
Teen who murdered man in front of shoppers and children is jailed
Passing sentence, Mr Justice Paul McDermott said the teen, who can't be named because he was a minor when he first came before the courts, murdered Aaron Keating (43) as an "angry aggressive youth acting in a drug rage".
Advertisement
Although he has pleaded guilty to murder, the youth is not subject to a mandatory life sentence due to his age at the time of the offence.
Mr Justice McDermott said he had to take into account the defendant's age, lack of maturity and the need to rehabilitate young offenders. Therefore he sentenced the defendant to 15 years with the final two years suspended for two years on a number of conditions.
The now 19-year-old was one month short of his 18th birthday when he murdered Mr Keating on June 13th, 2023 at Main Street, Ongar, Dublin 15.
Mr Justice McDermott said it had been a sunny Tuesday afternoon when the defendant and a group of youths were hanging around Main St smoking cannabis. Mr Keating, who had mental health difficulties all his life, was a frequent visitor to the area and was known to all the youths.
Advertisement
CCTV footage
CCTV footage showed an altercation between Mr Keating and the defendant which prompted the youth to run to a nearby stairwell where he had stashed a knife for self-protection.
He returned within 90 seconds of the first altercation and pursued Mr Keating across the road despite one of his friends telling him to stop.
The defendant attempted to stab Mr Keating but missed before he "made another lunge", the judge said, causing the fatal wound to the abdomen. A pathologist found the cause of death to be haemorrhage and shock due to the single stab wound.
Mr Justice McDermott noted that the defendant attacked his victim openly, in a public place, presenting a "terrifying spectacle" to shoppers, including women and children.
Advertisement
The defendant fled the scene, disposed of the knife and made no attempt to assist the dying man, the judge said. Mr Keating was loved by his family, the judge said, and is deeply missed. His life was "needlessly and violently taken", he said.
The judge said that the defendant had done well in primary school but by the age of 12, he began regularly using drugs. He had seen numerous doctors and therapists over the years but continued to abuse drugs.
He said drug use had "a dominating role" in the murder and in causing a disintegration in the youth's education. Drug rehabilitation, he said, will be a factor in efforts to prevent the teenager reoffending. The defendant is currently considered at a high risk of reoffending if he were returned to a community setting within 12 months.
Mr Justice McDermott set a headline sentence of 25 years but reduced that to 21 to account for the defendant's age. He further reduced the sentence to 15 years after considering mitigating factors including the teenager's guilty plea and his "early and consistent expression of remorse, which appears to be genuine and comprehensive".
Advertisement
When sentencing children, the Supreme Court has found that it is preferable to suspend part of the sentence to encourage rehabilitation.
Mr Justice McDermott suspended the final two years on condition that the defendant keep the peace for two years after release, address his addiction needs with the probation services and accept any treatment recommended. He must also participate in a drug rehabilitation programme and any mental health services recommended by the probation services.
Sentencing
At a sentencing hearing last week, Det Gda Jenny Greene told prosecution senior counsel James Dwyer that the defendant was hanging around Ongar smoking cannabis with a group of teenagers from about 3pm that afternoon. He had a number of interactions with Mr Keating.
At about 6pm, "something triggered a reaction" in Mr Keating, who pushed the youth up against a window.
Advertisement
The other youths who had been with the defendant encouraged Mr Keating to leave the area. He crossed the street but about 90 seconds after the previous interaction, the defendant appeared wearing his t-shirt over his head and face and carrying a knife. He ran towards Mr Keating and made "a number of attempts to stab him", inflicting one stab wound to the abdomen, Det Gda Greene said. Mr Keating collapsed within seconds and died from the injury.
The defendant went to a garda station the following morning with his mother and admitted to what he had done. In subsequent interviews, he said he had been smoking cannabis and taking mushrooms when Mr Keating asked him for a joint. He said he laughed, refused to give him a joint and called Mr Keating a junkie.
Ireland
Pensioner blackmailed woman with sex pics recovere...
Read More
He claimed the deceased attacked him so he ran to get the knife so he could "get him before he gets me". He said he didn't want Mr Keating to die but wanted to scare him. "He was egging me on," he said. "I don't know what he said but he triggered me."
The defendant entered his plea of guilty to murder following a Supreme Court ruling last year that, despite now reaching adulthood, he will not face a mandatory life sentence because he was a child when he committed the offence.
The teen previously sought to halt the proceedings against him because, having aged out while awaiting trial, he faced a mandatory life sentence if convicted of murder.
However, following a recent Supreme Court ruling, judges now have discretion when sentencing a person who committed murder while a child, regardless of what age they are when they come before the courts.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


BBC News
2 hours ago
- BBC News
Anita Rose murder: Could Roy Barclay have been caught before killing?
The sun was rising over the village of Brantham in Suffolk when Anita Rose set off for an early morning dog walk. She was a mother of six, and a grandmother of 13. Within an hour, she had been assaulted so brutally that her injuries were akin to those of someone in a head-on car crash. She died four days man responsible, Roy Barclay, was on a list of Suffolk Police's most wanted criminals but he had managed to avoid being recalled to prison for the past two years by sleeping in makeshift despite this, Barclay had left a sizeable digital footprint - using his bank card to order items online and leaving hundreds of reviews on Google all this online activity, how did he manage to evade police and remain free to murder Anita? Anita was an "early bird", her partner Richard Jones said. She loved to walk her springer spaniel Bruce around Brantham, a village where she'd lived for six years and always said she felt safe. The 57-year-old loved watching the sun come up before other people were the morning of 24 July last year, Mr Jones and Anita chatted on the phone while she walked. He worked as a lorry driver and would spend time away from home during the week, so the couple would catch up while Anita took Bruce on the first of his three daily couple had known each other since they were teenagers and had started dating in 2011 after a chance meeting at a petrol station in Copdock where Anita pair's final conversation ended with Anita telling the 59-year-old to "drive safe, I love you".Within an hour of hanging up, she was found unconscious and severely injured on a track road near a railway line by a cyclist, Jerome Tassel, and dog walker Rachel Island. During the trial, Ms Island told the court Anita had "laboured breathing" and patches of blood on her face, and was only wearing leggings and a black sports bra, despite leaving the house wearing her pink Regatta Tassel described how her dog Bruce was lying "patiently" next to her body with his lead wrapped twice around her leg - this turned out to be something Barclay had also done after the 2015 attack for which he was Dr Kieran Allinson, who treated Anita at Addenbrooke's Hospital in Cambridge, likened her injuries to those seen in high speed car crashes and said they were consistent with kicking, stamping and repeated impacts to the head. In the weeks that followed, Barclay was described during his Ipswich Crown Court trial as having lived in carefully-hidden camps and shaving his head to change his had been wanted by police since 2022, when he breached the terms of his licence by making himself homeless. Barclay had been jailed in 2015 for a violent, unprovoked assault on an elderly man in an Essex seaside town, and was released on parole in killing Anita, his internet search history showed he had looked up news articles about the attack. He also looked up Anita's partner on social is also said to have kept some of her belongings - including a pink Regatta jacket - at his makeshift camps. In the weeks after Anita's murder, Suffolk Police entered into one of its biggest-ever investigations to find the culprit.A number of people were arrested and meanwhile, continued to be a prolific reviewer on Google Maps for hundreds of locations around Suffolk and 2022 and October 2024, he posted thousands of photos of churches, Amazon lockers, libraries, beaches, council buildings, statues and more - earning himself a 'Level 8' contributor status (the highest being level 10).One review was of Decoy Pond in Brantham, with photos posted between April and July - the month he murdered Anita a short distance away. Three months after the murder, his final few Google reviews were about Flatford, a historic area on the Essex-Suffolk border famed for inspiring iconic paintings."It's a beautiful, unspoilt rural idyll that somehow exists in its own timelessness, as if awaiting the return of John Constable," wrote Barclay in a review posted in October then he was camping out a mile from where he'd killed Anita - but a chance meeting with a Suffolk Police officer near White Bridge, between Brantham and Manningtree, led to his gave the officer, Det Con Simpson, a fake name, coming across as "quite nervous and quite anxious", the detective days later on 21 October, at Ipswich County Library, Barclay was arrested and was subsequently charged with Anita's murder, which he denied. After his conviction, the Crown Prosecution Service described Barclay as "an individual that… has a history for acting violently so we knew that this was somebody that could act unprovoked in a very violent manner".The 2015 attack in Walton-on-the-Naze left the victim, 82-year-old Leslie Gunfield, with serious injuries to his head, neck, face and was jailed for 10 years for the assault, but was released on licence after Ministry of Justice (MoJ), which is responsible for probation services, told the BBC that a recall notice for Barclay was issued quickly following the breach of his licence doing this, finding Barclay became the responsibility of Suffolk Police. The force began looking for him in 2022, issuing a press release in January 2024 asking for members of the public to get in touch if they saw him, saying he had "links across Suffolk and Essex".Just over a month before he murdered Anita, on 10 June, Barclay had left a comment on an online article called 'Fixing Fixed Term Recalls'. He accused the MoJ of "deliberately" setting up prison leavers "to fail" and "return like a boomerang"."Is it really any surprise that so many of those on license are on recall within the first year of release?" he wrote. The MoJ has refuted these claims. Hamish Brown, a former detective inspector who worked for the Specialist Crime Directorate at New Scotland Yard, said his own experience taught him that officers were often not given "huge amounts of time" to investigate wanted in this case, he said, the force would have serious questions to answer."Suffolk Police failed in tracking him down, despite him using his bank card and reviewing places on Google."I'm surprised Suffolk Police missed this and didn't find him, despite the trail he was leaving."The bottom line is it could have been prevented if the police had done their job and gone looking for the person."So the police will have to brace themselves and be answerable."But Paul Bernal, professor of information technology law at the University of East Anglia, believes there would have been a limit to how useful the Google reviews could have been in tracking Barclay down."There is absolutely no way a social media or search provider would know that those things are in any way needed in a police investigation," he told the BBC."How could you tell if somebody named Roy Barclay is saying this cafe is rather nice... that might be something useful in an investigation? It would be really difficult." Speaking after the jury found Barclay guilty, Anita's family stood on the court steps and spoke of the changes they said "need to be made within the probation service and justice system"."We need make sure our communities are safe and criminals are taken back to prison when they break the terms of their probations," her eldest daughter Jess said."They cannot remain at large - there's too much at stake." 'Definitive answers' Suffolk Police confirmed it would conduct a voluntary partnership review which would look at how the force and the probation service handled the search for Barclay. "It will look closely at the information sharing processes and how the organisations collaborated," said assistant chief constable Alice Scott."This review will be a thorough assessment and scrutiny of the processes concerning Barclay. "It will be expedited as soon as possible so we can provide clear and definitive answers for Anita's family." Follow Suffolk news on BBC Sounds, Facebook, Instagram and X.


Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Shocking post-mortem update on the Coonabarabran boys found dead in their grandmother's home
The case of a woman accused of murdering her young grandsons in their rural home has been briefly heard in court. Prosecutors are still waiting for post-mortem results in the case of a woman accused of murdering her two young grandsons in their rural home. Kathleen Joyce Heggs, 66, is facing two counts of domestic violence murder over the deaths of Max and Sam Johnson, aged seven and six. The brothers were found dead in their home on the outskirts of Coonabarabran, in north-west NSW, on the afternoon of May 5. Police will allege that Heggs drugged the boys before smothering them while they were asleep in separate bedrooms. It's also alleged an autopsy found traces of a prescription medication in the boys' systems. Heggs' case was briefly mentioned in Dubbo Local Court on Thursday morning, but she was not required to appear via audio-video link from Silverwater jail. Solicitor Kathleen O'Keeffe, for the Director of Public Prosecutions, said the brief of evidence was not yet complete. 'There are a few things outstanding, the most crucial though is the post-mortem,' Ms O'Keeffe told the court. Magistrate Margaret Quinn adjourned the matter until September, noting prosecutors have a November deadline to serve the brief of evidence. During a previous mention in July, Heggs' solicitor Christopher Ford said her defence would relate to mental health. 'This is going to be a question of my client's mental health at the time of the offences,' Mr Ford said. Heggs was the sole carer for the boys and the family had moved from the NSW Central Coast to Coonabarabran about a year before the alleged murders. Two junior police officers broke into their house on a semi-rural property after a message sent to the communities and justice department triggered an emergency response. They found the boys' bodies in their bedrooms. Heggs, their maternal grandmother, had harmed herself and was arrested and taken to a mental health unit at Orange hospital before being transferred to the Sydney prison. Charge sheets before the court alleged she may have killed the boys as early as 10.30am on May 5. Police have previously said there were no weapons involved in the alleged murders. The boys' deaths shook Coonabarabran, where they went to the local primary school and attended karate classes. Community members held a candlelight vigil in a park by the Castlereagh River, where they planted two trees in the boys' honour and displayed the yellow karate belts they were due to receive. Heggs' case will return to court on September 4. Lifeline 13 11 14 beyondblue 1300 22 4636


Daily Mail
4 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Jury to visit haunting site where Hannah McGuire's remains were found in a burnt-out car
A jury will visit the site where Hannah McGuire's body was found in a burnt-out vehicle as her former boyfriend stands trial for her murder. Lachlan Young, 23, admits he killed Ms McGuire on April 5, 2024, before driving her body to a remote location and setting the car on fire. But he has pleaded not guilty to murder, claiming her death was an unplanned and spontaneous incident. The 14 jurors selected to decide Young's fate will on Thursday visit the Scarsdale site in regional Victoria where Ms McGuire's remains were found. They will also be taken to the property where the alleged murder happened and the home of Young's parents, the court was told. Prosecutors allege Young formed and then carried out a plan to murder Ms McGuire after months of abusive and controlling behaviour. Young killed the 23-year-old woman when he realised their relationship was over and he would lose the house they had bought together, crown prosecutor Kristie Churchill said. After killing Ms McGuire, he then tried to stage her death as a suicide by sending messages to her mother from her phone. He also sent himself messages from Ms McGuire's mobile and transferred thousands of dollars out of her bank account. Defence barrister Glenn Casement told the jury it was conceded that Young killed Ms McGuire and his actions after her death were 'shameful'. But it was disputed that he held an intention to kill or cause her really serious injury, the barrister said. Intention was one of the four elements of murder the prosecution must prove beyond reasonable doubt before an accused is convicted. Mr Casement urged the jury to keep an open mind to the defence case. 'Be careful not to obtain a distorted picture of what was happening the day or two before her death,' he told the jury on Wednesday. As Justice James Elliott sent the jurors home for the day, he advised them to bring an umbrella and wear warm clothing for their trip to Scarsdale. The temperature is expected to dip to 7C on Thursday. Lifeline 13 11 14