Judge rejects Nelson man's emergency excuse for driving while drunk for the seventh time
Gregory Robinson has now logged his seventh conviction for driving while over the alcohol limit.
Photo:
Creative commons
A man tried arguing a family emergency was the reason he chose to drunk drive, but a judge was not buying it.
Gregory Robinson has now logged his seventh conviction for driving while over the alcohol limit, and despite his efforts to avoid being disqualified, he's now off the road for a year and serving a sentence of community detention.
Robinson was at dinner with friends on a Saturday night in July last year when he got a message about a "family emergency".
His former partner said she needed to get her daughter to the hospital and she would be dropping Robinson's son at his house.
Robinson had already drunk some Bourbon pre-mix drinks but thought he would be okay to drive.
He was stopped by the police for speeding on SH60 on his way to Richmond, near Nelson. A breath test showed him with 502 microgrammes (mcg) of alcohol per litre of breath.
The legal limit for drivers aged 20 and over is 250mcg, and infringement notices are issued for readings under 400mcg.
He later admitted a charge of driving with excess breath alcohol on a third or subsequent time.
Robinson has six previous drink-drive convictions dating back to 1980. His most recent was in 2016.
The self-employed builder tried arguing his reason this time was good enough to prevent him from being disqualified from driving.
But Judge Tony Snell said during last week's sentencing in the Nelson District Court he had plenty of options to get home.
Rather than get behind the wheel himself, he could have taken a taxi or asked a friend to drive him home.
Judge Snell said Robinson's view that he felt he was under the limit at the time was speculation, and he was not responding to a genuine emergency when he decided to drive.
"Your choice to drive may have been motivated by your need to get home, but it was a poor decision.
"It was made by you, thinking you were under the limit, rather than any emergency to get home."
He declined Robinson's application to avoid mandatory disqualification.
Judge Snell also noted Robinson's 39 previous convictions for a "wide range" of offences, from driving to violence, drugs, and dishonesty, and this time, the offending was aggravated by his driving over the speed limit.
The judge noted Robinson, who worked in a physical role as a builder, claimed he was unable to do community work for health reasons.
Robinson was given credit for the "modest" breath alcohol reading and his early guilty plea.
He was sentenced to six months of supervision, with three months of community detention, which was imposed with an 8pm to 6am curfew.
Robinson was also disqualified from driving for a year.
- This story originally appeared in the
New Zealand Herald.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
2 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Police to re-examine murder of 6-year-old, 45 years on
Alicia O'Reilly was murdered in 1980, when she was just six years old. Photo: Supplied/New Zealand Herald Police have announced they are continuing to examine new evidence and to use a forensic tool in the hopes of solving the murder of six-year-old Alicia O'Reilly, who was killed in Auckland 45 years ago. A police statement on Saturday said O'Reilly was raped and was killed at her Canal Road home in the suburb of Avondale, early on 16 August 1980. At this stage nobody has been convicted for her death. O'Reilly's case was reopened in 2020 and the investigation dubbed Operation Sturbridge. In a statement, Detective Inspector Scott Beard said on Saturday that a DNA sample had been obtained which police hope could provide leads. Police are also working with a new technology, trailing an Investigative Genetic Genealogy tool, he said. "This is a slow process, and we are working carefully through this trial. "Modern scientific technology continues to advance, and we are working very closely with PHF Science to try and establish a DNA link to a potential offender." Experts from the Behavioural Science Unit are also contributing to the investigation, Beard said. "Part of the investigation is looking at reviewing every person who was considered a person of interest back in 1980, whether they were eliminated or not - even those who may have passed away." Beard said police still had hope the investigation would yield answers and a resolution. "We would dearly like to give Alicia's family the answers they so deeply deserve after all this time," he said. "My thoughts are with them today especially ... They continue to suffer from not knowing who is responsible for this crime." He urged anyone with knowledge about what happened to come forward: "Even after all these years, if there is someone out there who has any knowledge as to who was involved ... Police want to hear from you - it's not too late."
NZ Herald
2 days ago
- NZ Herald
Auckland teacher who abused, photographed girls, had prior indecent act convictions
But the Thursday afternoon sentencing at Manukau District Court wasn't the first time Fisher had been before the courts for committing indecencies. A court document obtained by the Herald reveals that in 2002 he was convicted of three counts of committing an indecent act. Despite these convictions, it appears he was able to pass background checks and gain employment at various schools and teaching providers. It is unclear if his convictions were subject to the Clean Slate scheme. EduExperts, the Crimson-'powered', after-school tutoring brand that Fisher worked under, said it was shocked by the revelations and undertaking an urgent investigation. In a statement provided by a public relations representative, the company said Fisher was a contracted teacher at an independently-owned franchisee with a licence to operate under the EduExperts brand. 'Our understanding is that the contracted teacher had been working at [the independent franchisee] since 2019 and his contract was terminated once police commenced an investigation into his conduct. Timothy Fisher pleaded guilty to 14 charges and was sent to prison after sentencing this week in Manukau District Court. Photo / Sylvie Whinray 'As a nationwide and trusted education provider, EduExperts is disappointed by this case and expresses its sympathy to those impacted by the contracted teacher's conduct. The safety and wellbeing of students is our top priority.' The statement said Fisher held a current practising certificate and the independent franchisee had received a positive reference letter from a school where he formerly worked. Franchisees were required to follow strict recruitment processes, including only hiring registered teachers with current practising certificates from the Teaching Council. Any teacher applying for or renewing their practising certificate was required to undergo a police vet, the statement said. 'EduExperts is conducting its own investigation into this case and working with [the franchisee] to review this in detail. Any further questions relating to the case should be directed to police.' 'You see the face but not the heart' The independent franchise owner, who the Herald cannot name for legal reasons, said she was devastated to learn of Fisher's offending and her heart went out to the victims. She said she bought the franchise in 2019. The previous owners told her Fisher held a current teaching licence, provided the school reference letter and 'said they did all the checks'. She was stunned to learn yesterday that Fisher had previous convictions and that some of the offending had happened at the company's premises. 'We feel shock and sorrow. We trust our teachers ... and try our best to keep an eye on everybody.' She said her company had security cameras and had passed all the footage to police. It had co-operated fully since learning Fisher was under investigation last year and immediately dismissed him as a teacher when alerted. She said Fisher was a 'very good' teacher. Learning he was a child sex offender was difficult to comprehend. 'You see the face but not the heart.' Sexual predator 'knows he does have a problem' At the Thursday hearing, Judge Sacha Nepe sentenced Fisher to four years and five months' imprisonment on 14 charges, which included committing indecent acts on children and making objectionable material. She gave him a 25% discount for his guilty plea, 10% for childhood issues raised in his psychiatric report and 5% for the counselling he had undertaken. Judge Sacha Nepe (right) being sworn in as a new judge by Gisborne Judge Hemi Taumanu in May this year. His lawyer, Tim Blackwell, said Fisher 'knows he does have a problem'. Blackwell sought a discount for remorse and told the court some of his client's comments to report writers had been taken out of context. Prosecutor Kristy Li said Fisher told a report writer he did not feel remorseful because he felt the victims were not 'traumatised' by his offending. Judge Nepe sided with Li: 'I am not prepared, Mr Fisher, to give a discount for remorse. I have looked at the material before me… In my view there was an almost justification for the behaviour.' She uplifted his sentence by two months for his prior offending. A place on the sex offender register was automatic. Details of abuse laid out in court A summary of facts says Fisher taught English at two of the franchisee's branches. The youngest victim was 9 and the oldest 14. Almost all of the indecent offending listed on the document occurred at one campus, with the physical offending occurring in February 2024. Fisher indecently abused the young girls in various ways, including touching their buttocks, lower backs, chest, thigh and groin area over clothing. Timothy Fisher was sentenced to four years and five months' imprisonment after pleading guilty to 14 charges. Photo / Sylvie Whinray He tried to photograph one child's groin area and legs from under her desk while she did schoolwork in an undisclosed location. Eight of the nine victims were offended against physically. Judge Nepe said some of the videos Fisher created were made at an unnamed high school he had worked at. On one occasion, Fisher filmed himself masturbating in an undisclosed location next to two female students who were blindfolded and not aware of his actions. Other footage he captured showed unknown prepubescent girls swimming in a public pool while he pleasured himself from inside a sauna. Another video depicted him recording himself masturbating in a classroom at the high school while nearby students were unaware. In a different clip, he filmed himself masturbating with a child on his lap. He also was found in possession of objectionable material, including of adults abusing children. When spoken to by police, he denied indecently assaulting the students but stated he had 'crossed a line' with the girls and 'got too comfortable'. For his most recent offending, Fisher was charged with seven representative counts of committing an indecent act on a child. Each carries a maximum of 10 years' imprisonment. A representative charge means the offending occurred more than once. Police also laid four attempted intimate visual recording charges and one representative indecent act on a young person charge. In addition, Fisher faced a representative charge for possessing objectionable publications and another representative charge for making an objectionable publication. The maximum term for these charges is 10 and 14 years' imprisonment respectively. Detective Senior Sergeant Martin Bienvenu, Counties Manukau CIB, acknowledged the courage of the young people who came forward to report the offending. Asked if Fisher had been subject to the Clean Slate scheme, Bienvenu said he couldn't comment and referred queries to the Ministry of Justice. A Justice Ministry spokeswoman said convictions were automatically concealed under the scheme if the person was eligible. However, the scheme did not extend to people applying for certain jobs or roles. She said the Children's Act required safety checks for people working with children and the Clean Slate Act did not apply to those safety checks. Katie Harris is an Auckland-based journalist who covers issues such as sexual assault, workplace misconduct, media, crime and justice. She joined the Herald in 2020. Lane Nichols is Auckland desk editor for the New Zealand Herald with more than 20 years' experience in the industry. Sign up to The Daily H, a free newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Otago Daily Times
2 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Family pay tribute to Bay of Plenty stabbing victim
Police at the scene at Awakeri Hot Springs on Thursday. Photo: Pūkāea A cousin of a woman fatally stabbed in the Bay of Plenty on Thursday says she was a loving mother, daughter, niece, cousin, aunty and friend. Emergency services were called to Awakeri Hot Springs Holiday Park around 4.30pm on Thursday after reports of a serious assault. Despite medical attention, an injured woman died at the scene and a 25-year-old woman was charged with murder. "You were a strong hardworking lady that done everything to provide the best for your babies. You stood staunch for your family would do anything to make sure we were all good. One of the loyalest (sic) family members i ever knew. Rest in eternal love now my cuzin your with your dad, sister and all our loved ones. Forever in our hearts," said the victim's cousin in a statement provided to RNZ. Police remained at the holiday park this morning, and the hot pools part of the facility is closed. Campers remain in the campsite. The executive producer of iwi news provider Pūkāea, Kereama Wright, said local kaumātua led a karakia at the holiday park this morning. He spoke to relations of the Māori landowners who said they were very upset by yesterday's events. "For a long time Awakeri hot pools has been a place for whānau to gather for celebrations, for whānau gatherings, for a little bit of reprieve, so to hear this sort of news happening at such a popular site within the region is sad and speaking to some of the people who are camping there, they are definitely shocked and quite disturbed by what happened," he said. Wright had interviewed campers this morning and said he understood both the victim and the accused had been staying at the campground recently. "We spoke to a couple of the campers who were present when the incident occurred yesterday and they were visibly shaken and still very upset at what they saw and what they experienced," he said. The 25-year-old accused appeared in Whakatane District Court this morning charged with murder and was remanded in custody to reappear in early September.
