The Guardian view on Egypt and Alaa Abd el-Fattah: Starmer and Lammy vowed to do all they can. So do it
Progress has not been made and time is running out. Arbitrary detention has stolen almost a decade of Mr Abd el-Fattah's life, while that of his remarkable mother, Laila Soueif, may be drawing to its close. As of Tuesday, the 69-year-old, who lives in London, had not eaten for 261 days, as she demands her son's release. After taking 300-calorie liquid supplements for a short period, she returned to a full hunger strike almost a month ago and has been hospitalised since the end of May. In Egypt, Mr Abd el-Fattah has been on hunger strike for more than 100 days.
Mr Abd el-Fattah, whose current ordeal began when he was detained in 2019, should never have been held. He was sentenced to five years for 'spreading false news'; his real offence was to speak truth to power. But the injustice was compounded when, instead of releasing him in September, as Egypt's own criminal code requires, the state chose to ignore his pre-trial detention. His jail term was deemed to have begun only after his conviction in December 2021, meaning that it would run until the end of next year.
The UN working group on arbitrary detention found last month that his detention was unlawful on multiple grounds, including the lack of arrest warrant, violation of his right to free expression and the lack of a fair trial. His 13-year-old son, who lives in Brighton, has been denied the chance to know his father.
In over a decade in office, Gen Abdel Fatah al-Sisi, Egypt's president, has proved to be even more repressive than his former boss, Hosni Mubarak, who was overthrown in the Arab spring. Executions have soared, and more than 1,500 political prisoners were detained last year alone. Sir Keir has twice raised Mr Abd el-Fattah's case directly in calls with Gen Sisi, and has written to him multiple times. Yet Britain has not even gained consular access to the 43-year-old. Egypt has released dual nationals before when under pressure. It appears particularly obdurate in this case.
Supporters have made a strong case for imposing sanctions and bringing a case at the international court of justice. Given the health of Mr Abd el-Fattah and Ms Soueif, however, the priority must be measures with immediate effect. The first should be to change travel advice, warning against travelling to Egypt, and to refuse trade talks. Mr Abd el-Fattah's case clearly indicates the risks for Britons, given the lack of fair process and consular access. Egypt's economy, which remains fragile following an International Monetary Fund bailout last year, is heavily dependent on tourism and around half a million Britons travel there every year.
The prime minister's advocacy is welcome. But as Mr Lammy demanded in 2022, 'what diplomatic price has Egypt paid for denying the right of consular access to a British citizen?' It is clear that Britain has not, in fact, done everything it possibly can to change the Egyptian government's mind. It must now do so.
Do you have an opinion on the issues raised in this article? If you would like to submit a response of up to 300 words by email to be considered for publication in our letters section, please click here.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
2 hours ago
- The Independent
PM to speak with allies, amid reports Trump mulling Russian land grab in Ukraine
Sir Keir Starmer will meet European allies on Sunday, amid reports Donald Trump favours a Russian land grab in Ukraine to end the war. The Prime Minister, French President Emmanuel Macron and German Chancellor Friedrich Merz will host the coalition of the willing on Sunday afternoon. The video conference of allies who plan to keep the peace in Ukraine comes ahead of Volodymyr Zelensky's White House meeting with Donald Trump on Monday. The one-on-one in the Oval Office could pave the way for a three-way meeting alongside Russian leader Mr Putin, the US President has said. The Russian and American leaders met on Friday at a military base in Anchorage, Alaska, for a summit to broker an end to the war in Ukraine. Several news outlets have cited sources which claimed that during the negotiations Mr Putin demanded full control of Donetsk and Luhansk – two occupied Ukrainian regions – as a condition for ending the war. In exchange, he would give up other Ukrainian territories held by Russian troops. Other outlets reported that Mr Trump is inclined to support the plan, and will speak to Mr Zelensky about it on Monday when they meet in the Oval Office. Sir Keir commended Mr Trump's 'pursuit of an end to the killing' following a phone call with the US President, Mr Zelensky and Nato allies on Saturday morning. But he insisted Ukraine's leader must not be excluded from future talks to broker a peace in Ukraine. The Prime Minister and European leaders appeared increasingly confident that Mr Trump will offer a 'security guarantee' of air support to back up allied troops on the ground in Ukraine, should they be deployed to keep the peace. But Mr Trump also appeared to have a change of heart on what he wants to achieve from the talks, indicating that he wants a permanent peace settlement rather than a ceasefire, echoing the sentiment of Mr Putin. The Alaska summit was 'timely' and 'useful', Mr Putin said after he left. Experts have warned the face-to-face summit has risked legitimising the Russian leader, who has been made a pariah by the international community for invading Ukraine. Ukraine's President Mr Zelensky warned Russia may ramp up its strikes against his country in the coming days 'in order to create more favourable political circumstances for talks with global actors'.
ITV News
5 hours ago
- ITV News
UK must bring in sick and injured children from Gaza 'without delay', MPs demand
A cross-party group of 96 MPs have urged the government to bring sick and injured children from Gaza to the UK for treatment "without delay". In a letter to Home Secretary Yvette Cooper, Foreign Secretary David Lammy and Health Secretary Wes Streeting, the MPs warn the health system in Gaza has been "decimated" and that conditions in the territory are "worsening by the minute". More than 50,000 children are estimated to have been killed or injured in Gaza since October 2023, according to Unicef. With "essential infrastructure destroyed" and a long-running blockade by Israel of food, water and medical supplies, they say the population now faces a "medical and humanitarian catastrophe of horrific proportion". Citing World Health Organisation estimates, the letter warns 14,800 Palestinians are "in urgent need of medical evacuation - including children at immediate risk of death from trauma injuries and severe pre-existing conditions, such as cancer and cardiovascular disease.". "Given this grave reality, we urge the government to launch the medical evacuation scheme without delay". The letter, co-ordinated by Labour MP and GP, Dr Simon Opher, welcomes the government "finally prioritising" the issue but calls on senior ministers to "recognise the real urgency around medical evacuations". The group make six key demands of ministers while a scheme is developed: Timeline: MPs ask ministers to confirm the planned timeline for a medical evacuation scheme for Palestinian children. "This should be done in close coordination with the WHO and civil society organisations, with all eligible evacuees and their accompanying family members expedited as a matter of urgency," they add. Medical needs first: " The prioritisation of medical evacuations from Gaza must be determined solely based on clinical necessity and individual case assessment, without regard to financial implications, political considerations or reputational interests," the letter says. Funding: "Large-scale evacuations cannot rely on private donations or diversion of aid from other conflict responses," MPs say. "We urge you to ensure adequate government funding for medical treatment, psychosocial support, housing and other essential costs." Family unification: The 96 MPs say it is "vital" that children are accompanied by parents, close family members or another appropriate caregiver. "There is clear medical evidence to suggest their presence can positively impact the recovery of sick or injured children," they add. Legal status of evacuees: Ministers are asked to clarify the legal status of evacuees upon their arrival in the UK and following completion of medical treatment, including any rights to remain and pathways to settlement."We would urge that children and their families are given the option of applying for asylum, humanitarian protection or the chance to resettle in the UK. Evacuees must not be returned to Gaza," the MPs say. Biometrics:"The requirement for biometrics as a prerequisite to issue visas remains a major barrier, given that the only authorised biometrics centre in Gaza closed in October 2023," the groups warns. "We urge you to waive biometric requirements for evacuees under this scheme and permit applications to be completed after departure from Gaza." ITV News has contacted the government for comment on the MPs demands. Ministers have already started working on plans to evacuate up to 300 seriously ill or injured children from Gaza for NHS treatment in the UK. Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer said in late June that the government was 'urgently accelerating' efforts to bring children over for treatment. Two weeks ago a government spokesperson said: 'We are taking forward plans to evacuate more children from Gaza who require urgent medical care, including bringing them to the UK for specialist treatment where that is the best option for their care. 'We are working at pace to do so as quickly as possible, with further details to be set out in due course.' Scottish First Minister John Swinney welcomed the move to fly up to 300 children from Gaza but criticised the Westminster government for not taking action sooner. 'We have been consistently clear that the suffering being inflicted on the people of Gaza is beyond any justification.'People in Gaza are being bombed and left to starve by Israel on a massive scale. I wrote to the Prime Minister on 9 July to request support from the UK government in meeting the call from Unicef to provide medical care for children from Gaza.'If the UK government is prepared to evacuate Palestinians for medical treatment it would be entirely only regret is the UK government has taken this long to act."
Telegraph
a day ago
- Telegraph
David Lammy is anything but a man of the people
It was the most stomach-churning political photograph of the summer. That was until, deliciously, it began to disassemble. David Lammy, the Foreign Secretary, 'fishing' with JD Vance, the US vice-president, at the start of the 41-year-old's British vacation. JD had accepted an invitation from Lammy to pop by Chevening, the grace-and-favour house near Sevenoaks in Kent used by foreign secretaries, for a spot of fishing and then tea in the drawing room. I saw the photos and swore I could hear the distinct sounds of gurgling and spluttering, such as emanates from an ancient bathtub as the waters drawn by gravity exit the plughole and descend into the deepest reaches of some ancient plumbing system. That was, in fact, the hideous noise of Lammy sucking up to Vance. Lammy is on that revolting conveyor belt of nauseating genuflection with which the Trump administration has managed to bewitch the world. Let's hope it doesn't spread farther than the Trumpaline circus. God forbid you're in a rural pub, you hear an American voice and suddenly start fawning over the brash tourists, telling them how much you love their movies, cars, doughnuts and grande lattes – and before you know it you've lent them your fishing rod. Not that David Lammy is a fisherman. That much is clear from the photographs, as he stands by the 18th-century-constructed ornamental lake holding a rod like a man clutching a saucepan who's lost an oven. Neither is he dressed for the part, in comfy black shoes, beige trousers and dark blue shirt. Vance at least looks like he couldn't give a damn – a stance and attitude that appears to serve him well. And they're standing far too close together, of course. You don't fish like that. Fishing is solitary. Or you fish while your pal sits on the bank eating a sandwich. And only weirdos fish for carp in ornamental lakes. Muddy carp aren't nice on toast, so it's not worth their torture of being caught. The only people who fish for carp in Britain are illegal eastern European migrants who are fed up with being arrested for catching swans. Thus, the flunkies set up the photo. And Lammy does his gruelling best-buddies-with-Vance act, which must sit so deeply uncomfortably with him. He's a man, after all, most at home in front of a radio microphone, mouthing off about Right-wing monstrosities. He was lucky, though, to be given the mouthpiece of LBC, as his garbled rantings were little better than the spewings I used to listen to that emanated from the pirate radio stations of west London. Except that Lammy, ex-SOAS London and a spell at Harvard, always dreamt of bigger things. Which, unfortunately, were finally gifted to him by a catalogue of shambolic Conservative administrations and a fed-up and gullible electorate. While he might be more comfortable parading about a stately palace, he now plays the man of the people. And there's no more blokey accoutrement than the fishing rod. Rod in hand, the angler takes to the bank to engage in that most pointless of exploits: to catch and release fish. He returns home for his tea with nothing for the table but tales of weather and traffic congestion. Lammy's fishing stunt attempts two things: hands across the Atlantic and to pose as a country person. One wonders, as Vance prepared for his trip to the Cotswolds and then Scotland, whether Lammy added some factual context to where he would be staying in the ensuing days. Perhaps, as his vulgar cortège passed Banbury, he could look in on the Carrdus, a magnificently old-fashioned English boarding school that Lammy and his chums managed to recently shut down through their infantile VAT raid on private English education. Or he could stop by at any number of farms and see how the Labour Party's policies on inheritance tax, its lack of interest in food security and general ambivalence to farming are wrecking the sector. Or, indeed, he could have a tour of all the country pubs that are closing, taxed out of existence by this Government. Perhaps he could highlight the fields across which, thanks to Labour, a person's freedom to ride to hounds following a trail is fast disappearing. And indeed the copses, woods and forests in and around which – if Labour get their way – folk with shotguns will no longer be able to harness a pheasant or a partridge for their cooking pot. Lammy limply dangles his rod into the weedy waters of the Chevening lake and shows not just the hypocrisy of his country chap stance but also his complete ignorance of country law and rites. For as we now gloriously and exquisitely know, Lammy was fishing without a licence. Such is the stranglehold of British nanny-statism, that once you're over the age of 13, you cannot fish even on private land without a licence. Grease up to your bombastic, bearded US buddies, rods in hand, and along will come the Environment Agency threatening a £2,500 fine. Imagine the backstage scrambling once news of this gaffe emerged, the flunkies and flunkettes despatched to make good, the statement then issued saying that Lammy had referred himself to the environment watchdog and that licences were subsequently purchased retrospectively. And there's Vance, tucked up in the Cotswolds and musing on modern Britain, where we tear down statues, limit free speech and where you need a licence to not catch fish. His rural disaster now framed in glorious technicolour, Lammy has doubtless made a hasty retreat to the Smoke – as far away as possible from lakes, rods and muddy carp.
