logo
Beyond the Courtroom: Fali Nariman's legal legacy

Beyond the Courtroom: Fali Nariman's legal legacy

Indian Express25-04-2025

'The characteristic features of Indian culture have long been a search for ultimate verities and the concomitant disciple-guru relationship' – these are the first words of Autobiography of a Yogi written by Indian spiritual leader Paramahansa Yogananda, originally published in 1946.
Close to eight decades later, a manifestation of these very words came to public notice in the relationship between the late Fali S. Nariman, a towering figure in Indian Jurisprudence and Subhash Sharma, his trusted lieutenant for nearly 40 years.
In fact, Sharma had read out a 1952 speech of Yogananda to Nariman five hours before the eminent lawyer breathed his last on February 21 last year. 'I started crying after reading the speech…looking at me, Fali started weeping too,' Sharma told The Indian Express.
Months after his death, Sharma meticulously curated a book with a selection of Nariman's most influential speeches.
'Beyond the Courtroom' showcases the vast breadth and depth of Nariman's constitutional expertise through his illuminating lectures and articles. It even goes a step further outlining the jurists views on the state of Indian Democracy. From making arguments on why a new constitution is impossible today, to stating why a strong opposition is needed for the betterment of democracy, this book covers a wide range of subjects.
'The first lesson about written constitutions is that they don't function on their own. A special effort must be made by their custodians – those entrusted with their functioning – to work them,' reads a chapter titled 'The Silences in our Constitutional Law'.
This chapter stood out as it speaks about how the Silences of the constitution were interpreted and in turn its provisions broadened by the Judiciary. This reinterpretation, argued Nariman, has made the document a 'dynamic, living' one.
Nariman speaks about the evolution of Article 368 of the constitution (power of Parliament to amend constitution) to drive home the point of the dynamism of the constitution and bringing to the fore the tussle between the Parliament and the Judiciary.
He begins with how within a year of the constitution being brought into force, the Parliament passed the first amendment of the Constitution which dispensed with the payment of compensation for taking over large estates (zamindaries). Article 31A and 31B were introduced which provided that legislations for agrarian or land reforms were outside the protection of the fundamental right to property. 'Article 31 B was an innovation,' says Nariman, as it protected enactments included in the ninth schedule of the constitution from being declared void on the basis of infringement of fundamental rights.
In 1971, he points out, came more amendments, all meant to further limit the power of the constitution and increase that of the parliament by limiting which laws Courts could declare void if passed in contravention of fundamental rights.
Nariman traces the history of this tussle all the way to the Basic Structure Doctrine in 1973 where it was finally decided by a 13 judge bench held that the power of the Parliament to amend the Constitution couldn't alter its 'basic structure'. In the next chapter Nariman says: '…the only final interpreter of the Constitution is the judiciary' pointing out the active role that he feels judges must play in bringing life to the document.
Divided into five sections (Nation, Judiciary, Constitution, Law and Arbitration), the book also offers advice for young lawyers, tackles ethical questions and is sprinkled with quips throughout – usually towards the end of each chapter.
'Paramhansa used to think Mahatma Gandhi was a prophet…for me, Nariman was a prophet,' Sharma told The Indian Express. 'I've always felt this deep spiritual connection with him. I can't put a finger on it, but I always somehow felt close to him.'
Sharma is a well-known name in the legal circles and has been the devoted gatekeeper for Nariman's offices. As his junior since 1986, Sharma's name appears in virtually every case handled by Nariman. It was Sharma who would be the first point of contact for lawyers or litigants to Nariman's office since the veteran neither carried a cell phone nor directly accessed his email account.
Sharma considers it a stroke of serendipity that he got a chance to work with Nariman. After the book was published in early 2025, he kept a copy on the shrine of Yogananda – who was revered by both – in Forest Lawns, Los Angeles.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

U.K., and four other allies sanction Israeli Ministers Ben-Gvir, Smotrich
U.K., and four other allies sanction Israeli Ministers Ben-Gvir, Smotrich

The Hindu

time28 minutes ago

  • The Hindu

U.K., and four other allies sanction Israeli Ministers Ben-Gvir, Smotrich

The U.K, along with Australia, Canada, New Zealand and Norway, has sanctioned two Israeli Government Ministers, Itamar Ben-Gvir and Bezalel Smotrich on Tuesday, 'for inciting violence against Palestinians in the West Bank'. While the move was focused on the West Bank, a joint statement from the countries said it could not be viewed in isolation from the 'catastrophe' in Gaza. 'There must be no unlawful transfer of Palestinians from Gaza or within the West Bank, nor any reduction in the territory of the Gaza Strip, the statement said. With regard to the U.K. both Ministers will immediately be subject to an asset freeze, travel ban and be disqualified from the directorship, management, formation or promotion of a British company. Also read | Western countries condemn expansion of Israeli operations in Gaza The move comes as pressure mounts on the government of U.K. Prime Minister Keir Starmer change tack and adopt a stronger position against Israel's actions, particularly its military operations in Gaza and restrictions on humanitarian aid reaching the strip. Last month the U.K. announced sanctions against certain Israeli settlers in the West Bank and the suspension of trade talks with Tel Aviv. Last week, former Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn led a group of MPs in introducing a bill in the U.K. Parliament calling for an independent inquiry into the U.K. government's role in the Israel-Gaza conflict since October 2023. Israeli Foreign Minister Gideon Sa'ar said the Israeli government had been 'informed' of U.K.'s decision to sanction its ministers . Mr Sa'ar said it was 'outrageous' that elected representatives could be subject to these kind of actions and that a special meeting would be held early next week to decide on a response to the sanctions. The sanctioning countries emphasized that the move did not undermine their 'unwavering' commitment to Israel's security and their condemnation of the October 7, 2023 attack on Israel by Hamas. The actions of Mr Smotrich and Mr Ben-Gvir had undermined Israel's security, the statement said, adding that the sanctioning countries continued to want a 'strong friendship' with the people of Israel.

Mamata slams centre over Pahalgam attack, lauds armed forces for Operation Sindoor
Mamata slams centre over Pahalgam attack, lauds armed forces for Operation Sindoor

United News of India

time38 minutes ago

  • United News of India

Mamata slams centre over Pahalgam attack, lauds armed forces for Operation Sindoor

Kolkata, June 10 (UNI) West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee on Tuesday strongly criticised the BJP-led Union government over the April 22 terror attack in Pahalgam, Jammu and Kashmir, which claimed 26 lives, mostly tourists. Speaking on a resolution in the state Assembly moved from the Chair conveying appreciation for Indian Armed forces in combating militant and terrorist activities in Jammu and Kashmir, Banerjee called the incident a result of the Centre's "callousness and total failure" and demanded political accountability, asserting that the government had failed to ensure citizens' security. Banerjee questioned the absence of security forces at the site during the attack, asking, 'Why were no security personnel or police present?' She condemned the politicisation of the armed forces' bravery, accusing the BJP of using military valour for electoral gains. Despite her sharp criticism of the Centre, Banerjee praised the Indian armed forces for their actions during Operation Sindoor, launched on May 7 in response to the Pahalgam attack. The operation led to the destruction of nine terror camps in Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied Kashmir. 'There was a need to teach the terrorists a lesson. We salute the bravery of our armed forces,' she said. Banerjee further said that during the military escalation, India had an opportunity to assert control over Pakistan-occupied Kashmir. 'Our party strongly stands against terrorism. Terrorism has no religion, caste, or creed. We demand justice for the victims of the Pahalgam attack,' she added. The chief minister also raised concerns about India's international diplomacy, noting that Pakistan secured loans from the IMF despite its involvement in cross-border terrorism. She criticised Prime Minister Narendra Modi, accusing him of focusing more on self-promotion than national security. Following India's strike, Pakistan retaliated with shelling and drone attacks along the Line of Control. India responded by targeting Pakistani military infrastructure, including the Nur Khan and Rahim Yar Khan airbases. Both nations agreed to de-escalate on May 10. The state Assembly adopted a resolution to honour the courage of the armed forces but the opposition alleged that there was no mention of 'Operation Sindoor" in the text of the resolution. ''Operation Sindoor' is not mentioned in the resolution. It is surprising. The House is praising the armed forces without mentioning the name of the operation. Her sentiments towards our armed forces and Prime Minister Modi seem contradictory—both cannot coexist,' a BJP legislator remarked. UNI XC SSP

PM meets Op Sindoor delegates who took India's stand against terrorism global
PM meets Op Sindoor delegates who took India's stand against terrorism global

India Today

time40 minutes ago

  • India Today

PM meets Op Sindoor delegates who took India's stand against terrorism global

Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Tuesday met members of the seven multi-party delegations that recently travelled to over 30 countries to highlight India's strong stance against terrorism following Operation meeting took place at the Prime Minister's residence at 7, Lok Kalyan Marg in Delhi. Delegation members, including MPs from across party lines, former parliamentarians and senior diplomats, shared their experiences of engaging with foreign leaders and representatives during their outreach. The seven multi-party delegations recently travelled to over 30 countries and spoke about India's anti-terror operation. advertisementThe delegations had been sent as part of India's diplomatic campaign to draw attention to the Pahalgam terror attack and India's subsequent response. Each group visited key capitals around the world to underline India's resolve against Pakistan-sponsored terrorism and reinforce the country's commitment to global peace. "The visit was aimed at projecting national unity and ensuring the global community hears one voice from India on terrorism," said a government official earlier. The outreach is part of a larger effort to counter Pakistan's attempts to internationalise the Kashmir issue while downplaying cross-border 50 individuals were part of the outreach mission, including current and former MPs and ex-diplomats. Among the leaders who headed the delegations were BJP's Ravi Shankar Prasad and Baijayant Panda, Congress MP Shashi Tharoor, JD(U)'s Sanjay Jha, Shiv Sena's Shrikant Shinde, DMK's Kanimozhi, and NCP(SP)'s Supriya Sule. The presence of leaders from the opposition as well as the ruling alliance lent the initiative a bipartisan External Affairs Ministry had earlier appreciated the teams for representing India's stance effectively in international forums. Foreign Minister S Jaishankar also held a separate interaction with the delegates last week, praising their role in building global awareness about the threat of terrorism emanating from delegation had a specific regional focus — from the US and Europe to the Middle East, Africa, and Southeast Asia. Discussions ranged from counterterrorism cooperation to strategic partnerships, with the Indian teams also addressing concerns related to misinformation and government's decision to send inclusive delegations, featuring MPs like Asaduddin Owaisi (AIMIM), Manish Tewari (Congress), and Prem Chand Gupta (RJD), was widely seen as an attempt to present a unified front on an issue of national Prime Minister's interaction with the delegates capped off a significant phase of India's diplomatic offensive post-Operation Sindoor.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store