Public disquiet factor in Casey's removal from crypt
It also revealed that Dr Casey was formally removed from public ministry in 2007 by the Vatican, following allegations, which included his niece Patricia Donovan's complaint of child sexual abuse.
The Vatican restriction was never disclosed during Bishop Casey's lifetime.
Casey consistently denied all allegations against him, and he was never convicted of any sexual crimes.
He remained a bishop until his death in March 2017.
Although it was not widely known at the time, the funeral, which was attended by 1,600 people, was scaled back for a bishop whose greatest discretion known at that point was an affair with Annie Murphy who had a child by him.
The Papal Nuncio, the Vatican's representative in Ireland, did not attend.
Again, the presumption was that the man had sinned in the eyes of the church by fathering a child.
What emerged through the work of Ms Sheridan and the RTÉ team was that there were four allegations of child sexual abuse made against Casey, including by his niece Patricia Donovan, who claimed in the programme that she was groomed by her uncle and sexually abused by him from the age of five.
Another safeguarding allegation noted in the documentary did not meet Tusla's threshold of abuse.
The programme ended with footage of the former bishop's funeral and his burial in the crypt under Galway Cathedral.
The decision to place his remains in the crypt was one made by the Galway Diocese.
The documentary confirmed that it had records of child sexual abuse allegations against the former bishop.
Considering the Vatican requested that Bishop Casey was not to exercise public ministry for the last ten years of his life, the view of some contributors to the programme was that this was a significant sanction for a bishop.
The Vatican would have viewed the burial of Bishop Casey as a decision for the diocese, as would the Catholic hierarchy in Ireland at the time. Such a siloed approach is not unusual in the Catholic Church.
Therefore, consideration over Bishop Casey's remains in the wake of the allegations entering the public domain fell to the current Bishop of Galway Michael Duignan.
The Irish Daily Mail carried out a poll around a month following the documentary which showed that 60% of people aged 55 years and older felt that Bishop Casey's remains should be removed.
Patricia Donovan expressed her disbelief in the documentary over his burial in the crypt.
These kinds of burials are a symbol of the deceased's ongoing spiritual presence and connection to their diocese, even in death.
This practice is rooted in the Catholic tradition, where cathedrals are the principal churches of a diocese and the bishop's seat of authority.
Inundated with queries as to what he would do, Bishop Michael Duignan expressed his commitment in July last year to "working with anybody affected, to help bring truth, healing and peace to such terribly painful situations".
In this context, he said the interment of the remains of Bishop Casey in the crypt beneath Galway Cathedral was "a very sensitive issue that deeply affects people in different ways, and which has different facets".
He said it required a period of "careful consideration and consultation" and he requested "time and space" to "adequately and appropriately bring this undertaking to completion".
A year on, the Galway Diocese has confirmed that the remains have been removed.
It is not known when this occurred; however, the statement says that there were prayers for the dead, and his mortal remains were removed.
This was with the "assent and cooperation" of members of the late bishop's family who have requested privacy at this time. The remains have been entrusted to their care.
It is questionable how the Galway Diocese could have kept Bishop Casey's mortal remains at the cathedral indefinitely, considering the public disquiet over their presence.
The statement said: "Significant consensus emerged around the unique role of a Cathedral as a place of unity rather than division, healing rather than hurt and peace rather than disquiet."
The current Bishop of Galway Michael Duignan, who was born the year after Eamon Casey became Bishop of Kerry in 1969, is not speaking publicly about the decision.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
11 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Behind the Story: Charity hopes to give families answers to possible 'hidden homicides'
A charity established in Northern Ireland to help families who have questions about the tragic deaths of loved ones is investigating a number of cases in the Republic. These involve people whose deaths were ruled as accidental but their relatives have suspicions over what exactly happened to them. The Katie Trust was established in memory of Katie Simpson, a 21-year-old showjumper whose death in August 2020 was originally ruled as suicide. However, a year later, 36-year-old Jonathan Creswell, the partner of her sister, was arrested on suspicion of murder. His trial ended in April last year following his sudden death. A review by Northern Ireland's Police Ombudsman found the initial police investigation was flawed and had failed Katie Simpson's family. The detective who uncovered the brutal truth about her death is former detective James Brannigan who has now retired from the Police Service of Northern Ireland. Originally from Dublin, he told RTÉ's Behind the Story that he had founded The Katie Trust because families like Katie's deserve answers to what could be a "hidden homicide". "There was questions that needed to be answered surrounding Katie's death," he said. "Why did [Jonathan Cresswell] not call the ambulance, why did he try to drive her to the hospital, where's her phone? "These are simple questions that any investigator should ask". Mr Brannigan said flags were raised to him by family members and friends. "When you're dealing with an abuser, they will isolate the individual and a lot of these domestic murders you deal with are well-planned events. "It was friends who knew Katie and knew Creswell and knew how he was treating Katie that really had the real-life experience of what he was doing". Mr Brannigan said Creswell peddled a story that Katie had been trampled by a horse. "But when you saw her body, it was horrendous: all the bruises up her leg, up her arm… and her hands were like two boxing gloves – swollen and bruised. "I didn't buy it from the outset that a horse did this". Mr Brannigan said he started the charity in Katie's memory to "make sure this never happens again". "I've been just shocked by the amount of families coming forward; to date, we have 14 families who have come onboard," he said. "I've a number of cases coming from the Republic of Ireland. "The Minister of Justice has said they're going to meet with the charity and some of our trustees. "The Garda Commissioner is also trying to facilitate a meeting". 'Huge closure' Mr Brannigan said he believes the trust can help families of victims as well as the State. "It's not just going to assist families, but it's also going to assist the Department of Justice and the police." Mr Brannigan explained that the trust hopes to examine cases classified as suicides, accidents or disappearances and their family has concern over how their loved one died. "If we look at that and we can say to the family, 'we can see that there's no other hand involved in your loved one's death', that's going to give them huge closure," he added. In a statement to Behind the Story, the Department of Justice said: "Under Irish law, criminal investigations can only be carried out by An Garda Síochána, which then submits a report to the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP). "The DPP decides whether or not someone should be prosecuted and for what crime. By law, both the Gardaí and the DPP are independent in their functions and neither the Minister nor the Department can intervene or direct either organisation to prosecute any particular case."
Irish Post
13 hours ago
- Irish Post
Homicide detectives investigating after Irish woman found dead on boat in the US
HOMICIDE detectives are investigating the death of an Irish woman who was found dead on a boat in the United States. Suffolk County Police Department in New York state have identified the woman as 33-year-old Martha Nolan-O'Slatarra. According to RTÉ, Ms Nolan-O'Slatarra was originally from Co. Carlow but lived in Manhattan, having emigrated to the US nine years ago. She was the founder of fashion brand East x East, which was set up in 2021 and recently opened a pop-up in the upscale Hamptons resort. In a statement, Suffolk County Police Department revealed Ms Nolan-O'Slatarra was found deceased on Tuesday on a boat docked at the Montauk Yacht Club in New York. "Suffolk County Police Homicide Squad detectives are investigating after a Manhattan woman was found dead on a boat docked in Montauk this morning," said a police spokesperson. "East Hampton Town Police responded to a 911 call from a man reporting a woman unconscious on a boat docked at the Montauk Yacht Club, on Star Island Road, at approximately 12am. "Good Samaritans attempted to perform CPR on the woman. "Martha Nolan-O'Slatarra, 33, of Manhattan, was pronounced dead on the boat by First Responders. "The preliminary investigation and exam were inconclusive regarding the cause of death, which will be determined by an autopsy conducted by the Suffolk County Medical Examiner's Office." Ireland's Department of Foreign Affairs said it is aware of the case and is providing consular assistance. "As with all consular cases, the Department does not comment on the details of individual cases," added a spokesperson.
RTÉ News
16 hours ago
- RTÉ News
'Terrifying' - US man recalls being kidnapped in Haiti
A US citizen who was held for ransom by a gang in Haiti for 43 days has said negotiators will have a "hard time" pretending to Irish woman Gena Heraty's kidnappers that she is a "no one". Jeff Frazier said he lost 22.5kg while being held captive in 2023, while being provided with just a little food and water, which he described as "problematic". Mr Frazier said his "heart absolutely goes out" to her family. He described it as a "deeply jarring experience to go from free to captive, especially in such a terrifying environment, with guns in your face and lots of screaming". He said despite Ms Heraty "probably keeping her cool" due to being in intense environments while working in Haiti over the years, cortisol levels can get very high while being held captive. Speaking on RTÉ's Morning Ireland, Mr Frazier said: "I imagine within 72 hours you kind of settle with the idea of being captive, but it never goes away." He said that by now a fluent Haitian speaker would be established as the primary negotiator, with Ms Heraty's family and organisations associated with her liaising with the negotiator. He said he believed that the gang has already made its initial demands. "The negotiating team has for sure dismissed those and called them ridiculous and then the dance will begin," he said. He added: "Unfortunately, because the national and global press has picked this up already, she is going to have a hard time pretending she is no one". Mr Frazier added: "Luckily, my team hid me and scraped everything off the internet, quickly, and began the ruse of making sure that the gang thought that I was alone and had nobody to help me and wasn't going to get any money from the US." He stressed that the involvement of the Department of Foreign Affairs and Minister for Foreign Affairs Simon Harris can be a "good thing" but only if it is in secret. "Obviously it is not now (a good thing). The reason it can be good is that you can start leveraging non-monetary forms of persuasion. "Things that the gang may or may not want and you can get them quickly," he said. The only way to get out quick is to pay a large amount and even then, it is rare that they let you out, he said, adding that often the gang will "just make you pay again". "Many of the people that I was in with, we watched pay four or five times. "Luckily my team was wise to that and didn't fall prey. "We did pay once, that was a failed ransom attempt," he said. While he would not disclose the fee, Mr Frazier said it was a very small sum of money. On the publicity surrounding Ms Heraty's captivity, Mr Frazier said it increases the value of the hostages, which the kidnappers will use as leverage, either monetarily or non-monetarily. "However it got public was certainly a misstep," he said. He said not only "money talks" but "time talks", stressing that you can keep your amount low and leverage high if you have patience. "My team knew that there was no way of getting me out quickly. So, they kept saying very tiny numbers, $3,000, $4,000, $7,000 and over weeks, knowing that there was no way they were going to let me out before 30 to 60 days," he said. Mr Frazier said Ms Heraty and the other captives should remain hopeful, adding: "She will get out".
