'It's painful': NRL fans say same thing as Ray Warren detail laid bare during Origin
Many would prefer to pay up and hear the Fox League commentary crew during games, but State of Origin and the grand final are exclusively on Channel 9. For those who only watch Nine four times a year, it can be a rather grating experience.
Andrew Johns and Cameron Smith usually come in for plenty of criticism, and don't typically try to hide their bias towards NSW and Queensland respectively. On Wednesday night it was no different, with many expressing some brutal opinions about the NRL legends on social media.
There was an awkward moment during the game when lead caller Mat Thompson used the word "superfluous", and Johns didn't appear to know what it meant. 'Err, excuse me? A what?" he replied.
As for Thompson, the play-by-play caller has done a commendable job since the retirement of legendary predecessor Warren. But the general consensus is Channel 9 have never been able to fill the void left by the great man.
Journalist Peter Lang wrote on social media on Wednesday night: "I don't want to be overly critical of Channel 9's State of Origin commentator Mat Thompson last night…but geeze I miss 'Rabs'. Ray Warren was Origin."
However a fan responded: "Be over critical. It's diabolical. Fox Sports need to have the rights. 9 is beyond bad in all aspects." Another wrote: "I thought Matt Thompson was alright. He needs someone in there with him with a bit of energy. Andrew Johns ain't that person."
Another commented: "I watched the game mostly on mute, it's painful…" While a fourth wrote: "It was awful. I have my whinges about Foxtel, but sweet jesus, they are miles ahead of 9."
I watched the game mostly on mute it's painful…
— Dennis Feher (@DrDennisFeher) May 29, 2025
They need to let Fox get rights to showing it live. I watched their coverage for a bit after the game and oh my the quality difference is crazy.
— Oliver (@OliverMulqueen3) May 28, 2025
@NRL You really need to allow @FOXNRL to broadcast the SOO, WSOO & GF at the same time channel 9 does.@NRLonNine are killing the NRL. Tonight's SOO was like watching it in a Library!! The commentary lacklustre and no passion whatsoever!Bring on @FOXNRL please!!!!Please
— MARBROLAY (@marbrolay) May 28, 2025
The commentary is as bad as the game. I miss Ray Warren. #StateofOrigin
— BMC (@BrianMichaelC) May 28, 2025
I get he's passionate, but Joey's bias is insufferable.
— Stephen 😁 (@SJOBrien8906) May 28, 2025
Cameron Smith is certainly not impartial
— 91 03 21 22 23 24 PREMIERS 🐾🏆 (@SnoogThe) May 28, 2025
On Wednesday night, many accused Smith of being too biased towards Queensland, particularly in regard to the controversial sin-binning of Brian To'o for a mid-air challenge on Xavier Coates that officials ruled was a professional foul. And Johns also copped backlash for a bizarre theory he floated about the balls being used.
After Nathan Cleary missed three conversion attempts in a row, Zac Lomax replaced him but also shanked one from close range. Johns said he thought the ball sounded different when being kicked, and suggested it might have had something to do with the sponsorship logos on it.
'Even the sound of the ball when they were kicking it just sounded different," the NRL Immortal said. 'Mitchell Moses kicked one in the in-goal, he never gets that wrong. Sometimes they are a little bit fatter, maybe the graphics on the ball whether that changes it. Zac Lomax, he missed it by a mile.'
RELATED:
Craig Bellamy's Origin move that could come back to haunt Storm coach
Trainer at centre of Origin incident unmasked as NRL great's brother
Johns even put his theory to Nathan Cleary after the game. But Cleary said: 'The last one I kicked it was definitely just an F-up. But I don't know, I think I'll reflect on that and I think there was just a bit going on in my brain.
'I had so many things I wanted to do. But I've thought about being back in this arena so often and so many things I wanted to do. Sometimes you just need to calm down a bit and just go through the processes.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
5 hours ago
- Yahoo
Bulldogs' Hayward switch could be best in 15 years
No NRL premier has made such a big and late tactical change at hooker in 15 seasons but Canterbury players insist Bailey Hayward's promotion to No.9 can help the Bulldogs become even better. With five rounds before finals, Hayward started as an NRL rake for the first time in Canterbury's defeat of the Warriors and retains his spot for Friday's clash with the Sydney Roosters. It's left North Queensland-bound Reed Mahoney, starting dummy-half in a grand final three years ago, consigned to a bench spot as the third-placed Dogs eye a first premiership since 2004. "Respectfully, there probably wasn't a spot for (Hayward) in the 17 at the start of the year and he's just forced his way into the team every week," said Bulldogs prop Max King. "Now he's forced himself inside that 13, in the No.9. It's a credit to himself and how he's going." The footwork from Hayward 🕺 #NRLBulldogsRoosters Telstra Moment of the Match. — NRL (@NRL) May 16, 2025 Hayward's breakout season notwithstanding, it is rare for premiership-winning teams to make such a dramatic shift in the crucial position so late in a campaign. The most recent example of a team tinkering with its starting hooker this late in a premiership run was in 2022, when Penrith's Mitch Kenny began to start ahead of Api Koroisau. But that change was nowhere near as seismic as the Hayward move, with Koroisau always swapped to the bench on game day and still playing the majority of each game at hooker. South Sydney memorably thrust Koroisau into starting hooker when Issac Luke was suspended for the 2014 grand final, while rookie Sam Verrills replaced the injured Jake Friend with seven regular-season games to play in 2019. But it's not since 2010 that a side has made as big a tactical move at hooker this late in the season and gone on to win the premiership. That year, St George Illawarra coach Wayne Bennett began deploying Dean Young at the expense of dual premiership-winner Luke Priddis, who only started again when stars were rested before finals. Coincidentally, Bennett began the tactical change with five games before finals - the exact same time of the season as Canterbury have begun starting the newly re-signed Hayward. But Hayward's teammates are confident the late change can take the Bulldogs to new heights. "Bailey's biggest attribute is his communication and the way he works with teammates," King said. "He makes us all better. Everyone speaks about the greatest compliment you can get is (being) a player that players want to play with. He fits into that mould. "He makes us a better team." Canterbury retooled their attack ahead of their season's best performance, a 42-4 walloping of Manly three weeks ago, and Hayward has been tipped to continue their ascent in that area. "(Hayward at hooker) is obviously going to add that value to us in attack. We're obviously building on that each week but he'll bring a dimension to that as well," said five-eighth Matt Burton. "He's been great for us all year." Mahoney played 16-and-a-half minutes from the bench on Saturday, only coming on once the result was sealed. "(The change) is not really a discredit to him, it's just more of a credit to Bailey and how he's been performing. It's a tough position for Reed but I feel like he's handled it really well," King said.
Yahoo
7 hours ago
- Yahoo
Swans champion flags full-time switch in NRL after leaving AFL club after 15 years
Sydney Swans champion Nick Davis has hinted at making a full-time switch to NRL coaching after announcing his departure from the AFL club after 15 years. Davis is a Swans cult hero after winning the AFL flag with Sydney in 2005. He famously kicked four-straight goals in the final quarter as the Swans beat Geelong in an iconic semi-final that year, before their win over West Coast in the decider. Since retiring in 2008 he's held numerous coaching roles at the Swans (starting in 2010), and was previously a runner for the AFL club. He's been a specialist skills coach for the men's team, and also helped the women's team as an assistant. But with Dean Cox entrenched as the men's head coach and Scott Gowans leading the women's team, Davis feels his time at the club has run it's course. "After 15 years coaching at the Sydney Swans, I've made the call to move on," he wrote on social media this week. "I've coached across every level and am proud to have helped build culture, set the standard, and bring success to the club. I'm excited and looking forward to what's next……..Thanks for the memories." Nick Davis could make full-time switch to NRL coaching Elaborating on SEN radio on Wednesday, the 45-year-old flagged a potential full-time switch to the NRL. Davis has worked as a kicking and catching coach at the Sydney Roosters for a number of years, and also played for the club at the defunct NRL Nines event in 2020. He also works with the NSW Waratahs women's team in the SuperW. "It's been something that's been building up since the start of this year," he said. "I've had a variety of roles at the Swans and I've probably just hit my head on the ceiling a little bit. There was probably only two spots to go into, but obviously Coxy is the coach of the men's and Scotty Gowans is the coach of the women's. "The club have always been really good to me in terms of some of the other roles I have with other codes. At the start of the year I took some time off to sort of work out what I wanted to do with the next part of life and coaching. It's an opportunity to expand some of my other roles that I do across some of the other codes." RELATED: Ross Lyon's eye-opening claim about Harley Reid amid Saints bombshell AFL world rocked after Ben Cousins goes public with awful revelation Davis didn't go into detail about what the future might hold, but hinted at taking on a larger role with the Roosters in the NRL. He's had a part-time role with the TriColours for a number of years, but could be set for a more permanent code switch. "Having some time off from the Swans has allowed me to up my time at the Roosters and have a bit of success there in a few areas over the last month," he said. "My biggest job today is putting up some bombs for Ted (James Tedesco). There's a few conversations going on and I'm definitely excited to expand some of the roles I've been doing at the Roosters." Davis revealed he worked with Hugo Savala in the Sydney Swans' academy before the youngster switched codes and signed with the Roosters. Savala has been a revelation in 2026, with many calling for the Roosters to backflip on their plans to sign Daly Cherry-Evans so Savala can remain in the halves.
Yahoo
8 hours ago
- Yahoo
Panthers' poaching of Canberra player that could see Roosters star sign with Raiders
Penrith's signing of young playmaker Keahn Skipps from Canberra could open the door for Sandon Smith to land at the Raiders. Reports emerged this week that Smith is in talks with the Raiders about joining Ricky Stuart's team, with Canberra suffering a hit to their playmaking stocks in recent times. NRL halfback Jamal Fogarty will join Manly next season on a three-year deal, with young gun Ethan Sanders likely to step into the role. Skipps had emerged as another option to fill Fogarty's boots, and captained Canberra's Jersey Flegg (Under-21) side. But news emerged this week that Skipps had signed a three-year deal to join Ivan Cleary at the Panthers. With Fogarty and Skipps departing, it could explain why the Raiders are going after Smith. Smith has been given permission to leave the Roosters a year early if he can secure a deal with a rival club. The 22-year-old made a bright start to 2025 while playing five-eighth for the Roosters, but lost his spot in first-grade when Sam Walker returned from injury. Walker and Hugo Savala have cemented their spots in the halves for Trent Robinson's side, and the arrival of Daly Cherry-Evans in 2026 will hamper Smith even further. The Roosters also have young gun Toby Rodwell as a future star in the halves, meaning Smith has become surplus to requirements. "He's been in conversations with the Raiders, the Raiders are looking at some depth," Michael Chammas said on Channel 9 this week. "I don't know if it will play out that way, whether or not he wants to go somewhere and start. Options are limited." Newcastle also keen to sign Sandon Smith Smith could be a good option for the Raiders if they don't think Sanders is ready for NRL level. The 21-year-old joined Canberra from the Parramatta Eels this season, and has big raps on him. On Tuesday, veteran journalist Phil Rothfield reported that Newcastle have emerged as a suitor for Smith and have made him a sizeable offer. According to Rothfield, the Knights view Smith as their starting hooker and are keen to give him regular playing time at No.9. The Knights have Dylan Brown arriving in 2026 to partner Fletcher Sharpe in the halves, and Smith would be a handy pick-up to add to a spine that also includes Kalyn Ponga. Smith is from the central coast of NSW, meaning a move to Newcastle would see him get closer to home. Tyson Gamble and Jack Cogger are both on the way out, with Cogger agreeing to re-join Penrith for 2026. RELATED: Storm rocked by Papenhuyzen news as Warriors make Jett Cleary call Ivan Cleary calls for NRL rule change that would disadvantage Storm Keahn Skipps leaves Canberra to join Panthers Meanwhile, Skipps will get valuable tutelage from superstar halfback Nathan Cleary at the Panthers. The youngster's management reportedly asked the Raiders for a release a number of times this year, saying the 19-year-old was homesick. Skipps is originally from the Gold Coast, and Stuart expected him to sign with a Queensland club. But the teenager is moving to Penrith, where he'll back-up the Panthers' gun halves pairing of Cleary and Blaize Talagi.
