Debating the pope's denunciation of war
Jacoby omits any mention of the pope's reference to the people of Gaza, where Israel's campaign fails two key Catholic standards for a just war: the
Get The Gavel
A weekly SCOTUS explainer newsletter by columnist Kimberly Atkins Stohr.
Enter Email
Sign Up
Finally, war must be
Advertisement
C. J. Doyle
Executive director
Catholic Action League of Massachusetts
Boston
Lest it be misunderstood: Jesus condemned violence
'All who take the sword will perish by the sword' (Matthew 26:52).
I appreciate Jeff Jacoby as a thoughtful, conservative writer, and I judge that he had a reasonable argument going when he declared Pope Leo XIV as 'deeply misguided' when the pope said that 'war does not solve problems.' However, Jacoby made a big mistake when he tried to clinch his own view that some wars do solve problems when he used a quote from Jesus.
Advertisement
One can use pretty much any individual biblical citation to bolster one's argument, as I have above in rebuttal, in referring to the Gospel of Matthew, in which Jesus tells Peter to put his sword away after cutting off the ear of a soldier during Jesus' arrest. This is called
Furthermore — and the bigger point — almost all biblical scholars would agree that Jesus condemned violence throughout his life and certainly wouldn't agree with Jacoby's assertion that 'sometimes only through deadly force' can evil 'be overcome.'
As for the pope, my guess is that when he says that war only 'amplifies' problems, he is not only alluding to the enormous suffering brought about by war, which Jacoby acknowledges, but also the problematic aftermath of most wars.
For example, Jacoby cites how Operation Desert Storm liberated Kuwait. What he failed to acknowledge is that following that event,
Advertisement
Art McDonald
Salem
The writer is a retired Unitarian Universalist minister.
'Then justice will dwell in the wilderness'
I prefer Isaiah's hope/prophecy regarding peace and justice:
'Then justice will dwell in the wilderness ... The effect of righteousness will be peace ... My people will abide in a peaceful habitation, in secure dwellings, and in quiet resting places' (
May it be so.
Jean Condon Lechtenberg
East Falmouth
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
6 hours ago
- New York Post
Chris Matthews says Dems ‘falling into a trap of defending what's indefensible' on crime
Former MSNBC host Chris Matthews said Wednesday that the Democratic Party was 'falling into a trap of defending what's indefensible' in reacting to President Donald Trump's plan to address crime in Washington D.C. MSNBC 'Morning Joe' co-host Mika Brzezinski asked Matthews about the politics of Trump's announcement, describing it as a political win for the president before adding, 'I think that the Democrats need to go beyond saying, 'No, look at the data, crime is going down.' I feel that is exactly the wrong response politically, even if it's true.' Trump announced on Monday that he was activating approximately 800 National Guard troops and taking control of the Metropolitan Police Department to tackle crime in D.C. Matthews criticized Trump for the Jan. 6 riots but said the move was about the president showing strength, before explaining that he lives in D.C. and that homelessness and graffiti were evident despite it being a beautiful city. 'Trump looks at the city visually like a real estate agent. He wants to beautify the city like he's doing at the White House with that ridiculous ballroom he's putting in and getting rid of the Rose Garden. That's Trump work,' Matthews said. 'But I think it shows strength… I think this is a strength move against the big cities who are in a difficult situation on crime. And the murder rate, you can't keep saying violent crime is down with the murder rates up. To the average person, the murders are about life and death. You don't brag about a rising murder rate. And the Democrats are, I agree with you, Mika, they're falling into the trap of defending what's indefensible,' he added. Ex-MSNBC host Chris Matthews said Wednesday that the Democratic Party is falling into a trap against President Donald Trump's plan to send the National Guard to Washington, D.C. AFP via Getty Images Brzezinksi agreed and said it was a 'trap.' 'Yes, it's a trap. If it's not a winner politically to say, 'Oh, you're wrong, look at the data,' because you know if one violent crime happens in a very heavily populated part of the city, people hear about it and it's visceral. They don't want it. And they'll gravitate to the person who appears to be doing something about it,' she continued. Matthews made an appearance on 'Morning Joe' claiming 'the Democrats need to go beyond saying, 'No, look at the data, crime is going down.' MSNBC Matthews recently praised Trump for his political skill during an interview on Charlie Rose's podcast. 'He's very good at knowing your condition, your worries, your insecurities. I mean, he'd be a great bully in a grade school, a Catholic high school or grade school. I mean, he'd be the scariest bully because he'd know everybody's weakness. But he's really good at the moment. I mean, he's out there watching television and keeping up, and, 'Is this the right thing to do, what we're doing right now?'' he told Rose. 'Biden couldn't do that in a million years, not a million years,' Matthews added.
Boston Globe
9 hours ago
- Boston Globe
Why autocracy is rising in America, and how to stop it before it's too late
These two examples are but a sample of the laser-focused and ever-intensifying Get The Gavel A weekly SCOTUS explainer newsletter by columnist Kimberly Atkins Stohr. Enter Email Sign Up 'This is about how do you dismantle democracy, in real time, in plain sight,' Stacey Abrams, voting rights activist and former Georgia state legislator, said in an Advertisement It can all feel overwhelming, as if it is too much coming at us too fast to wrap our arms around, let alone fight. But that isn't true. There are things we all can do to push back against and mitigate the autocratic turn our nation has taken. But first, we have to be clear about how and why authoritarianism can so easily take over a democracy like America's. Advertisement It's not just the Supreme Court's continued targeting of the Voting Rights Act or the flagrant partisan gerrymandering to keep increasingly purple states like Texas bright red. Democracy is dying by a thousand cuts, though many feel more like machete wounds. They include Then there's the plan, straight out of Project 2025, to There is also the federal And so much more. Ask yourself: If Republicans were so confident that their policies were popular, why would they be working so hard to rig the electoral system to hold onto power? They give their own game away. But they couldn't do it unless a significant portion of Americans (far short of a majority) were willing to go along with it. I'm often shocked at the willingness of so many Americans to watch our democratic guardrails crumble with barely an 'oh, hum.' But Abrams raised an important point: The way autocrats win over supporters is by telling them the lie that democracy cannot give the people what they need, and that they should embrace an alternative. That was exactly how Rodrigo Duterte rose to power in the Philippines and Viktor Orbán in Hungary. And now it's happening here. Advertisement Republicans have been successful in making their supporters think, as Abrams said, that 'it's this community of people [Democrats] who are the reason you don't have anything, and so we will let you [Republicans] oppress an entire population if it justifies our convenience and guarantees us what we need.' Add a healthy dose of fear-mongering (the entire basis of the Trump administration's militarized attack on immigrants and cities like Washington, D.C.) and otherwise sensible people's tolerance for democratic backsliding skyrockets. But there is reason for hope: We are not without power to push back in real, meaningful ways. 'We need your investment,' Abrams said. 'This is not just about money. It's about time, talent, and treasure.' Give money to pro-democracy causes and candidates if you have it to spare, but that's not the only way. Contact advocacy organizations — from immigrant support groups to organizations dedicated to keeping elections free and fair — and ask what they need. Often it isn't just money but also volunteer time and effort. Contacting members of Congress is useful, but so is showing up at your local town council and school board meetings and demanding they fight against local-level autocracy like book banning and conservative takeovers of school curricula. Talk to your neighbors, your family, and your friends about how much we have to lose if we don't take action. 'We've got to show up and show that democracy can still deliver, even if it's being delivered by individuals,' Abrams said. 'Your church, your organization, your Girl Scout troop, whatever coalition you have, has to step into the gap.' It was a wonderful reminder to me that we are not powerless. I want to remind you of that, too. Advertisement Kimberly Atkins Stohr is a columnist for the Globe. She may be reached at
Yahoo
11 hours ago
- Yahoo
Ashley Biden's Late Brother Beau Set Her Up with Husband Howard Krein Before His Death: Inside the Couple's 15-Year Relationship
The former first daughter, who reportedly filed for divorce on Aug. 11, met Krein at a hospital while Beau was recovering from a stroke in 2010NEED TO KNOW Former first daughter Ashley Biden filed for divorce from her husband, Dr. Howard Krein, on Aug. 11, according to The Philadelphia Inquirer Ashley was introduced to Krein by her late older brother, Beau Biden, who was in the hospital after suffering a stroke when he facilitated their first date Beau's stroke would later be recognized as a symptom of the aggressive brain cancer that killed him in May 2015 at age 46Ashley Biden, the daughter of former President Joe Biden and former first lady Dr. Jill Biden, has reportedly filed for divorce from her husband, Dr. Howard Krein, after 13 years of marriage. The Philadelphia Inquirer reported that Ashley, 44, filed the the documents in the Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas on Monday, Aug. 11. She and Krein, 58, have been married since June 2, 2012. Ashley was initially set up with Krein by her late brother, Beau Biden. President Biden told the story of their unfortunate meet-cute in a December 2014 conversation with Politico. In 2010, Beau was hospitalized after suffering a stroke. The medical emergency, as it turns out, would change the life of both the Delaware attorney general and his younger sister in drastically different ways. While Beau was recovering, Joe recalled, Ashley came to the hospital to check on him at the same time that her future husband, who knew Beau, stopped by for a visit. "Ashley walked in the room, panicked about her brother and jumped in bed with him and [said] 'Beau, you okay, honey?' " the former president remembered in the 2014 interview. "This guy [Krein] was at the foot of the bed visiting. And after it was all over, Howard walked up to Beau and said, 'Beau, you think you could set me up with your sister?' " Joe added. Ashley initially refused the idea, her father claimed, but Beau wore her down. "He said, 'As a favor, please, for me, do this.' [She said], 'Okay, alright, alright.' " Krein, who is 15 years her senior, was an impressive candidate. A plastic surgeon with both an M.D. and a Ph.D., he would also become an associate professor of otolaryngology at Thomas Jefferson University, a founding partner and co-director of the school's Facial Aesthetic and Reconstructive Center, and the chief medical officer at StartUp Health, which helps entrepreneurs build sustainable health and wellness companies. Later on, when Joe asked his daughter how the date went, "She said, 'Ah, he's alright.' " Two years later, they were married, in an interfaith Catholic and Jewish ceremony at the same Delaware church where Ashley was baptized. Their wedding reception was held in the Bidens' backyard. Ashley shared an anecdote about the ceremony in a speech at the 2024 Democratic National Convention, recalling, "At the time, my dad was vice president, but he was also that dad who literally set up the entire reception. He was riding around in his John Deere four-wheeler, fixing the place settings, arranging the plants." Thankfully, the big brother who introduced the couple got to see his sister's special day. But it was a close call. As it turned out, the stroke that landed Beau in the hospital in 2010 was part of the reason doctors eventually discovered he had glioblastoma multiforme, the most aggressive type of brain cancer. Chemotherapy and radiation kept the disease in check for a few years, but on May 20, 2015, he was admitted to Walter Reed National Military Medical Center in Bethesda, Md. Ten days later, he died at the age of 46. Ashley has kept Beau's memory alive throughout the years. When she founded the clothing brand Livelihood in 2017, the logo — the letters LH being pierced by an arrow — was a tribute to her late brother. "We have to sometimes be pulled all the way down to shoot forward," Ashley explained to The Lily in 2020. "He was my bow. His cancer brought me to my knees. I had no choice but to shoot forward, keep going, keep aiming at my own dreams." Never miss a story — sign up for to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories. While Ashley is technically a half-sister to Beau and Hunter — who are Joe's sons from his first marriage to late wife Neilia — the Biden family bond is strong. The former first daughter doesn't have much of a social media presence, but many of the photos she does post feature the smiling former president and first lady, as well as her nieces and nephews. In fact, Ashley traveled with Beau's daughter, Natalie, on Joe's final official international trip as president in December 2024. Ashley celebrated her adventure with "my girl" with an Instagram photo carousel of memories. Throughout Krein's 15-year relationship with Ashley, he has stayed mostly out of public view, first while his father-in-law was vice president, then throughout Joe's presidency. Ashley frequently attended events with the Biden family while her father was in office, usually without Krein, a practicing physician and professor who specializes in plastic surgery and facial reconstruction. In 2013 and 2016, Krein was out in the spotlight with Joe and Jill on international diplomacy trips, and he was notably in the Oval Office beside Ashley in July 2025 as President Biden delivered a speech from the Resolute Desk about his historic decision to end his reelection campaign. After the Bidens left the White House in January, Ashley and Krein returned to living largely private lives. The divorce filing was confirmed to the Inquirer through a representative for Ashley, and she has not yet publicly commented on the news. Read the original article on People
