
Could Trump be persuaded to save Palestinians in Gaza?
Most US presidents have stuck with the Israeli government regardless of its atrocities because the political fallout of deviating was too high. Any pressure on Israel would be sure to trigger outrage from Christian evangelicals (Israel's largest group of supporters in the US) and the conservative segment of American Jews represented by the lobbying group Aipac.
Trump is less susceptible to such pressure because there is no major political figure to his right. Israel's supporters can complain, but they have no place to turn.
Trump has already used that latitude to differ from the Israeli prime minister on a range of issues. He lifted sanctions on the interim Syrian authorities when Netanyahu preferred a crippled neighbor. He struck a deal with Houthi forces in Yemen to stop attacking shipping without insisting on an end to attacks on Israel. He authorized direct negotiations with Hamas, which Netanyahu considered anathema, and initially pursued negotiations with Iran while Netanyahu preferred immediate bombing. He visited the Arab Gulf states without stopping in Israel. And he put pressure on Netanyahu twice to agree to temporary ceasefires in Gaza.
In other respects, Trump has supported the Netanyahu government. He authorized renewed delivery of the 2,000-pound bombs that Joe Biden had suspended because Israel was using them to decimate Palestinian neighborhoods. He vetoed a UN security council call for an unconditional ceasefire. He imposed sanctions on the international criminal court (ICC) prosecutor for charging Netanyahu and former defense minister Yoav Gallant with the war crime of starving and depriving Palestinian civilians. He also sanctioned two ICC judges for affirming the charges, and a UN special rapporteur for accurately reporting on and denouncing Israel's genocide.
But Netanyahu could find it perilous to count on Trump. Despite the periodic shows of mutual support, there seems to be no love lost between the two men. Moreover, Trump's mood changes with the weather. He can turn on a dime with barely a blush. His loyalty is foremost to himself. His only lodestar is his political or financial self-interest.
There are plenty of reasons for the transactional Trump to sour on Netanyahu. While Trump bellyaches about the funds spent to defend Ukraine's democracy from Vladimir Putin's invasion, the US government has sent more than $22bn to Israel to sustain its war in Gaza, with no end in sight (more than $300bn since Israel's founding in 1948). Netanyahu seems to treat an open spigot from Washington as an entitlement, but Trump can easily develop an allergy to such enormous expenditures.
Then there is Trump's ego. Netanyahu's pronouncement during his White House visit this month that he had nominated Trump for a Nobel peace prize was cringe-worthy in its pandering, especially from a man whose willingness to relentlessly kill Palestinian civilians as a vehicle to retain power and avoid pending corruption charges is the main obstacle to a ceasefire.
But Trump seems genuinely to want a Nobel peace prize. That won't happen by underwriting the ethnic cleansing of Gaza, which Trump initially proposed and Netanyahu's far-right ministers, who are capable of collapsing his governing coalition, are demanding. Nor will it come from sequestering Palestinians in a 'concentration camp', as former Israeli prime minister Ehud Olmert describes the proposal of the Israeli defense minister, Israel Katz, to confine Palestinians on the ruins of a corner of Gaza.
Trump would deserve accolades for truly ending the conflict and enabling the rebuilding of Gaza. But the conflict is unlikely to truly end, and the Gulf Arab states will be reluctant to pony up the billions needed for reconstruction, for a mere return to the apartheid that Israel has imposed on Palestinians in the occupied territory. A Nobel-worthy end to the conflict would be a Palestinian state living side-by-side with an Israeli one.
Netanyahu has devoted his career to avoiding that possibility. The massive settlement enterprise is designed to preclude it. But because none of the alternatives – mass expulsion, endless apartheid or equal rights in a single state – is morally or politically viable, a Palestinian state is the best option.
It is difficult to imagine Trump pushing for a Palestinian state. He has appointed an ambassador to Israel, Mike Huckabee, whose vision for a state is to put it anywhere but in Palestine. But if Trump's quest for accolades, his bid for the history books, takes priority in his mind, which is entirely possible, we should not discount this turn of events.
Trump turned on Putin last week when he proclaimed: 'We get a lot of bullshit thrown at us by Putin, if you want to know the truth. He's very nice all the time, but it turns out to be meaningless.' That describes Netanyahu to a T.
Why does Trump let Netanyahu keep playing him the way Putin did? How can Trump proclaim himself the Master Negotiator when he can't manage to use his enormous leverage over Netanyahu to get him to stop bombing and starving Palestinian civilians? Is Trump not sophisticated enough to move from real-estate deals to international negotiations?
I'm sure that Trump would hate to be asked these questions. The sycophants around him won't. Others can and should. Trump's fragile ego, his insatiable need for praise, may be the Palestinians' best chance of turning him in a constructive direction.
Kenneth Roth, former executive director of Human Rights Watch (1993-2022), is a visiting professor at Princeton's School of Public and International Affairs. His book, Righting Wrongs: Three Decades on the Front Lines Battling Abusive Governments, was published by Knopf and Allen Lane in February
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Reuters
18 minutes ago
- Reuters
Trump suggests Fed Chair may cut interest rates
WASHINGTON, July 25 (Reuters) - President Donald Trump said on Friday he had a good meeting with Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell and got the impression Powell might be ready to lower interest rates.


Daily Mail
18 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Trump tears into his haters amid new Epstein revelations
Donald Trump is still trying to blame the Jeffrey Epstein files outrage on 'crazy Democrats ' as his base demands answers amid claims of a 'cover-up.' Convinced that his haters are trying to distract from his 'great' first six months back in office, Trump is hoping that his direction to unseal grand jury testimony will be his saving grace among MAGA loyalists who are growing impatient. During his 2024 campaign, Trump vowed transparency on the Epstein files and claimed his administration would release troves of government secrets, including in the child sexual trafficking case. Trump dubbed the entire ordeal a 'con job' and 'scam' as he again tore into the continuation of the saga in a Thursday night Truth Social post. It comes as yet another piece of evidence emerged that may shine additional light on Trump's relationship with Epstein. The New York Times reported that the president called Epstein 'the greatest' in a newly unearthed message he wrote for the disgraced billionaire on a copy of his 1997 book 'Trump: The Art of the Comeback.' The report comes as Trump is grappling with the fallout from a story by the Wall Street Journal claiming that the president signed a birthday note with a drawing of an outline of a naked woman to Epstein in 2003. Epstein's longtime girlfriend and British socialite Ghislaine Maxwell wrote an introductory letter to a leather-bound book of birthday notes, which the Times also published. Trump has fiercely denied ever drawing the picture and sued the Journal for $10 billion for libel claims. Shortly after the WSJ article was published, Trump shot back in a post to Truth Social saying: 'The supposed letter they printed by President Trump to Epstein was a FAKE.' The report claimed that Trump wrote in his birthday note to Epstein: 'May every day be another wonderful secret.' Trump's communications director has a standard statement he appears to be sending to all media who ask about Trump's connection to the Epstein debacle, and dismissing the reports as more 'fake news.' 'The fact is that the President kicked him out of his club for being a creep,' Cheung said in the statement sent to multiple outlets, including the Daily Mail. 'This is nothing more than a continuation of the fake news stories concocted by the Democrats and the liberal media, just like the Obama Russiagate scandal, which President Trump was right about,' he concludes. Trump is now all-in on his direction for the Justice Department to request courts unseal grand jury testimony. 'As things are revealed and, I hope will take place quickly, you will see that it is yet another Democrat con job,' Trump said on Truth Social in relation to the Epstein files. 'Hopefully, the Grand Jury Files will put an end to this hoax,' the president wrote on Truth Social shortly after the NYT piece was published. 'Everyone should see what is there, but people who are innocent should not be hurt.' Trump last week instructed Attorney General Pam Bondi to request the grand jury testimony on the Epstein case amid mounting pressure from his base to release more information. However, his plan is already hitting a snag. The Southern District of Florida this week denied the request for the highly-sensitive materials to be made available. And the Southern District of New York asked Trump's DOJ to respond to a request for more information on why they are seeking the additional court documents. It's very difficult to get grand jury testimony unsealed as it's one of the more highly-protected and secretive pieces of court materials. In a continued effort to make a show of transparency in the case, Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche flew to Florida and met with Maxwell on Thursday to find out what more she knows and can reveal. Maxwell is serving a 20-year prison sentence for her crimes in Epstein's sexual trafficking ring. It's no secret that Trump associated with Epstein in the 1980s and 1990s. His name appears on flight logs for Epstein's private plane – known as the Lolita Express – and his family members are part of the 'black book' of Epstein's contacts. Trump and Epstein ran in similar circles in New York City and Palm Beach decades ago and were oftentimes pictured together or at the same events. CNN unearthed images this month that showed Epstein attended Trump's second wedding to Marla Maples on December 20, 1993 at The Plaza Hotel in New York. The photographs also showed Epstein alongside Trump's young children Ivanka and Eric at the Harley Davidson Cafe opening in New York in 1993.


Scottish Sun
20 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
Major Scots road & bridge CLOSED amid ‘protest' as cops race to scene
'AVOID THE AREA' Major Scots road & bridge CLOSED amid 'protest' as cops race to scene DRIVERS have been warned that a major Scottish road and bridge is closed as a huge protest gets underway. Emergency services raced to the Forth Road Bridge in South Queensferry this afternoon. Advertisement The alarm was raised at around 1.05pm after cops received reports of a protest starting to build. Police are urging motorists to stay clear of the area as they deal with the incident. Officers are currently at the scene and are "engaging" with those involved in the protest. It's currently unclear what sparked the protest. Advertisement However, it comes on the day that President Donald Trump is due to land in Scotland for his four-day visit. The US President is jetting into Glasgow Prestwick Airport on Air Force 1 between 7.20pm and 8.05pm. Another no-fly zone is in place from 7.30pm to 8.50pm between the airport and his Trump Turnberry hotel and golf course. The force released a statement which said: "The Forth Road Bridge is closed due to a protest reported to police around 1.05pm on Friday, 25 July. Advertisement "Officers are in attendance and engaging with those involved. "Please avoid the area." Traffic Scotland has asked motorists to use the Queensferry Crossing while police remain at the scene. Posting on X, formerly known as Twitter, it said: "Users of the Forth Road Bridge are advised to use the Queensferry Crossing at this time due to a police incident" Advertisement West Lothian Council also warned the public that the bridge is closed to anyone travelling "by bus, taxi, motorcycle or by foot". The local authority posted on Facebook: "For anyone who is planning on travelling over the Forth Road Bridge today by bus, taxi, motorcycle or by foot. "The Forth Road Bridge is closed due to a protest reported to police around 1.05pm on Friday, 25 July." More to follow... Advertisement For the latest news on this story keep checking back at The Scottish Sun. is your go to destination for the best celebrity news, football news, real-life stories, jaw-dropping pictures and must-see video. Like us on Facebook at and follow us from our main Twitter account at @TheScottishSun.