How Jewish scholars are attacked in America for calling out Gaza genocide
US-Israeli genocide scholar Raz Segal was the first academic to label Israel's war on Gaza a 'textbook case of genocide' in 2023. But that also came with a price.
The prominent Israeli-American historian delves into the context, the intense backlash faced by Jewish scholars who speak out, and the implications for international law and human rights.
Segal is currently the associate professor of Holocaust and genocide studies at Stockton University.
Middle East Eye delivers independent and unrivalled coverage and analysis of the Middle East, North Africa and beyond. To learn more about republishing this content and the associated fees, please fill out this
form . More about MEE can be found
here .
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Middle East Eye
an hour ago
- Middle East Eye
Turkey warns Syrian Kurds: Don't become Israeli pawns
Turkish Foreign Minister Hakan Fidan on Wednesday issued yet another ultimatum to Syrian Kurdish armed groups, urging them to abandon hopes of cooperating with Israel against Damascus and to honour their agreement to integrate with the central government. In an unusually sharp tone, Fidan said Ankara was not naive and was fully aware of the Syrian Democratic Forces' (SDF) activities. 'They say that the agreement we made with Syria does not bind us much in terms of the clauses written in it,' he said. 'Well then, what does concern you? Is it making the esteemed Kurdish brothers of the region into Israel's pawns that concerns you?' Fidan's remarks came as Syrian Foreign Minister Assad Al-Shaibani visited Ankara, accompanied by the Syrian defence minister and intelligence chief, to discuss security challenges in northern Syria as well as the situation in Sweida. New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters On Tuesday, Shaibani had attended a meeting in Jordan with US Special Envoy Thomas Barrack, aiming to find a path forward that would accommodate both Syrian and Israeli concerns regarding the safety of the Druze community in Suwayda. At the joint press conference in Ankara, Shaibani also criticised a recent conference held by the SDF in Hasakah, where representatives of various ethnic and religious minority groups called for autonomy. He said they did not represent the Syrian people and warned that Damascus remained resolute in preserving Syria's territorial integrity. Damascus last week cancelled a meeting with SDF representatives in Paris in protest for the conference, partially also because of Turkey's objections to the French mediation. Negotiations and centralisation In March, Syrian President Ahmed al-Sharaa signed a memorandum with SDF commander Mazlum Abdi, agreeing in principle to integrate with Damascus. The deal included incorporating SDF forces into the national army, transferring control of borders, government institutions, prisons, and oil and gas fields to the central authorities. This step coincided with Turkey's own peace talks with the Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK), which announced its dissolution in May following appeals from its imprisoned founder Abdullah Ocalan. The SDF later said the process doesn't concern them either. Since then, the SDF, widely seen as a PKK offshoot, has shifted its stance and begun demanding autonomy and a decentralised system of governance, particularly after Israeli air strikes on Damascus and southern Syria. In multiple interviews, Abdi has said he wants the SDF to remain under a separate command structure. 'In an environment where Turkey's security concerns are not addressed, there is no way for us to remain calm here' - Hakan Fidan, Turkish Foreign Minister Fidan warned that Ankara's patience was wearing thin as the SDF failed to take concrete steps to address Turkish security concerns. 'At present, we see that members of the SDF coming from Turkey, Iraq, Iran and Europe have not left Syria,' he said, referring to the foreign fighters the SDF had pledged to expel. 'On the contrary, we see that they are waiting for possible problems to maximise their benefit from all processes - both in Damascus and in Ankara. They should not think we do not see this; we do see it.' Fidan further alleged that the SDF was seeking Israeli assistance to maintain control over Arab-majority areas by force and to preserve its ties to the PKK. 'But in an environment where Turkey's security concerns are not addressed, there is no way for us to remain calm here,' he said. While calling on the SDF to pursue peace with both Turkey and Damascus, Fidan also suggested that no one should be surprised by potential developments, hinting that Ankara was prepared to take other measures, possibly including military action. Deadlines Last month, Middle East Eye reported that Turkey and the US, in a meeting with SDF officials, had given Abdi's group a 30-day deadline to accelerate the process of joining Damascus. That deadline is set to expire within days. According to a regional source speaking to MEE, US officials warned the SDF that the international coalition might not be able to shield them if Damascus decided to launch a military offensive in the event the 10 March agreement was not upheld. Security sources told MEE that while Turkey would not directly intervene against the SDF, the Turkish Armed Forces could provide indirect support for a limited operation carried out by the Syrian army. They said preparations for such an operation had already been completed. Syrian democracy campaigners wary of upcoming 'selected' elections Read More » The sources also revealed that US Special Envoy Thomas Barrack, in meetings with Turkish officials in Ankara, requested more time for diplomatic efforts and negotiations with the SDF. Turkish officials reportedly responded, in diplomatic terms, that 'the decision and authority on the matter rest with the Damascus government, and that in line with the military cooperation between Damascus and Turkey and Turkey's national security sensitivities, any request for support from Damascus would be met positively'. Meanwhile, intermittent clashes have broken out between the Syrian army and the SDF in Deir Hafir, east of Aleppo, and around the Tishrin Dam last week, with both sides trading blame for the escalation. Syrian security sources told MEE that the Syrian delegation's visit to Ankara would focus on this context, with key agenda items including shared threats, border security, follow-up on agreements, and potential economic investments. Last month, Syria formally requested that Turkey extend security assistance. The sources added that discussions on the deployment of Turkish Armed Forces in Syria would also be part of the talks.
Middle East Eye
an hour ago
- Middle East Eye
South Sudan 'in talks' with Israel to take in ethnically cleansed Palestinians from Gaza
South Sudan is reportedly in talks with Israel about resettling Palestinians forcibly displaced from Gaza, as Israeli representatives arrived in the East African country for an inaugural official visit. On Tuesday evening, the Associated Press reported that talks had taken place between the two countries about transferring Palestinians, citing six sources familiar with the discussions. It is unclear how far the talks have progressed. Joe Szlavik, a US lobbyist working with South Sudan, told AP he was briefed by South Sudanese officials on the talks, and that an Israeli delegation had planned to visit the country to explore the possibility of setting up camps for Palestinians. Sharren Haskel, Israel's deputy foreign minister, arrived in South Sudan on Tuesday to hold a series of meetings as part of the first ever official Israeli visit. Haskel will meet with the country's president and foreign minister, among others. The newspaper Israel Hayom reported that the visit was scheduled a while back, and is unrelated to recent reports about displaced Palestinians from Gaza. New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters 'While the international community is focused solely on Gaza, South Sudan is facing a real humanitarian crisis and the threat of genuine famine that is claiming the lives of many refugees from the war in Sudan,' Haskel said on Tuesday. 'All hunger experts in the international community and in the media [should] come here and see with their own eyes what happens when there is a real famine.' It's not clear if Haskel's trip is the same delegation that Szlavik was referring to. 'Jews Say No to Ethnic Cleansing': Hundreds of rabbis and artists reject Trump's Gaza plan Read More » Israel's and South Sudan's foreign ministries did not respond to questions on the talks by AP, while a US State Department spokesperson said it did not comment on private diplomatic discussions. Two weeks ago, Gideon Saar, Israel's foreign minister, hosted his South Sudanese counterpart in Jerusalem. The discussions with South Sudan are part of months-long efforts by Israel to find third nations to realise US President Donald Trump's proposal to ethnically cleanse the Palestinian enclave. Trump said in February that Washington would 'take over' the Gaza Strip and eject the Palestinian population to other countries. In the meantime, the enclave would be turned into the 'Riviera of the Middle East'. Weeks later, Israel set up a new government agency to oversee what it described as "voluntary departures", in compliance with Trump's proposal. 'I think that the right thing to do, even according to the laws of war as I know them, is to allow the population to leave, and then you go in with all your might against the enemy who remains there,' Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu told Israeli TV station i24 on Tuesday, in relation to the displacement plan. He did not mention South Sudan. The semantics of ethnic cleansing Experts in genocide and international law told Middle East Eye last month that Israeli officials' talk of "voluntary emigration" should actually be read as forced displacement. Two Egyptian officials told AP that they had known for months of Israeli efforts to find a country to take in Palestinians, including its contact with South Sudan. The officials said that they had lobbied South Sudan against taking in displaced Palestinians. Musk's AI chatbot briefly suspended 'for saying Israel is committing genocide in Gaza' Read More » AP previously reported that the US and Israel had reached out to officials in Sudan, Somalia and the self-governed region of Somaliland about the plans. South Sudan has been devastated by a civil war that broke out after it gained independence from Sudan in 2011. Around 400,000 have been killed, and the country relies on international aid to feed its population of 11 million people. A fragile peace agreement was struck seven years ago. South Sudan faces a number of sanctions imposed by the US, including the revocation of visas for all its nationals, as well as individual sanctions on a number of figures and entities it links with threatening peace. It is not yet known if talks with Israel about accepting ejected Palestinians are linked with sanctions relief.
Middle East Eye
an hour ago
- Middle East Eye
Air traffic controller suspended in France for saying 'Free Palestine'
An air traffic controller was suspended in France after saying "Free Palestine" to an Israeli airline crew. The staff member at Paris Charles de Gaulle airport said the slogan during a radio exchange with the crew of an El Al flight on Monday, the French Ministry of Transport announced. "Analysis of the recordings proves that the facts are true," Minister Philippe Tabarot wrote on X on Tuesday. He added that the controller had "been deprived of all authority to work until further notice". "Disciplinary proceedings were immediately initiated. The sanction must be commensurate with the seriousness of the facts," Tabarot said. New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters For the minister, the incident violates "radiocommunication rules, which must be limited to the safety and regularity of air traffic" and demonstrates "a failure to respect the duty of civil servant confidentiality", which is the status of air traffic controllers in France. The Representative Council of Jewish Institutions in France (CRIF) branded it an "unacceptable incident", which "contravenes both the imperative of political neutrality and the security protocols governing communications between a control tower and an aircraft during takeoff". A number of social media users criticised the move, however. "The urgent thing is to stop letting Israeli planes pollute our French skies and soil. We do not want to be complicit in the genocide in Gaza, apartheid and crimes in the West Bank," said one. Another user accused the minister of turning a "blind eye to flagrant violations of all international treaties, to a genocide unfolding before his eyes, tens of thousands dead, but he suddenly finds the dignity to protest against a possible violation of the telecommunications code." Pro-Palestine airlines controversies The incident is the latest in a line of pro-Palestine controversies that have taken place in Europe involving airlines in recent months. Last month, a video released on X appeared to show a female airport agent returning the papers of several people at an unidentified Paris airport, while telling them, "Free Palestine". Despite the lack of information surrounding the incident, it was nevertheless reported to ADP, the capital's airport manager, who said it had opened an investigation. ADP later confirmed that the scene was filmed at Paris Charles de Gaulle airport, also known as Roissy airport, in mid-July, in a restricted area. Was it legal for France, Italy and Greece to let Netanyahu fly over their airspace? Read More » The employee implicated in the video was reportedly identified as an Air France contractor. "Passport checks on flights are carried out by an authorised external security company, in accordance with current local regulations," the airline told Le Figaro, adding it was "deeply committed to the values of hospitality, respect and neutrality". "We will ensure that these principles are reiterated in the strongest possible terms to this service provider, whose staff are subject to a duty of confidentiality," it said. Another recent incident that made headlines happened on a flight of the Spanish airline Iberia, where Jewish passengers received kosher meal trays tagged with handwritten messages reading "Free Palestine". Iberia described the incident, which took place earlier this month, as "unacceptable" and announced the opening of a "comprehensive" investigation, both internally and involving external meal providers, to "shed light on the facts and adopt all relevant measures". Israel's war on Gaza, which has so far killed 61,722 Palestinians since 7 October 2023 and has been described as a genocide by a growing number of states, rights organisations and legal experts, has provoked outcry across Europe and led to mass demonstrations and public acts of protest, sometimes targeting individual Israelis.
