Judge tosses lawsuit over Chandler mayor's eligibility
State of play: Questions emerged in May over whether Chandler's city charter permits people to serve two consecutive four-year terms as City Council members and then another two as mayor, or if they're limited to eight total years for either office.
Hartke and former Mayors Boyd Dunn and Jay Tibshraeny served two terms on council before their two mayoral terms.
Driving the news: Maricopa County Superior Court Judge David McDowell in late July dismissed a lawsuit filed by Ruth Jones, who ran against Hartke in 2022, seeking to have him removed from office.
The judge ruled the suit was a challenge to Hartke's qualifications for office, which, under state law, must be filed within 10 days of submitting nomination papers.
The judge added that lawsuits under a different statute challenging the eligibility of winning candidates must be filed within five days of an election's certification.
What's next: Voters will have a chance to settle the term limits question before next year's Chandler election.
The City Council referred Proposition 410 to the November ballot, which would amend the city charter to clarify that people can serve a total of 16 consecutive years — two terms as a councilmember and two as mayor.
Anyone who serves 16 consecutive years wouldn't be eligible to hold office again until at least four years after the end of their last term.
Prop. 410 will be on a special election ballot with several other measures.
What she's saying: Jones told Axios the ruling was an "unfortunate result" and said her lawsuit wasn't an election challenge.
"I neither seek to challenge that election or become mayor," she said, adding she hasn't decided whether to appeal.
The other side: "I'm glad to get it behind," Hartke told Axios.
The intrigue: The special election could clarify the eligibility of at least one mayoral hopeful — two-term City Councilmember Matt Orlando, who is running for Chandler's top office.
If voters approve the charter language, it would head off a potential lawsuit challenging his eligibility.
But if the measure fails, it could leave Orlando's candidacy at the mercy of the courts.
He told Axios he's confident voters will approve the change.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
23 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Tacoma City Council to consider ‘Worker's Bill of Rights'
This story was originally published on Tacoma's City Council will hold a special meeting Friday morning to decide whether to adopt or send to voters a proposed 'Worker's Bill of Rights.' Known as Measure 2, the initiative would raise the city's minimum wage to $20 per hour and expand protections for workers. Supporters said the measure is necessary to address the rising cost of living and improve workplace conditions. 'Some people think that by raising the minimum wage, then the cost of everything is going to go up, but the truth of the matter is, we're chasing the cost of living,' UFCW 367 President Michael Hines told The Tacoma News Tribune. 'We're not ahead of it. We haven't been ahead of it in a long time.' Tacoma businesses voice concerns At a recent council meeting, members of the local business community voiced concerns about the proposal. Andrea Reay, CEO of the Tacoma-Pierce County Chamber of Commerce, warned that some businesses may not survive if the measure is enacted. 'We're in a fragile moment,' Reay said. If the council does not approve Measure 2, it will be placed on a future ballot. The timing of that vote has not yet been determined. The meeting is scheduled for 9:30 a.m. Friday at Tacoma City Hall. Frank Lenzi is the News Director for KIRO Newsradio. Read more of his stories here. Solve the daily Crossword
Axios
3 hours ago
- Axios
Trump's team tosses a dart at Pritzker as tensions rise
The White House is conceding that a major project it has undertaken to keep an invasive fish out of the Great Lakes has stalled — and is pointing its finger squarely at an archenemy: Illinois Gov. JB Pritzker. Why it matters: The flare-up highlights how tensions between President Trump and Pritzker — a potential 2028 Democratic presidential candidate who regularly savages the administration — are boiling over. It comes days after Pritzker welcomed to Illinois dozens of Democratic legislators from Texas who fled the state to try to stop a Trump-backed redistricting push to create more GOP seats in Congress. Pritzker has called Trump a "cheater" over the remap effort, and accused him of trying to "steal" seats in the U.S. House, where Republicans have a slim majority heading into the 2026 midterms. Trump has called Pritzker "probably the worst" governor "in the country," and ripped him for opposing the president's hardline immigration measures. The backstory: Trump in May signed a memorandum offering his support for the Brandon Road Interbasin Project, a $1 billion effort involving Illinois, Michigan and the federal government that's aimed at preventing invasive Asian carp from entering the Great Lakes. Asian carp have been migrating northward toward the lakes, and would pose a danger to native fish populations and harm the region's recreational fishing, boating and tourism industries, officials say. Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer — another potential Democratic presidential contender — is an outspoken proponent of the project and lobbied Trump to support it. Whitmer has remained in close contact with Trump about the project, and met with him at the White House this week. Her team also has been coordinating with administration officials. But White House officials say they haven't received the same cooperation from Pritzker or his team. They say their calls to Pritzker haven't been returned. And they note that unlike Whitmer, Pritzker hasn't sat down with the president to discuss the project. What they ' re saying: A senior White House official tells Axios the project has "stalled" since Trump's May 9 memorandum. "Gov. Whitmer has asked for support and showed an eagerness to engage on this critical project. Pritzker has not," said an administration source working closely with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers on the project, which is overseeing construction. Funding, permitting and environmental issues have been central to the talks. "President Trump stands ready to get this project back on track, but the governor of Illinois is going to have to show some effort to get things moving again," the source added. The other side: Pritzker spokesperson Matt Hill vehemently denied that Pritzker has been MIA on the subject. Hill noted that Pritzker on July 24 hosted officials from Michigan and the Army Corps of Engineers at the Brandon Road Lock and Dam in Joliet, Ill., to discuss the project. Hill said attendees "shared positive updates on the progress we are making to protect the Great Lakes." "If Trump wants to try lying to play political blame games he can, but Illinois will focus on delivering results," Hill said. "If the White House needs an update on the project, we welcome their outreach but have not received any to date." A Whitmer spokesperson did not respond to a request for comment. Bottom line: There's no reason to believe the tensions between Trump and Pritzker will die down anytime soon.
New York Post
9 hours ago
- New York Post
President Trump, do what's right for NYC and endorse Mayor Eric Adams for re-election
President Trump, if you decide to get involved in this year's mayoral race, do what's right for the city we all love: Back Eric Adams. With his commitment to public safety and civic pride, Adams has shown he deserves a second term in Gracie Mansion. He has stood up to the left-wing legislators of Albany and the City Council, the radicals who want to legalize theft, hold no one on bail and empty all the jails. Advertisement 3 President Donald Trump speaks in the Oval Office at the White House in Washington, DC, August 6, 2025. REUTERS For the first half of this year, New York enjoyed the lowest number of shootings since the city started keeping track. That didn't happen by accident. Advertisement Socialist Zohran Mamdani would reverse all that progress. The 'defund the police' activist would hobble the NYPD, drive away businesses and make the streets unsafe. We agree Mamdani must be stopped. But don't believe that Andrew Cuomo, who already failed to beat Zohran once, is the answer. He's everything at once Advertisement Reports are that Andrew Cuomo's campaign is heavily lobbying you to help him in the New York City mayoral race. Don't listen to them, Mr. President: You know as well as we do that Cuomo cannot be trusted — except to betray anyone and everyone as fits his convenience. For starters, consider how he treated you during your first term, casting doubt on the 'Trump vaccine.' Then, once Democrats decided it was their vaccine, Cuomo was a leader of the 'you must get jabbed or else you'll be fired' crew. Advertisement 3 Democratic nominee for mayor Zohran Mamdani addresses the media outside the Federal Jacob Javits Building in New York, NY, on August 7, 2025. / MEGA Cuomo was for fracking until he was against fracking. He was for charter schools until he was against charter schools. He signed all of the 'no bail' laws and other 'reforms' that caused crime to skyrocket, but now claims he would 'fix' them. And he still refuses to admit those laws were a mistake. Heck, he won't admit to any mistake, ever. 3 Mayor Eric Adams speaks to supporters before the ribbon-cutting of his campaign's Brooklyn office. Stefano Giovannini How wormy is he? Advertisement On Thursday (after planting stories to the contrary), Cuomo flatly denied talking to you recently. He's also blatantly contradicting himself on how hard he'll 'fight Trump': He recently told business leaders that he's not 'personally' looking for conflict with the president. Hah! A month ago, in advance of the Democratic primary, he was vowing he'd 'spend eight years in Washington' fighting against your agenda. Advertisement No: If you care about the city's future, the man to support is Eric Adams. Adams was one of the few Democrats who stood up to Joe Biden, telling the truth about the massive border crisis. And for that, the previous administration punished him and New York City. Keep up with today's most important news Stay up on the very latest with Evening Update. Thanks for signing up! Enter your email address Please provide a valid email address. By clicking above you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Never miss a story. Check out more newsletters Found his footing Advertisement There have been missteps, but Adams has lately found his footing — particularly by finding a great police commissioner in Jessica Tisch. Another positive sign: The Police Academy just graduated its largest class in years. Qualified young folks want to join New York's Finest, confident that they have a commish and mayor who'll have their backs. An Adams re-election would mean that excellent work will continue. Advertisement A Commissioner Tisch won't be there under a Cuomo or Mamdani. We're sure Cuomo's pollsters painted a picture about the former governor's chances, but they were wrong in the primary and they are wrong now. All Cuomo is doing is selfishly splitting the vote, trying to hold on to one last shred of relevancy. Adams is supported in his re-election bid by all of the police unions and all the major black churches. You know New York, Mr. President, and understand that's a remarkable coalition — a perfect start on building a majority in November.
