Australian doctor who volunteered in Gaza says hospital staff also starving
"You just watch all these images on social media and television, and you just feel really helpless," Emma Giles said.
After a 12-hour bus journey from Amman in Jordan, stopping at numerous checkpoints, Dr Giles arrived at Al-Quds Hospital in Gaza City in mid-May.
She was only allowed to bring 3 kilograms of food with her and a limited amount of medical equipment for her four-week stay, where she lived at the hospital and worked with Palestinian medical staff.
"There are fairly strict limits on what you can take with you," she told ABC Radio Perth's Jo Trilling.
"You're allowed to take items which are for personal use only and for those that you can use in your own personal professional career.
"So I couldn't take surgical stuff in, but I could take anaesthetic stuff in."
Once at the hospital, Dr Giles got to work.
"We had some anaesthetic machines which were quite similar to what I would use in Australia, but the disposable items weren't there," she said.
"For example, [in Perth] I would put a breathing filter on my anaesthetic machine between every patient, so I don't transmit respiratory diseases, but we had none of those.
Israel stopped allowing almost all food aid into Gaza on March 2.
Dr Giles found the effect of severe food shortages was apparent in many of her patients by May.
"We'd see a lot of people, particularly children, quite malnourished, poor healing," she said.
"They would come back every two to three days to have further wash out of their really, really nasty wounds to try and prevent infection.
"We'd just do it under anaesthesia."
Dr Giles said the food shortages extended to the medical and nursing staff, who were only being given one meal a day by the hospital.
"[The local staff] are absolutely exhausted and burnt out," she said.
"They often work in multiple hospitals and do 24-hour shifts because travel is so difficult and dangerous. They choose to do longer shifts.
Since she left, Dr Giles has been told the situation has worsened.
"There is no food supplied by the hospital anymore," she said.
"They're often starving and weak during the day, often feel a bit faint while they're working, and they're absolutely desperate to keep going."
Dr Giles lost 6 kilograms during her four weeks in Gaza.
On May 26, amid international outcry about the lack of food available, an organisation backed by the United States and Israel called the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF) began handing out food at distribution points.
The Israeli military created long approach corridors for each of the GHF sites, and it soon became clear how dangerous they were.
"The GHF started up close to where we were, about halfway through my time there, and that's when we started getting mass casualties as a real issue in the hospital," Dr Giles said.
"They were open for maybe 10 to 15 minutes in a day, and then the people will just crowd in and get food. It's very much a survival of the fittest."
The UN reported that as of July 21, 1,054 people had been killed in Gaza while trying to get food, 766 near GHF sites.
"When they were crowding in [at GHF sites], often that would be seen as threatening by armed personnel around who would shoot them," Dr Giles said.
"If we saw people walking past the hospital carrying bags of flour, we knew that there would be mass casualties coming in soon.
"When you were operating on people, you often saw that the patients had this white ingrained flour in their hands — people who had actually managed to get food had then been wounded."
Dr Giles travelled to Gaza as a volunteer with the Palestinian Australian New Zealand Medical Association (PANZMA).
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

ABC News
9 hours ago
- ABC News
Doctors in Gaza are treating children who may never recover from malnutrition
In clinics across Gaza, starving children are getting treatment, but they probably can't be saved. They lie on hospital beds, skeletal, wasted, many barely making a sound. Medical workers say that's what scares them most. CONTENT WARNING: This story contains images of sick children that may be distressing. "They're so exhausted, they're so sick, they're no longer able to cry," said Rachel Cummings, the humanitarian director for Save the Children in Gaza, describing a visit to one of the organisation's clinics last week. "It was nearly silent." Many of those children who can still speak are saying they want to die. "We have many children now in our child protection services saying that they wish to die [because] in heaven, in paradise, there is food, there is water," Ms Cummings said. Malnutrition deaths likely under-reported: doctor Many adults in Gaza are malnourished too, but the impact on children is worse. ( ABC News ) The horrifying truth, according to doctors in Gaza, is that many will soon get their wish. "All of the children who are currently malnourished will die," said Canadian doctor Tarek Loubani, the medical director of the healthcare organisation Glia, who is working in Gaza at the moment. "That is, unless there is an absolutely rapid and consistent reversal of what is happening. "However, let's be very realistic. Anybody who is malnourished right now will die." Children being treated at the Patient Friends Hospital, a specialist malnutrition treatment centre in Gaza. ( ABC News ) The number of malnutrition deaths in Gaza could be vastly under-reported, said Dr Loubani, who spoke at a recent press conference alongside multiple aid workers, including Ms Cummings. They don't include children with pre-existing medical conditions, even if those conditions are also exacerbated by the war, he said. "The figures are very, very conservative," he said. Aid organisations have said malnutrition cases are growing at an alarming rate. ( ABC News ) "The directive that we receive in the emergency [ward] is that we do not report any death that has a substantial — even primary — malnutrition component if there is any other comorbidity. "That is to say, the only deaths that are marked as malnutrition deaths are the ones where there is really well and truly nothing else going on but the malnutrition." He believes the official malnutrition death numbers could be just 10 per cent of the reality. 'It's not enough to save them' The medical term "malnutrition" masks the harshness of the situation. What's occurring in Gaza now — say doctors, aid workers and the people themselves — is starvation. Clinic workers say it's devastating to treat children, knowing they're unlikely to recover. ( ABC News ) In the Patient Friends Hospital, which hosts the main specialised malnutrition treatment centre in Gaza City, doctors can't do much to help. "Although a nutritional plan is attempted, there are no adequate supplies — there's simply nothing available to nourish the children," said Dr Fawaz Al Husseini, a paediatrician specialising in malnutrition. "In normal circumstances, infants might consume butter and milk at home. But here, even hospitalised children with severe malnutrition gain little weight due to the limited food available. "What little aid enters Gaza is grossly insufficient; it doesn't even begin to meet the children's needs." The red part of this tape indicates a child is suffering from acute malnutrition. ( ABC News ) Even for moderately malnourished Gazan children, the prospects are grim. The use of a simple, yet specialised, measuring device called a MUAC (Mid-Upper Arm Circumference) tape determines whether a child is healthy (green), moderately malnourished (orange) or suffering from acute malnutrition (red). The orange and red cases are given a paste from peanut, sugar and milk powder called "Plumpy'Nut" — a Nutella-inspired health supplement designed to treat malnutrition. But it's not enough to save them. Doctors say the most chilling thing about these clinics is the silence. ( ABC News ) "The treatment for moderate, the orange, is inadequate because there are no complementary foods. You can't survive on Plumpy'Nut alone," Ms Cummings said. "Children are just getting sicker and sicker, even though they're in a treatment program for malnutrition. "This is why we see this downward trajectory of child outcomes and that's why my team were so upset … because they know they're sending the children home [and] they will bounce back to the clinic in a worse state." More than two months of no food Israel blocked all food from entering Gaza from March 2 to May 21, saying it was trying to pressure the militant group Hamas to accept its ceasefire terms. It also tried to replace the comprehensive and extensive UN-led aid distribution system with a newly formed American contractor, the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF), which had never before delivered humanitarian relief. Palestinians seen carrying bags of aid in the northern Gaza Strip this week. ( Reuters: Mahmoud Issa ) Israel argued these changes were to stop Hamas diverting aid, something the UN and international relief agencies denied was occurring and for which a US government analysis found no evidence. The result of Israel's policy was widespread deprivation and desperation, culminating in an urgent declaration by the UN's Integrated Food Security Phase Classification group that most of Gaza had crossed famine thresholds. Hundreds of people were killed — likely by Israeli tank and gunfire — trying to get food from the limited aid points set up by the private contractor, which, by its own numbers, has never distributed enough food to come close to feeding Gaza's population. The few aid trucks that came through have been swarmed by desperate people, as seen in recent satellite vision. It was only when faced with global condemnation and pressure from its closest ally, the United States, that Israel allowed more trucks into Gaza. Over the past week, the UN said Israel also granted an increased number of requests from its agencies to pick up aid already sitting under Israeli military guard inside the strip. Israel also announced "tactical pauses" — basically agreeing not to bomb or attack certain areas with ground troops — so drivers can take goods to stricken populations. Some aid workers say the humanitarian situation has become a "survival of the fittest". ( Reuters: Mahmoud Issa ) It allowed several countries to parachute food into Gaza by plane, a practice condemned by many aid agencies as ineffective, dangerous and expensive. The United Nations said those measures have made little difference to the overall situation, with most of the trucks that did bring aid into the strip this week being looted. 'Cruel phase of war' Mohassen Shaaban says no aid has made it to her and her baby daughter. ( ABC News ) Palestinians seeking aid allege Israeli soldiers continue to shoot at and kill them and vulnerable people continue to miss out. Aid workers say the situation has devolved into a "survival of the fittest" and is failing to deliver food to people like Mohassen Shaaban, who is nursing her one-month-old daughter Rahaf in a tent in a camp in Gaza. "They keep promising aid but we haven't seen anything," she told the ABC. Mohassen Shaaban isn't getting enough food to even breastfeed baby Rahaf. ( ABC News ) Because most of the increased aid over the past week has been looted before making it to the agencies' warehouses, there has been no distribution to people like her. "We adults have nothing to eat — no food at all. So how can I feed her [baby Rahaf]? I can't find anything for her or for us," she said. "The situation is terrible for us — imagine what it's like for the children." Mohassen Shaaban and her baby daughter Rahaf are living in a camp. ( ABC News ) Ms Shaaban said she often boiled mint leaves in water to give to her daughter, in an attempt to stop her crying. "She needs milk. She needs a clean place to live. We all need milk and a clean, safe space," she said. "We need food — not just for the children, but for ourselves too, so we can breastfeed them. There are no nutrients. "This situation is driving me crazy. It's unbearable not being able to find anything to feed her." Damage from malnutrition 'not reversible' Aid organisations have said malnutrition centres are being overwhelmed by patients. ( ABC News ) Even if Gaza's malnourished children survive this cruel phase in the war, they will be forever marked by it. "Child malnutrition causes cognitive impairment, memory loss, and inflammation; impacting the child's developmental potential," said Fawaz Al Husseini, the paediatric malnutrition specialist. "It affects walking, memory, and vision — it impacts the entire body. In some cases, it even affects the kidneys; some children suffer kidney failure due to malnutrition." Doctors say the children they are treating are struggling to gain weight. ( ABC News ) Many adults in Gaza are malnourished too, but the impact on children is worse. The developmental damage is irreversible, said Rob Williams, the CEO of the War Child Alliance. "The process of development stops, the process of building a brain, of creating neurons that will establish cognitive ability, will stop," he said. "If you're a child at a vulnerable age for brain development … if that development stops, that is not reversible. "The trucks coming in now will do nothing to restore the injury that's been done to the brains and the physical development of children who have been acutely malnourished. "It's also true to say that hundreds of thousands of children have permanent damage — permanent physical and cognitive damage — from a deliberate policy of restricting the supply of food in Gaza." Some doctors say all of the chlidren who are currently malnourished, will die. ( ABC News ) The UN and other agencies say only a ceasefire and the unrestricted opening of Gaza's crossings to aid and commercial goods will solve the hunger crisis. "It's not just about how many trucks get to the barrier, it's how effectively they get to the population, and especially the vulnerable ones who can't fight for food as the trucks enter and who can't risk their lives going to the GHF," Mr Williams said. "The question that policymakers seem to be asking themselves is not 'How do you stop mass starvation in Gaza?' — the question they seem to be asking is 'How do we do something that will make it look like we're doing something?' Even if children recover from malnutrition, their development is likely to be permanently affected. ( ABC News ) "We are at the point in Gaza where anything that doesn't include a complete ceasefire, a complete opening of those walls, a complete opening of the perfectly competent aid system that was there before … anything less than is policymakers condemning tens of thousands of people to death."

ABC News
21 hours ago
- ABC News
Calls for better warning labels on alcohol
Andy Park: The WHO classified alcohol as a carcinogen back in the 1990s, even saying there's no safe level of consumption. Now Australian researchers are calling for bright coloured labels to be added to alcoholic drinks, warning consumers that alcohol causes cancer, not unlike the warnings on tobacco. Experts say many Australians don't know there's strong evidence that alcohol is directly linked to seven types of cancer. Joanna Crothers reports. Joanna Crothers: Alcohol's links to cancer aren't top of mind for these Perth workers at knock-off time. Perth worker 1: I'm not entirely sure that I know that there's a direct link. I haven't seen any evidence to suggest that. Joanna Crothers: But the general health risks were more familiar. Perth worker 2: Yeah, I'm quite aware if you're a heavy drinker it can lead to issues. Joanna Crothers: As well as illnesses like heart and liver disease, the World Health Organisation warns alcohol causes at least seven types of cancer, including bowel and breast cancer. UNSW's Dr Claire Wilkinson is on the WHO's advisory group for alcohol labelling. Claire Wilkinson: I think people are not aware that alcohol causes cancer. So liver cirrhosis, people are more aware of that link. But other types of cancers such as breast cancer, colon cancer, colorectal cancer, people are less aware of the causal link. We think that as a product, consumers have the right to know. Joanna Crothers: Dr Wilkinson is calling on Australia to adopt the WHO's recommendations for cancer warnings on alcohol. She says a trial in Canada proved cancer warnings, improved awareness and encouraged people to rethink their drinking habits. Claire Wilkinson: The label was about, I'd say, two centimetres tall. It was in a very strong contrast of bright red and bright yellow. And it had the message, alcohol can cause cancer in black bold font. And then it went on to say, including breast, colon and stomach cancer. Joanna Crothers: Canada also leads the way on alcohol consumption guidelines, recommending no more than two drinks a week, while Australia recommends no more than four drinks on any one day and a maximum of 10 a week. But Alcohol Beverages Australia's Executive Director Alistair Coe says further restrictions are not needed, including cancer warnings on bottles and cans. Alistair Coe: The industry does not support these warning labels. Of course we promote a culture of drinking in moderation, but simply putting another label on a container is not going to bring about change. Joanna Crothers: Mr Coe says the majority of Australians drink responsibly. Alistair Coe: So we need to make sure we're taking a holistic and very well evidence based position. Joanna Crothers: In a statement, the Health Department says the National Alcohol Strategy identifies reforms and aims to prevent alcohol related harm, and the department will monitor the impact of Ireland's warning labels. Last week, Ireland postponed the rollout of these labels until 2028. Back in Perth, these people had mixed views on warning labels. Perth local 1: I think there's enough advertising and awareness of that sort of thing. And at the end of the day, people need to take responsibility for their own actions. So we're not two year olds. I think we're governed enough as it is in this state. Perth local 2: Yeah, I think it is probably something that people should be warned about, because in Australia, most people drink every night. So it would be a bit more in your face. Perth local 3: I don't think it's going to make any difference. If somebody's going to drink, they're going to drink. Andy Park: Perth drinkers. Ending that report by Joanna Crothers.


SBS Australia
a day ago
- SBS Australia
'Constantly dizzy, exhausted': An SBS contributor in Gaza's daily struggle to feed his family
Father of four Rakan Abed El Rahman spends his days in Gaza searching for both food and news to share with the outside world. The 37-year-old journalist is a regular contributor and camera operator who assists with SBS news-gathering in Gaza amid an ongoing ban on international media. His day starts at the local market, where he says even the most basic foods are hard to find. "I've spent hours in the market looking for any kind of food, simple food ... the situation here is really, really difficult, and people cannot find anything to eat. "For days now, I have been looking for milk for my two-years-[old] baby and I haven't found it yet, which really, really breaks my heart that I'm not able to provide it." Abed El Rahman says cash is also hard to come by in Gaza and he only gets half the value of the money he electronically transfers to a merchant in exchange for local currency. Credit: Supplied What food can be found for his infant and other children — a 12-year-old daughter, and two sons aged eight and 11 — comes at a steep price. "One kilo of this tomato is about maybe 15 US dollars." Two out of three famine thresholds have been reached in the strip, according to the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification platform. 'A grave risk of famine' Officials from humanitarian groups like the UN Children's Agency, UNICEF, say the region "faces a grave risk of famine". According to UNICEF, "severe malnutrition is spreading among children faster than aid can reach them" in Gaza, citing data from the Palestinian Ministry of Health. At least 16 children under five have died from hunger-related causes since mid-July, while over 20,000 were treated in hospitals for acute malnutrition. Israeli officials deny that starvation is occurring in Gaza. Israeli officials have instead blamed either the United Nations' inefficiency or Hamas for aid not reaching people in areas it has claimed to control for much of the war, a claim that Hamas has denied. According to internal UN databases, since 19 May 2025 over 1,750 aid trucks have been intercepted "either peacefully by hungry people or forcefully by armed actors, during transit in Gaza". In response, Israel has installed the US-backed Gaza Health Foundation as the primary deliverer of aid in Gaza, which the UN had declined to work with, saying it distributes aid in ways that are inherently dangerous and violate humanitarian neutrality principles, contributing to the hunger crisis across the territory. More than 100 people were killed, and hundreds of others injured, along food convoy routes and near Israeli-militarised distribution hubs in the last two days of July, according to the UN. The GHF says nobody has been killed at its distribution points, and that it's doing a better job of protecting aid deliveries than the UN. The Israeli military has acknowledged that civilians have been harmed by its gunfire near distribution centres, and says its forces have now received better instructions. 'This is my daily meal' On the day of recording the video diary embedded above, Abed El Rahman found flour — something that isn't a regular occurrence, he says. The portions of flour are taken from a bag clearly marked with the World Food Programme logo, which Abed El Rahman believes was stolen from aid deliveries. He buys two kilograms of flour, a kilo and a half of eggplant and two plates of hummus. Whatever he's able to find at the market makes up the one daily meal he and his family eat. Abed El Rahman's family sits down to eat a simple dinner cooked over a wood fire. Credit: Supplied "This is my daily meal, it is just one meal, it costs me around 80 dollars," he says. "This is a heavy burden on me … and it's a privilege for me that I can buy it now, some days I cannot buy it because I don't have the cash to buy this." On those days, he says, the family goes to bed hungry. But he's grateful they still have a roof over their heads. In the first month of the war, an Israeli airstrike destroyed his neighbour's home and partially destroyed the second level of his home where his father had been staying, he says. "The rescue teams pulled out my father from under the rubble … lucky for me, me and my family were not here at home on that night." Sometimes though, hunger makes it hard for him to leave the house. "I am constantly dizzy, exhausted, [and] tired due to the lack of food. I approximately lost 15 kilograms in a short time. There are numerous days that I cannot go to work because of [a] lack of energy in my body." At home, Abed El Rahman prepares the meal with his 11-year-old son, who gathered scrap wood to make the fire on which they will cook as gas is no longer available in the strip. He's grateful that he's able to provide for his family — at least for today.