Hong Kong judges, Jimmy Lai's lawyers lock horns over ‘armchair punditry'
Advertisement
Lai's lawyers and the three presiding judges hearing his
national security trial found themselves entangled in a recurring debate on the interpretation of allegedly incriminating remarks made by the outspoken Beijing critic, as the defence pressed on with its closing speech at West Kowloon Court on Thursday.
Defence lawyer Robert Pang Yiu-hung SC argued that the court could not conclude that Lai, 77, must have sought foreign interference through sharp criticisms made after the national security law's implementation in June 2020.
He noted that some of those comments, which covered Beijing's '
wolf-warrior ' style of diplomacy and US
embargoes on hi-tech exports to mainland China, could have been made by anyone in a local restaurant 'over a dim sum table'.
'If you take it neutrally, he's concerned with human rights, he's being careful with his words. How can then you draw the inference, not that he was just requesting sanctions, but he was also part of a conspiracy to do so?' Pang said.
Jimmy Lai's national security trial is reaching its conclusion. Photo: AFP
That contention did not appear to convince the three High Court judges, who warned against examining selected pieces of evidence in isolation.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South China Morning Post
35 minutes ago
- South China Morning Post
Scammers exploiting rental platforms in Hong Kong amid rise in investment fraud
Online rental platforms have become scammers' latest tool for swindling Hong Kong residents, as the number of online investment fraud cases rose by nearly a quarter in the first six months of 2025 compared with the same period last year, with losses surging 36.4 per cent to HK$1.48 billion (US$189.5 million). Police Senior Superintendent Carmen Leung Oi-lam said that online rental platforms were a new channel that scammers were recently exploiting to establish contact with victims. 'When some property owners put their flats on online rental platforms, scammers will target them, posing as high-income potential tenants,' Leung warned. The force recorded 2,273 investment scams from January to June, a 24.8 per cent rise from 1,822 cases in the same period last year. Losses in the first half of the year reached HK$1.48 billion, 36.4 per cent higher than the HK$1.09 billion recorded in the same period in 2024. The biggest investment scam involved a 65-year-old retiree who lost more than HK$30 million in April after joining a stock investment group on WhatsApp via a Facebook page.
South China Morning Post
an hour ago
- South China Morning Post
Hong Kong's anti-corruption credentials on display in handling of fraud case
Corruption comes in many forms. Those involved in such crimes seem to have limitless imagination when it comes to taking advantage of others. So it was encouraging to see Hong Kong's anti-corruption agency arrest a group including healthcare professionals for allegedly taking millions in subsidies earmarked for the city's elderly. The Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC) said a registered nurse and an occupational therapist were among five people arrested in July after an investigation sparked by a complaint last year from the Social Welfare Department. The case involved the Community Care Service Voucher Scheme for the Elderly. Matthew Chang Chor-ming, principal investigator in the ICAC operations department, said the group defrauded the government by 'exploiting residents who were unfamiliar with the scheme or manipulating their greed'. The three women and two men allegedly collected the funds through fake visit records and shared the money with the residents' family members. Three of them worked at a private care agency established by the nurse. All five are out on bail. The fraud revolved around government vouchers the elderly can use to directly purchase services ranging from day care to at-home support. As of August, 12,000 elderly people were using the vouchers and 319 recognised service operators were under the scheme. The care agencies served 20 to 200 elderly residents per month and took in about HK$18 million (US$2.3 million) in subsidies. Chang said the case was complex because the two agencies mixed genuine services with fraudulent ones. It is good that the Social Welfare Department has promised to step up checks of service provider records and to interview suspected victims and their families. Vigilance will also be needed in areas on the mainland where the scheme is in use. It was expanded early last year so Hongkongers could use vouchers in the Greater Bay Area The case also underscores the ICAC's effectiveness. Set up in 1974, the agency has earned an international reputation for helping make Hong Kong one of the least corrupt places in the world. All in the city should applaud its recent work to protect resources needed by some of Hong Kong's most vulnerable residents.
South China Morning Post
2 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
Trump and Canada PM Carney talk about trade, agree to speak again soon
US President Donald Trump and Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney had a 'wide-ranging conversation' on Thursday that included trade and the war in Ukraine, according to Carney's office. The two leaders talked about 'trade challenges, opportunities, and shared priorities in a new economic and security relationship between Canada and the US', according to the statement. They also discussed 'how to build on the president's leadership to support long-term peace and security for Ukraine and Europe'. Carney initiated the call, according to a government official who spoke on condition they were not named. The two leaders agreed to speak again soon. A Trump administration official acknowledged the call took place and said the leaders discussed trade, without disclosing further details. 04:27 Trump meets new Canadian PM, who tells him Canada is not for sale Trump meets new Canadian PM, who tells him Canada is not for sale It is the first time Carney or Trump has publicly acknowledged a conversation since Trump raised US tariffs on Canadian goods at the beginning of August.
