French surgeon handed maximum sentence in mass child-abuse trial
In what is considered to be France's largest child-abuse trial, retired medical doctor Joël Le Scouarnec, 74, admitted to abusing a total of 158 male and 141 female patients with an average age of 11 between 1989 and 2014.
Prosecutors had accused the defendant of having treated his victims like lifeless objects, showing no empathy whatsoever, and exploiting his position as a doctor.
He often abused patients who were still under anaesthetic or children who were unable to classify his actions as abuse.
The public prosecutor had demanded a 20-year prison sentence, the maximum possible penalty for the defendant.
It said the number of victims was higher still. So as not to delay the trial, 299 cases were initially brought to court. There would probably be further criminal proceedings for other victims.
State of shock
The case has shocked France, and questions have been raised as to why the health authorities were unable to stop the doctor earlier, as he had been given a suspended sentence for child pornography in 2005.
The defence lawyer spoke of "a major failure" of France's health systems. He said that indications of misconduct had been trivialized and that the authorities had preferred to keep the doctor in his post.
Victims of the surgeon also denounced the failure of the authorities.
"How was Doctor Scouarnec able to practise for 30 years, how was he allowed to go about his business, why didn't anyone know?" a 36-year-old woman asked in court.
France's medical association admitted its own failings in the trial.
The doctor had been sentenced to 15 years in prison for four cases of abuse in 2020. The investigation was triggered in 2017 by a complaint from a neighbour whose 6-year-old daughter was abused by the doctor in the garden.
During searches, the investigators came across around 300,000 photos of child abuse as well as diaries in which the doctor had recorded his decades of abuse in great detail. With this information, the investigators set out to find the often unknowing victims that the surgeon met during his work in rural hospitals in western France.
Traumatized victims
Numerous victims spoke in court about the trauma and psychological damage caused by the abuse. Children who had not been aware of the abuse had also reacted subconsciously to the violence they suffered.
Experts diagnosed post-traumatic syndromes, inhibitions and physical complaints in the victims as a result of psychological stress.
In some cases, these only materialized after the investigators visited the victims and revealed to them that they had been abused in their childhood.
At the start of the trial, the retired doctor gave a comprehensive confession. "I committed heinous acts," he said. "I must bear the responsibility for my actions and the consequences for the victims, which they will carry for the rest of their lives."
Unexpectedly, the doctor later admitted in court that he had also abused his granddaughter, who at the time was 2 years old.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNBC
an hour ago
- CNBC
Trump promised Ukraine 'security guarantees': Here's what they could look like
On the face of it, talks on Monday between U.S. President Donald Trump and Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelenskyy and European leaders went well. The U.S. and Ukrainian leaders were pictured looking jovial and smiling together — a far cry from the extraordinary shouting match and public humiliation inflicted on Zelenskyy during his last trip to the White House in February. Monday's talks, which involved a raft of European leaders, appeared to make progress toward ending the protracted war between Russia and Ukraine, with Trump saying a meeting between Russian President Vladimir Putin and Zelenskyy would be arranged, followed by a trilateral meeting that he would join. The most significant development result for Kyiv and Europe, however, was Trump's statement that security guarantees for Ukraine would be "provided" by European countries in "coordination with the U.S." Describing that as a "major step forward," Zelenskyy said later that the package of security guarantees for Ukraine — highly coveted by Kyiv's leadership and seen as a deterrent to future Russian aggression — will include a massive purchase of American weapons, with financing reportedly supported by Europe. The agreement would be "formalized on paper within the next week to 10 days," he said. As for what the security guarantees could include, the detail is still scant. Trump commented at a post-talks press conference that Europe would "take a lot of the burden" for these, but said the U.S. would help and would make it "very secure." In any case, security guarantees likely mean that Europe, and the so-called "Coalition of the Willing" of countries offering to oversee a peace deal, is on the hook to fulfill what they've previously promised. French President Emmanuel Macron hinted Tuesday that the "first security guarantee we are working on — and it is the most important — is a strong Ukrainian army, composed of several hundred thousand men, well equipped, with defense systems and higher standards." "The second is to have reassurance forces, the British, the French, the Germans, the Turks, and others ready to carry out these operations — not on the front line, not in a provocative way, but reassurance operations in the air, at sea, and on land. The goal is to send a strategic signal: peace in Ukraine is also our concern," he told French broadcaster TF1-LCI, in comments translated by NBC News. Jaroslava Barbieri, research fellow at Chatham House, told CNBC Tuesday that the overall mood from the talks on Monday was one of "cautious optimism," but there are many unknowns. "However, we have to say that the Kremlin's maximalist demands on Ukraine have not changed and so there's still a number of uncertainties about the security guarantees, the details, who is going to be doing what, if there are any troop deployments then where will they be stationed and for how long, which countries will be contributing?" she asked. European leaders have voiced misgivings over the lack of a ceasefire between Russia and Ukraine before a peace deal is negotiated, but they seem willing to acquiesce, for now, with the end goal of peace and Ukraine and Europe's security in mind. Gabrielius Landsbergis, Lithuania's former foreign minister, told CNBC Tuesday that Europe still appeared to be struggling to be heard, saying the bloc had not yet found its strength and "ability to create leverage." "What came out of the meeting yesterday was that Europe was asking the U.S. yesterday to continue its assistance, to ask for a ceasefire, to assist any stationing of troops, and then some of the leaders were even saying, 'Well, some of the Ukrainian territories might be lost, but that's a reality.' Well, that doesn't sound like Europe finding it's strength," he said. "It's more like Europe agreeing that, 'we are in a very weak position and we have to please President Trump as much as we can and we have nothing to put on the table'," he noted. What's more, it's unclear whether the Kremlin will even agree to direct talks with Zelenskyy. Putin's presidential aide Yuri Ushakov stated Monday that Trump and Putin had discussed "that it would be necessary to study the possibility of raising the level of representatives of the Ukrainian and Russian sides," but that no firm decision was made. The proposed future summits between Trump, Putin and Zelenskyy would keep a process towards a possible resolution of the conflict alive, but it would still follow the Russian script of a no-ceasefire scenario, Holger Schmieding, chief economist at Berenberg Bank, cautioned. "Putin may already set difficult conditions for a meeting with Zelenskyy. And in a meeting with Zelenskyy, Putin's major goal may be to pin the blame for any failure on Zelenskyy instead of agreeing to a truce or a final deal. The outcome remains very uncertain," he noted.
Newsweek
3 hours ago
- Newsweek
'Nuclear Power': NATO Ally Issues Trump Credibility Warning Over Russia
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. French President Emmanuel Macron warned that the global credibility of the U.S. and its NATO allies is on the line in Ukraine, as President Donald Trump attempts to end the Russian invasion once and for all. There remain significant barriers to a settlement that ends the conflict, most notably on territorial control. Ukraine has consistently said it is constitutionally bound not to cede any of the fifth of its territory that Russia has seized. Kyiv and its European allies have urged Trump not to reward Russia for its aggression in Ukraine, saying it has broader consequences for security on the continent, fearing Moscow has similar ambitions elsewhere in the former Soviet sphere. "What's happening in Ukraine is extremely important for Ukrainian people, obviously, but for the whole security of Europe," Macron told NBC News's Kristen Welker in an interview after a multilateral White House meeting with Trump. "Because we speak about containing a nuclear power, which decided just not to respect international borders anymore. And I think it's very important for your country, because it's a matter of credibility. "The way we will behave in Ukraine will be a test for our collective credibility in the rest of the world." This is a developing article. Updates to follow.
UPI
6 hours ago
- UPI
Trump works to broker bilateral meeting between Putin, Zelensky
1 of 15 | President Volodymyr Zelensky of Ukraine meets President Donald Trump in the Oval Office of the White House in Washington, D.C., on Monday. Zelensky was joined by European leaders as he met with President Trump in an effort to end the war between Russia and Ukraine. Photo by Aaron Schwartz/UPI | License Photo Aug. 18 (UPI) -- President Donald Trump spoke with Russian President Vladimir Putin on Monday during a White House meeting with President Volodymyr Zelensky of Ukraine and said he will arrange a bilateral meeting between the two, within the next two weeks. The call came during Monday's negotiations between Zelensky, Trump and European leaders, who had gathered to discuss ending the war in Ukraine. Trump said the future meeting would be followed by a trilateral meeting, involving the United States. On Monday night, the White House posted an Oval Office photo of Trump on the phone with Putin, as Secretary of State Marco Rubio and Vice President JD Vance looked on. Trump said Vance, Rubio and Special Envoy Steve Witkoff would be involved in coordinating the meeting between Putin and Zelensky. President Donald J. Trump on the phone with President Putin in the Oval Office. The White House (@WhiteHouse) August 19, 2025 In a post on Truth Social, Trump said he "had a very good meeting with distinguished guests," which included Zelensky, French President Emmanuel Macron and British Prime Minister Keir Starmer, as well as much of the European delegation and NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte. "I called President Putin and began the arrangements for a meeting, at a location to be determined, between President Putin and President Zelensky," Trump said. "After that meeting takes place, we will have a Trilat, which would be the two presidents, plus myself. Again, this was a very good, early step for a war that has been going on for almost four years." Trump met with Zelensky earlier Monday afternoon to signal that the United States would provide Ukraine with "very good protection." "The security guarantees would be provided by the various European countries, with a coordination with the United States of America," Trump said. "Everyone is very happy about the possibility of PEACE for Russia/Ukraine." Macron called the U.S. commitment for Ukrainian security guarantees the "first and most important" outcome of Monday's talks. "Today, it was agreed that we will work with the United States of America on the content of these security guarantees and the cooperation that each party is prepared to provide," Macron said, adding that any meeting would have to take place under a cease-fire. "Call it a truce or a cease-fire, but we cannot hold discussions under bombs," Macron added. Trump told Zelensky at the start of the meeting: "I have a feeling you and President Putin are going to work something out. Ultimately, this is a decision that can only be made by President Zelensky and by the people of Ukraine working also together in agreement with President Putin. And I just think that very good things are going to come of it." By the end of the day, Zelensky told reporters he is ready for "any format" of a meeting with Putin and said he would also participate in a trilateral meeting if there is progress in the first one. "I believe unconditionally we should meet and think about the further development of this path of the war," he said. Zelensky told reporters that the security guarantees included plans for Ukraine to purchase $90 billion in American weapons through European funding. Zelensky also said he and Trump had a long discussion about a map in the Oval Office, showing Russian-occupied territories in Ukraine. Rutte said Ukrainian territory was not discussed during the broader Monday meetings. Zelensky arrived around 1 p.m. EDT on Monday along with several EU leaders. Trump and Zelensky sat in the Oval Office, mirroring their meeting earlier this year. This time, they avoided the dramatic shouting match from six months ago in the same space. During the February exchange, Trump and Vance accused Zelensky of being "disrespectful" toward the United States and the Trump administration. Zelensky was much more complimentary during Monday's meeting, immediately thanking Trump for his efforts to stop Russia's war. Vance, who was in the Oval Office, said nothing this time. The meeting came after Trump's summit with Putin on Friday in Alaska. European Council leaders are scheduled to meet via videoconference Tuesday to discuss the meeting. The council's president, Antonio Costa, called the conference, he announced on X Monday. "I have convened a video conference of the members of the European Council for tomorrow at 1 p.m. CEST, for a debriefing of today's meetings in Washington, D.C., about Ukraine," Costa wrote. "Together with the U.S., the EU will continue working towards a lasting peace that safeguards Ukraine's and Europe's vital security interests." European leaders, including Rutte, Starmer, Macron, German Chancellor Friedrich Merz, Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, Finnish President Alexander Stubb and European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, accompanied Zelensky to Washington for the talks.
