logo
Beyond the Courtroom: Fali Nariman's legal legacy

Beyond the Courtroom: Fali Nariman's legal legacy

Indian Express25-04-2025

'The characteristic features of Indian culture have long been a search for ultimate verities and the concomitant disciple-guru relationship' – these are the first words of Autobiography of a Yogi written by Indian spiritual leader Paramahansa Yogananda, originally published in 1946.
Close to eight decades later, a manifestation of these very words came to public notice in the relationship between the late Fali S. Nariman, a towering figure in Indian Jurisprudence and Subhash Sharma, his trusted lieutenant for nearly 40 years.
In fact, Sharma had read out a 1952 speech of Yogananda to Nariman five hours before the eminent lawyer breathed his last on February 21 last year. 'I started crying after reading the speech…looking at me, Fali started weeping too,' Sharma told The Indian Express.
Months after his death, Sharma meticulously curated a book with a selection of Nariman's most influential speeches.
'Beyond the Courtroom' showcases the vast breadth and depth of Nariman's constitutional expertise through his illuminating lectures and articles. It even goes a step further outlining the jurists views on the state of Indian Democracy. From making arguments on why a new constitution is impossible today, to stating why a strong opposition is needed for the betterment of democracy, this book covers a wide range of subjects.
'The first lesson about written constitutions is that they don't function on their own. A special effort must be made by their custodians – those entrusted with their functioning – to work them,' reads a chapter titled 'The Silences in our Constitutional Law'.
This chapter stood out as it speaks about how the Silences of the constitution were interpreted and in turn its provisions broadened by the Judiciary. This reinterpretation, argued Nariman, has made the document a 'dynamic, living' one.
Nariman speaks about the evolution of Article 368 of the constitution (power of Parliament to amend constitution) to drive home the point of the dynamism of the constitution and bringing to the fore the tussle between the Parliament and the Judiciary.
He begins with how within a year of the constitution being brought into force, the Parliament passed the first amendment of the Constitution which dispensed with the payment of compensation for taking over large estates (zamindaries). Article 31A and 31B were introduced which provided that legislations for agrarian or land reforms were outside the protection of the fundamental right to property. 'Article 31 B was an innovation,' says Nariman, as it protected enactments included in the ninth schedule of the constitution from being declared void on the basis of infringement of fundamental rights.
In 1971, he points out, came more amendments, all meant to further limit the power of the constitution and increase that of the parliament by limiting which laws Courts could declare void if passed in contravention of fundamental rights.
Nariman traces the history of this tussle all the way to the Basic Structure Doctrine in 1973 where it was finally decided by a 13 judge bench held that the power of the Parliament to amend the Constitution couldn't alter its 'basic structure'. In the next chapter Nariman says: '…the only final interpreter of the Constitution is the judiciary' pointing out the active role that he feels judges must play in bringing life to the document.
Divided into five sections (Nation, Judiciary, Constitution, Law and Arbitration), the book also offers advice for young lawyers, tackles ethical questions and is sprinkled with quips throughout – usually towards the end of each chapter.
'Paramhansa used to think Mahatma Gandhi was a prophet…for me, Nariman was a prophet,' Sharma told The Indian Express. 'I've always felt this deep spiritual connection with him. I can't put a finger on it, but I always somehow felt close to him.'
Sharma is a well-known name in the legal circles and has been the devoted gatekeeper for Nariman's offices. As his junior since 1986, Sharma's name appears in virtually every case handled by Nariman. It was Sharma who would be the first point of contact for lawyers or litigants to Nariman's office since the veteran neither carried a cell phone nor directly accessed his email account.
Sharma considers it a stroke of serendipity that he got a chance to work with Nariman. After the book was published in early 2025, he kept a copy on the shrine of Yogananda – who was revered by both – in Forest Lawns, Los Angeles.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

In foreign countries, people still fondly remember Gandhi, Nehru & Indira: Supriya Sule
In foreign countries, people still fondly remember Gandhi, Nehru & Indira: Supriya Sule

Indian Express

time3 minutes ago

  • Indian Express

In foreign countries, people still fondly remember Gandhi, Nehru & Indira: Supriya Sule

EVEN as NCP (SP) chief Sharad Pawar on Tuesday reiterated there was no need to call a special session of Parliament to discuss Operation Sindoor, his daughter and Baramati MP Supriya Sule said during her recent visit to foreign countries to brief their governments about India's military operation, she found that people in those countries still fondly remember Mahatma Gandhi, Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru and Indira Gandhi. 'When I led the delegation of our country to four foreign countries, the first thing people there told me was that you come from the country of Mahatma Gandhi… They said Pandit Nehru had visited their country and they still remember his speeches. Calling Indira Gandhi an iron lady, they asked me to tell us more about her,' Sule said in her speech at the NCP's 26th foundation day celebration at Balgandharva Rangmandir in Pune. Sule said people in those countries also spoke about Prime Minister Narendra Modi. 'They were all praise for Prime Minister Modi,' she said. 'The entire delegation had the same experience in countries like Ethoipia, Egypt, South Africa and Qatar,' she said, adding India has to move forward with Mahatma Gandhi's ideology. Sule said she was fortunate to have led the country's delegation to four foreign countries. In his speech, Pawar reiterated there was no need to call a special Parliament session on Operation Sindoor as demanded by the opposition parties, saying there was need for secrecy in defence matters. 'When it comes to national interest, we should keep all our differences aside and remain with the nation,' Pawar said. 'Whichever government is in power in the country, the NCP will back it on national issues,' Sule said. Sule slammed the Hagawane family for the death of their daughter-in-law over dowry demand. 'I cannot believe the Hagawane family can stoop so low. An educated family forces their daughter-in-law to end her life for dowry. What is wrong with Maharashtra? Is this the Maharashtra that we dream of? The situation is very disturbing… Isn't it our responsibility as NCP to make Maharashtra dowry-free. Are we hankering only for power? Let us start a campaign against all social evils. Let us go around in Maharashtra. If the king is moving around in a plane, how will he know the plight of the people,' she said. She said the NCP came to power within six months of its formation. 'After that it remained in power for 18 years. The party has grown because of its dedicated and devoted workers and leaders. Everyone has contributed. Also, we cannot forget the contribution of those who are no more like R R Patil and others,' she said. Sule said Sharad Pawar's speech in rain in Satara completely changed the poll scenario in 2019. 'I cannot forget the incident of July 2… It changed the poll scenario completely,' she said. 'We have people who have never left Pawar saheb. These are men of steel,' she said.

Bengal Assembly Resolution on Pahalgam terror Attack: Mamata slams Centre, says ‘Total failure, colossal lapse in internal security'
Bengal Assembly Resolution on Pahalgam terror Attack: Mamata slams Centre, says ‘Total failure, colossal lapse in internal security'

Indian Express

time14 minutes ago

  • Indian Express

Bengal Assembly Resolution on Pahalgam terror Attack: Mamata slams Centre, says ‘Total failure, colossal lapse in internal security'

West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee on Tuesday demanded the resignation of the BJP government at the Centre over the Pahalgam terror attack in which 26 men, mostly tourists, were killed, calling it a 'total failure of the government' and a 'colossal lapse' in internal security. Speaking in the Assembly during the passing of a resolution commending the Indian armed forces for their precision strikes on terror hubs in Pakistan during Operation Sindoor – though the resolution did not mention its name – the chief minister said India had a 'golden opportunity' to reclaim Pakistan-occupied Kashmir (PoK) during last month's military conflict but failed to act decisively as she questioned the foreign policy of the BJP government. 'We had an opportunity to take control of PoK. Instead, Pakistan has been allowed in a committee on terrorism created by the UN. Is there a flaw in our foreign policy?' she said. Demanding accountability from the Centre for what she called a 'colossal lapse' in internal security during the Pahalgam terror attack, the chief minister said: 'When terrorists attacked, there were no police there. Kashmir police is not controlled by the state government. Those who were attacked by the terrorists repeatedly asked for help. But no police personnel, Army men were there to help them… Why were no security forces or police personnel present at the spot? We don't know the attackers in Pahalgam till date. No one has been arrested…Why? How did such an attack happen in a high-security zone.. This is a total failure of government, a total failure of agencies.' Asserting that 'we don't support terrorism; it has no religion, caste, or creed', Banerjee said those responsible for the Pahalgam killings must be brought to justice without delay. She praised the Indian military action, stating, 'There was a need for teaching them a lesson. We salute the bravery of our armed forces.' Referring to Prime Minister Narendra Modi's roadshows following Operation Sindoor, the TMC chief said that he was only 'busy advertising himself'. 'You just roam around promoting sindoor. We respect sindoor. You don't respect women. Why didn't the Prime Minister visit Rajouri, Poonch sites (hit by Pakistan shelling)?' she asked. Accusing the BJP of trying to politicise the valour of the armed forces with an eye on elections, she also recalled how the BJP allegedly politicised the Pulwama terror attack in the past and warned against similar attempts to 'provoke unrest' ahead of the upcoming general elections. Pointing to the BJP legislators, who chanted 'Modi Modi', Banerjee said: 'Apnader bhoi laage… Election aele ekta Pulwama korte hobe, eta jeno na hoi ('We are afraid of you…when election comes, do another Pulwama, that should not happen)'. She was referring to Pulwama terror attack in which a suicide bomber targeted a convoy of the CRPF, killing nearly 40 personnel, on Februaray 14, 2019, months ahead of the Lok Sabha elections. The CM also questioned why the Prime Minister or Defence Minister Rajnath Singh did not visit any foreign country instead had sent parliamentary delegations composed of MPs from Opposition parties. 'You needed to send your own minister, your Defence Minister. You should have gone yourself. Instead of you going, you sent the opposition parties, they did that job. That's why I thank them for doing their job brilliantly,' she said. Seven parliamentary delegations were sent to major global capitals to reinforce India's diplomatic messaging following Operation Sindoor. Amidst the ruckus, Banerjee continued her attack on the Centre, raising questions, and the recent appointment of Pakistan as the vice chair of the UN's anti-terror committee. 'Pakistan has become the vice chair of the UN's anti-terror committee. How? Were we lacking in diplomatic relations?' she asked, while calling External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar 'a good person, a capable bureaucrat.' Pakistan, a non-permanent member of the Security Council for the 2025-26 term, will chair the Council's Taliban Sanctions Committee for 2025 and will be vice-chair of the Counter-Terrorism Committee of the 15-nation UN organ. She also expressed concern about India's diplomatic strategy with respect to Pakistan. 'I don't know if there is an issue with our diplomacy, as Pakistan is still getting loans from the IMF, instead of being cornered internationally,' the CM said. She added, 'I support the resolution because I think this strike was important to send a strong message. I pay my respects to those who lost their lives. Terrorism can never be forgiven.' Banerjee referred to reports of Pakistani spies being arrested from Gujarat, the home state of Union Home Minister Amit Shah. 'How did information from Modi-Shah's state reach Pakistan?' she asked. Tempers flared in the House when BJP legislators interrupted her speech. Banerjee shot back, calling the BJP 'uncivilised' and 'liars'. 'You are fake Hindus. My voice will drown out your noise. You only promote yourselves and insult the people of this country,' she said, addressing the BJP benches amid loud sloganeering from both the opposition and treasury benches. With PTI Atri Mitra is a Special Correspondent of The Indian Express with more than 20 years of experience in reporting from West Bengal, Bihar and the North-East. He has been covering administration and political news for more than ten years and has a keen interest in political development in West Bengal. Atri holds a Master degree in Economics from Rabindrabharati University and Bachelor's degree from Calcutta University. He is also an alumnus of St. Xavier's, Kolkata and Ramakrishna Mission Asrama, Narendrapur. He started his career with leading vernacular daily the Anandabazar Patrika, and worked there for more than fifteen years. He worked as Bihar correspondent for more than three years for Anandabazar Patrika. He covered the 2009 Lok Sabha election and 2010 assembly elections. He also worked with News18-Bangla and covered the Bihar Lok Sabha election in 2019. ... Read More

Op Sindoor showed India now responds with strength if war imposed on it: Yogi
Op Sindoor showed India now responds with strength if war imposed on it: Yogi

Time of India

time14 minutes ago

  • Time of India

Op Sindoor showed India now responds with strength if war imposed on it: Yogi

Lucknow: Chief Minister on Tuesday said that showcased India's military might and asserted that India now responds with strength rather than silence if someone imposes war on the country. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Speaking at a press conference to highlight the achievements of the Modi govt at the Centre in past 11 years, the CM said that these years would be remembered as a "golden period in the making of a self-reliant India". "India now responds with strength rather than silence and if someone imposes war on the country, the answer will be in the form of Operation Sindoor. If someone encourages terrorism, the answer will be surgical strikes, air strikes and Operation Sindoor," Yogi said. "The whole world has seen the Indian military power, tested in Pakistan and trusted by the world," he added. "There was a tendency to chant the mantra of peace even in the face of aggression. But through the 'new normal' established under the current leadership, that approach has been completely reversed. Now, India responds with strength, not silence." He said that under Modi's leadership, India regained its honour on the global platform, which had "diminished during the 65 years of Congress and other unstable govts", he said. He said that PM Modi had given India a distinct global identity. "His governance is marked by service, good administration and welfare of the poor. Better service delivery on the ground has been assigned as primary duty and responsibility in the BJP ruled states," Yogi said. "Country has become free of corruption and nepotism while appeasement of community has been discouraged. Before 2014, country was facing various threats and vulnerabilities but after Modi took over, New India has leaped on the path of progress," he added. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now "The vision of 'Ek Bharat, Shreshtha Bharat' (One India, Great India) is being realised. India's 140 crore citizens have witnessed the govt's firm commitment to national unity and integrity, as well as its decisive approach towards security and terrorism," he added. Highlighting economic progress, he said the country's economy made great strides under PM Modi. "Through constant monitoring and thoughtful spending outlay, our country has become fourth largest economy in the world. India is the only country which has managed to double its per capita income from Rs 79,000 in 2013-14 to Rs 2.5 lakh. Soon, the country will climb to the third spot," he said. "Before 2014, India was marked by instability. Economy was uncertain, and people lacked confidence about the country's future. From 1947 to 2014, India had only managed to become the world's 11th largest economy and even that was fragile," he said. "Focus has been on deploying technology tools. Our govt has redefined the way IT services and direct beneficiary transfers are taking place," Yogi said. Referring to the abrogation of Article 370, Yogi said that decision brought Jammu, Kashmir and Ladakh fully into the constitutional fold. Pointing towards the way infrastructure has been augmented, Yogi said that pace of highway construction had tripled — from 11km per day during the UPA era to over 35km per day at present. "Successful coordination of faith and economy has created a new model of development, with spiritual heritage becoming a catalyst for economic growth," he said and cited the example of the Maha Kumbh, where five new economic corridors emerged, boosting employment and regional economies. "Under Lakhpati Didi Yojana, the goal is to make 3 crore women financially independent. Already, 10 crore women have joined over 90 lakh self-help groups. Presently, 14,500 schools are being upgraded under PM Shri school for foundational education. Since 2014, 8 new IITs, 7 IIMs, 490 new universities have been established and 8.6 lakh jobs were created through PSUs," Yogi said. "PM's vision of 'Healthy India, Capable India' has brought unprecedented reforms in the country's healthcare sector. While Congress govts built only one AIIMS, Atal Bihari Vajpayee added six, and Prime Minister Modi expanded the number to 23 — including two in Uttar Pradesh (Gorakhpur and Rae Bareli)," he said. "Till 2014, India had just 180 medical colleges but now there are 2,045 medical colleges nationwide, with 80 in Uttar Pradesh alone," Yogi said. He said that under Ayushman Bharat, over 50 crore people had been provided health cover and free treatment worth Rs 1.3 lakh crore. "Through e-Sanjeevani, over 37 crore teleconsultations have been provided, transforming healthcare accessibility across India," he said.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store