Government urged to support bill forcing social media firms to turn off 'addictive' algorithms for children
The Irish Council of Civil Liberties is calling on politicians to support a new bill which would force social media companies to turn off their 'addictive' recommender algorithms for children.
A study from Dublin City University's Anti-Bullying Centre last year showed the recommender algorithms used by social media platforms were rapidly amplifying misogynistic and male supremacist content.
The study tracked, recorded and coded the content recommended to 10 experimental or 'sockpuppet' accounts on 10 blank smartphones — five on YouTube Shorts and five on TikTok.
The researchers found all of the male-identified accounts were fed masculinist, anti-feminist and other extremist content, irrespective of whether they sought out general or male supremacist-related content, and they all received this content within the first 23 minutes of the experiment.
A new bill being put forward by People Before Profit is advocating for a situation where social media companies would have to automatically turn off their 'recommender' algorithms for children.
The bill also states any algorithms based on profiling or sensitive personal data should have to be actively turned on by adult users.
Senior fellow at the Irish Council of Civil Liberties Dr Johnny Ryan told Newstalk Breakfast he would urge every political party to row in behind this bill.
'These systems are dangerous, Meta, YouTube, Instagram, X, TikTok, you name it.
Each of them has a system that analyses how a child responds to everything that they see and then uses that insight to push into that child's feed things that will addict them.
'Far too often, what this results in is a personalised diet of self-loathing, self-harm, suicide, into the social feed of a child.
As we know, for adults, this also delivers the perfect drop of poison into each person's ear.'
Dr Ryan said Facebook whistleblowers had indicated internal studies at Meta showed 64% of individuals who joined extremist groups on the platform did so arising out of recommendation tools on Facebook.
'The good news is, although Government doesn't seem to share this view, when we polled people across Ireland last year in January with Uplift, we found that 82% of the Irish public supports a binding rule to switch [algorithms] off.
'It's exactly about engagement — the longer you spend glued to your screen, the more space there is for ads, which they can then sell to you or at you and that's what makes the money.
'The problem for them is, I don't think anyone really believes what these companies say anymore.'
Dr Ryan said while GDPR technically prohibited personalised data being used by these algorithms, the regulations were not enforced on large tech companies.
He believes with re election of Donald Trump in the US, it is the time for the EU to step up.
'Trump is now in charge, and he has his fingers on the scales for all of these companies.
'Europe now faces the likelihood, I think, of an algorithmic assault to boost authoritarians into power.
'We've allowed a situation where Trump is able to hold the hidden levers of Europe's internal political debate, and that is wrong.'
Read More
Meta says it will resume AI training with public content from European users
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Irish Government ‘willing to consider helping further' on Casement, Harris says
The Irish Government is 'willing to consider helping further' with the development of Casement Park, deputy premier Simon Harris has said. It comes after a UK Government pledge of £50 million (€58m) for the development of the west Belfast GAA stadium was included in Chancellor Rachel Reeves' spending review. However, that pledge still leaves the project far from its funding target under current plans. Mr Harris said it is up to the Northern Ireland Executive to decide how to proceed but said the Irish Government would be 'very helpful' in getting the stadium built. Plans for a 34,000-capacity stadium at the site have been mired in uncertainty because of a major funding gap. Stormont ministers committed £62.5 million (€73.4) to Casement in 2011, as part of a strategy to revamp it along with football's Windsor Park and the rugby ground at Ravenhill. While the two other Belfast-based projects went ahead, the redevelopment of Casement was delayed for several years because of legal challenges by local residents. The estimated cost spiralled in the interim. Last September the UK Government ended hopes that the west Belfast venue would host Euro 2028 games, when it said it would not bridge a funding gap to deliver the redevelopment in time. As well as the Stormont contribution of £62.5 million (73.4m), the Irish Government has offered €50m (roughly £42 million) and the GAA has pledged to contribute at least £15 million (€17.6m) It has been reported that the cost of the project has fallen to £270 million (€320m) since it was confirmed the ground would not host Euros matches. Under current plans and including the £50 million (€58.7)from Wednesday's announcement along with the other commitments, the funding shortfall stands at roughly £100 million (€117m). Asked on Friday whether the Irish Government would give an increased contribution, Mr Harris said: 'We're certainly willing to consider helping further, but I should say the Irish Government has already made a very significant willingness to contribute in relation to Casement. 'I welcome the fact that the British Government has joined us in that effort this week, as of course has the GAA. 'The Northern Ireland Executive – and I would have made this point to the First and deputy First Minister today – they obviously now need to decide how they wish to pursue and of course, the Irish Government will want to be very helpful in getting this built.' He told RTE's News At One radio programme: 'This is really, really, really important for the provision of sports facilities, and we will continue to engage constructively.' Speaking at the British Irish Council in Northern Ireland, Taoiseach Micheal Martin said Ireland had already made an 'unprecedented contribution' to the project through the Shared Island Fund. He added a 'realistic' framework for the project was needed. 'Now is the time really to try and reach an agreement in terms of how we proceed with the stadium, having a realistic sort of sense of the framework that would govern the construction of the stadium here because it's been idle for far too long, and I think there's an opportunity now to get a stadium built.' Meanwhile, DUP MLA Sammy Wilson accused Northern Ireland Secretary Hilary Benn of 'clear bias' by allocating money to the GAA rather than providing 'equal treatment of all sports'. Mr Wilson added: 'And in doing so, imposing on the Northern Ireland Executive to find a further £100m to £150m on top of what is already allocated to GAA.'
Irish Independent
3 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Richard Curran: As the billions flow into defence, are we slowly being conditioned for war?
There is a growing feeling of a big war coming. As Israel rains missiles on Iran's nuclear facilities and Irish citizens are warned not to travel to Israel because of likely escalation on the Iranian side, the uncertainty and instability of the last three years feels heightened.
Irish Independent
3 hours ago
- Irish Independent
John Downing: Why EU-UK deal on Gibraltar is also good news for Ireland
Gibraltar, at the bottom of Spain with a commanding vista over the Mediterranean, has been a British colony since 1713 and the focus of periodical Madrid-London tensions and repeated blockades. Its strange status is summed up by the Brexit debacle. Gibraltar is a British Overseas Territory, but it was among the European Union's forerunners, along with the UK, in January 1973. In June 2016, 96pc of Gibraltarians voted against Brexit, but the territory's 30,000 people were unhappily dragged from the EU, due to the 52pc overall UK vote to quit. My experience in Gibraltar led me to ponder its fate from 2016 onwards, which had parallels with Northern Ireland. My spell there was in autumn 1988, covering a long inquest into the killing of three IRA members who were planning to bomb a British military parade. They should have been arrested, as subsequent inquiries definitively established, but all of that is for another day. Feelings were running very high as many bars frequented by British soldiers, sailors and airmen were off limits to me and colleagues, and I did not often disport my Irish accent, deeming silence wiser. However, the weeks did soften the atmosphere, and we soon learned that the native Gibraltarians, Spanish-speakers with a Catholic background, were the ultimate pragmatists, with their main focus on the commercial opportunities that abound in the region. This deal will protect future generations of British Gibraltarians and does not in any way affect our British sovereignty Thoughts of Gibraltar returned this week as news broke of an EU-UK deal that ended all but a decade in limbo for 'The Rock'. Like last month's EU-UK reset framework trade deal, which brought good news for Ireland, there were predictable cries of 'Brexit sellout' and 'betrayal of Gibraltar' from diehard Brexiteers in UK Reform and the Conservative Party. Never knowingly undersold on Brexit rhetoric, the Daily Mail thundered about disloyalty to Gibraltar, which had held the British front line over the Mediterranean for 300 years. By contrast, Gibraltar's head of government, First Minister Fabian Picardo, hailed the EU-UK compromise, saying it would bring stability and certainty for business. 'This deal will protect future generations of British Gibraltarians and does not in any way affect our British sovereignty,' he told the venerable newspaper, the Gibraltar Chronicle, which has been publishing continuously since 1801. As with Ireland, this EU-UK Gibraltar deal aims to avoid a hard border, this time with Spain, which is crucial to the local economy. Central to the deal is Gibraltar's abandonment of its Vat-free rules, as demanded by Madrid, and a new 'transaction tax' bringing a higher rate of import duty. There will be no systematic identity checks on the Gibraltar-Spain border, but there is controversy around Spanish police doing checks inside Gibraltar at its airport and port. This has been the focus of Brexiteer ire amid allegations of 'sovereignty sellout'. But all sides point to the need to facilitate the estimated 15,000 workers who cross each day in both directions for work and business, and there is now hope that there will be no return to long delays due to identity checks. I am overdue a return to Gibraltar, and I remember affectionately the Irish links with the place, such as the school where the Christian Brothers taught The Spanish police presence in Gibraltar mirrors the presence of French personnel at London's St Pancras Eurostar train station and other arrangements such as US personnel at Dublin and Shannon Airports. Yet it will remain emotive for some as Gibraltar Airport is also an RAF base. I am overdue a return to Gibraltar, and I remember affectionately the Irish links with the place, such as the school where the Christian Brothers taught for many years and the Alameda Gardens, which feature in Joyce's Ulysses. I was surprised to learn there that Ireland's most celebrated fictional heroine, Molly Bloom, was, the story goes, born in Gibraltar.
