Four Targa Tasmania rally race deaths due to 'driver error', coroner concludes
Veteran driver Shane Navin was killed in the 2021 race when his 1979 Mazda RX-7 crashed at Double Barrel Creek on the Mount Arrowsmith stage of the race on the state's west coast.
His co-driver Glenn Evans survived.
The following day, driver Leigh Mundy, 68, of Hobart, and his co-driver Dennis Neagle, 59, of Withcott, Queensland, crashed on Wattle Grove Road near Cygnet.
The following year, on the first day of the competition, Anthony 'Tony' Seymour died in a crash on the Mt Roland stage in the state's north-west.
A coronial inquest was held in Hobart last year to examine the deaths of the Targa Tasmania competitors.
In his findings, released on Thursday, Tasmanian coroner Simon Cooper said the common factor for deaths of Mr Mundy, Mr Neagle and Mr Seymour was "excessive speed".
"I do not consider Mr Mundy and Mr Seymour took adequate precautions and care for their own safety (and the safety of their passengers) by driving at speeds that were, in all of the circumstances, excessive," Mr Cooper said.
"I consider Mr Navin's death was also due to driver error."
Mr Cooper also found that the driver's health was a "factor in each case".
"I do not consider people suffering from the medical conditions that Mr Mundy and Mr Seymour had, should have been competing in such an event," he said.
Mr Cooper said recommendations made from an internal review of the event "were comprehensive, and … adequately address many of the factors associated with the inquest".
That review made 94 recommendations in February 2023 to make future events safer.
The Motorsport Australia review, which made sweeping changes to Targa rules and safety requirements, came in the wake of four deaths within two years during Tasmanian events.
In February 2023, the Targa Review Panel released its report with 94 recommendations.
The popular events draw hundreds of competitors from around the country who race on public roads across a number of days.
Targa Tasmania is a six-day 1,900-kilometre rally.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
24 minutes ago
- ABC News
Geraldton mother Monique Burton to be sentenced over newborn baby's body in freezer
WARNING: This story contains distressing details. A woman who secretly gave birth on her lounge room floor put her newborn baby boy in a plastic bag before her partner stored the infant's body in a freezer, a Perth court has been told. Monique Ellen Burton, 35, denied being pregnant and told friends she had a terminal illness, which saw her raise thousands of dollars via a GoFundMe page. The mother, from Geraldton, is set to be sentenced in Perth tomorrow — and her appearance in the Perth District Court today unveiled the horrific circumstances surrounding the baby's birth. The court heard Burton gave birth at home in August 2022 before putting the baby in a plastic garbage bag and hiding it behind the couch. She claims it was stillborn, but police have not been able to determine when or how the baby died. Methamphetamine was detected in the baby's system, the court was told. Burton managed to conceal the fact she had just given birth from her partner Shaun Bradley Balaam, who took her to hospital because she was visibly ill. Once there, she denied giving birth, telling staff she had been menstruating, prosecutor Jehna Winter told the court. When he got home, Balaam found the garbage bag containing the baby — though he said he did not look inside. He told police he suspected it may have been a baby as he knew Burton had a history of concealing pregnancies, and had felt what he suspected was a head when picking up the bag. He put the bag in a chest freezer, under a bag of dog food, the court was told. Burton was meanwhile transferred to King Edward Memorial Hospital in Perth, where she was "repeatedly asked" about giving birth, but continued to deny she'd been pregnant. A friend then set up a GoFundMe on her behalf claiming she had been diagnosed with terminal liver cancer. Burton had made a minor liver issue "seem worse than it was", and got more than $3,000 in donations, the court heard. However, she was "never diagnosed with a terminal illness," Ms Winter said, and had never undergone dialysis Police became involved once Burton finally revealed to a social worker that the baby was "in the freezer on the back verandah", claiming it had been stillborn. Officers visited the house and found the body of the baby boy, with his legs were crossed, "arms close to his chest" and the umbilical cord still attached. The prosecutor said investigations "couldn't determine cause of death or whether it had taken a first breath". Ms Winter told the court that the boy was "anatomically normal" but methylamphetamine was detected in his system. The court heard Burton could not say why she did not reveal the pregnancy. Her lawyer Anthony Elliott described the concealment as 'amateurish'and said it was 'unlikely there was any sinister intention.' Mr Elliott said she suffered from 'depressive episodes' due to trauma, but "In terms of moral culpability, this is towards the lower end of the scale." Burton had pleaded guilty to interfering with a corpse with intent to prevent an investigation into the circumstances surrounding the death, and multiple counts of fraud related to the GoFundMe. Earlier, her partner Balaam received a 12-month community based order in Geraldton after admitting improper interference with a corpse. Burton is set to be sentenced on Friday.
ABC News
24 minutes ago
- ABC News
Home Affairs minister met with FBI director during secretive Australia visit
FBI Director Kash Patel paid a quiet visit Australia this week, with Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke later confirming he dined with the law enforcement chief while he was Sydney. Mr Patel, who is a loyalist of US President Donald Trump, stopped in Sydney earlier this week before travelling to New Zealand to announce the US would expand its FBI office in Wellington. Neither Australia nor the United States publicly flagged the visit, but after he was approached by the ABC Mr Burke said he "enjoyed" his evening with Mr Patel. "We share a commitment to keeping our people safe, and I'm optimistic about what we can achieve together in the interest of national security," he said. A source confirmed the FBI chief met with other officials from the security community while in Sydney, but played-down the significance of the stop-off, suggesting Mr Patel's main focus was on his New Zealand visit. Mr Patel wields significant power as the head of the US's law enforcement but he is also a controversial figure, in part because he's called some of those jailed for the January 6 assault on Capitol Hill "political prisoners". Greens home affairs spokesperson David Shoebridge on Thursday called on the government to provide "more transparency" over the meeting. "The minister, understandably, wanted his meeting with a defender of the January 6 rioters, kept secret," he said. "Equally understandably, the Australian public has an interest in knowing who our minister for home affairs is meeting with, and why. "Going forward the best way to avoid public concern about meeting with Trump appointees who defend the January 6 riots is not to meet them in the first place." While opening the FBI's new permanent office in New Zealand, Mr Patel said he was looking forward to working closely with New Zealand to counter the Chinese Communist Party and other threats in the region. New Zealand is a member of the Five Eyes intelligence-sharing alliance, alongside Australia, the United States, Britain and Canada. "Some of the most important global issues of our times are the ones that New Zealand and America work on together," he said. "The FBI cannot do it alone. The FBI, in my opinion, is the greatest law enforcement agency in the world, and our partners in the Five Eyes are our greatest partners around the world. But we need all of them ... to get after the fight and put the mission first."
SBS Australia
27 minutes ago
- SBS Australia
Too many: 602 Indigenous deaths in custody since the royal commission
Warning: this article includes the names of Aboriginal people who have passed and distressing content. When Senator Lidia Thorpe first entered Parliament she carried a message stick with 441 notches on it - each marking the death in custody of a First Nations person since the 1991 Royal Commission into Aboriginal deaths in custody. Today, five years later, she carried that same message stick into the Senate. It has 602 notches. The Parliament today supported a motion from Senator Thorpe calling for urgent national action on the crisis of First Nations deaths in custody, following the passing of 24-year-old Kumanjayi White in Mparntwe/Alice Springs in May. 'Kumanjayi White should be alive today," the Gunnai, Gunditjmara and Djab Wurrung woman said. "He was a young, disabled man who needed care and support, not restraint and force. His death is a national shame. "We are in the middle of a crisis. First Peoples continue to die in custody at horrifying rates. "There have been at least 17 deaths this year alone and still no government has fully implemented the Royal Commission's recommendations after more than three decades." Senator Thorpe's motion followed the release of the latest Closing the Gap data overnight, which shows rates of incarceration and suicide of First Peoples continue to worsen. "This motion extends the Senate's deepest sympathies to his family, to the Yuendumu community, to the families of the 17 First Peoples who have died in custody this year, and to the families of all those who have died since the 1991 Royal Commission," she said. These are not just statistics; they are sons, daughters, mothers, fathers, cousins, siblings, grandchildren – lost to a system that continues to harm our people. Her motion received support from crossbench and Labor parliamentarians in both the Senate and House of Representatives and Shadow Minister for Indigenous Australians Senator Kerrynne Liddle. Labor Senator Murray Watt said it was unacceptable that 602 First Nations people had died in custody since the royal commission. "The royal commission was clear that the best way to reduce First Nations deaths in custody is to reduce the high incarceration rate of First Nations people, including through social and economic responses, which the evidence shows can reduce crime, change the course of lives, and avoid people coming into contact with the police or justice system in the first place," he said. "This is what the Commonwealth Government is focusing on, including through the national agreement on Closing the Gap." Senator Watt said the Albanese Government was investing in First Nations-led justice reinvestment initiatives (where money that would be spent on prisons is, instead, invested in early intervention and diversionary programs) and called on the states and territories to do more. Senator Liddle and Senator Watt both extended condolences to Kumanjayi White's family and Yuendumu community. "His grieving family deserve answers," Senator Liddle said. "Australians, too, deserve answers. "The recommendations of the Royal Commission into Aboriginal deaths in custody released in 1991 outlined what needed to be done. "Indigenous Australians were disproportionately incarcerated, and they were also over represented in deaths in custody. "The Royal Commission report was a blueprint for change. "Change then was necessary; 34 years later, the job is still not done." Greens Leader Larissa Waters and independent Senator David Pocock also both spoke in favour of Senator Thorpe's motion. "We stand in solidarity with the Yuendumu and Warlpiri communities," Senator Waters said. "We join their calls for justice, and we echo the family's demand for an independent investigation, for the officers involved to be stood down, for the release of CCTV and body camera footage, and for the Northern Territory police to apologise for and cease publicly criminalising Kumanjayi White in their statements." Senator Thorpe called for unity and said the issue of First Nations deaths in custody was not about politics but about compassion. "The families of those who've died at the hands of the system need justice, not excuses," she said. "They need truth, accountability, and support to navigate a legal system that continues to fail us. "Ending deaths in custody – which are this country's great shame – must be a priority for this Labor government, they have the power to act now." Senator Thorpe said, while the support for her motion across the Parliament was encouraging, it must be backed up with action. "First Peoples have waited 34 years since the royal commission for action," she said. "Together, we can get this done."
