N.J. judge allows use of powerful DNA tool in quadruple murder trial
A New Jersey judge ruled that prosecutors can use evidence from a powerful and increasingly common DNA tool in the upcoming trial of a man charged in the 2018 murder of four relatives.
Monmouth County Judge Marc Lemieux agreed with prosecutors that STRmix, which allows forensic analysts to test tiny, complex DNA samples that likely would have been considered unusable a decade ago, had withstood repeated testing and been found reliable.
'STRmix works, and it appears to work very well,' he wrote in a 212-page ruling last week.
Defense lawyers for Paul Caneiro, who is awaiting trial in the murder of his brother and his brother's family, had urged the judge during a weekslong hearing last year to block evidence gathered using STRmix because they said it had not been properly vetted for use in criminal cases.
Caneiro, who was 51 at the time of the killings, has pleaded not guilty to charges of first-degree murder in the slaying of Keith Caneiro, 50; Jennifer Caneiro, 45; and their two children, Jesse, 11, and Sophia, 8.
They were found in their home on Nov. 20, 2018, in Colts Neck, 47 miles south of New York City.
Prosecutors have alleged that Caneiro fatally shot his brother, stabbed his niece and nephew, and shot and stabbed his sister-in-law before he set their home ablaze. He then set his own house on fire in an effort to cover up the crime, authorities have alleged.
Jury selection is expected to start in May.
Prosecutors introduced more than a dozen DNA samples in the case using STRmix, which was developed by scientists in New Zealand and Australia and introduced in the United States roughly a decade ago.
Experts have said the software — which uses statistical modeling to analyze complex samples obtained from something as small as a few cells left on a doorknob — has revolutionized how DNA is analyzed and is now likely used by a majority of forensic labs in the United States.
In one instance in the Caneiro case, DNA analysts were unable to obtain results using traditional methods when analyzing a pair of bloodstained jeans discovered in Paul Caneiro's basement.
But after the lab started using STRmix, the software showed that DNA from the stain was 2.7 septillion times more likely to have come from Paul Caneiro's nephew than someone else, a forensic analyst said during the hearing.
Paul Canerio's defense lawyers had challenged the software, saying it hadn't been proved reliable in the same way that 'safety-critical' systems used in cars and airplanes are. STRmix, they said in a brief, can produce false results that could help wrongfully convict someone.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NBC News
08-05-2025
- NBC News
A fingerprint found on a cigarette pack helped solve a 50-year-old cold case in California
An Ohio man has been charged in the decades-old murder of a California woman after authorities linked him to a fingerprint found on a cigarette pack in the victim's Volkswagen Beetle, officials said. The print belonged to Willie Eugene Sims, 69, and it was discovered in the car of Jeanette Ralston, 24, Santa Clara County Deputy District Attorney Rob Baker said Tuesday in a news release. Ralston appeared to have been strangled and sexually assaulted when her body was found wedged into the VW's back seat on Feb. 1, 1977, near a bar in San Jose, Baker said. DNA found on Ralston's fingernails and on the alleged murder weapon — a shirt used to strangle her — was later found to match Sims, Baker said. Sims is scheduled to be arraigned Thursday in San Jose on one count of murder, Baker said in an email. It was not immediately clear if he has a lawyer to speak on his behalf. He faces a maximum prison sentence of 25 years to life in prison. Baker said investigators had previously sought to identify the print through an FBI database. But those efforts had proved futile, he said. Then, last year, Baker said his office "threw a Hail Mary" and ran the print again after the FBI updated the search algorithm in the fingerprint database. The effort was successful, he said, and produced a "hit" for Sims, who was living in Ashtabula County, northeast of Cleveland. Baker told NBC Bay Area that Ralston's son, who was 6 when his mother was killed, told him that he was thankful for Sims' arrest. "His birthday is coming up," Baker said. "He said this was such a great birthday present." Ralston was found dead after her friends told authorities she left the bar with an unknown man just before midnight on Jan. 31, 1977, Baker said. Her VW was found the next day in the carport area of an apartment complex near the bar. Her killer had tried to burn the vehicle but failed, Baker said. At the time, Sims was a private assigned to what was then an Army base in Monterey County, south of San Francisco, Baker said. In 1978, he was convicted of assault with intent to commit murder and robbery in a Monterey County, California, case that involved another woman, court documents show. Sims was sentenced to four years in prison. Sims left California long before DNA became an essential forensic tool for law enforcement, Baker said, and although his prints were in the FBI's database, it was not until last August when Baker was notified of Sims' identity. ' Forensic genealogy gets all the attention these days,' Baker said. 'But a retired cold case prosecutor from the San Diego DA's Office told me years ago to never underestimate latent print search since the FBI upgraded the algorithm.' Baker also said they relied on a powerful new forensic tool known as STRmix to help develop DNA profiles from crime scene evidence.
NBC News
11-03-2025
- NBC News
N.J. judge allows use of powerful DNA tool in quadruple murder trial
A New Jersey judge ruled that prosecutors can use evidence from a powerful and increasingly common DNA tool in the upcoming trial of a man charged in the 2018 murder of four relatives. Monmouth County Judge Marc Lemieux agreed with prosecutors that STRmix, which allows forensic analysts to test tiny, complex DNA samples that likely would have been considered unusable a decade ago, had withstood repeated testing and been found reliable. 'STRmix works, and it appears to work very well,' he wrote in a 212-page ruling last week. Defense lawyers for Paul Caneiro, who is awaiting trial in the murder of his brother and his brother's family, had urged the judge during a weekslong hearing last year to block evidence gathered using STRmix because they said it had not been properly vetted for use in criminal cases. Caneiro, who was 51 at the time of the killings, has pleaded not guilty to charges of first-degree murder in the slaying of Keith Caneiro, 50; Jennifer Caneiro, 45; and their two children, Jesse, 11, and Sophia, 8. They were found in their home on Nov. 20, 2018, in Colts Neck, 47 miles south of New York City. Prosecutors have alleged that Caneiro fatally shot his brother, stabbed his niece and nephew, and shot and stabbed his sister-in-law before he set their home ablaze. He then set his own house on fire in an effort to cover up the crime, authorities have alleged. Jury selection is expected to start in May. Prosecutors introduced more than a dozen DNA samples in the case using STRmix, which was developed by scientists in New Zealand and Australia and introduced in the United States roughly a decade ago. Experts have said the software — which uses statistical modeling to analyze complex samples obtained from something as small as a few cells left on a doorknob — has revolutionized how DNA is analyzed and is now likely used by a majority of forensic labs in the United States. In one instance in the Caneiro case, DNA analysts were unable to obtain results using traditional methods when analyzing a pair of bloodstained jeans discovered in Paul Caneiro's basement. But after the lab started using STRmix, the software showed that DNA from the stain was 2.7 septillion times more likely to have come from Paul Caneiro's nephew than someone else, a forensic analyst said during the hearing. Paul Canerio's defense lawyers had challenged the software, saying it hadn't been proved reliable in the same way that 'safety-critical' systems used in cars and airplanes are. STRmix, they said in a brief, can produce false results that could help wrongfully convict someone.
NBC News
27-12-2024
- NBC News
Previously unusable DNA sample now evidence in the quadruple murder trial of N.J. uncle
Lawyers for a New Jersey man charged with the brutal murders of four of his relatives are challenging the use of an increasingly common tool that has transformed DNA analysis in dozens of labs across the United States, saying the technique hasn't been properly vetted for use in criminal courts. A weekslong pretrial hearing about STRmix, which allows forensic analysts to test DNA samples that most likely would have been considered unusable a decade ago because they were too complex or small, ended this month in a Monmouth County courtroom in the case of Paul Caneiro, who has denied killing his family in 2018. While Caneiro's defense lawyers and experts have argued that the software hasn't been proved reliable in the same way 'safety-critical' systems used in cars and airplanes are — and that it could produce false results that could help wrongfully convict someone — prosecutors have argued that STRmix has been tested and tried in labs and courts across the country. The 'motivation is to actually test the software well, try and break it if we can, and, if we miss something, just honestly report what has happened,' one of STRmix's developers, John Buckleton, testified last month, according to a transcript. 'I don't want to contribute to an injustice ever,' he added. A judge is expected to weigh in on the matter in February. Regardless of the outcome, said Marc Canellas, a public defender in Maryland who specializes in forensics and has handled cases that involve STRmix, the case highlights the long-standing need for stricter rules in an industry that can have accreditation standards but isn't overseen by a regulatory authority. 'Even if this judge says that STRmix is completely unreliable, another judge in the same courthouse the next day could say that it is reliable,' he said. Brutal deaths and then two house fires Caneiro, who was 51 at the time of the killings, was charged with four counts of first-degree murder and other crimes in the deaths of his brother, Keith Caneiro, 50; Keith's wife, Jennifer Caneiro, 45; and their two children, Jesse, 11, and Sophia, 8. The New Jersey family was found dead at its home on Nov. 20, 2018, in Colts Neck, 47 miles south of New York City. Prosecutors have alleged that Caneiro fatally shot his brother, stabbed his niece and nephew and shot and stabbed his sister-in-law before he set their home on fire. He then set his own house ablaze to destroy evidence and make it appear as if the entire family had been targeted, authorities have alleged. Caneiro has pleaded not guilty. His previous defense team said there was 'absolutely no reason in the world for Paul Caneiro to have committed the crimes he is alleged to have committed. He would never hurt any member of his family.' Jury selection is expected to start in March. Among the evidence cited by prosecutors were more than a dozen DNA samples that analysts processed using STRmix. STRmix's technology promises to help solve what has long been an issue in DNA analysis: The tinier the sample and the more complex it is — if it contained genetic material from multiple people, for instance — the more difficult it has been to properly analyze, said William Thompson, a professor emeritus of criminology, law and society at the University of California, Irvine, who has studied DNA for decades. Probabilistic genotyping Traditional DNA analysis was largely limited to samples that contained genetic material from a couple of people, said Monica Ghannam, a forensic scientist who testified in the Caneiro hearing, according to a local newspaper, the Asbury Park Press. Using STRmix, she testified, analysts can evaluate mixtures with DNA from four people, the newspaper reported. Developed by scientists in New Zealand and Australia, the technology is one of a handful of forensic tools that use 'probabilistic genotyping' to try to remedy that problem, said Jack Ballantyne, a professor of chemistry at the University of Central Florida and associate director of research at the National Center for Forensic Science. The software uses statistical modeling to analyze complex mixtures of genetic material that may have been obtained from something as small as a few human cells left on a doorknob, Thompson said. The makers of the technology say that STRmix can 'de-convolute' such mixtures to identify the genetic profiles of the people who may have left those cells behind, Thompson said, and that the software can estimate how much more likely it would be to find those profiles on the doorknob if the DNA came from a person of interest and not a random person. STRmix is the most widely used software in the United States that claims to do that, Ballantyne said. 'It has revolutionized the ability to analyze complex mixtures,' he said. 'There's no question that the U.S. is moving the DNA community lock, stock and barrel into the probabilistic genotyping arena.' Whether public or private, he added, the majority of labs in the United States that do forensic casework involving DNA most likely use the method. New technology, new results One set of results obtained by the New Jersey State Police DNA lab illustrates the possibility of the technology. A pair of jeans found in Paul Caneiro's basement had a bloodstain on the shin area, and when analysts examined it in 2018 using traditional DNA methods, they found that it contained genetic material from two people, said Christine Schlenker, a forensic scientist in the lab, a transcript of her testimony shows. But the quality of the DNA wasn't good enough to yield a result, Schlenker said. After the lab obtained the software, an analysis using STRmix showed that the blood in the stain appeared to mostly be that of Paul Caneiro's nephew, Jesse, Schlenker said. The DNA was 2.7 septillion times more likely to have come from Jesse than someone else, she said. Monmouth County prosecutors wouldn't comment on STRmix or its uses in the Caneiro case. At the pretrial hearing, prosecutor Nicole Wallace said STRmix has been tested repeatedly and is generally accepted in the scientific community that tracks and evaluates such technology, according to a transcript. And in a brief filed this year, prosecutors said there have been court hearings across the United States evaluating what defense lawyers have argued is 'novel' software. 'The results have been consistent,' the brief says. 'STRmix is not new — it is tried and tested.' But Caneiro's lawyers and software engineers who testified for the defense said that testing hasn't been carried out adequately or independently. Such testing has been key to preventing catastrophic software failures in aviation systems and nuclear weapons, said Canellas, the Maryland public defender, as well as on devices with far less serious stakes. 'We do this type of testing for mobile games and mobile apps, and yet we aren't doing it for the criminal legal system,' he said. 'That, to me, is just appalling.' The world's largest engineering organization, the Institute for Electrical and Electronics Engineers, has previously called on developers of digital forensics tools — including probabilistic genotyping software — to follow its strictest standard for independent verification and validation to avoid 'false imprisonment and the deprivation of people's rights,' the group said in a statement three years ago. That standard, which has been used on nuclear weapons and space exploration probes, requires independent testing at three levels — technical, financial and managerial — and it aims to assess everything from a product's fundamental concept to accurate coding and the likelihood of false results, the statement said. In his closing argument, Caneiro's lawyer, Christopher Godin of the New Jersey Office of the Public Defender, said the people behind STRmix are 'intimately' involved in helping DNA labs set up and test it. Buckleton, the STRmix developer, testified that the people who work on the software assist labs in their validations they assist labs in their validations and offered an analogy: 'If you had a new Pratt & Whitney jet engine for your Boeing aircraft, would you like to be handed the manual and say go for it?' Buckleton, who is principal scientist at the New Zealand Institute of Environmental Science and Research, described the standard from the IEEE, as the engineering organization is known, as 'sensible' and 'desirable' and said STRmix conforms with it. But Canellas, who has a Ph.D. in aerospace engineering and is a member of IEEE, said he has seen not publicly released details corroborating Buckleton's statement. (A manager for STRmix said it wouldn't comment on the matter.) 'Too much ambiguity' Caneiro's lawyers also pointed to several DNA analyses in the case that appeared to violate the labs' internal validation studies, or testing that labs do before they start using the software to establish what samples they can reliably analyze. The samples relied on less DNA than what had been examined in those studies, according to the defense brief, and the labs didn't test for a key part of the samples in the Caneiro case — 'relatedness.' Relatives share genetic markers, the brief says, and interpreting their DNA can be far more challenging. The Caneiro case involves five family members: four victims and one alleged perpetrator. 'There's too much ambiguity,' Godin said in his closing argument. Wallace, the prosecutor, countered that the analysts who examined the Caneiro samples had no difficulty assessing the relatives' DNA and that neither did experts who reviewed them later for the prosecution. Wallace acknowledged that one of the labs analyzed samples that were below what they'd examined in their validation studies, but she pointed to a recent appellate ruling that described that not as a fundamental flaw in the forensics, but as an issue for juries to grapple with. Thompson, of UC Irvine, said that from what he has seen, STRmix works well if it's used under the conditions it has been tested for. But, he said, labs can run into trouble when they analyze complex types of samples that haven't been validated, especially if they're relying on tiny amounts of DNA. 'I've been following the development of DNA technology for over 30 years now,' said Thompson, who wasn't familiar with the Caneiro case. 'There's a long history of people getting enamored of the technology and taking it a little bit too far and not quite understanding what they're doing. And I think that could definitely happen with regard to probabilistic genotyping. Probably it already has happened."
