Taoiseach backs existing Gaza aid agencies after EU official suggests helping Israel provide aid
His comments come today after two Irish MEPs described the offer from the European Union's top diplomat as
'utterly shameful' and 'against what we stand for'.
On Wednesday, the EU's High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy Kaja Kallas said she
had offered the Israeli Foreign Minister help
from the EU to 'distribute the humanitarian aid if they don't trust the other actors there.'
Asked about the comments today by
The Journal
, the Taoiseach said he had not seen the statement, but that 'the role of UN agencies cannot be, in my view, replaced, or shouldn't be.'
He said UNRWA, which is the UN's agency in Palestine, and the World Food Programme are both 'essential' in Gaza.
'UNRWA is a key agency in enabling humanitarian aid to get into Gaza. It has the scale and the capacity to do that,' he said.
The Taoiseach made the point that non-governmental aid agencies have the expertise that is needed to deliver aid and also have independence, which 'avoids the weaponisation of humanitarian aid'.
'And what Israel is essentially endeavouring to do, in my view, is to weaponise – well, it already has weaponised aid by refusing aid to go in.
'But if it now starts taking exclusive control of the distribution of aid, I have no doubt that that would involve further weaponisation of aid, and that's not acceptable,' the Taoiseach said.
The Taoiseach was joined in Arklow today by Fianna Fáil MEP Cynthia Ní Mhurchú.
Advertisement
Asked by
The Journal
if she agrees with her MEP colleague Barry Andrews, who said Israel's proposal 'undermines established humanitarian actors', Ní Mhurchhú said:
'I certainly would like to study further the comments of the High Commissioner. She's a very measured Commissioner, and to date, she has done great work.'
Ní Mhurchhú said she thinks there 'might be a misunderstanding of the move and the issuance of this utterance' and that she would like to look into it further.
'But I do think that any solo run, and Barry Andrews was quite right if he called it out in the manner in which he did…would have to be looked at very carefully in the context of the fact that the collegiate and the College of Commissioners, they have to work together.'
Ní Mhurchú added that Europe will be 'looking very carefully at any intervention, but I wouldn't like it categorised as a solo run on the part of Commissioner Kallas.'
Solo run
The Journal
understands that Kallas made the offer without consulting her colleagues and that her remarks do not reflect the EU's official position.
Irish MEPs spoke to
The Journal
and expressed concern about Kallas' offer of EU assistance.
'Rather than offering to assist in their plan to ethnically cleanse Gaza, the EU should be imposing the most severe sanctions on Israel, and leading calls for a permanent ceasefire,' said Sinn Féin MEP Lynn Boylan.
Fianna Fáil MEP Barry Andrews said: 'Israel's current proposal to bypass and undermine established humanitarian actors and take direct control of aid distribution is deeply alarming.'
Both MEPs said assisting Israel in taking over aid distribution would go against core humanitarian principles and undermine the work of the United Nations.
With reporting by David MacRedmond and Christina Finn.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Extra.ie
7 minutes ago
- Extra.ie
Who is the new favourite for President with Mairead McGuinness OUT?
Mairéad McGuinness has dropped out of the race for the Irish Presidential election. The former EU Commissioner and favourite to win the race, Ms McGuinness, has cited health reasons for her decision and disclosed that she was hospitalised last week. With Ms McGuinness withdrawing, the race has since been blown open — with former Mayor of Galway and Leas Ceann Comhairle Catherine Connolly emerging as the new favourite. Mairéad McGuinness has dropped out of the race for the Irish Presidential election. Pic:Ms Connolly, a Galway West TD, is now the only official candidate — with her having support from a number of left-leaning parties and independents including People Before Profit and the Social Democrats. Paddy Power have since placed Ms Connolly's odds of becoming President at 10/11, while Fine Gael's Seán Kelly — who was also expected to compete with Ms McGuinness before he himself dropped out — has also re-entered the betting pool, with his odds standing at 9/4 at the time of writing. Mr Kelly has not responded to potentially re-seeking the nomination following his colleague's departure from the race, saying at the time of his own decision not to seek the nomination that he ultimately decided against it after weighing up the pros and cons of taking on the job. Catherine Connolly, who is the only official nominee at the time of writing, has seen the odds of her winning the election go to 10/11 — making her the favourite. Pic: Eamonn Farrell/ While Fianna Fáil have yet to confirm who their candidate will be, many are speculating that former Taoiseach Bertie Ahern will be their nomination — with the odds of him replacing Michael D Higgins standing at 5/1. Similarly, Sinn Féin have not announced who their nominee will be or if they will run one at all — but after Mary Lou McDonald refused to rule herself out of the nomination, her odds have been slashed to 11/2. A number of potential candidates have also expressed their interest in running for the office, although the odds of them getting the keys to the Áras are slim — with Michael Flatley, who confirmed he's seeking a nomination, coming in at 18/1. Other potential nominees include former Taoiseach Bertie Ahern (pictured), former CMO Dr Tony Holohan and 2018 runner-up Peter Casey. Pic: Gareth Chaney/Collins Former Chief Medical Officer Dr Tony Holohan, who's also reportedly seeking the nomination, is a rank outsider, with Paddy Power having his odds of being the next President at 25/1, while pharmaceutical executive Gareth Sheridan, who's looking to be the youngest Presidential nominee ever, has seen his odds tumble from 22/1 when he initially announced his intentions to 50/1 at the time of writing. Former nominee and 2018 runner-up Peter Casey is currently 66/1, with other potential nominees standing at those odds including former Sinn Féin President Gerry Adams and GAA pundit Joe Brolly. Announcing her decision on Thursday (August 14), Ms McGuinness said that she was pulling out on health grounds, and had stayed in hospital last week. 'I have made the very difficult decision to withdraw my name as the Fine Gael nominee for the Presidential election,' Ms McGuinness said in a statement. 'This decision is not lightly taken and follows a stay in hospital last week. 'My priority now is my health. Given that the election is in a short couple of months, I do not believe that I have the strength to give the campaign my all.'
Irish Daily Mirror
7 minutes ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Michael Flatley will 'arrive at decision soon' about presidency run
Lord of the Dance Michael Flatley said he will 'arrive at a decision very soon' on running for the Irish presidency. Two weeks ago the entertainer's barrister announced his plan to run during a High Court case in relation to works carried out at his Cork mansion. Asked by Virgin Media if he is going to try and get his name on the presidential ballot, he said: 'It won't be long, I will arrive at a decision very soon.' Questioned about what issues he would run his campaign on, the Irish dancer said it's a 'non political role' and he is 'non political'. He added: 'I have always been an artist. My job is to spread Irish culture and I have done for the last 30 years. 'Tokyo to Texas from Mexico to Moscow, Boston to Beijing. We have promoted Ireland and Irish culture. I am in the joy business. I am very blessed. I am absolutely non-political. I'm not sure we need a political figure there, you need someone who is a statesman and ambassador. 'I'm certainly not thinking all the Irish people would vote for me, it's only if I thought I could be helpful.' Michael said he would be 'quietly confident' that if he decides to put his name in the hat he will get enough nominations to get on the ballot. Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here.
Irish Examiner
37 minutes ago
- Irish Examiner
Trump says he thinks Putin will make a deal on Ukraine
US president Donald Trump said on Thursday he thought Vladimir Putin was ready to make a deal on ending the war in Ukraine after the Russian president floated the prospect of a nuclear arms agreement on the eve of their summit in Alaska. Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelenskyy and his European allies have intensified their efforts this week to prevent any deal between the US and Russia emerging from Friday's summit that leaves Ukraine vulnerable to future attack. "I think he's going to make a deal," Trump said in a Fox News radio interview, adding that if the meeting went well he would call Zelenskyy and European leaders afterwards and that if it went badly he would not. The aim of Friday's talks with Putin is to set up a second meeting including Ukraine, Trump said, adding: "I don't know that we're going to get an immediate ceasefire." Putin earlier spoke to his most senior ministers and security officials as he prepared for the meeting with Trump in Anchorage, Alaska on Friday that could shape the endgame to the largest war in Europe since World War Two. In televised comments, Putin said that the US was "making, in my opinion, quite energetic and sincere efforts to stop the hostilities, stop the crisis and reach agreements that are of interest to all parties involved in this conflict". This was happening, Putin said, "in order to create long-term conditions for peace between our countries, and in Europe, and in the world as a whole - if, by the next stages, we reach agreements in the area of control over strategic offensive weapons." His comments signalled that Russia will raise the issue of nuclear arms control as part of a wide-ranging discussion on security when he sits down with Trump. A Kremlin aide said Putin and Trump would also discuss the "huge untapped potential" for Russia-US economic ties. A senior eastern European official, who requested anonymity to discuss sensitive matters, said Putin would try to distract Trump from Ukraine at the talks by offering him possible progress on nuclear arms control or something business-related. Activists dressed as Donald Trump (L) and Vladimir Putin pose after ripping up a map of Ukraine at a demonstration in front of the Brandenburg Gate. Picture: Sean Gallup/Getty "We hope Trump won't be fooled by the Russians, he understands all (these) dangerous things," the official said, adding that Russia's only goal was to avoid any new sanctions and have existing sanctions lifted. Trump said there would be a press conference after the talks but that he did not know whether it would be joint. He also said that there would be a give and take on boundaries and lands. Russia controls around a fifth of Ukraine and Zelenskyy and the Europeans worry that a deal could cement those gains, rewarding Putin for 11 years of efforts to seize Ukrainian land and emboldening him to expand further into Europe. An EU diplomat said it would be "scary to see how it all unfolds in the coming hours. Trump had very good calls yesterday with Europe but that was yesterday". Seeking clarity on security guarantees Trump had shown willingness to join the security guarantees for Ukraine at a last-ditch virtual meeting with European leaders and Zelenskyy on Wednesday, European leaders said, though he made no public mention of them afterwards. Zelenskyy said the security guarantees had been discussed in "considerable detail" in comments after a meeting in London on Thursday with British prime minister Keir Starmer. Friday's summit, the first Russia-US summit since June 2021, comes at one of the toughest moments for Ukraine in a war that has killed tens of thousands and displaced millions since Russia's full-scale invasion in February 2022. Speaking after Wednesday's meeting, French president Emmanuel Macron said Trump insisted that the transatlantic NATO alliance should not be part of security guarantees that would be designed to protect Ukraine from future attacks in a post-war settlement. Macron said, however, that Trump had also said the United States and all willing allies should be part of the security guarantees. Expanding on that, a European official told Reuters that Trump said on the call he was willing to provide some security guarantees for Europe, without spelling out what they would be. It "felt like a big step forward", said the official, who did not want to be named. It was not immediately clear what such guarantees could mean in practice. On Wednesday, Trump threatened "severe consequences" if Putin does not agree to peace in Ukraine and has warned of economic sanctions if his meeting on Friday proves fruitless. Russia is likely to resist Ukraine and Europe's demands and has previously said its stance had not changed since it was first detailed by Putin in June 2024. — Reuters
