Jury deliberates for 2nd day in the triple murder trial of Australian accused of mushroom poisonings
The jurors who began deliberating Monday are sequestered, a rarity in Australia that reflects public and media fervor about the case against Erin Patterson, with several news outlets publishing live blogs that covered every moment of the two-month trial. The jurors will remain secluded until they reach a unanimous decision on the charges of murder and attempted murder.
Three of Patterson's four lunch guests — her parents-in-law Don and Gail Patterson, and Gail's sister Heather Wilkinson — died in the hospital after the 2023 meal, at which she served individual beef Wellington pastries containing death cap mushrooms. The fourth, Heather's husband Ian Wilkinson, became gravely ill but survived.
Patterson, 50, told the trial she didn't deliberately poison her guests and must have accidentally mixed up store-bought and wild mushrooms, which she had foraged herself without knowing they were death caps. She also said she ate the mushrooms but didn't get as sick because she threw up soon after the lunch due to an eating disorder.
Prosecutors in the case, which has gripped Australia for two years, said the accused woman researched, foraged and served the mushrooms deliberately and lied to investigators to cover her tracks. Patterson accepted she had disposed of a food dehydrator after the fatal meal and reset her phone multiple times.
The prosecution said she lied about having a dire medical diagnosis to ensure her guests attended the lunch, cooked individual pastries to avoid poisoning herself, and faked symptoms to make it look as though she fell ill, too.
Prosecutors didn't offer a motive but suggested a deteriorating relationship between the accused and her estranged husband, Simon Patterson, as well as her exasperation with her former in-laws. Simon Patterson was invited to the fatal lunch but didn't go.
Patterson would face life in prison if she is convicted.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
an hour ago
- Scottish Sun
Chilling property ad inadvertently reveals haunting lost terror clues linked to massacre of 51 people
A PROPERTY listing has inadvertently revealed haunting lost terror clues linked to the massacre of 51 people in New Zealand. In 2019, white supremacist Brenton Tarrant, now 34, opened fire on two mosques in Christchurch, heinously targeting worshippers inside. 8 A property listing has inadvertently revealed haunting lost terror clues Credit: 8 Investigative journalist Joey Watson discovered that this apartment was the place Tarrant resided before he launched the heinous attack Credit: 8 Tarrant was sentenced for the terror attack Credit: AP Australian Tarrant targeted Muslim communities, shooting at Al Noor mosque and Linwood mosque in March that year. The terrorist pleaded guilty to 51 murders, 40 attempted murders and one charge of committing a terrorist act during the shooting rampage. Graphic footage of the attack was live-streamed on Facebook via a headcam he was wearing. Tarrant told police officers that it was his plan to burn down the mosques after his attack - and that he wished he'd done so. The terrorist was sentenced in August 2020 and will spend the rest of his life locked up. Now over six years on, a property listing has revealed harrowing clues linked to the massacre. Investigative journalist Joey Watson discovered that the apartment on the real estate website was where Tarrant lived before he launched the heinous attack. The property listing appears normal initially, with a fairly desolate kitchen, bathroom and bedroom. But pictured on the desk in the study is a computer, logged in, with the screen completely visible. Watson observed on the desktop home screen a saved Word document thought to be Tarrant's 74-page manifesto he wrote released before the massacre. Moment suspected 'terrorist' arrested after killing one and injuring 5 in horror knife rampage In the manifesto, Tarrant described how he'd been preparing for the attack since his trip to Europe two years prior. During his visit to France, he'd described a town in Eastern France as a "cursed place", calling immigrants "invaders". The author of the disturbing manifesto said he was inspired by Anders Breivik - the far-right terrorist who killed 69 children of a Workers' Youth League on the island of Utøya in Norway in 2011. The computer's background image also bears haunting clues linked to the attack, as it shows a painting from the 1860s called Among the Sierra Nevada by Albert Bierstadt. This painting is said to have reached popularity with extremists on dark internet sites visited by terrorists, Watson explained on his podcast Secrets We Keep: Lone Actor. The bombshell discovery comes years after New Zealand Police said it had never recovered the terrorist's computer. Journalist Watson even downloaded the image and discovered it had been taken on March 4, 2019 - 11 days before the tragedy. Two other icons on the homescreen were spotted - an anonymity browser often used to access the dark web called Tor, as well as a software called Eraser that permanently deletes files. 8 Initially, it seems like a normal property listing, with a kitchen, bathroom, and rooms with barely any furniture Credit: 8 On a desk in the study is a computer, still logged in, with the screen completely visible Credit: 8 The terrorist was sentenced in August 2020 Credit: Discord - a messaging app created for gamers - was also seen on the listing by Watson installed on the computer. The app had been used in the past by an international community of neo-Nazi groups which became collectively known as the Skull Mask network, according to Watson. Skull Mask is said to have emerged from an extremist forum called Iron March. Watson revealed how terrorist Tarrant was connected to such networks and posted on extremist groups. The Christchurch massacre The devastating attack at the Masjid Al Noor Mosque and the nearby Linwood Masjid took place at around 1.40pm on Friday, March 14, 2019. The gunman opened fire on the two mosques, targeting worshippers inside. He then returned to his car to pick up another weapon and resumed firing inside. He then shot two more people outside the Linwood Islamic Centre. Tarrant reportedly had been on a seven-year trip around the world before the attack after his dad Rodney Tarrant died of cancer aged 49. The attack prompted New Zealand to reform its gun laws - banning military-style semi-automatic weapons. His grandmother told news outlet 9News that she believed these travels changed him, saying: "It's only since he travelled overseas I think that boy has changed completely to the boy we knew". In his manifesto which he posted online before the attack, he said: "I had little interest in education. "I did not attend university as I had no great interest in anything offered in the universities to study.' 8 Brenton Harrison Tarrant appears in a screen via video link in Christchurch, New Zealand Credit: AP
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
EXCLUSIVE The astonishing photo of Pheobe Bishop's big sister with one of her mum's NDIS clients that has sparked a furious row: 'See you in court'
A photograph of Pheobe Bishop's big sister clutching a bong inside the home of an NDIS client of her mum's firm has sparked bitter legal threats amid a furious row. The picture showed Kaylea Bishop apparently holding a bong while sitting with a client of her mother Kylie Johnson's NDIS company, Smiley's Support Services. The image sparked a firestorm after it appeared on social media, with allegations that Kaylea was using the bong while working as a carer at the firm. But Ms Johnson has now fired back at the accusation, denying Kaylea works for her, and claiming the picture was taken by an employee who was later sacked. 'As the owner and director of Smiley's I can guarantee that this worker isn't employed by us,' she said. 'The person in the photo isn't employed by Smiley's, however the worker that took the photo was at the time employed by us. 'I will not breach the confidentiality of the participant. But this photo has been taken by a support worker that was recently dismissed by Smiley's for several serious breaches of our policies and procedures. 'This has now been forwarded to the Quality and Safeguarding Commission for further investigation by Smiley's.' Tanika Bromley (pictured left with Kylie Johnson) was employed at Smiley's Support Services before she was made redundant from her role last year Ms Johnson added that Smiley's was 'open to the commission coming and auditing us at any time with any queries relating to our participants, their funding and their wellbeing'. 'As always we are striving to provide a safe and supportive environment for all of our participants during this difficult time.' Kaylea also delivered a blistering response in reply: 'Everyone is trying to find a way to get to my mother and her company. 'That is all this s*** is. It is absolutely more than putrid. 'She lost her daughter, I've lost my sister, our family have lost an aunty, niece, friend, cousin in the most horrific way some decency.' She added: 'I know for a fact I did not work for Smiley's, I am actually independent. 'It's also very funny how I'm the 'worker' in this situation however it's clearly obvious the actual worker took the photo. 'We will see who has the most evidence in court. We will see what the court has to say and who has the actual evidence and legal to stand on.' Daily Mail Australia understands that the NDIS Quality and Safeguards Commission is investigating concerns raised about Smiley's. 'The NDIS Commission takes allegations of provider and worker wrongdoing seriously and can take strong action against any NDIS provider found to be contributing to, or complicit in, the abuse, neglect or exploitation of a person with disability,' it said in a statement. Pheobe, 17, went missing near Queensland's Bundaberg Airport about 8.30am on May 15 after booking a trip to WA to visit her boyfriend. Three weeks later, police discovered the teenager's remains near Goodnight Scrub National Park. On Monday afternoon Pheobe's family held a private funeral for the teen in Bundaberg before a cremation at the Springfields Crematorium. Pheobe's housemates, James Wood, 34, and Tanika Bromley, 33, have been charged with her murder and are being held in jail on remand before their next court appearance. Police allege they moved her body more than once. In the weeks since Pheobe's alleged murder, Ms Johnson's business has been the subject of local controversy Daily Mail Australia earlier revealed that Bromley was employed by Pheobe's mum as a support worker, until she was made redundant from her role last year. Rumours have circulated in the Gin Gin community that Pheobe was employed as a support worker by her mother's company - or that she was an NDIS recipient herself. False claims also emerged that Smiley's Support Services was 'unregistered' with NDIS. However, NDIS records show that Smiley's has approved registration status and is in force until it's up for renewal in February 2026. Ms Johnson took to social media earlier this month to hit back at the allegations. 'We've heard a few rumours about ourselves lately, however, we'd like to assure you all that Smiley's has NO intention of closing,' she wrote, adding that the business was 'continuing as usual'. Ms Johnson implied the rumours had come from other NDIS providers in the area. 'Imagine people from your own industry using this tragedy to benefit themselves?' she wrote. 'Your disability only defines you if you allow it to and Phee never let hers define her.' Ms Johnson did not specify what Pheobe's disability was. However, before she disappeared, the teen had shared a post to TikTok about borderline personality disorder. 'Having a partner with BPD (borderline personality disorder) means... getting blocked or left over small incidents... they will say very harsh things they don't mean when having an episode,' the post said, apparently in an attempt to explain her sometimes unpredictable behaviour. Ms Johnson previously said Pheobe 'didn't fit the mainstream school model' and struggled with her education until she was enrolled at the alternative Y School in Bundaberg. Pheobe's final posts to social media suggested the troubled teen had fallen out with her mother and would not return home. She also claimed in text messages to her aunt, Caz Johnson, that her mum had told her to 'get out'. The rubbish-strewn flat where she lived with Wood and Bromley was just down the road from her mother's business. Prior to registering Smiley's Support Services in 2021, Ms Johnson ran another Queensland business called Butterfly Spiritual Healing and Massage from 2015 to 2017, ABN records show. The business offered services such as reiki healing and aura cleansing. NDIS declined to comment when asked if Pheobe was a care recipient, citing privacy reasons. Support workers are potentially subject to a range of requirements prior to employment, such as working with children checks and police checks. Pheobe's cousin Whitney Woodfield replied to Ms Johnson's post, adding: 'These rumours are utterly ridiculous. 'The things this company has done for the community are incredible. 'Phee would never have been okay if they were taken down over this. Proud of you for standing your ground.' Bromley and Wood have not entered pleas and have now been sent to jail on remand - after previously being in police custody for several days after they were charged. Wood is now being held at Brisbane Correctional Centre, and Bromley is in Brisbane Women's Correctional Centre.
The Guardian
3 hours ago
- The Guardian
In a sleepy Australian town, court watchers bag spots for Erin Patterson's mushroom lunch trial verdicts
As the jury in Australia's mushroom lunch trial prepared to start their first full day of deliberations on Tuesday, the rain began to fall outside the regional court. For more than two months, Erin Patterson's triple murder trial has inched towards its conclusion. The seasons turned from autumn to winter, with the trees across from the court in Morwell, about a two-hour drive from Melbourne, now completely bare. The Victorian supreme court trial, which began in April, was scheduled to run for up to six weeks. As jurors woke on Tuesday – to begin deliberations, July had arrived and the trial was in its 10th week. Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email Morwell, in Victoria's Gippsland region, has hosted what has been one of Australia's most high-profile criminal trials, attracting global attention. On Monday, the 14-person jury was reduced to 12 through a balloting off process. The final 12 retired to consider their verdicts just after 1pm. The nation's media now waits. There is no timeline for a jury's deliberations and the judge overseeing the trial has told jurors they can take 'all the time you need'. Reporters are stationed in a nearby overflow room, metres from court room four which will reconvene when verdicts are returned. Outside the Latrobe Valley law courts, TV reporters preparing for live crosses, news camera operators and photographers mill around the entrance. Patterson's murder trial has also attracted documentary producers, TV screenwriters and authors who have flocked to the sleepy town. Within the court building, some members of the public are already waiting outside the court room in anticipation of the verdicts. On Tuesday afternoon, a row of six bags were outside the court room, reserving people's positions in line. After 40 days of evidence (likened to a 'jigsaw puzzle' by the judge), arguments and instructions, the jury must determine whether or not the crown has proved guilt beyond reasonable doubt on the four charges. Justice Christopher Beale has reminded jurors they are the only 'judges of the facts' in this case. These seven men and five women will determine Patterson's fate. Sign up to Breaking News Australia Get the most important news as it breaks after newsletter promotion Their deliberations are centred on whether Patterson deliberately and intentionally poisoned her estranged husband's family on 29 July 2023 with a lunch of beef wellingtons that contained death cap mushrooms, or whether it was a tragic accident. She faces three charges of murder related to her parents-in-law, Don and Gail Patterson and Gail's sister, Heather Wilkinson. Patterson is also accused of attempting to murder Heather's husband, Ian Wilkinson. She has pleaded not guilty to all charges. Each day, the jury is transported to court to commence deliberations inside a jury room between 10.30am to 4.15pm, with a one hour and fifteen minutes lunch break. During their deliberations, which can occur between Monday to Saturday, the jurors are sequestered. This means they will return to supervised accommodation each night to ensure they have no contact with the outside world that could influence their deliberations. Jurors can submit written questions to Beale throughout this period, before the court would reconvene to hear the answer. Jurors have been instructed to ring a buzzer inside the jury room when they have reached verdicts to alert court staff. Then, the wait will be over.
