Orissa High Court upholds right to protest, quashes Rayagada DM's order
The June 4 order, which also applied to noted activist Medha Patkar and 22 others, was imposed ahead of a planned protest against proposed bauxite mining at the Sijimali hills.
Delivering the verdict, Justice SK Panigrahi held that blanket bans on protest activities are contrary to constitutional values. 'In a constitutional democracy, the government should focus on dialogue and management rather than exclusion,' the court said, emphasising that reasonable regulation and not prohibition is the appropriate response to concerns over law and order.
The court took note of the context in which the ban was issued - during the Rath Yatra festivities, when police resources were stretched thin. However, it stated that those constraints were temporary and it was no longer justifiable to continue the restrictions.
Dr Sequeira, who has provided free healthcare services to tribal communities in Rayagada and Kalahandi for several years, had challenged the ban as unconstitutional. His counsel, Advocate Afraaz Suhail, argued that the order disrupted essential services and violated his client's fundamental rights.
While lifting the restriction on Dr Sequeira, the court laid down operational guidelines for future protests. These include prior notification to authorities, cooperation from organisers, state facilitation of venue and time, and proportionate restrictions to maintain public order. This apart, protesters must ensure peaceful conduct and authorities must avoid arbitrary denial of protest rights.
The court stressed that these guidelines are case-specific and do not dilute broader constitutional protections under Article 19. Violations by protesters or unjustified restrictions by authorities will both be subject to legal scrutiny, it said.
Dr Sequeira is now free to enter Rayagada district and resume his work. The status of the ban on other activists, including Medha Patkar and Prafulla Samantara, remains unclear as of the judgment by Justice Panigrahi on Friday.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
2 hours ago
- Mint
Get paid to make babies? China offers parents $1,500 in bid to boost births as population ages
Parents in China are being offered around $500 ( ₹ 44,000) a year for each of their children under the age of three. This initiative, announced on Monday, is part of the government's first nationwide subsidy, which is introduced with an objective of reducing the financial burden of raising children and encouraging more births in the world's second-largest economy. Despite scrapping the controversial one-child policy nearly a decade ago, China's birth rate has continued to fall, the BBC reported. The government hopes that these new handouts, which are expected to help around 20 million families with the cost of raising children, will reverse the trend of falling birth rates. Before this nationwide rollout, several provinces across China had already piloted some form of payouts to encourage people to have more children as the country faces a looming demographic crisis. The scheme has promised to offer parents a total of up to $1500 (10,800 yuan) per child, with the benefits being applied retroactively from the start of this year, as per the BBC report. This provision is also open for families with children born between 2022 and 2024; however, they will receive partial subsidies. The move follows efforts by local governments to boost birth rates in China. In March, Hohhot - a city in the northern region of China - started offering residents up to 100,000 yuan per baby for couples with at least three children. Shenyang, a city northeast of Beijing, offers 500 yuan a month to local families with a third child under three. Last week, Beijing also urged local governments to draft plans for implementing free preschool education. The need for such incentives is underscored by the high cost of raising children in China, according to a study by China-based YuWa Population Research Institute. The study found that raising a child to the age of 17 in China costs an average of $75,700, making it one of the most expensive places to have children relative to income. In January, official figures showed that China's population fell for a third consecutive year in 2024, despite a slight increase in birth, which was recorded to be around 9.54 million babies born in 2024, according to the National Bureau of Statistics. The country's 1.4 billion population is also aging fast, adding to Beijing's demographic concerns, the news agency reported.
News18
2 hours ago
- News18
Andhra Pradesh CM Naidu talks business with global firms in Singapore
Singapore, Jul 29 (PTI) Andhra Pradesh Chief Minister N Chandrababu Naidu on Tuesday discussed potential partnerships and investment opportunities with representatives of major industrial companies in Singapore. Naidu met with representatives of Keppel Corporation, Government of Singapore Investment Corporation (GIC) and Wilmar Oleochemicals & Biofuels on the third day of his visit to the city-state. He discussed collaboration on projects in the IT, commerce, and housing sectors in Visakhapatnam during his meeting with Lim Yong Wei, Executive Director of Keppel Corporation, a Singapore-based globally recognised company in the fields of urban development. Naidu also met with the Chief Investment Officer of GIC, Bryan Yeo, and discussed opportunities for investment in Amaravati's development, the real estate and industrial sectors, and infrastructure across the state. He assured that the Andhra government is ready to provide a conducive environment for GIC to invest in sectors like healthcare, education, urban planning, and civic infrastructure. He covered potential investment opportunities in food processing, edible oils, and agri-infrastructure sectors in his meeting with Rahul Kale, Group Head, Wilmar Oleochemicals & Biofuels. Naidu proposed collaboration in food processing to help create a value-based market for farmers. Wilmar expressed interest in providing the necessary technology for this initiative. PTI RD ZH RD RD (This story has not been edited by News18 staff and is published from a syndicated news agency feed - PTI) view comments First Published: July 29, 2025, 19:30 IST Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
India Today
3 hours ago
- India Today
ICE gave Taco Bell's number for urgent help, Indian-origin lawyer alleges
An Indian-origin immigration lawyer in the US has claimed she received Taco Bell's number when she was trying to contact US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) for assistance with her clients. An Ohio-based lawyer, Trisha Chatterjee, said she had been trying to reach ICE for days. After finally getting a response, she was disappointed to find that the number belonged to the fast-food outlet in the Columbus claim was made in a TikTok video and is being shared on other social media platforms too. The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has rejected the claims, saying the allegations are "nothing but lying for likes". The lawyer needed guidance from ICE on ways to submit paperwork for her clients held at Butler County Jail. After days without a response, she finally got through to an ICE officer who said he could give her the phone number of someone who could help, according to an Ohio-based newspaper, The Cincinnati Enquirer."For the very first time, finally somebody answered me, and I was genuinely so excited to have somebody who was going to help us and give us some information," she told The Enquirer."So, to get a Taco Bell phone number instead was definitely disheartening," the news outlet quoted her as FOR LIKES:DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND SECURITY REJECTS CLAIMSThe Department of Homeland Security (DHS) responded strongly to the claims, calling the allegations "nothing but lying for likes" and accusing activists and the media of unfairly attacking ICE officers."This is nothing but lying for likes. Once again, activists and the media are attempting to smear our brave ICE law enforcement, who are already facing an 830% increase in assaults against them. ICE did not give immigration attorney Trisha Chatterjee, the woman in the TikTok video, a phone number to a Taco Bell," DHS said in a statement on Sunday (US time).The DHS said that attempts have been made to reach out to her, but she did not make any attempt to contact ICE."After she posted the video, ICE even attempted to reach out to her to get her information on her clients. She was provided several avenues to directly contact ICE and help resolve any issues, but she has made no attempt to contact the agency," the post further TikTok video went viral on social was trying to file a "stay of removal" request to halt deportation proceedings, according to The wanted to submit a "stay of removal" for some of her clients. This protection prevents the DHS from deporting immigrants who are actively pursuing legal status or humanitarian protection, or are challenging their removal order. Homeland Security accepts or rejects these applications, The Enquirer have a number of people who are detained right now who have cases pending before US Citizenship and Immigration Services, or before the court," the newspaper quoted Chatterjee as saying. "They've got immigration proceedings already pending," she of removal requests must be submitted in person at the regional ICE field office – in this case, located in Detroit for Ohio cases. Based in Greater Cincinnati, Chatterjee had hoped to find an alternative way to said she called and e-mailed ICE and the Detroit field office asking if she could instead submit these applications at a closer ICE office in Blue Ash but got no response, according to the received another ICE contact number from Butler County Jail, which she noted had previously connected her with responsive ICE agent who picked up the phone gave her another number to call, Chatterjee said. That number allegedly went to a Taco Bell in Columbus."I called and they answered and they said, 'Hello, Taco Bell?' And I said, 'Taco Bell?' And the guy who was working said, 'Yeah, Taco Bell. Ma'am, you called me," Chatterjee recalled, The Enquirer was in such disbelief," she said. "So, I called the ICE officer back, just really frustrated with what had just happened. He says, 'Oh, I'm sorry. I was trying to lighten the mood and make you laugh," according to The IS TRISHA CHATTERJEE?Trisha Chatterjee, an immigration lawyer of Indian origin, practices in Greater Cincinnati and Dayton, graduated from Miami University in 2020 and earned her law degree from the University of Dayton in 2023, according to her LinkdIn to The Enquirer, Chatterjee works for the Law Office of Emily Feliz Garcia, Ohio, a small firm based in Springdale. Before that, she worked for Abdallah Law Offices in West Chester.- Ends
