deal, and said the 'sticking points have to do with maybe 20 different things'. He said it 'would be the biggest deal of them all if we make it'. Trump heaped praise on Starmer and Scotland's first minister, John Swinney, and said the French president, Emmanuel Macron, was 'a team player' but that France's planned recognition of Palestine as a state would not 'carry any weight'. Trump said he was looking forward to meeting Swinney. Before boarding the presidential plane, he told journalists: 'The Scottish leader is a good man, so I look forward to meeting him.' He said he had a 'lot of love' for Scotland. Trump hinted he was looking for more concessions from the EU, saying Japan had had a worse chance than Brussels of getting a deal but succeeded after offering more to the US. He also criticised what he called 'the windmills' – windfarms – which he claimed were 'ruining your beautiful fields and killing your birds', and hit out at the level of immigration in the EU, saying it was an 'invasion' which was 'killing Europe'. Von der Leyen said she 'had a good call' with Trump before he landed in Scotland and they had 'agreed to meet in Scotland on Sunday to discuss transatlantic trade relations, and how we can keep them strong'. Trump would not meet von der Leyen unless a deal was ready to be signed, sources have said. He also hinted he was ready to widen the deal he had already agreed with the UK, fuelling speculation he could finally eliminate the 25% tariff he imposed on steel. 'This week we want to talk about certain aspects [of the trade deal] which are going to be good for both countries; more fine tuning. We are also going to be doing a little celebrating together because, you know, we get along very well,' he said. 'We are going to have a good time, I think. The prime minister and I get along very well; the Scottish leader too, we have a lot of things, my mother was born in Scotland, and he's a good man, the Scottish leader … so I'm looking forward to meeting him.' Asked about a trade deal with the EU, he said: 'I would say that we have a 50/50 chance, maybe less than that … I would have said we had a 25% chance with Japan, and they kept coming back and we made a deal.' The EU is resigned to an agreement in principle on 15% baseline tariffs, including on cars, which will make brands from Volvo to Volkswagen more costly for US traders to import than Range Rovers from Britain, which carved out a deal allowing 100,000 cars a year to be imported to the US at a 10% tariff. On Friday, Volkswagen laid bare the cost of Trump's import tariffs saying it had taken a £1bn hit in the first half of the year as a direct result. Trump struck a deal with Starmer in May, reducing tariffs on cars from 27.5% to 10% in exchange for increases in UK imports of beef and ethanol. While it is being seen as a clever move by Starmer, the ethanol industry says it is fighting for survival against US ethanol, which is used in E10 biofuel in filling stations around the UK. The president of the National Farmers' Union, Tom Bradshaw, said his 'biggest worry' was that Starmer would sell farmers out by allowing in US dairy products. 'We understand the US is pushing very, very hard for dairy access, and for us that is a real red line as they use hormones that we stopped using in dairy production 30 years ago.' He said the farming sector could not 'give any more' and warned Starmer not to sacrifice agriculture. Before boarding Air Force One, Trump claimed he would have sealed deals with nearly all of the 60 countries he threatened with punitive tariffs by next Friday, his self-imposed deadline for agreements. He said he had not 'really had a lot of luck with Canada' but he was not focused on it, and rather was 'working very diligently with Europe, the EU' to get a deal.


The Independent
6 hours ago
- The Independent
Trump tells Europe ‘get your act together' on immigration as he arrives in Scotland
Donald Trump has claimed Europe 'had better get its act together' as he arrived at the start of a four-day visit to Scotland. Trump was greeted by Scottish Secretary Ian Murray as he landed at Glasgow 's Prestick Airport, before quickly launching a broadside at at EU migration policies as he spoke to waiting reporters. ' You better get your act together or you're not gonna have Europe anymore,' he said, adding: ' You've got to stop this horrible invasion that's happening to Europe.' Trump's comment come against a backdrop of tension over the housing of migrants in regional areas of the UK, with a string of violent protests taking place outside a hotel believed to be housing asylum seekers in Epping, Essex.


Metro
8 hours ago
- Metro
Trump touches down in Scotland for unofficial visit
To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video Donald Trump has landed in the UK for a five-day trip around Scotland. The US president touched down at Prestwick Airport at 8.28pm this evening and was met by Scottish Secretary Ian Murray. He then headed off to his Turnberry golf course in South Ayrshire. The visit has been described as a 'private' trip, before he returns for an official state visit in September. He will travel to golf courses across Scotland while also fitting in high-stakes meetings with the Prime Minister and the Scottish First Minister. Trump will then fly out of Scotland on Tuesday. The US President has a personal connection to Scotland. His mother, Mary Anne MacLeod Trump was born and raised on the Isle of Lewis before moving to New York aged 18. He is expected to open up a new 18-hole course dedicated to his mother at his Menie resort. Trump also owns the Turnberry hotel and three linked courses in Ayrshire, which he bought for about £40million in 2014. The US President has made several visits to Scotland in the past, often to visit his late mother's home or to play golf on one of his courses. Other than visiting his two golf courses in Scotland, Trump is due to meet Keir Starmer in Aberdeen on Monday. Trump's press secretary said the meeting was intended to 'refine the great trade deal that was brokered between the United States and the United Kingdom'. Scottish First Minister John Swinney has also said he is meeting the US president. Swinney publicly backed Kamala Harris for the presidency last year, but Trump called him a 'good man' before embarking on the trip. He plans to raise a number of domestic and international issues including tariffs on Scotch whisky and conflict in the Middle East. Trump is also due to meet European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen. The US and EU are currently locked in trade negotiations over tariffs, with agreement reportedly close to being reached. Trump's visit could strengthen the relationship between Starmer and the US president, as they look set to discuss Russia's war in Ukraine. Conflict in the Middle East could also take centre stage, just days after France announced plans to recognise a Palestinian state. Starmer said on Thursday the Palestinian people have the 'inalienable' right to a state, while Trump criticised Macron's plan, saying it 'doesn't carry any weight'. The US president will also be hoping the trip brings him some time out of the spotlight back home. A political crisis has erupted over his handling of the Jeffrey Epstein files and seen Trump take heat from his usually loyal MAGA supporters. The president once promised to release the files, but the Justice Department and FBI since announced that 'no incriminating 'client list'' existed. It was then sensationally reported by The Wall Street Journal that Trump's name appears in the files. There will be a 'festival of resistance', organised by the Scottish wing of the Stop Trump Coalition. More Trending This will kick off a day after his arrival – on Saturday – and will be held in Edinburgh, Aberdeen and Dumfries. An Ipsos poll in March found that about 70% of Scots have an unfavorable opinion of Trump, while 18% have a favorable opinion. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video The protests will be the prelude for even larger demonstrations in London planned by the group when Trump lands on his state visit in September. There are also plans to relaunch the Donald Trump baby balloon, which became a symbol of protests against the controversial leader on his first state visit in July 2018. Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at webnews@ For more stories like this, check our news page. MORE: Trump says 'I'll give you a list' of Epstein associates and 'I'm allowed' to pardon Maxwell MORE: Donald Trump's Scotland visit branded 'cynical circus' by his nemesis in land battle MORE: Starmer should give Trump a warm welcome – then a £14m bill