Labour MSP slams Scottish Government over autism support
Mr Johnson, who has ADHD, said it feels as though the Scottish Government "want us to disappear" through their response to the report and what he described as a lack of urgency to act on problems highlighted.
His comments come after Scotland's Autism organisations published a major survey report on Wednesday which found that some individuals are waiting over seven years for an autism diagnosis.
It also found that half of respondents (50.65%) said it was hard or very hard to get a referral for an autism assessment, with just over a fifth (21%) saying they had been refused a referral at some point.
Responding to the report, Mr Johnson said: 'This is a really chilling read.
'When people seek a diagnosis that is normally because of crisis, whether that is family crisis. For young people, school refusal. For adults, that could be relationships or work.
'So through these waits, you are prolonging that crisis. I am very concerned about all of this."
READ MORE:
Mr Johnson also said the focus on privatisation in the report was an important point.
Just over a fifth (21%) of survey respondents had sought a private diagnosis, with long waiting times and the absence of a local adult assessment pathway cited as key factors.
The average cost of a private diagnosis reported was £1,540 with the highest reported cost being £4,500.
A total of 39% of those who had sought a private diagnosis reported that this had caused them financial hardship.
Mr Johnson said: 'You are essentially saying that neurodevelopmental conditions are now not within the scope of the NHS and it is in essence privatising the provision of that healthcare for those people for whom it is an absolutely essential lifeline and that is unacceptable.'
The Scottish Government has since said long waits for support are "unacceptable" and they are "working to improve access to the best possible care".
In his response to the report, newly-appointed Wellbeing Minister Tom Arthur said accusations that the Scottish Government has 'removed' children from CAMHS waiting lists are false.
However, Mr Johnson has since hit back saying that CAMHS specific waiting lists were not referred to in the report as being the place where children were 'removed' from and people have been removed from waiting lists for referral.
"They have been removed.
"CAMHS may not be the right service, but they haven't specified what is the right service," Mr Johnson told The Herald. "Right now it is impossible, either as a matter of policy or a matter of fact, to get an assessment for autism or ADHD as a child or adult.
"Health boards have either stopped taking referrals or have such long waits they might as well have.
'It is Orwellian [from the Government]. To say it is false, just on a strict measurement, it is a fact."
Last month, John Swinney told parliament that assessment referrals would not be accepted without a co-occurring mental health condition.
Mr Johnson believes his own condition and autism have been neglected by the government.
The MSP told The Herald: 'These conditions very often get described as invisible disabilities.
"Right now it feels like the Scottish Government wants us to disappear because I don't see where we are in their plans at all."
He added: 'Alternative pathways for a diagnosis of autism or ADHD have not been created.
'For new referrals like in big parts of Scotland such as Tayside there is not presently a route to an assessment or diagnosis on the NHS and there are other parts of Scotland where they are not accepting new referrals, such as in Lothian.
'In most of Scotland, the wait time is being measured in decades. I have got constituents who are already on waiting lists who have been told they will be for 17 years.
'That just means it is de facto not available.'
The National Neurodevelopmental Specification for children and young people sets out the standards all children's services should follow to ensure those with neurodevelopmental support needs receive the support they need.
The Scottish Government has said this makes clear that support should be put in place to meet the child or young person's requirements when they need it, rather than be dependent on a formal diagnosis.
However, Mr Johnson argues this does not help those who are unsure about their condition.
The Scottish Labour MSP said: 'The line recently that the government has been using about not needing a diagnosis to access help is again Orwellian.
'You need a diagnosis to know what help you need. You're actually asking people to guess and stumble upon what their condition is.
'It is also wrong.'
The MSP said a broad range of local authority guidelines on additional help access often stipulates a diagnosis is required.
The government's handling of ADHD is also a concern for Mr Johnson.
A Holyrood committee has just launched an inquiry into treatment pathways and support for both ADHD and Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD).
'For ADHD, medication is a key line of therapy," Mr Johnson said, "That's what the NICE guidelines state. You cannot get medication without a diagnosis and currently on the NHS that requires specialist, secondary care diagnosis from a psychiatrist.
'To say you don't need a diagnosis to access help is just factually incorrect.
'By not providing the therapy or assessment, you are going to cause those comorbid mental health conditions. Unassessed autism and ADHD is a massive cause of mental health problems.
'The Scottish Government are wishing away a problem and pretending they are not causing more issues and I worry about what this means for the mental health of our young people in Scotland.'
The Labour MSP said the Scottish Government must recognise the 'crisis' in support and act urgently.
'They need to recognise the crisis. We need a pathway to assessment and diagnosis for those that need it.
'There's an urgency that's lacking here and that's just going to compound the crisis that so many people will be facing.'
The 'Experiences of Autism Assessment and Diagnosis in Scotland' report was undertaken by Autism Rights Group Highland (ARGH), Autistic Mutual Aid Society Edinburgh (AMASE) and Scottish Ethnic Minority Autistics (SEMA) in partnership with Scottish Autism.
These organisations are calling for a nationwide guarantee regarding timely access to assessments, an improved experience for people going through the process, and better provision of post-diagnostic support.
They also want the government to introduce a national neurodevelopmental assessment guarantee, meaning any adult in Scotland can access an assessment pathway should they need to.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
37 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
Ozempic-like fat jabs taken by millions linked to 181 cases of killer side effect and 5 deaths, health officials warn
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) FAT jabs have been linked to hundreds of people falling ill with a life-threatening illness and 10 deaths, the UK's drug watchdog has warned. Brits have reported falling seriously ill with pancreatitis, a condition where the pancreas becomes inflamed, after taking popular weight loss and diabetes drugs. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 1 Fresh figures from the UK's medicines regulator reveal more than 560 suspected cases of the illness linked to so-called GLP-1 drugs, which include Mounjaro, Wegovy and Ozempic. At least ten of these cases were fatal, although it's not clear the drugs were directly to blame. The Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (MHRA) says the reports have triggered a new investigation into whether people's genes could make them more vulnerable to side effects. Since the drugs were approved for use, 181 cases of pancreatitis have been linked to tirzepatide, the active ingredient in Mounjaro, including five deaths. Another 113 cases have been linked to semaglutide, found in Wegovy and Ozempic, with one fatality. Liraglutide, another weight loss jab, has been tied to 116 suspected cases and one death. Exenatide has been linked to 101 cases, including three deaths, while dulaglutide and lixisenatide have been associated with 63 cases in total, with no known fatalities. The MHRA said these are suspected adverse reactions reported by patients, carers or doctors and there is no firm evidence that the jabs directly caused the deaths. Pancreatitis can also develop in people who don't take these drugs, and is often triggered by gallstones or alcohol. However, regulators believe there could be a genetic link in some patients, and are now launching a study to investigate. The Yellow Card Biobank project, set up with Genomics England, is calling on anyone who has been admitted to hospital with pancreatitis while taking a GLP-1 drug to come forward and provide a saliva sample for analysis. Julia Hartley-Brewer slams government plan for NHS to offer free 'fat jabs' to tackle obesity crisis Dr Alison Cave, MHRA's chief safety officer, said: "Evidence shows that almost a third of side effects to medicines could be prevented with the introduction of genetic testing, it is predicted that adverse drug reactions could cost the NHS more than £2.2 billion a year in hospital stays alone. "Information from the Yellow Card Biobank will help us to better predict those most at risk of adverse reactions - enabling patients across the UK to receive the safest medicine for them, based on their genetic makeup. "To help us help you, we're asking anyone who has been hospitalised with acute pancreatitis while taking a GLP-1 medicine to report this to us via our Yellow Card scheme. "Even if you don't meet the criteria for this phase of the Biobank study, information about your reaction to a medication is always extremely valuable in helping to improve patient safety." Pancreatitis is a painful condition that causes severe stomach pain, vomiting and fever. Acute cases usually clear up with fluids and oxygen in hospital, but around five per cent are fatal or cause lasting damage. Despite the risks, experts say the drugs are still safe and effective for most patients. They help control blood sugar, trigger rapid weight loss, and cut the risk of dying from heart disease by around a fifth in people with obesity or type 2 diabetes. Roughly 1.5million people in the UK are now taking GLP-1 drugs, which have been hailed by some as game-changers in the fight against obesity. But health officials warn they are not a silver bullet and can come with side effects, most commonly nausea, constipation and diarrhoea. The MHRA also recently warned that Mounjaro could reduce the effectiveness of the contraceptive pill in some patients. Professor Matt Brown, chief scientific officer of Genomics England, said: "GLP-1 medicines like Ozempic and Wegovy have been making headlines, but like all medicines there can be a risk of serious side effects. "We believe there is real potential to minimise these with many adverse reactions having a genetic cause. "This next step in our partnership with the MHRA will generate data and evidence for safer and more effective treatment through more personalised approaches to prescription, supporting a shift towards an increasingly prevention-focused healthcare system."
The Guardian
2 hours ago
- The Guardian
As an NHS GP, I can now prescribe weight-loss jabs – but a quick fix for obesity is not what we need
A medicine that takes away your appetite by making you feel full and a bit nauseous doesn't sound very attractive, but it is a price many people are ready to pay for the chance to lose weight. Although widely available privately, until this week only doctors in specialist clinics were allowed to prescribe tirzepatide (Mounjaro) to treat obesity on the NHS and it was almost impossible for GPs to get their patients into these clinics. People up and down England will no doubt rejoice at the news that their own doctor can now prescribe it. Any celebrations may be premature, as the criteria for prescription in the first phase of the rollout are so tightly drawn that few patients will qualify. You need a body mass index (BMI) of more than 40, which corresponds to a weight of 102kg (16st) for a woman of average height or 123kg (more than 19st) for a man. (The BMI criterion is slightly lower if you come from a high-risk group.) To be eligible, patients need to be not just at risk of complications from their obesity, but already suffering from them. They must have existing diagnoses of four out of five specific conditions: type 2 diabetes, high blood pressure, abnormal levels of fats in the blood (dyslipidaemia), obstructive sleep apnoea and damage to blood vessels. Individually, all of these conditions are fairly common, and they are more likely if you are obese. However, in our GP practice of 12,500 patients, we have identified only two who meet these criteria. Anticipating a rush of inquiries, we have asked our reception staff to tell patients that we will contact them if they qualify. In the second phase of the rollout, expected next summer, the BMI threshold will be lowered, although as the list of conditions will stay the same, it seems unlikely many more of my patients will qualify. I have some patients who are really stuck with very severe obesity, with a BMI of more than 50, who I think would benefit from this medication, yet I cannot prescribe it as they do not have the specified diagnoses. One of the reasons for the slow pace of the rollout mandated by NHS England is probably a fear of overwhelming GP services. Six hours of training is advised before we start prescribing, and patients should be seen monthly and monitored for adverse effects as the dose is increased, and then every six months. As the criteria relax, and the number of eligible patients expands, this will add up to a lot of extra appointments. Along with the injections, patients should also have 'wraparound care', which will provide diet and exercise advice. We are waiting to hear from our integrated care board about exactly how this will be provided to our patients, but the dietary advice is important. Many people who are obese are nevertheless malnourished as the food they eat is often high in fat and sugar and low in essential nutrients. If, in response to appetite suppression, they eat very much less of the same low-quality food, they may run into significant problems with lack of protein, vitamins and minerals. Dehydration may also be a problem as thirst is reduced as well as hunger. Rapid weight reduction causes loss of bone and muscle mass as well as fat, so exercise is needed to prevent frailty. Tirzepatide is not cheap: at the maximum dose, it costs £122 a patient a month, or £1,464 a year. This could be considered a bargain if you compare it with the cost of treating obesity-related conditions, and we should factor in the improvements in quality of life that achieving a healthy weight will bring. However, there are big questions to answer around how long people should use weight-loss drugs for, and what happens when they stop. Rebound weight gain is almost universal after a period of dieting but it appears to be even more rapid after taking drugs such as tirzepatide; one study has found that patients can expect to return to their original weight within under two years of stopping. This feels inevitable, as much of dieting is learning to change your response to your body's signals of hunger; if you've been taking a drug that abolishes those signals, then when you stop and your appetite returns, you are likely to respond exactly as you did in the past. At a population level, I worry that by concentrating on this technical, pharmaceutical fix to our obesity problem, we are heading down the wrong path. More than a quarter of the adult population in England is obese, and medicating them all in perpetuity surely cannot be the answer. If the government is serious about its much-heralded shift from treatment to prevention, we need bolder and more imaginative plans to tackle obesity. We need restrictions on the availability of calorie-dense, nutritionally poor, fast food. Taxing sugar and fat would be one way of altering the nation's diet, and we should also look at the quality of school meals. Beyond food regulation, we need to buy back school playing fields, offer opportunities to exercise for free, and encourage active transport by making pavements pleasant and cycle routes safe. The current obesity crisis arises from a complex mix of social and commercial determinants of health and these are not problems that can be fixed with a simple injection. Helen Salisbury is a GP in Oxford
Telegraph
2 hours ago
- Telegraph
Poor sleep and no routine – the seven things that make ADHD worse
From forgotten appointments and lost keys to emotional ups and downs, poor sleep and chronic procrastination, living with ADHD can feel like being on a rollercoaster with no end in sight. While these daily struggles are frustrating, they rarely happen in isolation, and many things can make them worse. Research shows that those with ADHD often live with co-occurring mental health conditions such as anxiety and depression, as well as other neurodevelopmental disorders like autism or dyslexia. There's also a higher risk of addiction, which can further intensify symptoms. Medication can be transformative – but it doesn't work for everyone, and the wrong dose can be counterproductive. Yet alongside these more clinical drivers, experts point to a range of lifestyle and environmental triggers that can quietly make ADHD worse: inconsistent routines, poor sleep and diet, digital overload, even hormonal shifts in perimenopause. The good news is some of these are within your control. 'I commonly use this idea of being on and off track. Because ADHD is a disorder of dysregulation, many things can knock you off that track,' says Dr James Kustow, a consultant psychiatrist specialising in ADHD and author of How to Thrive with Adult ADHD. Here's what can make ADHD worse – and what might help. Lack of routine and structure Because of executive dysfunction struggles, routine is especially important for those with ADHD. 'ADHD can feel like you're a ship being blown around because every day is like Groundhog Day. You don't have a great sense of the past or future, so you need things in the present to anchor you, to make you feel safe and present, to stabilise the ship,' says Dr Kustow. Prioritising and decision making are often difficult, so without any external structure, there is a danger of drift or not being productive or efficient. 'Then you might miss deadlines, or not pay your bills, and suddenly you're in firefighting mode and all sense of balance goes out of the window,' says Dr Kustow. What to do: Build in consistency to your week with anchor points like a regular hobby, work periods or exercise class, with some flexibility for variation and novelty. Make sure there are fixed, scheduled activities (EG: 'Monday is yoga night, 'take pills after brushing teeth') and habits that repeat on a rolling basis. Plan out your days into blocks, making sure to allow time for meals and meal prep, morning and evening routines, work, social time and downtime. Poor sleep Struggling with sleep is a bit of a hallmark of ADHD, and one of the 'signs we look for in assessments,' says Dr Fleur-Michelle Coiffat, a consultant clinical psychologist who specialises in neurodiversity. ADHD-ers often have disrupted circadian rhythms, struggling to get to sleep or waking at odd hours. Poor sleep also worsens ADHD symptoms like focus, anxiety and impulsivity. ADHD is often called a 'dopamine disorder'. Lower levels of this neurotransmitter drive people to seek stimulation, like scrolling social media or watching TV late, which keeps the mind switched on. What to do: Dr Coiffat recommends a pre-sleep routine to relax the mind and body. 'Put down your devices, dim the lighting, and do calm activities like a bath, reading or gentle stretches.' She also suggests exercise to counter restlessness. 'If you don't burn off energy during the day, it can make you restless at night – including hyperactivity of the mind,' she adds. Journaling can help. 'Get your thoughts down on paper, but limit it to 10 minutes, so you don't start to get anxious,' she says. Meditation may also help quieten and slow down the mind. A negative mindset From comments like 'you're lazy', 'disorganised' and 'unmotivated', people with ADHD have often had a lifetime of absorbing negative messages and as a result often struggle with shame and lack of self-confidence. 'This can lead to withdrawal, people might think nobody likes them, or they'll say the wrong thing, or that they don't fit in or can't manage a task. But social interaction with trusted friends, family and colleagues can help with these negative thoughts,' says Dr Coiffat. Emotional dysregulation is often a key marker of ADHD, and many experts talk about 'rejection sensitivity dysphoria', where people are extremely sensitive to criticism and perceived rejection. What to do: 'Communication is important, it might be as simple as asking someone to adjust how they give feedback, or how they respond to emails,' says Dr Coiffat. Dr Kustow advises nurturing a growth, rather than a fixed, mindset. 'When faced with a setback, think about what you can learn from it, and how adversity makes you stronger. Also, it's important to address the self-esteem challenges of ADHD with support scaffolds – spiritual, social, family and therapeutic,' he adds. Poor diet leading to blood sugar crashes Many ADHD-ers reach for sugar, caffeine and energy drinks as well as processed foods to give them a short-term hit. This can lead to issues like overeating or skipping meals, which is why they have higher rates of obesity and binge-eating disorder. 'Reaching for sugar hits can be addictive, and get you into a vicious cycle. If your blood sugar levels are spiking, that will heighten issues with attention, focus and restlessness. A lot of people with ADHD, and I do this myself, are often so focused on something or using all their brain capacity just to get through the day that they forget to eat, which also leads to a crash,' says Dr Coiffat. What to do: Keep blood sugar consistent by eating regularly and healthily. Try to keep simple snacks like a handful of nuts on hand. Avoid sugar and simple carbohydrates like white flour and rice, and include sufficient protein in every meal, as protein helps stabilise blood sugar. Get 'hits' from other sources like live music, exercise, and cold water swimming. An over-stimulating environment People with ADHD can thrive on a certain degree of novelty and stimulation, as monotonous tasks can cause shutdown, zoning out or restlessness. However, it's a fine balance as chronic stress and anxiety can also intensify ADHD symptoms, leading to potential increased impulsivity, difficulty concentrating, problems with emotional regulation, performance at work and burnout. People can vary quite widely here. Many might struggle with a 9-5, desk-based job in an open plan office with a lot of potential for noise and distractibility. However, for others, the noise and routine could be helpful. 'There can be a struggle to get in for 9am because of their sleep rhythms, then there is the sensory overload of a journey on public transport in rush hour. The monotony of a desk job that involves little interaction can exacerbate physical and mental restlessness,' says Dr Kustow. However, many with ADHD are also on the autistic spectrum. 'I have a patient who loves archiving, because it's just bringing order into things, but that would be extremely boring for someone who doesn't have that combination,' he adds. Social media and excessive screen use are often a problem as ADHD-ers crave stimulation and the dopamine hits of excessive scrolling, but this can also exacerbate problems with concentration. What to do: In the workplace, it's important to limit screen time and schedule regular screen and meal breaks, as well as time to move around and get outside. 'Jobs that involve creativity, project work, variety and problem solving can be more suitable', says Dr Kustow. But take time to understand your individual needs. Toxins and environmental stressors This is an emerging area, but people with ADHD may be more likely to have allergies, autoimmunity and inflammation, says Dr Kustow. 'Some have more sensitive immune systems, with hypermobility, allergies or chronic illness.' He highlights mould. 'If you're in a mouldy home and struggling with brain function, they may be connected. Some evidence is anecdotal, but toxins may trigger inflammation in sensitive individuals,' he adds. What to do: If you are someone with ADHD who suffers from allergies and has poor immunity, it might be worth trying to reduce toxins in the areas that you have control over. You can gradually buy less toxic versions of cleaning products, both for your body and home, makeup, and natural, pesticide-free foods. Hormonal shifts like perimenopause and menopause Hormonal shifts can make ADHD worse, and also 'unmask' previously undiagnosed ADHD. Perimenopausal women are now one of the largest groups seeking diagnosis. 'During perimenopause, oestrogen levels become dysregulated and start going down, which also reduces dopamine. A woman with ADHD in their 40s may notice that their ADHD might worsen, and they might need higher doses of medication or HRT. Then there are the people who never got a diagnosis because they just about managed, but then suddenly it gets worse because of hormonal shifts and their ADHD is unmasked,' says Dr Kustow. What to do: Adjusting ADHD medication can be helpful, as can HRT. Some doctors might prescribe an antidepressant. Does ADHD get worse with age? ADHD is a neurodevelopmental condition, so it doesn't fundamentally change with age, although the way it manifests can evolve as a response to life events and physical changes. Children are more likely to be hyperactive than adults, and adults may have more issues with time management and organisation. 'In a minority, it can improve and resolve, but most will be stable but find that symptoms may get aggravated at different points in life, as demands change over time, including increasing life responsibilities, hormonal shifts, accumulated stress and physical decline. The demands of retirement are quite different from sitting at a desk doing complex calculations, for example, and symptoms may respond accordingly,' explains Dr Kustow. Dr James Kustow is the author of How to Thrive with Adult ADHD: 7 Pillars for Focus, Productivity and Balance. How to Thrive with Adult ADHD by Dr James Kustow is out now. All artwork by Nicholas Stevenson.
