2021 report warned province of wildfire risks in Whiteshell
Report included 10 recommendations, implementation of which is 'ongoing,' says provincial spokesperson
Caption: An out-of-control wildfire near Ingolf, Ont., is seen from Caddy Lake, in Whiteshell Provincial Park, on Wednesday, May 14. A report commissioned by the Manitoba government and completed in 2021 outlined what an out-of-control blaze in the park would look like. (Caroline Barghout/CBC)
As wildfires forced the closure of Whiteshell Provincial Park last week, CBC has learned a 2021 report alerted the province to what an out-of-control blaze in the area would look like, warning such an event would lead to catastrophic loss of life and property.
The report, which was commissioned by the Manitoba government, included 10 recommendations. Four years later, it appears none have been fully implemented, though the province says that work is "ongoing."
"Not surprised," one longtime resident said when told about the report's trajectory.
Shaun Harbottle has lived in the park for decades, and owns Crescent Beach Cottages and a general store in West Hawk Lake.
"Very little gets done in the Whiteshell," he said. "Our last big burn was 2016, and they said they were going to fix it then and they didn't."
Image | Shaun Harbottle
Caption: Shaun Harbottle, who owns Crescent Beach Cottages and a general store in West Hawk Lake, says the Whiteshell region was promised help to mitigate fires after 2016, but that never happened. Smoke from the wildfire that began near Ingolf, Ont., can be seen in the distance behind him. (Caroline Barghout/CBC)
Open Image in New Tab
Harbottle is referring to the 5,800-hectare fire that hit northeast of Caddy Lake in May of that year, forcing some evacuations within Whiteshell Provincial Park.
This year, the southeastern Manitoba park faced a threat after an out-of-control wildfire began along the provincial border, near Ingolf, Ont.
That led the Manitoba government to make the unprecedented decision to evacuate the entire park and declare a local state of emergency on Thursday, ahead of the May long weekend, at which point that fire had grown to 27,000 hectares and crossed the Ontario border into Manitoba.
Report highlights limited road access
The 70-page April 2021 report, titled the Whiteshell Provincial Park Wildfire Management Strategy, was never publicly released. CBC obtained it through freedom of information laws.
The report was a result of a request for proposals issued in October 2020 for the development of a strategy to "reduce public risk from catastrophic wildfire" in the park.
It highlights a combination of factors that make the 2,800-square-kilometre park, located near the Ontario border, particularly vulnerable.
Homes in the park are surrounded by one-lane roadways, dense treelines and numerous lakes, making it difficult to get out in the event of an emergency, according to the report.
"Any road closures from either traffic accidents or wildfire may result in large-scale entrapment situations leading to catastrophic events, including significant loss of life if evacuees become stranded along transportation corridors," the report said.
The park is home to about 3,500 cabins, along with businesses scattered throughout a vast area.
Surrounding those businesses and cabins are highly flammable trees, located close to properties and sometimes far away from a body of water that would help slow a fire, according to the report.
The report simulated wildfires in the park and along a 20-kilometre radius around it to determine the behaviour of a fire in the area.
It found the communities of Falcon Lake and Rennie, along with the Pointe du Bois area, were at the highest risk because of their limited access to escape routes and, in the case of north Rennie, its distance from water.
Harbottle's home and business are located near the southern shore of West Hawk Lake.
"If a fire were to start on my property here, everybody on the east end wouldn't have a way out. If a fire starts at the top of the hill, I don't have a way out. So it is a problem, and … it needs to be looked at," he said.
10 recommendations
Ten broad recommendations were made in the report, with the objective they were to be completed within five years.
They included:
Formalizing safety zones to be used by residents as a last resort if evacuation routes are unsafe to use.
Sharing the report's results with local first responders and working with them to identify gaps in evacuation route planning.
Completing an internal review to investigate creating alternative routes for evacuations.
Using the report to discuss with government officials which roads in the park should be upgraded.
Completing an evacuation simulation to understand the time required to evacuate an area.
Completing an "exposure analysis" to help residents understand how to mitigate risks.
Encouraging businesses and residents to implement FireSmart principles, such as clearing nearby trees and utilizing sprinklers.
Conducting controlled burns in areas to control pests and vegetation.
The Falcon Lake area, the Highway 44 corridor and Highway 312 were identified as the top areas to improve evacuation routes.
A government spokesperson didn't offer details on what happened with the recommendations in the report, but said a number of factors have changed since it was published in 2021.
Many of the recommendations in the report are "ongoing," and the current fire situation "will inform any future steps," the spokesperson said in a written statement Friday.
Further details may be provided once the urgency of the current wildfire situation subsides, the spokesperson said.
CBC asked Mike Flannigan, a wildfire scientist at Thompson Rivers University in Kamloops, B.C., who was not involved in writing the 2021 Manitoba report, to review it. He said its recommendations were useful, and prepared with the type of situation that emerged last week in mind.
The Whiteshell is a "flammable landscape," with lots of vegetation that would increase the intensity of a fire, he said.
Building new escape routes in high-risk areas can be costly but is necessary, said Flannigan.
"You have to build roads. And yeah, it's expensive and it fragments the landscape, but you need multiple escape routes," he said.
"They are planning for events like we're seeing unfold in front of us this week."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
44 minutes ago
- CTV News
Irishtown fire contained but hotspots persist: firefighters association
The Irishtown, N.B., wildfire was still out of control as of Tuesday. (Source: Government of New Brunswick) The Irishtown, N.B., wildfire that burned up to 54 hectares near Moncton is now contained, but officials are warning the public it could be reclassified as out of control if weather conditions change. The Department of Natural Resources first detected the fire on Sunday morning. It was classified as out of control before being reduced to 45 hectares and later being labeled as contained on Wednesday night. 'While crews will continue working to fully extinguish hot spots over the coming days, residents can rest easier tonight knowing the threat has significantly reduced,' the Moncton Firefighters Association said in a Facebook post. According to the Government of New Brunswick's website, a fire is considered 'contained' if it is 'is surrounded by barriers like bulldozer breaks or hose lines, which are expected to keep it from spreading further if firefighting efforts continue.' The government notes, however, that contained fires are still burning and could spread. 'Contained' is one step above 'under control' on the government's ranking of wildfires. A fire is considered 'out' when it is completely extinguished with no visible smoke for at least 24 hours. The Irishtown wildfire prompted evacuation advisories for the Irishtown, Evangeline, Tankville and Lakeville communities, but those have since been lifted. 'The fire in Irishtown is now contained, but active flames remain at the center of the perimeter,' said the rural community of Maple Hills in a Facebook post. 'Ash may still drift outside the area. 'Conditions could change quickly. The fire may be reclassified as out of control if weather or behavior worsens.' Other fires There are currently 15 active wildfires in New Brunswick. The biggest is the Oldfield Road fire near Miramichi, which is out of control and has grown to more than 1,300 hectares. Three other fires are considered out of control: Maple Glen, Caché and Chief's. Nine wildfires are being patrolled and two are contained. For more New Brunswick news, visit our dedicated provincial page.
CTV News
44 minutes ago
- CTV News
Montreal fire danger level could hit ‘extreme' this weekend: SOPFEU
The Greater Montreal area is expected to be back under an extreme fire danger rating by Saturday, according to Quebec's wildfire protection agency. Société de protection des forêts contre le feu (SPOFEU) fire information officer Mélanie Morin says a prolonged lack of rain has dried out vegetation across southern Quebec. 'Many gardens and lawns are dry, and that has been reflected in the fire danger rating as well as the fire activity that we've had,' she said. Although patchy rainfall on Wednesday lowered Montreal's fire danger to 'moderate,' Morin warns that relief should be short-lived. 'We're back down to moderate fire danger, but that is usually only a short-term relief,' she said. 'By Saturday, extreme for the Montreal area and very high for the Laurentians.' When conditions reach an extreme level, even a small ember can start a blaze, she warned. 'Once we get up into high, very high, extreme fire danger… the slightest spark could cause a wildfire,' Morin said. SOPFEU is urging residents to check local regulations before lighting fires, as they vary by municipality. In Montreal, open-air fires, bonfires, outdoor fireplaces and fireworks are always prohibited without prior authorization, regardless of the fire danger level. Morin says most of the recent fires in southern Quebec have been linked to human activity in areas where there's a lot of tourism, recreation, and cottages. 'People who are out and about using fire near the woods,' she said. For property owners in or near forested areas, Morin recommends using spark-arrestor fire pits, keeping vegetation around homes green and cleaned up where possible, and always extinguishing fires before bed. 'Make sure you put your fire out before you go to bed, and if you're in a fire danger area that's very high to extreme, avoid the use of fireworks,' she said. Morin says even though most wildfires typically occur in May and June across Quebec, drought conditions can increase the risk. 'We see it every few years, where a situation will build up, and then it'll take a change in weather — lots of rain, cooler temperatures,' to bring the risk back down, she said. Currently, there are no wildfires burning near Montreal. The closest active blazes are near Mont-Tremblant, where two small fires are under control.
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
Miramichi-area fire 1 of 4 out of control in New Brunswick, measuring more than 1,300 hectares
Smoke from the Miramichi fire billows is the sky. (Source: Government of New Brunswick. The New Brunswick government says the Oldfield Road fire in the Miramichi area is still out of control Thursday. The Miramichi-area fire continues to measure more than 1,300 hectares and is one of four considered out of control in the province, including Maple Glen, Caché and Chief's. There are 11 additional fires burning in the province, nine are being patrolled and two are considered contained. The province says multiple new lightning starts are under review and no structure losses have been reported at this time. Resources Fourteen air tankers, three helicopters and 177 firefighters are battling fires in New Brunswick. The government says, if weather permits, two more helicopters will arrive in the province Friday. Firefighters from Maine, Prince Edward Island, Nova Scotia continue to provide assistance. In case of evacuation The province is reminding residents to have an emergency kit stocked in case of evacuation. The kit should include necessities for at least 72 hours, such as: water food flashlight radio batteries first aid masks (for smoke filtration) prescription medications pet food 'Wildfires can move quickly, and not everyone may be able to get information or leave safely on their own. During an evacuation, take a moment to check on those around you,' reads a news release from the government. 'Lend a hand where you can, and have your own plan ready to go.' Advisory vs alert The New Brunswick Emergency Measures Organization wants to make sure residents understand the difference between two different terms – evacuation advisory and evacuation alert. 'Evacuation advisory - Be ready to leave on short notice. Pack essentials (ID, medication, pets, emergency kit) and be prepared to go quickly if conditions change,' reads a post on social media from the organization. 'Evacuation alert - Leave immediately. This means the wildfire poses an imminent risk. Follow the instructions in the Alert Ready notification and go to the designated safe location. Staying informed helps you act quickly and safely.' The organization has also opened 15 comfort centres across the province to allow people the chance to cool down and charge their electronics. Woods and fire bans in effect A provincewide burn ban is in effect and all Crown lands are closed. Residents are not allowed to hike, camp, fish or use vehicles in the woods at this time, and all trail systems through the woods are off-limits. Camping is only allowed in official campgrounds, but the province is asking people to reconsider their camping plans until the forest fire risk decreases. Private property owners are being encouraged to follow the same restrictions. Forestry operations such as harvesting, forwarding, skidding, scarification, chipping and all pre-commercial thinning and cleaning, are also prohibited. 'This is for your safety, the safety of your communities and the safety of firefighters putting their lives on the line,' said Public Safety Minister Robert Gauvin during Monday's news conference. 'Please remain outside the forests, we can't repeat it enough.' In Miramichi, the city has closed the following trails: French Fort Cove Millbank Nature Trails Morrison Cove Trails The province is also urging residents to stay away from the wildfires and give the firefighters space to do their jobs. 'Now is not the time for fire tourism,' said New Brunswick Premier Susan Holt. 'There have been people who have wanted to get that great picture for social media, but we need to keep our roads and our emergency areas as clear as possible.' Water conservation The City of Miramichi is urging residents to conserve water by: avoiding washing vehicles, watering lawns, or filling pools using appliances only with full loads taking short showers installing low-flow faucets where possible repairing plumbing leaks promptly Air Quality The City of Miramichi says there is a high probability of smoke affecting air quality in certain areas. Air quality issues can cause eye or throat irritation and shortness of breath. The city says to contact a physician or Tele-Care 811 is symptoms worsen and to call 911 if you are in severe distress. Vulnerable groups include: infants children pregnant women older adults smokers people with chronic heart/lung disease For more New Brunswick news, visit our dedicated provincial page.
