logo
Neurosurgeon loses High Court claim against McLaren branch over snowmobile crash

Neurosurgeon loses High Court claim against McLaren branch over snowmobile crash

Andrew Cannestra suffered a brain injury when his snowmobile crashed near Ivalo, northern Finland, on February 2 2020 during a four-night 'Pure McLaren Arctic Experience' arranged by McLaren Automotive Events.
Barristers for the 54-year-old Floridian told a trial in London earlier this month that the company was negligent and in breach of contract, including allegations that a safety briefing given by guides for a 'snowmobile safari' was inadequate.
They also claimed that a guide sped off, causing Mr Cannestra to lose sight of him and speed up in an attempt to keep up, which led to him losing control of the snowmobile on a turn, veering off the track into deep snow, and hitting a tree.
The company defended the legal action, with its lawyers saying there was 'no evidence' the briefing did not meet safety standards and that the 'irreducible risk' of the activity was 'reasonably controlled'.
In a ruling on Friday, Mr Justice Ritchie said the safety briefing complied with relevant standards and that the crash was caused by Mr Cannestra's 'accidental throttle use' when entering the turn.
He said: 'It was not caused by 'out of sight' guiding. It was not caused by the claimant going too fast because he was trying to keep up with a disappeared guide.
'It was caused by accidental throttle use by the claimant due to failing to follow the instructions which he had been given about safe operation during a left turn, with the guide well in sight before both turns one and two.'
Neil Block KC, representing Mr Cannestra, told a seven-day trial in London in written submissions that Mr Cannestra and his former partner, Kaitlin Mealor, spent almost £24,000 before flights on the 'couples package', with activities including driving a McLaren car on ice, and optional events such as snowmobiling.
While Mr Cannestra had experience driving supercars, he and Ms Mealor were 'absolute novices' on snowmobiles, Mr Block said.
The barrister said the pair were given a safety briefing by two guides, Arto Pitkanen and Jouni Satta, which lasted 'approximately five minutes', but alleged it was not 'proper and adequate' as it did not include information on track layout or the positions of potential hazards.
Mr Block said the Lynx Xtrim 900 snowmobiles had three modes – eco, standard and sport – with the tour beginning in eco mode, which had a top speed of 40kph.
Shortly after the activity began, Mr Block said the group stopped, and Mr Pitkanen approached Mr Cannestra and changed the mode, which increased its top speed and was 'not appropriate'.
Mr Pitkanen was alleged to have then set off at speeds of up to 60kph, causing Mr Cannestra to lose sight of him and speed up as he 'did not want to be on his own'.
He suffered a 'very significant' brain injury and 'orthopaedic injuries' as a result of the crash, the court was told.
Giving evidence, Mr Cannestra acknowledged he initially told others following the crash that it was his 'error', but said he was 'not thinking clearly' at that time due to his 'traumatic brain injury'.
He said: 'The guides simply did not guide me through the turns.
'That put my life in danger, and this never would have happened to me if that had occurred.'
Matthew Chapman KC, for the company, said in his written submissions that the turn where Mr Cannestra crashed was 'quite safe if negotiated at an appropriate speed', and that Mr Pitkanen changed the snowmobile's mode as Mr Cannestra was 'eager' for this to happen.
He added that Mr Cannestra's speed was 'wholly within his control', and the claim that Mr Pitkanen had driven too far in front 'cannot sensibly succeed'.
In his judgment, Mr Justice Ritchie ruled that Mr Pitkanen 'did not ride at excessive speed' and that the change of the snowmobile's mode did not have 'any proven causative effect on the accident', adding that Mr Cannestra was 'a mature, supercar and jet-ski aficionado, who had ridden confidently and wanted more speed'.
He continued that Mr Cannestra's evidence was 'illogical and contrived' and that a 'fundamental problem' with it was that it was 'contradictory to what he said after the accident'.
He said: 'For a man with substantial experience of driving super cars, with very high intelligence and a clear understanding of the dangers of driving at speed on corners, he based his case on ignoring those dangers and desperately wanting to keep up with a guide.'
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Struggling major carmaker to axe 500 jobs in ‘difficult decision' just 3 months after bombshell merger
Struggling major carmaker to axe 500 jobs in ‘difficult decision' just 3 months after bombshell merger

Scottish Sun

timea minute ago

  • Scottish Sun

Struggling major carmaker to axe 500 jobs in ‘difficult decision' just 3 months after bombshell merger

The merger is hoped to establish the company as a global competitor HIT THE BRAKES Struggling major carmaker to axe 500 jobs in 'difficult decision' just 3 months after bombshell merger Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) A MAJOR carmaker is set to axe up to 500 jobs just three months after a shock merger. Back in April, the merger between a luxury supercar maker and an electric car start-up came as a shock. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 2 McLaren announced its merger with Forseven in April 2025 Credit: AFP The merger between McLaren and Forseven could result in up to 500 job losses as part of a cost reduction process. It comes after several years of financial difficulty for the supercar company. After the pandemic it faced near bankruptcy in 2020, leading to significant restructuring. Sales continued to plummet in 2023, with the merger hoping to restore its financial position. A spokesperson said that they were proposing "a potential workforce reduction of up to 500 roles across the combined organisation". They added: "The realignment of roles and responsibilities is a necessary step in preparing for the coming together of our two businesses and will ensure that our operations are streamlined to enable resilience and success over the long term." The company said they would provide "comprehensive support and guidance to all those affected" while they try to minimise the impact on employees. "Looking ahead, we remain dedicated to expanding our portfolio of luxury vehicles and delivering the exceptional customer experiences that honour the McLaren legacy," the company said. A consultation process with its 2,500 employee workforce is already underway according to The Evening Standard. It reported that roles are expected to be cut in departments like design and engineering, IT, legal and HR. All UK car dealerships will STOP selling 10,000s of iconic brand's used models impacted by lethal airbag flaw Jobs that are duplicated across the two companies are most at risk. The cuts could affect employees at McLaren's main base in Woking, in addition to its Bicester, Leamington and Surrey sites. McLaren merged with Forseven in April to form McLaren Group Holdings, with Forseven CEO Nick Collins leading. While McLaren has a long-standing history as a leader in the supercar market, Forseven is still relatively new. The British start-up includes more than 700 industry professionals who are working to launch a luxury range by 2030. An announcement on the Forseven website reads: "Forseven has merged with McLaren Automotive with one clear vision: to become a world-beating automotive business." Abu Dhabi investment company CYVN Holdings is set to finance the new company. As part of the merger, an estimated 300 roles have been created which could reduce the impact of redundancies. Jassem Mohamed Bu Ataba Al Zaabi, Chairman of CYVN hopes to redefine the high-performance and luxury sectors. In a press release announcing the merger, the company said it hoped to "transform McLaren into a high-performing British automotive business on the global stage." Jassem Al Zaabi said: 'I'm personally committed to making this vision a reality. It isn't just about investing, it is about shaping the future of McLaren as a brand, as a business and its place on the global automotive map. "We want to - and we will - push boundaries and deliver groundbreaking innovations that drive real progress in the sector. 'This is the start of an exciting new era for McLaren as a car brand and an automotive business." In addition to McLaren's Automotive business, he also promised to continue working on McLaren Racing's long-term success. This includes "supporting the team in building on their successes, winning more podiums, and inspiring fans worldwide." They added that more details about the vision and strategy going forward will be announced later this year.

Struggling major carmaker to axe 500 jobs in ‘difficult decision' just 3 months after bombshell merger
Struggling major carmaker to axe 500 jobs in ‘difficult decision' just 3 months after bombshell merger

The Sun

time2 minutes ago

  • The Sun

Struggling major carmaker to axe 500 jobs in ‘difficult decision' just 3 months after bombshell merger

A MAJOR carmaker is set to axe up to 500 jobs just three months after a shock merger. Back in April, the merger between a luxury supercar maker and an electric car start-up came as a shock. The merger between McLaren and Forseven could result in up to 500 job losses as part of a cost reduction process. It comes after several years of financial difficulty for the supercar company. After the pandemic it faced near bankruptcy in 2020, leading to significant restructuring. Sales continued to plummet in 2023, with the merger hoping to restore its financial position. A spokesperson said that they were proposing "a potential workforce reduction of up to 500 roles across the combined organisation". They added: "The realignment of roles and responsibilities is a necessary step in preparing for the coming together of our two businesses and will ensure that our operations are streamlined to enable resilience and success over the long term." The company said they would provide "comprehensive support and guidance to all those affected" while they try to minimise the impact on employees. "Looking ahead, we remain dedicated to expanding our portfolio of luxury vehicles and delivering the exceptional customer experiences that honour the McLaren legacy," the company said. A consultation process with its 2,500 employee workforce is already underway according to The Evening Standard. It reported that roles are expected to be cut in departments like design and engineering, IT, legal and HR. Jobs that are duplicated across the two companies are most at risk. The cuts could affect employees at McLaren's main base in Woking, in addition to its Bicester, Leamington and Surrey sites. McLaren merged with Forseven in April to form McLaren Group Holdings, with Forseven CEO Nick Collins leading. While McLaren has a long-standing history as a leader in the supercar market, Forseven is still relatively new. The British start-up includes more than 700 industry professionals who are working to launch a luxury range by 2030. An announcement on the Forseven website reads: "Forseven has merged with McLaren Automotive with one clear vision: to become a world-beating automotive business." Abu Dhabi investment company CYVN Holdings is set to finance the new company. As part of the merger, an estimated 300 roles have been created which could reduce the impact of redundancies. Jassem Mohamed Bu Ataba Al Zaabi, Chairman of CYVN hopes to redefine the high-performance and luxury sectors. In a press rele a se announcing the merger, the company said it hoped to "transform McLaren into a high-performing British automotive business on the global stage." Jassem Al Zaabi said: 'I'm personally committed to making this vision a reality. It isn't just about investing, it is about shaping the future of McLaren as a brand, as a business and its place on the global automotive map. "We want to - and we will - push boundaries and deliver groundbreaking innovations that drive real progress in the sector. 'This is the start of an exciting new era for McLaren as a car brand and an automotive business." In addition to McLaren's Automotive business, he also promised to continue working on McLaren Racing's long-term success. This includes "supporting the team in building on their successes, winning more podiums, and inspiring fans worldwide." They added that more details about the vision and strategy going forward will be announced later this year. 2

F1's Spa weekend kicks off a new era for Red Bull
F1's Spa weekend kicks off a new era for Red Bull

Reuters

time3 hours ago

  • Reuters

F1's Spa weekend kicks off a new era for Red Bull

SPA-FRANCORCHAMPS, Belgium, July 23 (Reuters) - Formula One's Spa weekend marks a new start for Red Bull and reigning world champion Max Verstappen as the team go racing for the first time without Christian Horner at the helm. The Briton's sudden sacking after a 20-year reign of rare success, including the most dominant of seasons in 2023, has had the sport buzzing for weeks with plenty of questions to be asked in Belgium. A Saturday sprint will be the first race of new boss Laurent Mekies' tenure and the change, and how it affects four-times world champion Verstappen's future, remains the big talking point of the moment. Horner has made no public comment and Red Bull's preview for the 13th round of the 24-race season made no mention of him. "I was back at the factory last week to spend some time in the sim(ulator) with the team and I'm looking forward to working closely with Laurent," Belgian-born Verstappen was quoted as saying. Mekies, promoted from Racing Bulls who have handed over the reins to Alan Permane, arrives with Red Bull fourth overall and Verstappen a distant third in the drivers' standings behind McLaren's Oscar Piastri and Lando Norris. That intra-team title battle is likely to have some extra sizzle at Spa-Francorchamps as Norris seeks a third win in a row -- new territory for the Briton -- and the chance to take over at the top. The sprint format offers more points than usual and Norris, whose mother is Belgian, is only eight behind the Australian going to a high-speed track that is a favourite for most drivers. Piastri, despite his generally unruffled exterior, may also be still simmering at the 10 second penalty that cost him a win in Britain and handed victory to Norris. He will want to hit back as Formula One kicks off a Belgium/Hungary double-header -- the first fast and often wet while the second is twisty and hot -- before the long August break. George Russell, his contract expiring at the end of the season and in danger of losing his Mercedes seat to Verstappen or having him as an uncomfortable teammate, is also not short of motivation. The Briton was stripped of victory last year at Spa when post-race checks found his car to be underweight, handing victory to then-teammate Lewis Hamilton in what remains the seven-times champion's most recent win in F1. Ferrari have yet to triumph, other than a Shanghai sprint, since Hamilton moved from Mercedes to Maranello in January but they are gathering momentum. The Italian team are second overall and Charles Leclerc has secured three podiums in the last five races while Hamilton was fourth at Silverstone. Nico Hulkenberg will also be getting back to business at Sauber after an emotional first podium at the 239th attempt at Silverstone ended his unwanted record of most races without a top three finish. Sauber, the future Audi works team, are on the move and have scored the fourth most points of any outfit on the grid over the last four races.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store