&w=3840&q=100)
Can a new project stop flawed medical research before it causes harm?
Sarjna Rai New Delhi
Every day, clinical decisions, health policies, and patient treatments are shaped by scientific studies. But what if those studies are based on manipulated images, skewed data, or biased analysis? What if the medicine you are prescribed was approved based on flawed evidence? These are not just academic questions—they directly affect lives.
Flawed medical research is a growing problem
According to a report published by The Guardian last year, around 10,000 research papers were retracted by journals in 2023.
Watchdog groups like Retraction Watch have tracked the surge in scientific retractions, often issued only after serious flaws or fabrications are uncovered. An analysis by Nature showed a steep rise—from just over 1,000 retractions in 2013 to more than 4,000 in 2022, with numbers crossing 10,000 in 2023 —signalling a deepening credibility crisis in research publishing.
The pandemic accelerated this trend with a spike in pre-prints—scientific papers made public before peer review. While helpful in fast-tracking global knowledge sharing, this also allowed questionable research to bypass scrutiny. Between January 2020 and October 2021, 157 COVID-related papers were retracted, including some from top-tier journals, as reported by The New Indian Express. Notably, high-profile studies on hydroxychloroquine and blood pressure medication in COVID treatment were withdrawn after experts revealed serious data inconsistencies.
In 2016, an inspection of Semler Research's facility in Bengaluru by the US FDA uncovered severe data falsification, including sample manipulation and substitution. The FDA declared the firm's studies unreliable, forcing sponsors to redo trials through alternate agencies. The World Health Organization and European Medicines Agency also took action, highlighting the global reach of flawed data.
What is the Medical Evidence Project trying to do?
The Medical Evidence Project aims to tackle the mounting crisis in research reliability. Funded by a $900,000 grant from Open Philanthropy, the project will focus on identifying manipulated or low-quality studies before they affect patient care or policy.
Led by Boston-based research scientist James Heathers, the initiative will be run under the Centre for Scientific Integrity, the non-profit that also operates Retraction Watch. Heathers will collaborate with Ivan Oransky, the centre's executive director and co-founder of Retraction Watch.
'We originally set up the Centre for Scientific Integrity as a home for Retraction Watch, but we always hoped we would be able to do more in the research accountability space,' Oransky said in a statement. 'The Medical Evidence Project allows us to support critical analysis and disseminate the findings.'
By combining editorial review, forensic screening, and whistleblower tips, the initiative hopes to build a stronger accountability model—preventing both misconduct and honest errors before they influence decisions.
From whistleblowers to watchdogs: How the system will work
The Medical Evidence Project will operate via a dual strategy—combining tip-offs from whistleblowers with systematic screening using digital tools. A core team of up to five investigators will use forensic metascience methods to analyse papers for signs of manipulation, bias, or methodological error. Their findings will be published on Retraction Watch, known for tracking research retractions.
James Heathers described the process in a blog post:
A flaw is identified in a published paper
A detailed report is prepared
If the flaw is serious, it undergoes internal peer review
The findings are then made public
In addition, the project will:
Build software tools to automate parts of the verification process
Follow up on anonymous tips through a dedicated whistleblower channel
Pay external reviewers to independently verify and scrutinise findings
The team aims to uncover at least 10 flawed meta-analyses per year, with the broader goal of raising the reliability of published medical literature.
Why this matters to patients, policymakers, and the public
A study in Misinformation Review by Harvard Kennedy School found that nearly two-thirds of sampled scientific papers on Google Scholar showed signs of being generated using AI tools like GPT. Roughly 14.5 per cent of these flagged studies were health-related—some even appearing in established journals.
The problem is worsened by the fact that Google Scholar does not differentiate between peer-reviewed publications and unvetted content like preprints or student theses. Once flawed studies are cited in meta-analyses or referenced by clinicians, they can misguide patient care, misallocate public funds, and skew health policies.
This is why initiatives like the Medical Evidence Project are vital—not as punitive measures, but as proactive efforts to improve transparency, raise research standards, and restore faith in evidence-based medicine.
Conclusion
Science thrives on credibility. The global push to catch flaws before they become crises marks a pivotal shift in how health research is verified. With ethical oversight, smarter tools, and dedicated investigators, the goal is clear and urgent: to ensure medical evidence truly serves the people who depend on it.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
29 minutes ago
- Time of India
New COVID variant Stratus (XFG) spreads in the US: Symptoms, risks, and what you need to know
As the United States experiences another wave of COVID-19, a variant named Stratus (XFG) has caught the attention of health authorities. Officially identified as XFG, this recombinant strain was first detected in Southeast Asia in January 2025. While initially flying under the radar in the US, XFG accounted for 14% of all cases by late June, making it the third most prevalent variant according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Globally, the World Health Organization ( WHO ) has added XFG to its monitoring list, though it continues to classify the variant's overall public health risk as low. Experts reassure that current COVID-19 vaccines remain effective against symptomatic and severe disease caused by this strain. What is the new covid variant in the US Stratus (XFG) and how is it different XFG is a recombinant variant, meaning it combines genetic material from two earlier strains: F.7 and LP.8.1.2. While LP.8.1.2 is now the second most common strain in the US, XFG is notable for its mutations that may help it evade the immune system. Importantly, experts emphasize that these mutations do not make XFG more dangerous. According to Dr. Subhash Verma, microbiology and immunology professor at the University of Nevada, XFG does not cause more severe illness or different symptoms compared to earlier Omicron variants. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Use an AI Writing Tool That Actually Understands Your Voice Grammarly Install Now Undo Health authorities classify the variant as low risk, but continued monitoring is essential to track its evolution. How fast is this covid variant As reported by USA Today, XFG's prevalence in the US has increased rapidly in recent months: March 2025: 0% of cases April 2025: 2% of cases May 2025: 6% of cases Late June 2025: 14% of cases Globally, the WHO reported a rise from 7.4% in early May to 22.7% by the end of June across 38 countries. Despite this growth, XFG has not surpassed the top two variants, but its upward trend underscores the importance of ongoing genomic surveillance and vaccine coverage. Symptoms of Stratus (XFG) variant As USA Today reported, know the familiar COVID-19 symptoms for XFG infections. These include: Fever or chills Cough Fatigue Sore throat Loss of taste or smell Nasal congestion Muscle aches Shortness of breath Headache Nausea or vomiting Health officials stress that symptom patterns remain consistent with prior Omicron variants, and early testing, vaccination, and isolation are key to controlling spread. Prevention tips for Stratus (XFG) variant To reduce the risk of infection from the XFG variant (Stratus), follow these recommended safety measures: Stay up to date with COVID-19 vaccines: Ensure primary doses and booster shots are current, as vaccines remain effective against severe disease. Practice good hygiene: Regular handwashing, using hand sanitizer, and avoiding touching the face can reduce transmission. Wear masks in crowded or enclosed spaces: Especially in public transport, healthcare facilities, or areas with high case counts. Maintain physical distancing: Avoid close contact with people showing respiratory symptoms. Monitor symptoms and test early: Get tested if you experience fever, cough, fatigue, or other COVID-related symptoms. Isolate if infected: Follow local health guidelines to prevent spreading the virus to others. Ventilate indoor spaces: Increase airflow in homes, offices, and public spaces to reduce viral concentration. Disclaimer : The information provided in this article is for general educational purposes only and is based on data available from the reputable news sources as of August 2025. It should not be considered medical advice. Always consult healthcare professionals for personal guidance on COVID-19 prevention, testing, and treatment. Also read | Sudden cardiac arrest in gyms: Causes, prevention tips, and urgent advisory issued for young athletes by Punjab government
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
What your cough says about your health: Spot the difference between dry, wet, and wheezing
Coughing is more than a minor annoyance; it can reveal important clues about your health. According to a study published in PLOS One, understanding whether your cough is dry, wet, or wheezing helps identify its cause, from viral or bacterial infections to asthma or lingering post-infection irritation. A dry cough is often persistent and hacking, while wet coughs produce mucus, and wheezing signals potential breathing difficulties. Recognising these differences can guide treatment choices, self-care, and when to seek medical attention. By learning what your cough says about your body, you can act early, protect your lungs, and prevent serious complications. Different types of cough : How to spot viral, bacterial, and lingering coughs Viral cough A viral cough is typically dry, persistent, and sometimes painful. It often comes on suddenly and is caused by viral infections such as the flu, the common cold, or COVID-19. Unlike bacterial infections, a viral cough usually doesn't produce thick mucus. Cough suppressants may provide relief, but expectorants, medications that help clear mucus, are generally ineffective in this case. While uncomfortable, viral coughs often resolve on their own within a week or two. Bacterial cough A bacterial cough is generally wetter, producing yellow or green mucus. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Benefits of Trading Bitcoin CFDs IC Markets Learn More This type of cough can signal bacterial infections like bronchitis or pneumonia. If left untreated, it can escalate to serious complications. Antibiotics are typically required to tackle the underlying infection, while expectorants and adequate hydration can ease symptoms. The colour of the mucus is an important clue: yellow or green usually indicates bacteria, whereas clear mucus points toward a viral cause. Whooping cough Whooping cough, or pertussis, is a severe bacterial infection caused by Bordetella pertussis. It is marked by intense coughing fits followed by a high-pitched 'whoop' when inhaling. This condition can be particularly dangerous for infants and young children, so prompt medical treatment is crucial. Vaccination remains the most effective preventive measure, but early intervention with antibiotics is essential for those infected. Post-infection cough Sometimes, coughing persists long after the initial infection has cleared. This post-infection cough can be phlegmy and lingering, especially in smokers or people with underlying lung conditions. Though usually not dangerous, it can be disruptive and may even become chronic in some cases. Remedies like herbal teas, steam inhalation, and gentle expectorants can provide temporary relief while the airways fully recover. Not all coughs need immediate medical attention, but certain warning signs should not be ignored. If your cough persists for more than a few weeks, produces thick yellow or green mucus, or is accompanied by fever, chest pain, or difficulty breathing, consult a healthcare professional. Prompt evaluation can help prevent serious complications and ensure appropriate treatment. Wet vs. dry cough: How to tell the difference A simple way to differentiate coughs is by checking for mucus. Wet coughs produce mucus or phlegm and are often linked to infections in the lungs or airways. Dry coughs, on the other hand, don't produce mucus and are commonly associated with viral infections, allergies, or irritants like smoke and dust. Understanding this distinction can guide treatment choices and self-care measures. Mucus colour and what it reveals about your cough The colour of your mucus can provide additional clues about the cause of your cough. Clear or white mucus usually points to viral infections or mild irritation, while yellow or green mucus suggests a bacterial infection that may require antibiotics. Monitoring changes in mucus colour and consistency can help you track the progression of your illness and decide when to seek medical help. Wheezing and asthma: When coughing signals a serious issue A wheezing cough, a high-pitched, whistling sound during breathing, can indicate asthma or other bronchial conditions. Asthma-related coughing may be triggered by allergens, exercise, or respiratory infections. If wheezing is frequent or accompanied by shortness of breath, it's important to see a doctor for diagnosis and treatment. Asthma medications, including inhalers, can manage symptoms and prevent severe breathing difficulties. While most coughs resolve on their own, ignoring persistent symptoms can be dangerous. Bacterial infections can progress to pneumonia, while untreated asthma may lead to severe respiratory complications. Chronic coughing can also strain the chest muscles, disrupt sleep, and reduce overall quality of life. Recognising the underlying cause early helps prevent these complications and ensures proper care. Treatment depends on the type of cough and its cause. Dry coughs may respond well to cough suppressants, while wet coughs benefit from expectorants, staying hydrated, and resting the lungs. For asthma-related coughs, inhalers and other prescribed medications are essential. Supportive care, such as warm fluids, humidified air, and avoiding irritants like smoke, can also help alleviate symptoms. Also Read: 11 signs your blood sugar is too high: Spot the warning symptoms early
Mint
2 hours ago
- Mint
Why India needs to take prediabetes more seriously
Delhi-based Mansi Kashyap, 29, a chartered accountant, was in peak physical shape during her college years. But post-graduation, her life shifted. With career anxiety mounting and family pressures weighing her down, her once-vibrant energy began to fade. Already diagnosed with anxiety, she chalked up the fatigue and lethargy to mental health struggles. 'I'd wake up tired and feel drained all day, despite my job being sedentary," she recalls. 'Then my belly started changing shape. I took up brisk walking and even jumped rope, but nothing improved. For two years, I ignored these signs until I started experiencing excessive thirst and frequent urination." Alarmed, she finally went in for a full health check-up—the first in nearly a decade. The results were sobering: she had prediabetes. Kashyap's experience is far from unique. Millions across India may be living in this silent zone of metabolic dysfunction unaware that they could be inching towards a chronic disease that could have been intercepted with timely action According to a 2023 ICMR–INDIAB study conducted by the Indian Council of Medical Research, at least 136 million Indians, or 15.3% of the population, are living with prediabetes. 'The prediabetic stage is crucial because it represents a window of opportunity: blood sugar levels are elevated but not yet high enough to be classified as diabetes," says Dr Paras Agarwal, clinical director & head of diabetes, obesity & metabolic disorders at Marengo Asia Hospitals, Gurugram. 'While typically asymptomatic, individuals in this stage are at significantly higher risk of developing type 2 diabetes." India, home to the second-largest diabetic population globally, has long focused on treating diabetes. But it is in the years—often decades—before full-blown disease sets in that the body sends warning signs. Most people just don't know how to read them. 'In India, nearly 50% of people living with diabetes are unaware of their condition, and prediabetes often goes unnoticed until it progresses. This silent progression is usually uncovered only through incidental findings during routine health check-ups, indicating a reactive, rather than proactive, diagnostic culture," notes Aditya Kandoi, CEO & founder of Redcliffe Labs. 'Routine screenings often miss prediabetes in younger or asymptomatic individuals because they aren't perceived as 'at risk.' As a result, what could be caught and managed early is allowed to evolve into a full-blown disease." SIGNS TO LOOK OUT FOR According to Dr Aarathi Bellary, consultant internal medicine at KIMS Hospitals, Kondapur, the numbers are already staggering. 'In India, prediabetes prevalence ranges from about 5–22% across regions, with recent large studies showing rates near 10–14% in both urban and rural populations," she explains. 'However, a significant proportion of individuals with prediabetes and even diabetes remain undiagnosed, particularly in lower socio-economic and less-educated groups, and increasingly rural populations." Doctors agree that prediabetes doesn't arrive with an announcement—it creeps in masked as exhaustion, skin changes, or vague complaints of gastric distress. 'Insulin resistance often develops gradually, but certain clinical signs can offer early clues," says Agarwal. These include central fat accumulation, acanthosis nigricans—a darkening of skin on the nape— and skin tags around the neck or armpits. Bellary offers a broader checklist of symptoms: 'Energy fluctuations, brain fog, cravings, disturbed sleep, mild depression, premature balding—these clusters, especially in those with a family history or other risk factors, should prompt early metabolic assessment—even before blood sugar meets prediabetes cut-offs." She adds that even 'seemingly healthy young adults, especially those not obviously overweight or without family history, are never screened until they present with more severe symptoms." Dr Abizer Manked, consultant physician at Saifee Hospital in Mumbai, notes, 'Routine screening is very underutilized in India. None of the younger generation does any blood tests unless they're unwell. Prevention is better than cure but it has to start with awareness and regular health checkups." STRESS, SLEEP AND METABOLISM Modern life is a metabolic minefield. Long commutes, job stress, screen-induced insomnia, and irregular meal timings don't just exhaust the mind—they disrupt the body's hormonal balance, too. 'Chronic stress and poor sleep are increasingly recognized as independent risk factors for metabolic disorders," notes Agarwal. 'Even in the absence of a poor diet or lack of exercise, these factors can significantly worsen glycemic control, elevate blood pressure, and increase the likelihood of cardiac events." Dr Jaspreet Singh, endocrinologist, Ujala Cygnus Group of Hospitals, Jammu highlights, 'In urban settings, we increasingly see young Indians with borderline or elevated fasting insulin and HOMA-IR scores, despite normal body weight and diet. Sleeping for less than six hours, high nighttime smartphone usage, and work-related stress are the leading causes of stress among individuals. These non-dietary triggers now play a clinically significant role in the early onset of metabolic dysfunction in the younger population." Bellary expands: 'Urban environments foster a 'wired but tired' phenotype: people may exercise occasionally and avoid obvious junk food but compensate with poor sleep and high stress, which can stealthily tip them into prediabetes despite a normal BMI." She further highlights a concerning trend in semi-urban India: 'Rural and semi-urban populations are addicted to carbonated high-sugary drinks with absolutely no awareness—this is another big problem." PREDIABETES IS REVERSIBLE 'Prediabetes represents a 'gray zone'—a transitional stage between normal metabolic function and full-blown diabetes. Unlike diabetes, which is considered remissible at best, prediabetes is largely reversible," Agarwal affirms. The key lies in lifestyle intervention. 'Improving dietary patterns, increasing physical activity, and losing excess weight can reduce insulin resistance and, in many cases, return blood sugar levels to normal. These changes can also delay or prevent the onset of diabetes by years." 'In Indian culture, mithais are a must for every occasion. We need a cultural shift to happen where we cut sugar, reduce carbs, move more, eat less fried food. We are a sedentary nation—and that has to change," says Manked. Singh notes, 'Although we can reverse prediabetes with timely action, India's healthcare system remains largely reactive. Most interventions begin only after a confirmed diabetes diagnosis, rather than during the warning stage. The current infrastructure lacks scalable programs for routine screening at the community level. Public health workers like ASHA and ANMs are often overburdened and undertrained for metabolic screening. To shift toward prevention, we must integrate early screening protocols, like community-based HbA1c testing, into primary health centers and corporate wellness programs. Without proactive follow-up systems, even identified prediabetes falls through the cracks." To stop prediabetes from becoming India's next major health crisis, experts agree: change must start at every level. Tanisha Saxena is a Delhi-based independent journalist. She writes stories that are on the intersection of art, culture and lifestyle.
