St. Francis Schools hit with two lawsuits over controversial book policy
St. Francis Area Schools received two lawsuits over its book policy on the same day.
Education Minnesota St. Francis and ACLU Minnesota filed complaints on Monday.
Dozens of people protested the Library Materials Policy outside the district office.
ST. FRANCIS, Minn. (FOX 9) - St. Francis Area Schools (SFAS) received two separate lawsuits on Monday challenging the district's book policy.
The complaints allege the school district is banning books "unlawfully".
The backstory
The policy at the center of this controversy is the district's Library Materials Policy the school board passed last year.
The policy relies on a book ratings website called Book Looks to filter what books can make the district's library shelves.
Critics of the policy have taken issue with relying on a singular, outside source to decide what should be on the district's library shelves.
Supporters of the policy said it is in place to protect students from any harmful material.
Legal battle
Education Minnesota St. Francis filed a lawsuit on Monday alleging the district banning books violates state law by discriminating against certain viewpoints.
The union filed a complaint in Anoka County District Court on behalf of eight students in the school district. All eight students have parents who are teachers.
Education Minnesota said the purpose of the lawsuit is not to seek any monetary damages or attorney's fees, but to reverse the book bans.
The ACLU of Minnesota also filed a similar lawsuit against the school district on Monday.
"The St. Francis Book Looks policy is a particularly egregious violation of St. Francis students' constitutional right to free speech, to receive information, and to a uniform an adequate education," said Catherine Ahlin-Halverson, ACLU Minnesota attorney.
"We want the local ability to look at our books, decide which books are best for kids, have healthy conversations between parents, educators, and school board," said Ryan Fiereck, Education Minnesota St. Francis president.
What's next
Board Chair Nathan Burr said he is not able to comment on any details of the lawsuits at this time, but did confirm both lawsuits are being reviewed by the district's legal team.
Burr said the district is committed to transparency and addressing them thoroughly and appropriately.
The Source
St. Francis Area Schools, Education Minnesota, ACLU Minnesota
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
04-07-2025
- Yahoo
Rochester Public Schools is waiting to see the outcome from the $7 billion of federal funds in limbo
Jul. 3—ROCHESTER — Although The U.S. Department of Education has withheld nearly $7 billion in funding from schools across the country, it's not yet clear what kind of impact that will have for Rochester Public Schools. On June 30, the U.S. Department of Education sent a notification to state agencies, notifying them that the release of the funding was still under consideration. That update began sounding alarm bells for schools and education advocates alike. "This is not just a budget cut — it's an assault on the rule of law and our commitment to every child's right to a quality education," said Monica Byron, president of Education Minnesota, which is the statewide teachers union. "By withholding funding that Congress has already approved, the Trump administration is playing politics with our children's futures." According to the publication EducationWeek, the federal funding that has been withheld from schools amounts to $6.8 billion. RPS Communications Director Mamisoa Knutson said the district is monitoring the situation and "waiting to see what that means" for local programs. Although federal funding doesn't provide the bulk of Rochester Public Schools' budget, it still represents millions of dollars for the district. In 2024-25, federal funding comprised 4% of the district's budget, which amounted to $17.08 million. The Minnesota Department of Education provided a copy of the notification it received from the federal government to the Post Bulletin. According to MDE Communications Director Sam Snuggerud, the federal government issued an individual notice for the funding associated with each program. However, the notifications only differed in the name of the program. They read: "Given the change in Administrations, the Department is reviewing the FY 2025 funding for the [Title I-C, II-A, III-A, IV-A, IV-B] grant program(s), and decisions have not yet been made concerning submissions and awards for this upcoming academic year. Accordingly, the Department will not be issuing Grant Award Notifications obligating funds for these programs on July 1 prior to completing that review. The Department remains committed to ensuring taxpayer resources are spent in accordance with the President's priorities and the Department's statutory responsibilities." Even before the federal department issued the notice, state agencies were beginning to worry about the delay in the funding. On June 26, The Minnesota Department of Education sent a letter to its federal counterpart, asking when it could expect to receive information on the matter. MDE Commissioner Willie Jett's letter listed a number of programs that rely on the funding. They include those that aid English-language proficiency, support teacher development and retention, and provide academic enrichment opportunities "outside of school hours for students who attend low-performing schools." "At this writing, Minnesota has not received critical information for school districts to obligate federal funding in time for a July 1 deadline," Jet wrote in his June 26 letter. "While the most recent state tables posted on ED's website include updated figures, these programs are notably absent. Without this information, and with July 1 approaching, it is not possible for schools, districts, and the Minnesota Department of Education (MDE) to complete the steps needed to begin obligating these funds as scheduled."
CBS News
10-06-2025
- CBS News
St. Francis school district scraps book banning policy, will return titles to shelves
A lawsuit stemming from a book banning policy in the St. Francis school district has been settled, and the books will return to shelves. In March, Education Minnesota-St. Francis and the American Civil Liberties Union of Minnesota filed lawsuits after the district adopted a policy that removed librarians and teachers from the book approval process and replaced them with a website called "Book Looks." The website, which shut down in late March, was affiliated with Moms for Liberty, a group at the forefront of the conservative movement targeting books that reference race and sexuality. The website ranked the books from zero to five, with zero being "for everyone" and five being "aberrant content." If a book with a rating of three or above was challenged, the policy dictated that it would be removed from shelves, the ACLU said in its lawsuit. More than 30 books were removed from libraries and classrooms, including "The Bluest Eye," "Slaughterhouse-Five," "The Kite Runner," "Brave New World," "The Handmaid's Tale" and "Night." The school board accepted the settlement during its regular meeting on Monday. The education union agreed to drop the lawsuit and did not seek any financial damages. A new book policy in St. Francis will include input from teachers, librarians and student representatives. A review committee can only remove a book with a supermajority vote, and the school board can only overrule the review committee after publishing a report and acting in a public meeting. The new policy must also stay in place for at least three years. "We achieved this settlement because parents, students, our community and even Minnesota authors stood with educators to defend the freedom to read in public schools," said Education Minnesota-St. Francis President Ryan Fiereck. "The students' stories and commitment to fixing this terrible policy were particularly inspiring." WCCO has reached out to the St. Francis Area School Board for comment.
Yahoo
10-06-2025
- Yahoo
St. Francis schools to put banned books back on shelves
() St. Francis Area Schools will place banned books back on library shelves and rewrite its library policy to comply with state law, according to a settlement reached in a lawsuit filed by the teachers union. The district had banned hugely popular and celebrated books including 'The Handmaid's Tale,' 'The Perks of Being a Wallflower,' 'The Bluest Eye' and 'The Kite Runner,' among others. The settlement requires them to be returned to library shelves. Education Minnesota sued the district in March on behalf of students, teachers and parents, alleging that the district was violating state law by banning books based on their ideas, stories and characters. The American Civil Liberties Union also filed a separate lawsuit. In 2024, the Democratic-Farmer-Labor-controlled Legislature passed a law touted as a ban on book bans. The law does allow for books to be removed from shelves based on practical reasons, 'legitimate pedagogical concerns, including but not limited to the appropriateness of potentially sensitive topics for the library's intended audience,' and to comply with other state or federal laws. But school districts cannot remove books based solely on its viewpoint or the messages, ideas or opinions it contains. St. Francis Area Schools relied on a website called — which has ties to the right-wing group Moms for Liberty — to determine which books were subject to removal from school shelves. (Booklooks has since shut down, but a third-party organization is maintaining the website's catalog.) The St. Francis case provides a free speech victory following years of repression of books, especially those with themes about race, sexuality and gender. 'I think the book ban movement … it really has little to do with protecting children. It has everything to do with targeting books with diverse viewpoints that may not be in line with the reviewers' political or religious beliefs,' 'Kite Runner' author Khaled Hosseini told the Reformer in March. In the settlement with the teachers union, St. Francis Area Schools agreed to put the books back on shelves and create a new library materials policy that guarantees input from parents and qualified media specialists.
