Arts Council 'greatly regrets' €6.7m IT failure, PAC hears
The council confirmed that it is now pursuing legal cases against two of the IT contractors involved in the failed project.
Arts Council chairperson Maura McGrath said that in relation to the IT system failure the project was "not and is not an optional extra".
"It began out of necessity, and it is a necessity that remains to be addressed."
She also questioned the expectation that "small state bodies set up for specialist purposes" should be expected to "carry the load on complex IT projects".
Ms McGrath added that the Arts Council "accepts the findings" of the Examination Report published by the Department of Arts in February this year.
Arts Council Director Maureen Kennelly said that council began this project to modernise its IT systems and integrate five systems into one, explaining that the systems date from 2008, are not integrated and are difficult to use.
Everything on this project was procured under public procurement guidelines, she said, adding that the council used the Office of Government Procurement framework, and the main contractor was on the OGP approved ICT framework.
She added that the council "engaged external contractors to manage and deliver the work, as we did not have the internal resources to deliver this large-scale project".
Ms Kennelly said that as the council approached their expected delivery in September 2022, a year later than initially planned, "multiple bugs were discovered".
The sub-standard work meant the project could not move forward to completion. The council then ended contracts with both the testers and developers, she said.
She added that they changed the developers, project governance and management structure and began work to "rectify and complete the programme".
Ms Kennelly then said that the council was ultimately advised that the system was "too flawed to rectify in a reasonable timeframe".
She said that system development was then paused, and it stopped following a board decision, with the input of the office of the Government Chief Information Officer, in June 2024.
The effect of this decision was an overall loss of value of €5.3 million, which was reported to the C&AG and included in the 2023 annual report and accounts.
"Throughout, we provided information and discussed with our colleagues in the department how increasing costs were to be funded from within our capital grant.
"In summary, lack of internal expertise, poor performance by our contractors and also, the impact of Covid-19 all contributed to the project failure."
Ms Kennelly explained that the council has commenced legal proceedings against two contractors and is in the pre-action stage in relation to two others, adding that the council is "vigorously" pursuing the cases to reduce the loss to the taxpayer.
She also said that they have senior ICT expertise in-house now and are in the process of implementing all recommendations relevant to us from the department's examination report.
Secretary General of the Department of Tourism, Culture and Arts Feargal Ó Coigligh told the PAC that his department had "failed" to properly exercise its oversight function.
He added that they "should have intervened more actively and much sooner" to reduce the exposure of the taxpayer to this failed project.
The minister has established an Expert Advisory Committee, led by Professor Niamh Brennan, to review the Governance and Organisational Culture in the Arts Council, said Mr Ó Coigligh.
A parallel review of the department's internal governance operations is also under way with the assistance of the IPA.
National Gallery of Ireland
A team from the National Gallery of Ireland will also appear before the PAC to explain why it purchased a scanner for €125,000, that has yet to be made operational.
The X-ray machine purchased in 2017 will be operational by the end of the year, the National Gallery of Ireland has said.
National Gallery Director Dr Caroline Campbell said issues around the storage of the scanner led to a contract being awarded for the construction of a "dedicated lead-lined cabinet".
Dr Campbell said that the manufacturing of the X-ray cabinet will "commence shortly", with the expected delivery, installation and operation of the X-ray system, before the end of the year.
She added that all costs associated with it will be borne from the resources generated by the National Gallery and not from the Exchequer.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
14 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Cash-strapped Tusla splurges €3m on private cabs in one year as taxi bill TRIPLES & some trips costing hundreds
So far in 2025, €1.4million has been spent on taxis TAXI FOR TUSLA! Cash-strapped Tusla splurges €3m on private cabs in one year as taxi bill TRIPLES & some trips costing hundreds THE cash-strapped child and family agency Tusla spent almost €3million on taxis last year. The cab bill is TRIPLE what the organisation paid in 2019, we can reveal. Advertisement Some trips cost hundreds, with drivers sent from Dublin to other counties — then asked to wait and come back again. Our revelations come after the State's child protection agency recently warned they will blow their budget by €68million this year as it struggles to deal with the demand for its services. Figures released to The Irish Sun on Sunday show Tusla's spending on taxis has grown rapidly in recent years. The info — provided under the Freedom of Information Act — shows they spent €2.98million on cabs last year. Advertisement This is almost a threefold rise on 2019, when €927,000 was paid out. Taxi bills fell during Covid, with €708,000 forked out in 2020 and €955,000 in 2021. But after the pandemic, the agency spend skyrocketed, with €1.9million spent on fares in 2022, followed by €2.5million in 2023 and €2.9million last year. So far in 2025, €1.4million has been spent on taxis. Advertisement Tusla told us it 'uses private transport such as taxis during the course of its day-to-day work', with the bills including both staff and client trips. Tusla are planning a trial in Dublin from next month where they'll directly employ drivers as a cost-saving measure. But they said: 'To date, the cost/benefit analysis shows that providing these services through bought in arrangements such as taxis is less costly than agency drivers and owned cars along with required maintenance.' 1 Figures released to The Irish Sun on Sunday show Tusla's spending on taxis has grown rapidly in recent years Credit: Getty
Irish Daily Mirror
2 days ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Clubber GAA's a perfect mix of tech and David Clifford's GAA 'magic'
It's been some week for popular GAA streaming platform 'Clubber' and their CEO and founder, Jimmy Doyle. After five years of steady growth - or "blood sweat and tears" as Doyle terms it - they signed a high-profile sponsorship deal with insurance giant Aviva. And this weekend Clubber will show a record-breaking 81 live GAA club championship games from eight different counties. Doyle now has 14 County Boards on his books and he can't fully understand why more don't sign up. Viewership goes along expected lines with one massive outlier to it all. Clubber's highest viewership ever was for a Kerry Intermediate Championship Final two years ago. 'There's a valid reason,' says Doyle. 'You can probably guess why that was. You know who plays for Fossa?' Yes we do. 'It helps when David Clifford is on the pitch - he's good for numbers,' continues Doyle. 'He's great. In the semi-final of that competition they (Fossa) were down a point going into injury time and he scored a point for the ages on the sideline. It was just magic. 'He went on to have an unbelievable performance in that game to get his club into the final. I think they (Fossa) are still our top gun.' Surprisingly, just 10percent of Clubber's audience is outside Ireland. At €150 for an annual subscription, fans can literally view hundreds of games live or watch them back again. They're a slick operation now and a tight one, with 10 full time staff and a small but growing army of camera operators and commentators across the country, with most games a two person job. The Aviva sponsorship deal is another string to their bow. 'It's a really nice validation for us,' said Doyle - a hurling fanatic from Tipperary. 'It's a big brand in the industry. You put years into something and it's moments like this that show you're on the right track. 'It's a big moment for us. The team in the background makes it all possible — I probably just get in the way at this point. 'I'm still fairly active on it all - don't get me wrong. So I'm not able to let it go. I suppose it's more maybe I'm getting in their way now at this stage. "And they're like, 'Stop interfering and let us at it - we know what we're doing.'" Doyle has big plans to branch into ladies sport and other sports as subscriber numbers increase. Clubber is still a child, very much a covid baby. While the world stood still, Doyle saw an opportunity in the sudden shift towards live-streamed sporting events with costs a fraction of the satellite technology used for TV. The former Moyne-Templetuohy hurler, who spent over two decades at Microsoft - where he led engineering teams and worked across global markets - had found a way to combine his passion and his profession. 'The whole streaming space kicked off during Covid and became a necessity,' he explains. 'Everybody started to just figure it out and it really just started to come to me in terms of 'Wow, there's real potential here,' and I started going at it then. 'It's (GAA) a key part of your identity and then the marrying with tech. It became a really, really passionate project for me. It taught me the right and wrong ways to build software. Fossa's David and Paudie Clifford celebrate after their All-Ireland junior final win in 2023 (Image: ©INPHO/Bryan Keane) 'Clubber, for me, is a tech company. It's built from the ground up and that's really where my experience has lent itself so well to it.' It certainly wasn't all smooth sailing. Doyle still remembers the early days vividly - especially the turmoil around a McGrath Cup match in January 2021, with Kerry facing Limerick. "It's still fairly etched on my brain," he says. Clubber suddenly went from small club games to a big inter-county news story. 'Jack O'Connor was just back in with Kerry," says Doyle. "Kerry supporters just went crazy to watch it relative to what we would have seen before. 'And suddenly I'm like, 'Jesus Christ, there's just that much more people coming in here relative to what we were used to.' 'Suddenly the site does not behave too well and you're getting calls. I had the naivety of having my phone number up there at the point in time so my phone is hopping. It was a crazy day. 'That gave us a really harsh lesson. We've never forgotten that moment and we spent probably the next six months fine-tuning all the software and really protecting ourselves for such an eventuality. "Thankfully we've moved on since then. But the mistakes you make, the harsh lessons, they're the best lessons.' Clubber's audience skews towards young male fans, but Doyle says they're seeing significant engagement across the full range of demographics, including older people, females and families, all tuning in. 'We're seeing decent growth year on year on the subscriber base and that's the thing that we're trying to grow and that's the thing that I think will ultimately be the long-term value for people," he says. 'I'm sure you've seen our pricing versus even counties who are just doing their own games and they're really pushing to €200, €250 to just watch an individual county. 'Whereas we're €150 to watch 14 counties. We put up a 20percent promotion (discount) there for about two weeks and it definitely took off more than we were expecting. That was nice. 'We think we're really well priced. We've had strong growth year on year, and we're trying to keep delivering value — whether that's for a die-hard fan in their 70s or a young player watching their own highlights on socials.'
The Journal
2 days ago
- The Journal
Ryan Tubridy has paid RTÉ back that €150,000 he received via the barter account
LAST UPDATE | 26 mins ago BROADCASTER RYAN TUBRIDY has repaid €150,000 to his former employer RTÉ. He received the money for two promotional events that did not take place. Tubridy had previously committed to paying back the sum of money he received from an RTÉ barter account . He made the commitment during an Oireachtas committee meeting appearance following the announcement that the station underreported his salary over four years in 2023. The scandal opened up questions around the governance and financial management of RTÉ , leading to the cash-strapped station facing a deepening funding crisis, and a plan for 400 job cuts . Advertisement Tubridy said he repaid the money today, adding: 'I made this payment through my solicitor, without any discussions with RTÉ – or with anyone acting on their behalf – and without condition. 'I have said on various occasions that I intended making this payment, and I'm happy to have been able to do so today.' The presenter was paid the €150,000 to host in two events, external to RTÉ, as part of a tri-partite agreement between Tubridy, car manufacturer Renault and the station . These payments were made via what's known as a barter account , which are used by companies to exchange goods or services for other goods or services. The Covid-19 pandemic resulted in the events being suspended, but – despite not signing the deal until years later – RTÉ had verbally agreed to underwrite the agreement, leading to the station having to pay out the sum owed to Tubridy. During his appearance before the Oireachtas Media Committee in 2023, Tubridy indicated he would be willing to repay the balance of €150,000 if he returned to RTÉ. Related Reads RTÉ to receive €725m over three years as part of new 'multi-annual' funding model The statement that cost Ryan Tubridy his job at RTE RTÉ, Ryan and Renault: The broadcaster's deal to keep Tubs on side RTÉ boss Kevin Bakhurst has previously said Tubridy had planned to return the money, stating that there was a 'moral case' to pay RTÉ back. However, he has also said previously that on a legal basis, the money might not be available to recuperate. The use of barter accounts is an industry standard but is done through an intermediary, so doesn't come for free – in this case, RTÉ spent an additional €80,000 in fees to the intermediary, on top of the €150,000 that was paid to Tubridy. In a statement to The Journal , an RTÉ spokesperson confirmed that it received payment of €150,000 from Tubridy via his solicitor this afternoon. 'RTÉ welcomes the payment and would like to thank Ryan Tubridy for making it,' added the spokesperson. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
