Walkers to decide if Nehru Park should get air purifiers; activists aren't so sure
The minister said the final decision about installation will be based on the analysis of public response. Sirsa earlier announced plans to set up 150 outdoor air purifiers at Nehru Park, where breathable air is available to people the entire year, especially during the peak winter season.
The survey, which began on Sunday, will continue till Tuesday, after which the feedback of walkers and joggers will be analysed.
"The initiative of installing air purifiers is designed for the people, especially for walkers. Hence, their feedback is crucial in this exercise," said Sirsa. He said if the public disapproves of the idea, they may consider alternative spaces. "We are also exploring busy markets. The plan is to create clean spaces where the air quality is within permissible limits throughout the year, especially during winter months when pollution is high," said Sirsa.
You Can Also Check:
Delhi AQI
|
Weather in Delhi
|
Bank Holidays in Delhi
|
Public Holidays in Delhi
The DPCC has set up a kiosk at Nehru Park, asking the public to fill out a form with a question: "Would you like to have an air purifier in your park?" The question includes four responses: "Yes, any day"; "Yes, when low maintenance and low cost"; "No"; and "I only want trees."
However, experts and some walkers opposed the plan. They said the focus should be on eliminating regional and local sources of pollution. Sunil Dahiya, founder and lead analyst at think tank EnviroCatalysts, said: "While the use of air purifiers at sensitive locations in closed environments such as hospitals can be recommended, using purifiers in open environments is not the scientific approach to reducing air pollution .
"
Green activist Bhavreen Kandhari said Delhi's plan to install 150 outdoor air purifiers in Nehru Park is a troubling repeat of past policy failures. "The Rs 25 crore smog towers at Connaught Place and Anand Vihar were deemed ineffective. DPCC confirmed they reduced PM2.5 levels by just 17% within a limited 100m radius, while costing Rs 15 lakh per month to operate. Scaling such technology across the city would cost over Rs 11 lakh crore, a huge misuse of public funds.
Worse, this project is being trialled in Nehru Park, one of the city's few green lungs, where air quality is already better than surrounding zones. This reflects a fundamental policy disconnect ," said Kandhari.
She added that what Delhi needs is tough enforcement against pollution sources, not cosmetic fixes in isolated green spaces. "Citizens don't need more purifiers in parks. We need cleaner air across the city," she said.
Scoffing at the idea of air purifiers being planned for an open-air place like Nehru Park, a regular walker said, "Forget big air purifiers, water purifiers at Nehru and Lodhi Gardens don't work very often. If anything, only more trees should be planted, wherever possible, across polluted urban areas.... Somehow, only big-ticket spending ideas catch the fancy of the powers that be."
Sirsa had earlier said that the air purifiers can be installed in a small area of just two square feet. Each unit will consume nearly 1,500 electricity units in a month for 24x7 operation. He added that if the technology is feasible, govt will try bring a private player and get the purifiers installed.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Delhi hounded by strays, kids pay price: Girl (6) dies of rabies after dog attack, family alleges official apathy
NEW DELHI: Amidst the rising threat of stray dog attacks in the national capital, the death of a six-year-old girl has reignited the debate on civic apathy and public health failures in Delhi's Pooth Kalan area, near Rohini. Chavi Sharma, the girl who was attacked, was a Class 1 student who had recently started school. On June 30, she was attacked by a rabid stray while on her way to visit her aunt. The dog bit her multiple times, leaving deep wounds on her left leg, arm and palm. You Can Also Check: Delhi AQI | Weather in Delhi | Bank Holidays in Delhi | Public Holidays in Delhi "The dog had been roaming in this area for the last couple of months, attacking passersby and chasing two-wheelers. We had complained to the councillor, to no avail," said Shakuntala, 64, a previous victim of the same dog's attack who rushed to the spot upon hearing the child's screams. Chavi was taken to Ambedkar Hospital, where her anti-rabies treatment began. She received two injections and was scheduled for her third dose on July 28. But on July 24, she developed fever. Doctors at Ambedkar Hospital allegedly dismissed her fever as seasonal flu. As her condition worsened and she had difficulty swallowing water, she was referred from one hospital to another, first to Kalawati Hospital, then Lady Hardinge — which cited the lack of an isolation ward — and from there to Ram Manohar Lohia Hospital, and later to Safdarjung Hospital. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Paras Sector 59 Gurgaon | Luxury Awaits at Paras Floret Paras The Florett Book Now Undo Finally, the family admitted the child to a private hospital at Pitampura on July 25, where Chavi passed away the next day. "It had only been two days since she started attending," said her elder brother Vishal Sharma, 27, staring at her teddy bear on the bed. "Had the dog been removed, my sister wouldn't have lost her life." Chavi was the daughter of Santosh Sharma, and was adopted by Manju and Satish Sharma when she was 3-4 months old, after her mother passed away in 2019. The family has been living in a rented home in Pooth Kalan for the past 25 years. Manju, a homemaker, and Satish, a carpenter, have three other children — Vishal, Akansha and Manish. Chavi's biological father, Santosh, is yet to arrive to bid her farewell. The family has submitted a complaint at Sultanpuri police station, demanding legal action against MCD officials, who they believe failed to act despite repeated complaints about the dog menace.
Hans India
an hour ago
- Hans India
CMRF cheques worth Rs 72 lakh distributed
Kondapi: Social Welfare Minister Dr Dola Sree Bala Veeranjaneya Swamy strongly criticised YSRCP for allegedly spreading 'poison' against the coalition government's welfare initiatives. He distributed Chief Minister's Relief Fund (CMRF) cheques worth Rs 72 lakh to 83 beneficiaries from Kondapi assembly constituency, at his camp office in Turpu Nayudupalem on Sunday. Speaking on the occasion, the minister praised Chief Minister Chandrababu Naidu for saving lives through CMRF assistance and providing healthcare support to the poor through large-scale cheque distributions. He said that the government is doing good work for people, but YSRCP is spewing venom against it. He highlighted the improvements in welfare hostels, noting that the coalition government has spent Rs 143 crore on hostel repairs within a year of coming to power, with 80 per cent of the work completed. The minister criticised the previous YSRCP government for neglecting hostel maintenance and questioned whether former CM Jagan ever considered student welfare during his five-year tenure. He announced plans to provide quality meals with fine rice and cosmetic kits containing 11 items to welfare hostels and Gurukula students. He stated that special medical officers have been appointed in each district for student healthcare, with over 20 students' lives saved through specialised treatment during the last academic year.
Time of India
6 hours ago
- Time of India
Hovering over the toilet? You may be hurting your bladder
New Delhi: Hovering over public toilets to avoid germs may seem hygienic, but doctors warn it can harm your bladder. The half-squat position often adopted by women prevents full bladder emptying, increasing the risk of urine retention, urinary tract infections (UTIs) and long-term pelvic floor issues. "It causes increased bladder pressure and can raise the risk of UTIs, bladder irritation, and even long-term problems," said Dr Nikhil Khattar, associate director, urology, PSRI Hospital. He explained that when this posture is used regularly, it trains the body into a habit of incomplete urination. This affects how the bladder muscles function, and may eventually cause symptoms like frequent urgency, leakage or difficulty emptying the bladder fully. You Can Also Check: Delhi AQI | Weather in Delhi | Bank Holidays in Delhi | Public Holidays in Delhi "Retained urine also provides a good environment for bacteria to grow, which increases the chance of recurrent UTIs and, in some cases, even kidney infections," he said. The risks are similar when people delay urinating for too long, which many do in public places to avoid using unclean restrooms. "Whether you are holding your urine or not sitting properly while passing it, both habits harm the pelvic floor muscles and interfere with normal bladder emptying," Dr Khattar added. Dr Neelam Suri, senior consultant in obstetrics and gynaecology at Indraprastha Apollo Hospitals, said the full squat position — as used with traditional Indian toilets — is much healthier. "In a full squat, the pelvic muscles relax fully, making it easier to empty both the bladder and bowel," she said. "Half-squatting or hovering keeps the muscles tense and doesn't allow proper urination." According to her, many women hover over Western-style toilets out of fear of infection. But the posture itself can do more harm in the long run. "Studies suggest that hovering increases the risk of incomplete urination and pelvic strain, which can lead to chronic issues," she added. Dr Gaurav Garg, senior consultant, urology, Max Smart Hospital, Saket, also said long-term half-squatting can contribute to pelvic floor dysfunction and stress incontinence — where urine leaks out during coughing, sneezing or physical activity. "Many women who come to us with these issues don't realise it's linked to their posture during urination," he said. Doctors also clarified a common myth: simply sitting on a public toilet seat doesn't directly cause UTIs. "UTIs are primarily caused by bacteria like E. coli entering the urethra and multiplying in the urinary tract," said Dr Khattar. "Poor hygiene, improper wiping, touching contaminated surfaces or not washing hands properly are bigger risks. The toilet seat itself is rarely the cause." D r Atul Goswami, director of urology and uro-oncology at Sri Balaji Action Medical Institute, said awareness is key and women should feel empowered to sit properly by using tools like disposable seat covers or toilet seat sanitisers when using public toilets. "Touching the seat is not as dangerous as incomplete urination, which can cause real and lasting harm," he said. Experts stressed the need to educate women about proper toilet habits and break the widespread fear around public toilet seats. "We must spread the message that sitting properly and emptying the bladder fully is essential for good urinary health," said Dr Suri. In a country where access to clean public toilets remains a challenge, doctors say small changes — like carrying hygiene products and choosing to sit instead of hover — can help protect long-term health. What feels like a quick fix may be doing silent damage, and the best choice might just be the one that feels most uncomfortable: sitting down.
