logo
Mormon church rocked by child sexual abuse allegations in California

Mormon church rocked by child sexual abuse allegations in California

The Guardian08-03-2025

The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints (LDS) in the US has been rocked by a slew of sexual abuse allegations launched against it in California in the latest scandal to hit the organization that is better known as the Mormon church.
A three-year look-back legal window that allows adult survivors of sexual assault to file claims in California has produced almost 100 allegations of childhood sexual abuse by Mormon leaders.
The claims, in keeping with similar allegations against the Catholic church, the Church of Scientology, the Boy Scouts of America and other hierarchical institutions in the US, have a consistent theme: alleging that officials used their power to groom, manipulate and abuse children, and that senior leaders of the institution that either knew or should have known about the abuse did not act to halt it.
In the most recent claims against the Utah-based church, five plaintiffs allege they were abused in San Diego county, including three who say they were sexually assaulted by the top spiritual leaders of their congregations.
Several allege they disclosed the abuse to other church leaders. A female plaintiff alleged that the leaders 'acted to protect' the abusers and the church 'handled the repeated allegations internally as a 'matter of sin' and not one leader reported any matter to police'.
A woman from Escondido alleged that she was sexually assaulted from 1961 to at least 1978 by two male family members, including a bishop and a 'home teacher' assigned to deliver spiritual lessons.
Another claim filed on behalf of the estate of woman alleges repeatedly abused by two LDS home teachers beginning in 1961. A man alleges he was abused between five and nine times over a two-month span in 1978 by his bishop, when he was 14. He alleges he later disclosed the abuse to the bishop of a different area but was 'ignored and disregarded plaintiff'.
Another claims he was assaulted by a bishop in 1995 and reported the abuse to his father, who in turn reported it to an LDS official who warned him 'that he needed to support his son's abuser or risk being excommunicated from the church'.
A fifth claimant claims he was abused, at age 16, during private lessons by a bishop who told him, the lawsuit alleged, that 'if he kept quiet, he would go to heaven, but if he told of the abuse, he would go to hell'.
Michael Carney, a Los Angeles attorney with Slater Slater Schulman, told the San Diego Tribune that the LDS church is unique because of 'how much power and influence the church has over people's lives'.
A church spokesperson said that 'abuse of a child or any other individual is inexcusable. The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints believes this, teaches this, and dedicates tremendous resources and efforts to prevent, report and address abuse' and outlined steps related to abuse LDS church leaders and members are instructed to follow: stop the abuse, help victims receive care and comply with whatever reporting is required by law.
But the spokesperson also noted that the cases were filed by a single contingency law firm, 'which has aggressively marketed for clients' and many are decades old and some potential witnesses have died.
'The church takes these claims seriously and is carefully investigating each case individually,' the spokesperson added. 'Early investigation has revealed multiple discrepancies in many of the claims.'
The lawsuits against the LDS church have become so numerous, and with so many common threads, that attorneys want to consolidate the actions into a single multi-district litigation in the central district of California.
One focus of the litigation against the church involves claims that an LDS 'help line' was used to suppress reports of abuse and shield abusers, not to help victims. The LDS church's general handbook directs church leaders to 'not involve themselves in civil or criminal cases for members in their units without first consulting with Church legal counsel'.
'Institutions are more concerned about their public appearance because that translates into monetary donations,' said Mitchell Garabedian, an attorney known for representing sexual abuse claims against the Catholic church. 'History has taught us that first and foremost institutions protect themselves and not the child.'
But the success of claims against individuals and institutions is not as legally sure-footed as it was at the onset of the #MeToo movement seven years ago. Earlier this week, Jay-Z filed a lawsuit against attorneys Tony Buzbee and David Fortney and their Jane Doe client over a lawsuit claiming sexual abuse that that was subsequently dropped.
Jay-Z – also known as Shawn Carter – proposed three causes of action to an Alabama court: malicious prosecution, abuse of process and civil conspiracy against all three defendants, as well as defamation against the Jane Doe, claiming the allegations of rape against him were knowingly 'false' and 'malicious'.
Next month, movie mogul Harvey Weinstein, 72, faces retrial in New York on rape charges after his earlier convictions five years ago for the third-degree rape of one woman and a first-degree criminal sex act against another woman were tossed on appeal.
According to Wendy Murphy, a former sex crimes prosecutor and director of the Women's and Children's Advocacy Project in Boston, it's harder to prove liability in claims against institutions because the plaintiff needs to show that a high-level officer had knowledge and failed to take action. With institutions that are in some ways structured around secrecy, claims of offenses in cases dating back decades can be especially difficult to establish.
'The capacity to structure secrecy so that they can somehow avoid being held accountable by the way they create their power structures also means they have to accept the consequences that a lot of bad stuff is going to happen,' Murphy said.
Despite efforts to weaken liability standards, Murphy said, deference to the sanctity of religious organizations provides 'unbelievable natural insulation from accountability and oversight, not just because that's how the legal standards are set up but because of an added layer of first amendment protections. Law enforcement often doesn't want to intrude behind the doors of godly places.'
Whatever the legal outcome of abuse claims against the Mormon church, says Garabedian, any change will probably come externally from the legal framework of institutional protections.
'Institutions are icebergs unto themselves, so the real change comes from the public realizing that institutions are not properly supervising and protecting children,' he said, 'and the public is now more aware that they have to watch their children.'
In the US, call or text the Childhelp abuse hotline on 800-422-4453 or visit their website for more resources and to report child abuse or DM for help. For adult survivors of child abuse, help is available at ascasupport.org. In the UK, the NSPCC offers support to children on 0800 1111, and adults concerned about a child on 0808 800 5000. The National Association for People Abused in Childhood (Napac) offers support for adult survivors on 0808 801 0331. In Australia, children, young adults, parents and teachers can contact the Kids Helpline on 1800 55 1800; adult survivors can seek help at Blue Knot Foundation on 1300 657 380. Other sources of help can be found at Child Helplines International

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Married teacher, 43, who had sex with student, 17, after ‘neglect' by husband breaks silence as she's jailed for 3 years
Married teacher, 43, who had sex with student, 17, after ‘neglect' by husband breaks silence as she's jailed for 3 years

Scottish Sun

time11 hours ago

  • Scottish Sun

Married teacher, 43, who had sex with student, 17, after ‘neglect' by husband breaks silence as she's jailed for 3 years

She previously claimed that her husband's "neglect" drove her to the horrifying abuse TEACHER SHAME Married teacher, 43, who had sex with student, 17, after 'neglect' by husband breaks silence as she's jailed for 3 years A MARRIED Catholic school teacher who had sex with a teenage student has broken her silence as she was sentenced to three years behind bars. Emily Nutley had pleaded guilty to two counts of sexual battery over her relationship with a 17-year-old student at St. Xavier High School in Cincinnati. Advertisement 2 Emily Nutley, 43, was sentenced to serve three years behind bars on Tuesday Credit: WLWT 2 She addressed the crimes while at Hamilton County Common Pleas Court Credit: WLWT The 43-year-old was fired from the school last October when the abuse came to light, which led to her arrest and indictment. She addressed the crimes while at Hamilton County Common Pleas Court on Tuesday. The mother-of-three said: "There is no excuse for what I did. "I crossed a line that should never have been crossed. Advertisement read more in world news TREASURE TROVE Gold-laden '£16bn' ship found 10yrs ago is long lost 'holy grail of wrecks' "I think every day about the impact of my actions. "I've lost my husband, my home, my friends. I've caused harm and embarrassment to my children." Nutley further told Judge Jennifer Branch she is now "engaging with professionals who will help me understand [my] choices". She previously claimed that her husband's "neglect" drove her to the horrifying abuse. Advertisement "I am not asking for forgiveness because I have not earned it," she added. The abusive sexual encounters are reported to have taken place between November to December 2023, the MailOnline has reported. Evil mum jailed for SELLING daughter, 6, 'to healer who wanted eyes & skin' Nutley's husband filed for divorce following her arrest. The judge sentenced her to three years behind bars, adding that she was hoping to hear more of an apology. Advertisement "I was looking for you to say that you acknowledge the harm that you caused this young man," the judge said. "You pretty much ruined the rest of his high school career. "I didn't see it. I didn't hear it." The teen also reflected on the abuse in a letter read out in court. Advertisement He said it had "altered my high school experience and my life". "When the abuse started, I didn't know I was being taken advantage of," the teen added. "She told me she would kill herself if I ended it. "Even at sporting events, people yell her name at me." Advertisement He further said it had "left me confused, lacking self worth and depressed". "I can't get away from this. I have a hard time trusting people, especially authority figures."

Scots mum jailed over monkey torture footage which saw macaques crucified & being dipped in boiling oil
Scots mum jailed over monkey torture footage which saw macaques crucified & being dipped in boiling oil

Scottish Sun

timea day ago

  • Scottish Sun

Scots mum jailed over monkey torture footage which saw macaques crucified & being dipped in boiling oil

Sick Natalie Herron, from Airdrie, was sharing hundreds of barbaric videos in online chats BARBARIC Scots mum jailed over monkey torture footage which saw macaques crucified & being dipped in boiling oil A WOMAN involved in a disturbing global monkey torture network has been jailed for more than two years. Natalie Herron, 39, joined online chat groups which encouraged torture of macaques by offenders based in Indonesia. Advertisement 2 Natalie Herron appeared at Airdrie Sheriff Court Credit: Andrew Barr 2 Natalie Herron encouraged the torture of baby macaques in warped online forums The mum-of-two, from Airdrie, Lanarkshire, became a group administrator for the network and shared hundreds of images and videos of the abuse. Barbaric acts of cruelty included crucifixion, machete attacks and one video showed a baby monkey being dipped in boiling oil. Herron made contact online with Michael Macartney, the US-based ringleader of the network who used the alias 'The Torture King'. The group paid people in Indonesia to carry out and film the atrocities on baby long-tailed macaques. Advertisement Investigators from the National Crime Agency alerted Police Scotland and a raid on Herron's home in 2022 discovered an iPhone with 1,084 images and videos of monkey torture. Officers also discovered 4,000 messages on a WhatsApp group which had been sent by Herron discussing torture and hatred of the animals. Messages included "Oh my God the little b*****d is making my ears bleed," and "I am shocked how easily the drill went through the skull, it was like butter". Another message read: "Trying to find a video where they will kill the mum and the babies watch." Advertisement Herron appeared at Airdrie Sheriff Court where she was sentenced to two years and three months imprisonment. She had earlier admitted two charges of possessing and distributing obscene material, namely videos depicting animal torture, between October 2021 and September 2022 at her home address. Shocking moment dog walker drags animals by their leads & hurls them into home as owner's pal slams 'sickening' footage She admitted a further charge of behaving in a threatening or abusive manner likely to cause fear or alarm by sending messages to various online and social media groups which described and promoted animal torture. The court was told she made payments to Macartney but she claimed it was not for the videos but to "help him". Advertisement Nicky Matteo, defending, said: "In all the years I have been practising I have not seen a case like this. It has not been a pleasant experience. "She has had horrific problems in life and she built up a connection with other group members. "She was trying to ingratiate herself with other members, it was a false sense of escapism. "She is no longer the person that was responsible for sending those messages. She recognises the severity of it." Advertisement Sentencing Herron, Sheriff Derek Livingston said: "The fact you not only joined these groups but then helped to facilitate them only helped to increase the animals' suffering." A BBC investigation uncovered the warped network that began life on YouTube before it moved to private groups on the messaging app Telegram. The online group paid for baby long-tailed macaque monkeys to be taken from their mothers in Indonesia and then tortured and killed. Members, who claimed they were angered at the monkeys destroying land in Indonesia, even voted on proposed methods. Advertisement Last year Adriana Orme, 56, from Upton-upon-Severn, and Holly Le Gresley, 37, from Kidderminster, were jailed after admitting being part of the global network. Worcester Crown Court heard graphic details of the suffering experienced by young macaques in Indonesia - with the footage sold to people around the world. Le Gresley was jailed for two years while Orme was handed a 15-month term. Macartney, 51, was also jailed last year after pleading guilty in the US state of Virginia to conspiracy to create and distribute animal cruelty videos. Advertisement He was given three years and four months behind bars. This investigation was part of a wider operation with the National Wildlife Crime Unit, which saw Herron arrested on Wednesday, 7 September, 2022 following intelligence from the National Crime Agency. This is the first time someone has been sentenced in Scotland for cruelty that took place abroad, making it a landmark case. Officers said this was one of the most horrific cases they had dealt with and the material was like nothing they had seen before. Advertisement Detective Sergeant Karen Murray said: 'This was a long and complex investigation which involved a number of organisations including the National Crime Agency (NCA) and the National Wildlife Crime Unit (NWCU) and was the first of its kind in the UK. 'Thanks to the work of these organisations Herron will now face the consequences of her actions which led contributed to the cruel torture and immense suffering of a number of innocent animals. 'Through dedicated police work, the investigation team was able to show that Herron was watching and distributing this horrific material and I would like to take this opportunity to thank all who worked on it. 'This was one of the most disturbing and graphic cases we have worked on and we hope this sentence shows that even though the cruelty took place abroad, that these types of crimes will not be tolerated and we will use all the tools at our disposal to hold people accountable.' Advertisement Detective Inspector Mark Harrison from the National Wildlife Crime Unit said: 'This investigation is truly shocking and unsettling. "The people involved are not just motivated by money, this is also about getting some sort of gratification from watching animals being tortured and then sharing those images with others. 'It has been well documented in the media recently what impacts these sorts of online images can have on people, especially young people and there are proven links between those involved in animal cruelty and violence towards people, so we take it very seriously. 'This investigation is part of a larger transnational investigation that the NWCU has been assisting with and the NWCU would like to thank Police Scotland for their hard work and dedication on this case. Advertisement "It shouldn't be underestimated the impact that working on a case like this can have on those involved. 'Wildlife crime can occur in many forms and the NWCU will continue to work with partners from across the world to ensure that we have the expertise, resources, and skills to fight this type of crime however it may occur.' Anyone who has any concerns around this type of behaviour is asked to contact Police Scotland on 101.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store