Poor handling of transgression
The Green Island vs Taieri game from two weeks ago is in the headlines for all the wrong reasons — a citing and suspension. Social media as per usual has bubbled over. I've had a lot of comment from club coaches, officials, supporters (unsolicited) on the goings on. I'm not here to re-litigate the event, that's for judicials and appeals boards. I've seen the video on numerous occasions and we just got this wrong. The incident while not deliberate, was reckless and should have been sorted at the judicial hearing Wednesday week ago. It was a difficult one as the officials missed it thus there was no card. Green Island cited the Taieri player post game. Following the judicial meeting, the player was handed a one-week suspension. Green Island were rightly not happy and appealed to the NZRU. As I write this column (on Thursday afternoon) no decision has been forthcoming. If the Taieri player had received a sentence commensurate with the transgression, say a four-week suspension, the matter would have been done and dusted. Nobody has won out of this, justice for the injured player and our guilty player is being tried four times. Twice by the judiciary, once by media, and by social media. The judiciary system in Otago in my view works pretty well as a rule but we've let ourselves down here. Also the ''secret squirrel'' process used for judicial inquiries makes no real sense. We need to look at what happened and make sure it doesn't recur. The second round
The only people who have trouble with the scoring system for the split round of the Prem Competition are the ODT sports reporters and a few supporters. So this is the last time I'll explain it, so read carefully. We've had the first round and every team had a bye which no points were awarded for. In the split round over five weeks, there is two pools, 1, 3, 5, 7, 9 and 2, 4, 6, 8 based on where you finished the round robin. You play across pool, so the first pool will all have a bye and initially no points are allocated for that. At the end of the round 5, 4, 3, 2, 1 points will be allocated to our first pool depending where they finish in the second round. The teams in pool 1 with top team first are Dunedin, Southern, Harbour, Varsity and AU. Simple really, and no correspondence please. Rugby, racing Sunday
The last big meeting for the season for Otago Racing Club is on at Wingatui on Sunday starting at 11.30am. All sports clubs are invited to the event and to take part in the Punters Club and associated activities. Just get a hold of Noelle today, she is taking late entries on 022 035 8373 or gm@wingatui.co.nz. There are great prizes and it's always a great day. I hear five rugby clubs are in, including Taieri, GI and West Taieri plus a few other sports clubs. Get involved I'll see you out there. Topp Cup on the farm
It's that time of year again when the rugby comps in South and Central Otago are put on hold for the Mighty Topp Cup. This is where the best of South and Central Otago go to war in the annual tribal battle.This year it's being played in Alexandra at Molyneux Park. The Topp Cup is at 3pm with the Development game played as the curtain raiser at 1.15pm. There are kids' games late morning and a junior colts and women's development game thrown in. So if you're passing, drop in for a gander. There is no love lost between Central and South Otago when it comes to the Topp Cup. More fauna on the Taieri
We all know there is fauna on the Taieri in the shape of Eels but there was another intruder behind the bar in the Taieri Club on Saturday afternoon. A few of the lads were having a beer during the game (shame on you!) when they noticed screaming from the bar and Fred the barman was wielding a softball bat with malice. As the fracas subsided, it came to light he was hunting a nefarious rat although he may have claimed it was just an extraordinarily large mouse. One question? How tough does it get out there on a Saturday night if he's got a softball bat behind the bar? The late mail
I hear Southern's other stalwart lock Corban Agar plays his 50th game this weekend — good on ya mate. I also hear the DCC called off practice on council grounds last night because of rain. Calm down team, it hasn't rained for three months! I know it's wet at the Edgar Centre but the grounds are crying out for some of that! This weekend
Destroyed Mayor Jules with a perfect 60 points (all games and margins) so he has had a forgettable year — bad luck mate. On to Otago Volts' best ,Thorn Parkes, who is starting out with a –10 differential, so he'll be an also ran come Monday. GI are at home to Varsity out at the Toolbox and chances are the track will be heavy. This game will be very tight as Varsity may have some ''NZU'' players back and GI will have a few Landers out. Green Island are the favourites but I'm smelling an upset as Varsity (12-) are their bogey team. Taieri (13+) are at home to Harbour for the second time in six weeks and the Eels are travelling well despite the narrow loss to the Sharks — they get up comfortably. Dunedin (13+) beat Zingers by 70 a few weeks ago, so go in as favourites. They've got a lot of experience out injured but should prevail. In the last game Kaik (13+) will be all over AU like a cheap suit.
Down on the farm I suffered the worst loss of my career to Clark (Yam Fingers) Frew, so still struggling to sleep. Anyways, on to Ernie Muir, one of South Otago's favourite sons. Played rugby and cricket down there forever and was still reffing until recently — much to the horror of visiting teams! We go head to head on Topp Cup games, so I have my work cut out. In the big game I'll take Central (12-) at home in Alex but with no real conviction. In the Development game I'll also take Central (12-) but I'm positive they win. In the women's game, I'll take AU (13+) to beat Central because they need to win something!
paul.dwyer@odt.co.nz
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
18 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Skating on down to the roller derby
The speed, strategy and shoulder-to-shoulder thrills of roller derby will be on show this weekend. Dunedin Derby is presenting "Frozen Fury", Sunday, 1pm at the Edgar Centre. The free afternoon of demonstration games will feature athletes from Dunedin's A team, the Gallow Lasses and B team, the Bonnie Brawlers, along with players from Southern Most Skaters, of Invercargill and Dead End Derby, of Christchurch. Dunedin Bonnie Brawlers coach Kate Kavanagh said the inter-league scrimmage was an opportunity to showcase what roller derby was all about. "It is a fun game." The family-friendly and inclusive sport built confidence, she said. Whether you are suited to be a nimble "jammer" or a sturdy "blocker", there were plenty of roles. "If you are tall or small, or you are strong and big, or you are little and tiny there is a space for you." The free event on Sunday was an opportunity for people to learn about the sport and decide if they want to join. Besides training to be a player, there were other opportunities for people to take part. Participants could serve as non-skating officials, timing penalties and jams or operating the scoreboard. People could also train as referees "in the zebra stripes", skating while monitoring the action inside and outside the track. "So yeah, there's lots of ways that you can get involved in derby." For those choosing to take the plunge, the team's "Learn to Skate" programme took place on Sundays in the afternoon, she said. "It takes around six months to get from Learn to Skate to actually doing contact and being able to play. It's quite an intensive course." "We do have skates and protective gear for people who want to learn to skate that they can borrow." The course taught skills such as skating forwards and backwards, stopping safely and manoeuvring around others. If people decided after the programme that playing was not for them, the skills would still come in handy for on-skate or off-skate officiating. "A lot of the skills that you do in Learn to Skate will transfer to being a ref." For beginners who had never skated, a pathway into roller derby was to first join the Dunedin Inline/Roller Skaters entry level group. The roller derby team trained on Tuesday and Thursday nights and Sunday mornings "Safety is really important to us, obviously we wear lots of gear, we don't want to get injured. "We do quite intensive warm-ups to make sure we are ready to skate." Roller derby players adopted derby names; for example, Kavanagh's was Flat Liner. She said it was a very enjoyable sport. "I think the people are awesome, a really good group of people. "The fitness is amazing, so it is a really good way to keep fit. "The sport is a good way to relieve a bit of stress". "If you're doing the contact stuff, you know, you can come and hit people. And they want to be hit, so that's quite fun."
Otago Daily Times
3 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Shadows over netball's place in the sun
Netball has long had a special place for New Zealanders. It has been the number one women's team sport in both interest and participation. Its stars, outside of Olympic Games heroes, often represented the pinnacle of sporting achievement for female sport. Netball legends, including Dunedin's former New Zealand representative and revered coach Lois Muir, have long been admired and celebrated. Showdowns against Australia were eagerly anticipated. A broad cross-section of sporting fans recognised the team and its players. Viewership during the heyday of World Championship and Commonwealth Games finals was immense. Yet, much has and is changing, at least at the elite level. The domestic netball competition once commanded high fees for broadcast rights. These were sold to Sky, both a blessing and a curse. The money enabled the players to be paid salaries and boosted professionalism but, because the games were on a subscription service, much of the population was excluded. Children had fewer opportunities to see potential heroes in action. Netball faded a little from the limelight. Netball's appeal to broadcasters has waned, and in recent months it has struggled to secure a broadcast partner. While TVNZ 1 will now show games live and on demand, reports suggest Netball New Zealand had to pay for the privilege. This year, the domestic competition was shortened to reduce costs. Its format for next season remains uncertain. Meanwhile, top players are heading overseas in search of better financial rewards. Superstar Grace Nweke left for Australia this year, initially sacrificing her eligibility to represent New Zealand. Unable to offer competitive salaries, Netball NZ has backtracked, allowing certain players, including Nweke, to depart while retaining Silver Fern eligibility. The criteria for this dispensation remain undisclosed. Several players are heading overseas, including Southern Steel co-captain Kate Heffernan. Who can blame them, when top players might earn $120,000 in Australia compared to just $60,000 in New Zealand? Even that figure is uncertain, with pay cuts expected next year, and many players earning significantly less. Next year, the televised league will also lack the draw of its 10 or so most recognised netballers, weakening its appeal. On the other hand, the presence of many of them in the Australian league could offer a new platform for New Zealand fans to follow the sport Netball might go the way of basketball, football and rugby league, with one or two New Zealand teams competing in Australia. That would be a long way from the days when the two countries shared a competition with the same number of teams. Premier netball is shifting from professional to semi-professional, and perhaps even amateur. Unlike rugby or cricket, it lacks a male counterpart to help underpin professional structures. Unlike football, it lacks international clout and the revenue generated by World Cups. And unlike basketball, it is not a global sport offering pathways such as US college scholarships. Viewers now have compelling alternatives in women's rugby, rugby league, football, and cricket, most of which carry greater overall clout. These sports are also drawing athletic talent that once gravitated toward netball. As a result, netball's standards are likely to decline, and New Zealand may struggle to consistently reclaim a top-two global ranking. Netball also faces intensified competition for commercial interest and sponsorship. The good news is the enduring strength at the community level. It continues to benefit from dedicated volunteers and, particularly in the South, capable development officers. Southland, of course, remains the standout region for netball support. Netball New Zealand's registered player numbers rose from about 120,000 in 2024 to about 145,000 last year. However, there may have been a decline in secondary school participation. Basketball and volleyball have grown in popularity. Indoor team sports have growing costs and organisational advantages over those based on fields. Volleyball demonstrates that a high profile is not necessary to thrive. Netball's deep roots in New Zealand society will serve it well in the challenging times ahead.
Otago Daily Times
3 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Young Canterbury entrepreneur working to help women in sport
Canterbury's Molly Macpherson is on a mission to keep girls active through sport and change the culture around female participation as they grow up. The 20-year-old from West Melton has been developing her start-up, EmpowerHer, since the beginning of the year. It aims to educate and support girls and women in sport, while also helping coaches better understand how to work with female athletes. 'Something I'm really passionate about is stopping girls from dropping out of sports. 'It is a programme designed to educate girls and women about how their body works in sport, and why sport is good for the female body,' Macpherson said. Her efforts were recently recognised at the Selwyn Awards, where she won the Young Contributor award. EmpowerHer was also a finalist in the Innovation category. Macpherson said Maggie, her 14-year-old sister, was one of the inspirations behind the initiative. 'I've seen her go through the struggles and the ups and downs, not wanting to play sport. Being a bit taller than others, I think she struggled with that.' She said puberty could also be a struggle for girls. Research by Sport NZ in 2022 showed that by age 16, there is a 17% gap between male and female participation in sport and recreation in New Zealand, rising to 28% by age 17. Macpherson knows these challenges firsthand. Although currently sidelined with an injury, she normally plays basketball for UC Christchurch Girls' High in the French Cup and had hoped to represent the Selwyn Hawks. But there was no girls' team available for her age group. 'I've struggled with getting into sports because there are not many girls my age playing.' As well as supporting young female athletes, she wants to see coaches educated, too. 'I want coaches to do this programme too so they know how females work,' Macpherson said. To support her start-up, Macpherson is studying sports coaching and business management at Canterbury University. She also coaches an under-16 Selwyn Hawks team and is an assistant coach for the under-16 rep team, and helps run the Girls Got Game holiday programme for the Hawks. While she recovers from injury, she stays involved in the game as floor controller for Canterbury Basketball every Saturday. Macpherson's love of basketball began at Darfield High School, where the sport had started gaining popularity. She has since become a fan of the WNBA, the women's professional league in the United States, and says Caitlin Clark of the Indiana Fever is her favourite player. Outside basketball, she also coaches tennis – a sport she started playing aged five, though she no longer competes herself. If that wasn't enough, Macpherson has also been running her own gardening business for the past three years. 'Dad owns a landscaping business, so I started helping out, and then went out on my own,' she said. Her business interest started at high school, where she was part of the Young Enterprise Scheme. Her team won the regional final with their design for a drink bottle holder to be used with a car's cup holder. After winning, they pitched their idea to water bottle company Frank Green, where they learned a big lesson about business – don't give away your design. 'We made contact with Frank Green, and they were really happy and wanted to work with us. So, we sent them our plans – and they ghosted us. 'A couple of weeks later, they came out with their own.'
