European court to rule in Semenya sports gender case
A top European court will decide Thursday whether double Olympic champion Caster Semenya can be required to lower her testosterone levels to compete as a woman, in a key decision on contested gender testing.
The European Court of Human Rights' decision comes after a row engulfed the 2024 Paris Olympics over the gender of an Algerian boxing champion.
Advertisement
South African runner Semenya, 34, was the Olympic 800m champion in 2012 and 2016 and world gold medallist in 2009, 2011 and 2017.
She is classed as having "differences in sexual development", but has always been legally identified as female.
Semenya has refused to take drugs to reduce testosterone levels since World Athletics, track and field's governing body, introduced new rules on women competitors in 2018.
So, she has since been barred from competing in her favoured 800m.
Semenya has said she hopes the ECHR will protect athletes' human rights and "inspire all young women to be and accept themselves in all their diversity".
Advertisement
Antoine Duval, a sports law expert at the Asser Institute in The Hague said the case would "determine what comes next in terms of challenging the rules for access to women's competitions".
Semenya has already tried other tribunals to try to change the rules.
The Lausanne-based Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) ruled against her in 2019 and the decision was validated by the Swiss Federal Court in Lausanne in 2020. It judged that a testosterone level comparable to that of men gave female athletes "an insurmountable advantage".
- 'Human guinea pig' -
The ECHR in 2023 ruled that Semenya was the victim of discrimination by the CAS.
Advertisement
Swiss authorities, supported by World Athletics, appealed to the European court's 17-member Grand Chamber.
The ECHR decision was however largely symbolic as it did not call into question the World Athletics ruling nor allow Semenya to return to competition without taking medication.
There are many types of "differences in sexual development", a group of rare conditions involving genes, hormones and reproductive organs.
Formerly known as intersexuality, they occur in approximately one in 1,000 to 4,500 births.
Before the 2009 world championships, where Semenya won the 800m gold aged just 18, she was forced to undergo gender testing.
Advertisement
She was subsequently put on medication to reduce testosterone levels, spending several months sidelined by World Athletics.
Semenya, born with the "46 XY" chromosome rather than the XX chromosome most females have, said she felt she was being treated like a "human guinea pig" and vowed to never again allow it.
Testosterone is produced by men and women, but men produce 20 times more of the sex hormone.
How much the hormone boosts performance remains a matter of debate.
- 'Degrading' -
The International Olympic Committee is weighing reintroducing gender testing, while several sports have already embraced the practice.
Advertisement
World Athletics and World Boxing have adopted chromosomal testing -- generally a cheek swab to check for the SRY gene, that reveals the presence of the Y chromosome.
World Aquatics in 2023 adopted a policy that foresees such testing.
Supporters say such screening simplifies access to women's competition, and UN rapporteur Reem Alsalem has said such tests are "reliable and non-invasive".
But Madeleine Pape, a sociologist of gender in sport, says there is a lack of research proving that transgender athletes or those with one of the many forms of DSD gain a "disproportionate advantage" over XX competitors.
Advertisement
Human Rights Watch has argued that World Athletics regulations "are degrading and invasive of privacy, on grounds that are scientifically contested".
The gender debate reignited in June around Paris Olympic boxing champion Imane Khelif.
Donald Trump, Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, and Harry Potter author J.K. Rowling were among those who stoked a row over the Algerian's gender.
bur-pau-ah/jh
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
26 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Brevis' record-breaking century for South Africa ends Australia's 9-match winning streak in T20s
DARWIN, Australia (AP) — Dewald Brevis smacked a record T20 century to help South Africa end the nine-match winning streak of Australia's cricketers as a 53-run victory on Tuesday levelled the three-match series at 1-1. The 22-year-old Brevis bludgeoned eight sixes and 12 fours in his breath-taking 125 not out off 56 balls to surpass Faf du Plessis' South Africa record of 119, made against the West Indies in 2015. Brevis displayed an extraordinary range of shots all around the wicket to propel South Africa to 218-7, after Australia captain Mitchell Marsh had won the toss and elected to field on the same wicket where his team had successfully defended 178 two days before. Australia's top-order batters briefly had a crack at the steep target with Tim David scoring a robust 50 off 24 balls. But once he perished in the 10th over, the wheels came off as the home team was bowled out for 165 in 17.4 overs. 'I have not really thought about it (the record), but extremely grateful,' Brevis said after receiving his player of the match award. 'Just happy we won today, great to be out here on the winning side.' Another South African youngster, Kwena Maphaka (3-57), followed his four-wicket haul in the first game by removing big-hitters Cameron Green (9), Glenn Maxwell (16) and Mitchell Owen (8). South Africa also shrugged off the dew at the venue and held onto some brilliant catches with Nqabayomzi Peter, one of the two changes the visitors made from the first game, holding onto a spectacular low catch at mid-wicket to dismiss Green in Maphaka's first over. In sharp contrast, Australia was scrappy in the field. Substitute fielder Matthew Kuhnemann dropped Brevis soon after the power-hitter had completed his half century off 25 balls. The ball burst through his hands on the long-on boundary, much to the disappointment of bowler Maxwell. Maxwell, who finished with 2-44, had earlier seen Adam Zampa drop a skier off Lhuan-dre Pretorius in the powerplay. Despite losing three quick wickets, Brevis didn't hold back in a 126-run fourth-wicket stand with Tristan Stubbs, who contributed 31 off 22 balls. Brevis pummelled spinners Zampa (1-46) and Maxwell soon after getting his life on 56. He also took charge against Josh Hazlewood (1-56) in the second half of the innings as he completed his second fifty off just 16 balls. Zampa broke the century partnership by having Stubbs caught at backward point Australia rallied to take four wickets at the end, but Brevis had done enough damage by that time to give South Africa its imposing total. Marsh, whose side beat West Indies 5-0 after chasing successfully in all five games in the preceding series, praised Brevis. 'He is a young, powerful man,' Marsh said. 'An upcoming player in international cricket and well played to him. Chasing that down was going to be tough. We needed a few partnerships early and could not do that.' The final game will be played on Saturday before the teams compete in a three-match ODI series. ___ AP cricket: The Associated Press
Yahoo
39 minutes ago
- Yahoo
'Words can't describe': Wallaby star's emotional return
After fearing he'd played his last Test, James O'Connor is being lauded for delivering maybe his best performance yet in a Wallabies gold jumper. A record-breaking 17 years after debuting as a teenage utility in Padova, O'Connor pulled all the right strings as chief playmaker in Australia's extraordinary 38-22 comeback win over the world champion Springboks in Johannesburg. Only drafted into the squad following injuries to preferred flyhalves Noah Lolesio, Tom Lynagh and Ben Donaldson, O'Connor played a starring role in the Wallabies' first win at Ellis Park since 1963. Despite turning 36 next year and having only been used as a cameo finisher off the bench during the Crusaders' triumphant 2025 Super Rugby Pacific campaign, O'Connor controlled proceedings for the entire 80 minutes on Sunday morning (AEST). "Look, genuinely, words can't describe right now," he said. "That's personally definitely my favourite win. It meant so much. "It's been a lot of emotion this week, a lot of reflection. I thought my time in the gold jersey was done three years ago. "I fought bloody hard to get back here and the opportunity came with some of the guys getting injured, but I'm here now and I'm loving it." As well as slotting four conversions, O'Connor helped set up Australia's opening try for Dylan Pietsch that sparked the remarkable comeback from 22-0 down, then threw a magical two-man cut-out pass for the 65th-minute five-pointer from Max Jorgensen that virtually sealed the Wallabies' famous win. "He just grew into the game," said Wallabies coach Joe Schmidt. "I thought he got a little bit rattled in the first 20 minutes, just with the heat that the Boks brought. "But the longer the game went on, I felt he started to manage it really well." O'Connor readily admitted returning to the Test ranks after a three-year absence had been daunting at times. "I'm not going to lie," he told Stan Sport. "There's been plenty of times I've thought in my mind, 'Jeez, have I bit off more than I could chew here' because training's quick, everything's hard, everything's quicker. "And I thought, 'Man, I might have talked it up too much now'. "But the boys who got around me, they've looked after me and we've slowly just built into this game plan and, yeah, I'm really loving that detail that Joe's bringing. "He's allowing us to play and really execute in killer moments of the game." The 65-Test veteran agreed with Schmidt that it took a while to find his feet as the Springboks made a ferocious start to the Rugby Championship with three tries in the opening 17 minutes. "A scratchy first 20, but I could feel the gaps were there," O'Connor said. 🗣️ JOC reacts to our historic win at Ellis Park#Wallabies — Wallabies (@wallabies) August 16, 2025 "The space was there. I just couldn't get the ball to that space in the first 20. "Then I felt we eased into the game in that second 20 minutes of that first half. "I felt like we built momentum well and we started to get some outcomes. "So halftime we spoke about it. 'Look, we're in this game, we know we can score points. It's just about trusting what we've built.' "That belief is strong in us now. We've been building. You could see in that Lions series that we're building belief. "So doubling down and there you go, that's a result, so super proud and stoked."
New York Times
41 minutes ago
- New York Times
Manchester United vs Arsenal: The mood, transfer window, hopes for the season and predictions
Manchester United host Arsenal on Sunday in the pick of the games from the opening weekend of the 2025-26 Premier League season. Ruben Amorim's home side will be desperate to prove they have been transformed over the summer following a truly abysmal domestic campaign and Mikel Arteta's team are looking to go one better after three consecutive second-placed finishes in the top flight. To get you in the mood, The Athletic asked one of our United writers, Mark Critchley, and Arsenal counterpart James McNicholas for their insights before the game at Old Trafford. Mark Critchley: The impact of Sir Jim Ratcliffe's cost-cutting measures was still being felt over the summer, with more football-focused staff let go at the end of the season. Others departed voluntarily, and some are only staying around until replacements are found. The hope at United is that the club are now past the worst of all the upheaval of the past year, and that those who remain can truly call the renovated men's training building at Carrington their place of work. Ratcliffe cut the ribbon on the £50million ($67.8m) facility last week. It is certainly an upgrade on the Carrington of old and a symbol of what United believe will be a fresh start. Advertisement James McNicholas: Perhaps the most significant change is that Arsenal now have most of their key players fit again. In the second half of last season, they were without Bukayo Saka, Kai Havertz, Gabriel and others for significant periods. There has also been significant incoming transfer business, including the addition of centre-forward Viktor Gyokeres. It's fascinating that this game could see him line up against fellow striker Benjamin Sesko — at the start of the summer, many believed the latter would sign for Arsenal, and that Gyokeres would end up reuniting with Amorim after working together at previous club Sporting CP in Lisbon. Critchley: It has been quietly impressive. Matheus Cunha's £62.5million signing from Wolves was a relatively straightforward deal and was finalised early. The same could not be said for the pursuit of Bryan Mbeumo, which lasted 44 days and ended with Brentford earning a guaranteed £65m, but in the end, United secured their two priority targets. Sales were said to be needed before they could make further additions, but there was always the possibility that Ratcliffe borrowed to spend and drew down on the club's revolving credit facilities. Sesko has filled the priority position at centre-forward for an initial €76.5million (£66.1m; $89.5m), despite no permanent exits and formidable competition for the RB Leipzig striker from Newcastle United. But outgoings are still necessary, especially after Amorim ostracised five players — Marcus Rashford, Alejandro Garnacho, Antony, Jadon Sancho and Tyrell Malacia — to form a so-called 'bomb squad'. So far, only Rashford has departed, to Barcelona, and even that is only a loan. McNicholas: Arsenal's incoming business has been good. A deal for midfielder Martin Zubimendi was formally completed in July, but had effectively been agreed months before. The long hunt for a new striker ended when Gyokeres joined for a €63.5million upfront fee, plus €10m in potential add-ons. Arsenal have also added depth by signing Kepa Arrizabalaga, Christian Norgaard and Cristhian Mosquera. Advertisement The wildcard signing is arguably Noni Madueke. Bought from Chelsea for an initial £48.5million, the England international provides Arteta with another option on either flank. As with United, Arsenal are prioritising sales in the final part of the window. Reiss Nelson, Fabio Vieira, Albert Sambi Lokonga and Karl Hein are all available. Critchley: More positive than you might think. Amorim and his players have regularly spoken of a bond developing in the camp this summer. Yes, you would expect them to say that on the eve of a new season, but talk to those around the club and it largely checks out. Having exiled the out-of-favour five, Amorim is now working with a group of players who are fully aligned with his vision. United's results and performances in pre-season have been broadly positive. Can such optimism survive a tricky set of opening fixtures? United's worst finish of the Premier League era last season leaves little margin for error. And though their summer spending is proof that Amorim has the hierarchy's support, it also shows how critical it is that he avoids a repeat of his first campaign in charge. McNicholas: The mood is good, especially after the comprehensive 3-0 win over Athletic Club in their final friendly of pre-season. Expectations are high, however. The Emirates Cup that the club won after beating the Bilbao side last Saturday is not going to satisfy supporters. After falling short of major silverware in each of the past five seasons, there is definite pressure on manager Arteta. Arsenal have a very challenging start to their Premier League campaign — including this trip to Old Trafford — and they need to come through it without sustaining too much damage. A few bad early results, and all that hope and anticipation could easily bubble over into something more negative. Advertisement Critchley: It was 32 points last season. The only time it has been bigger in the Premier League era was 1994-95, when United finished 37 clear of Arsenal (though that was in a 42-game campaign). United were runners-up that year. Arsenal finished in the bottom half for the first time in a long time, and also lost a European final. The parallels are there if you want to go looking for them. Arsenal were still three years away from winning their next title — the timeframe United have set for 'Project 150', their target to be crowned champions again by 2028, in line with the club's 150th anniversary. It is a very different league three decades on, but United could catch up quickly. We are still talking about the second- and third-placed clubs from just three seasons ago. McNicholas: The gap is a gulf. For someone raised on the title races between these clubs in the 1990s and early 2000s, it was surreal to see United so close to the foot of the Premier League last season. Amorim has been granted more time after his mid-season arrival. One wonders if Arteta's journey at Arsenal strengthened United's conviction to stick with their new manager. The Spaniard had a dismal period in the winter of 2020 when he got the job, but the board kept faith. Ultimately, that loyalty has been rewarded by Arsenal's return to the Champions League and their improved capacity to challenge for silverware. United will hope Amorim can follow a similar trajectory. Critchley: The obvious answer is Bukayo Saka, who could have a lot of joy down United's left if Patrick Dorgu plays as high up the pitch today as he has during pre-season, which could potentially leave Luke Shaw to deal with Arsenal's most potent open-play threat. Set pieces have to be considered too, though, especially as United conceded the joint-fourth-most in the league from dead balls last season, including two in the Premier League fixture at the Emirates. Jurrien Timber and William Saliba were the scorers that December night, but Gabriel is typically more dangerous, and scored after the breakdown of a corner in January's FA Cup meeting. Advertisement McNicholas: Even when United have been at their lowest, the quality of Bruno Fernandes has shone through. His decision to stay this summer after interest from Saudi Arabia provided them with a considerable boost. If Sesko starts, there will naturally be a huge media focus on his performance. Arsenal tracked his progress for years and deliberated over signing him this summer, before ultimately plumping for Gyokeres. United's great threat may come on their right-hand side. Myles Lewis-Skelly and Riccardo Calafiori occasionally leave space in behind on Arsenal's left, and Mbeumo and Amad have the speed and quality to exploit that. Critchley: I've gone back and forth between Liverpool, Arsenal and Manchester City all summer, but I'm leaning towards Arteta's side to be champions. As much as everyone banged on about not having a recognised striker, and though a signing like Gyokeres was obviously needed, injuries, sendings-off and a creative over-reliance on Saka were as much a part of their downfall last season. Maybe they run into some of those issues again, but you could chalk most of them down to bad luck. And if they avoid those pitfalls, there is a stable, familiar foundation for Arteta to work with at a time when Liverpool and City are having to rebuild. McNicholas: Full disclosure: I have no idea. So much depends on what kind of progress the squad have made in understanding and implementing Amorim's system. My gut tells me United will be a top-half team again, though I'd be surprised if they finished in the Champions League qualification places. Somewhere between sixth and 10th feels most plausible to me. Critchley: We all know by now that Amorim is not going to budge from his 3-4-2-1, and all of United's summer business has been geared towards filling its roles and responsibilities. Cunha and Mbeumo have been signed to play as the left and right attacking midfielders respectively, which is likely to see Fernandes drop back into midfield. All three started up top together in the pre-season meeting with Everton, though, and could do so again if Sesko is not deemed ready for his debut. Advertisement Amad is also likely to be repositioned this season as a result of Mbeumo's arrival and could see more minutes at right wing-back than he did last term, although this could be the type of contest where Diogo Dalot's defensive solidity is preferred. McNicholas: It'll be Arsenal's standard variation on a 4-3-3. The improved depth at Arteta's disposal means he will have options in a variety of positions. He can choose between Lewis-Skelly and Calafiori at left-back, and Ben White and Timber on the opposite side of his back four. A midfield of Zubimendi, Declan Rice and Martin Odegaard picks itself. The most intriguing decision is whether Arteta deems Gyokeres ready to play from the start. He scored in that final friendly against Athletic Club, and the manager may be tempted to go with the Swede — especially after Havertz suffered a minor injury last week, which disrupted his pre-season preparation. Critchley: A repeat of the 1-1 draw in the corresponding fixture in March. Amorim's setup has frustrated 'Big Six' opponents in the past, even if his 10 matches against those clubs across all competitions last season only resulted in one United win (two if you include beating Arsenal on penalties in the FA Cup). McNicholas: Arsenal are the better side but history shows that doesn't always translate into results. A draw is a good bet, a result could suit both clubs. I'll go for a 2-2. Spot the pattern. Connect the terms Find the hidden link between sports terms Play today's puzzle
