The Menendez brothers' resentencing would have shocked 1990s L.A.
I never caught the slew of documentaries and dramatizations about The Menendez Brothers, whose notoriety in Southern California is such that they should just trademark their names already. So imagine my surprise last year when then-L.A. County Dist. Atty. George Gascón announced he backed a resentencing of the brothers, arguing 35 years was enough time for the crime of murdering their parents — and besides, they had expressed enough remorse.
And imagine my surprise yesterday, when L.A. County Superior Court Judge Michael Jesic agreed.
The Menendez brothers now face 50 years to life in prison, which makes them eligible for parole because they committed their murders before they were 26 years old, according to my colleagues James Queally and Richard Winton — the Freddie Freeman and Shohei Ohtani of local crime reporting. Not only that, they have a clemency hearing before the office of Gov. Gavin Newsom next month.
Growing up in a Latino Catholic household in Southern California in the 1990s, there were no monsters worse than Erik and Lyle Menendez.
I was 10 years old when their parents, Jose and Kitty, were brutally killed in their Beverly Hills home. Their sons were arrested on suspicion of murdering their parents the following year and went through two trials before a jury found them guilty of first-degree murder in 1996. A judge sentenced them to life in prison without the possibility of parole. Everyone figured that was that.
Erik and Lyle garnered next to no public sympathy that I could remember. Lyle did them no favors by going on spending sprees in the months after their parents' deaths, according to witnesses. Nobody bought the story that the two did it because Jose sexually abused them while Kitty did nothing. It also didn't help that courtroom footage and photos of the Menendez brothers — Erik's intense stare, Lyle's dead eyes, both wearing pastel sweaters in an effort to soften their image — cast them as poor little rich boys who thought they could get away with anything.
The teenage part of me today still can't believe Erik and Lyle have any supporters at all. Who would ever support someone who shot their mother dead while she was trying to crawl away, as Lyle testified in the first trial? The adult part of me knows that public perception of them has dramatically changed in the time they've been imprisoned.
A series of updates supported their story that their father had abused them. A Netflix show produced by Ryan Murphy softened their image; a Netflix documentary retold their story to a new generation. More important, their extended family united to argue they and the brothers have suffered enough and want to close the sad Menendez saga once and for all.
'I don't think they are the same people they were 30 years ago,' Anamaria Baralt, a cousin of the brothers, said on the stand during the resentencing hearing.
At this point, the only person who seems to be angry about the idea of the Menendez brothers having a chance at parole is L.A. County Dist. Atty. Nathan Hochman. He unsuccessfully fought to overturn Gascon's request for a resentencing hearing, and his prosecutors unsuccessfully argued against it at the Van Nuys courthouse on Tuesday. Hochman's office was so unsuccessful, in fact, that Judge Jesic issued his ruling after just a day of hearings, when everyone expected at least two.
The Menendez brothers' parole hearing still hasn't been scheduled, and Newsom and future governors can keep them incarcerated forever. But teenage me never would have believed they could get to this point. What's next, he would have asked: OJ Simpson, a criminal?
Sky says: 'Midnight Rider by the Allman Brothers.'Paul says: 'Lyin' Eyes by The Eagles.'
Email us at essentialcalifornia@latimes.com, and your response might appear in the newsletter this week.
On May 15, 1940, the first McDonald's restaurant was opened by brothers Maurice and Richard McDonald in San Bernardino.
Three years ago, Times columnist Patt Morrison wrote about how Southern California has given the world so much, including fast food giants that began as mom-an-pop undertakings, or pop-and-son enterprises, and wound up as corporate owned chains.
Have a great day, from the Essential California team
Gustavo Arellano, California columnistKevinisha Walker, multiplatform editorKarim Doumar, head of newsletters
How can we make this newsletter more useful? Send comments to essentialcalifornia@latimes.com. Check our top stories, topics and the latest articles on latimes.com.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Elle
2 hours ago
- Elle
Everything We're Expecting From 'Dept Q' Season Two
Currently, the TV circuit has been giving us back-to-back thrillers (The Better Sister, Nine Perfect Strangers and Code Of Silence), and on May 29, Netflix delivered its own offering: Dept. Q. A nine-part series which sees the grouchy Detective Carl Morck (Matthew Goode) assigned to a police department in Edinburgh, where he is tasked with the assignment of solving the cryptic disappearance of prosecutor Merritt Lingard (Chloe Pirrie) who has been missing for four years. Created by American screenwriter, director and producer Scott Frank (Godless, The Queen's Gambit), the series is based on the book series by Danish writer Jussi Adler-Olsen. If like us, you've finished the series already and are keen to know more about the series' potential return for season two, keep on reading below. FIND OUT MORE ON ELLE COLLECTIVE While season two of the series is still yet to be confirmed, a number of the show's cast members have expressed that they'd be more than on board for returning for another round of Dept. Q, which of course, is always a promising sign. In a recent interview with The Hollywood Reporter, Goode revealed wasted no time sharing his thoughts, 'It's begging for it,' he said, of the series' potential return. Elsewhere, he told Yahoo that there is hope of a second season. 'I was saying to Scott [Frank] the other day, what we really need to do is a season two, and we need to get Alexej into eight weeks of Krav Magar training so the fight scenes in season two can be amazing. It's going to be a sort of Syrian Bourne.' Meanwhile, Frank told the BBC that while the previous seasons that he has worked on were 'meant to be one and done,' Dept. Q has the potential for more. 'There was no more to say but I'd love to do more with this and the next book in the series is even more interesting and relevant.' At the beginning of the season, we see Carl and his former partner James involved in an on-duty shoot-out, which ends in a young police constable dying, his partner paralysed, and Carl scarred for the foreseeable. We have not yet seen who shot Carl but is quite possible that it could be revealed in season two to give more context to his trauma. After Carl saves Merritt's life, the two are unable to properly meet due to Merritt barely being conscious after the ordeal. When she wakes up, she asks to meet Carl to thank him, however, she is told that he is taking time off of work. The two do end up meeting - but not realising who the other is - when they bump into one another by an elevator. Carl does not reveal his identity to Merritt, so she does not realise the significance of their brief encounter. As the series has not been confirmed and Scott has provided little information it's hard to say. However, if he plans on following on with the sequence of the Adler-Olsen's books, the second season would be centred around the second book, The Absent One (the first being Mercy). This would see Carl go on to solve yet another case, whereby he is tasked with solving the double murder of a brother and sister, which occurred two decades ago. While one of the suspects is already in prison for the crime, Carl is not convinced that the case has been adequately settled. ELLE Collective is a new community of fashion, beauty and culture lovers. For access to exclusive content, events, inspiring advice from our Editors and industry experts, as well the opportunity to meet designers, thought-leaders and stylists, become a member today HERE.
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
This Shocking True Crime Story Is The Top Film On Netflix Right Now
'A Widow's Game' is the most popular film on Netflix right now, according to the streamer's public ranking system. The Spanish thriller is based on a true story out of Valencia, Spain. In August 2017, Antonio Navarro Cerdán was found stabbed to death in the Patraix district, less than a year after he married his longtime girlfriend, María Jesús Moreno Cantó aka Maje. The film — which changes the name of the real-life victim — follows the investigation of the murder and takes viewers on a wild ride that's both suspenseful and intriguing. The film stars Ivana Baquero, Tristán Ulloa and Carmen Machi and was directed by Carlos Sedes. Read on for more trending films of the moment across streaming services, including Max, Peacock, Prime Video and Paramount+. And, if you want to stay informed about all things streaming and entertainment, subscribe to the Culture Catchall newsletter. 'Mountainhead' is HBO's newest original movie, and it's already atop the cable streamer's programming. The film, directed by 'Succession' creator Jesse Armstrong, stars Steve Carell, Ramy Youssef, Cory Michael Smith and Jason Schwartzman as billionaire tech bros who retreat to a mansion in the mountains during an economic downturn. You can read HuffPost's review of 'Mountainhead' here. Sometimes when you need a laugh, you gotta turn to a classic comedy. 'Happy Gilmore,' which is streaming on Peacock, was one of the top films this week on the streamer. The film stars Adam Sandler as the titular Happy, a former ice hockey player who starts playing in golf tournaments to help save his grandmother's house from foreclosure. Sandler is reprising the character for an upcoming sequel, which is set to hit Netflix on July 25. Another sequel topped a streamer this week: 'Another Simple Favor,' starring Blake Lively and Anna Kendrick. The follow-up to 'A Simple Favor' picks up seven years later when Stephanie (Kendrick) and Emily (Lively) reunite for Emily's wedding in Italy. You can read HuffPost's review of 'Another Simple Favor' here. This action thriller stars Jack Quaid as Nathan Caine, an assistant manager at a credit union who deals with an inability to feel pain. He ends up using his condition as a superpower to get back the girl of his dreams who has been kidnapped by some bank robbers. If you're looking for other films to watch, check out our What We're Watching blog. 'Mountainhead' Tries To Skewer Billionaire Tech Bros — But Fails Miserably Blake Lively's Newest Movie Is Another Terrible Sequel No One Needed Actor Lauren Weedman Was Diagnosed With Bell's Palsy. Then, Hollywood Showed Up In The Most Unexpected Way.
Tom's Guide
4 hours ago
- Tom's Guide
Netflix is about to lose the wildest psychological thriller of 2024 — here's your last chance to stream it
"Trap" is one of 2024's more infamous releases; you don't need to look far to find plenty of critics and viewers telling you to steer clear of the M. Night Shyamalan thriller... but I'm no "Trap" denier. I saw this twisting thriller in theaters and left with a smile on my face; despite its flaws, "Trap" is a ton of fun. And, seeing as this movie is leaving Netflix very soon, now seems as good a time as any to recommend it to would-be viewers. Yes, now that we have Netflix's June schedule, we know that your last day to stream "Trap" on Netflix is Tuesday, June 10. As of the time of writing, that means you've got just one week left to stream "Trap" on Netflix, at the time of writing. If you need convincing, you can find a little more info about the movie — and why I think "Trap" is worth adding to your watchlist — below. "Trap" sees American firefighter and picture-perfect suburban dad Cooper Abbott (Josh Hartnett), taking his teen daughter Riley (Ariel Donoghue) to see her favorite popstar, Lady Raven (Saleka Shyamalan) in concert... where something sinister is about to go down. Turns out the cops believe that a grisly serial killer known as "The Butcher" is also in attendance, so they've got the whole place locked down to finally bring his reign of terror to an end. And given we learn Cooper's the one with a killer secret mere minutes into the film, that presents him with a major problem. How on earth is he going to make it out of the arena? Get instant access to breaking news, the hottest reviews, great deals and helpful tips. In addition to Hartnett, Donohue, and Shyamalan, "Trap" also stars Alison Pill, Hayley Mills, Jonathan Langdon, Marnie McPhail-Diamond, and Mark Bacolcol, among others. Look, I'm not entirely sure that "Trap" is actually a good movie, but I'd be lying if I said I didn't have a good time when I saw it in theaters. Chiefly, that's because of our protagonist. Josh Hartnett's playful performance is worth the price of admission alone. Watching Cooper puzzle out his predicament is a real treat precisely because Hartnett is so invested in the role. It's the same commitment that makes his recent action-comedy "Bullet Train" riff, "Fight or Flight" work so well. He's committed to doing as much as possible with this absurdly silly conceit. And, while "Trap" at times feels like little more than a way to promote Saleka's music career, when we're outside the concert hall, it's packed with increasingly absurd turns that make it worth sticking with. "Trap" is assuredly messy and will doubtless not work for everyone, but if you can revel in Hartnett's killer charisma and buy into campy storytelling, this is a entertaining ride that lives up to the "thriller" label. Critically, the reaction could politely be described as "mixed." At the time of writing, "Trap" currently holds a 57% critics' rating on Rotten Tomatoes, with a slightly higher 64% score from fellow moviegoers. As an example of what reviewers had to say, THR's Lovia Gyarkye described "Trap" as "a concert movie for Shyamalan's daughter [...] wrapped in a middling thriller kept afloat by a compelling performance from Josh Hartnett." Entertainment Weekly reviewer Jordan Hoffman called "Trap" Shyamalan's "most preposterous movie yet" and "a film mostly of surface pleasures," but adds "there's a lot of fun waiting to be had for those willing to check any large items like scrutiny or skepticism before entering the arena." Empire's Dan Jolin offers a more negative take, giving it a 2-star rating and calling it "an oddly inert wannabe nail-biter", summing "Trap" up as "an initially cool premise that goes nowhere interesting as it heads off somewhere else too quickly. Hartnett does his best, but director Shyamalan seems more interested in trying to convince us of his daughter's pop-star credentials." Nevertheless, I do think there's some fun to be had with "Trap," and if your interest is piqued, I'd strongly recommend streaming "Trap" on Netflix before it leaves the platform on June 10. Not convinced? We can still help you find something new to watch. Check out our round-up of the best movies on Netflix for tons more streaming recommendations perfect for your next movie night.
