St. Francis Schools hit with two lawsuits over controversial book policy
The Brief
St. Francis Area Schools received two lawsuits over its book policy on the same day.
Education Minnesota St. Francis and ACLU Minnesota filed complaints on Monday.
Dozens of people protested the Library Materials Policy outside the district office.
ST. FRANCIS, Minn. (FOX 9) - St. Francis Area Schools (SFAS) received two separate lawsuits on Monday challenging the district's book policy.
The complaints allege the school district is banning books "unlawfully".
The backstory
The policy at the center of this controversy is the district's Library Materials Policy the school board passed last year.
The policy relies on a book ratings website called Book Looks to filter what books can make the district's library shelves.
Critics of the policy have taken issue with relying on a singular, outside source to decide what should be on the district's library shelves.
Supporters of the policy said it is in place to protect students from any harmful material.
Legal battle
Education Minnesota St. Francis filed a lawsuit on Monday alleging the district banning books violates state law by discriminating against certain viewpoints.
The union filed a complaint in Anoka County District Court on behalf of eight students in the school district. All eight students have parents who are teachers.
Education Minnesota said the purpose of the lawsuit is not to seek any monetary damages or attorney's fees, but to reverse the book bans.
The ACLU of Minnesota also filed a similar lawsuit against the school district on Monday.
"The St. Francis Book Looks policy is a particularly egregious violation of St. Francis students' constitutional right to free speech, to receive information, and to a uniform an adequate education," said Catherine Ahlin-Halverson, ACLU Minnesota attorney.
"We want the local ability to look at our books, decide which books are best for kids, have healthy conversations between parents, educators, and school board," said Ryan Fiereck, Education Minnesota St. Francis president.
What's next
Board Chair Nathan Burr said he is not able to comment on any details of the lawsuits at this time, but did confirm both lawsuits are being reviewed by the district's legal team.
Burr said the district is committed to transparency and addressing them thoroughly and appropriately.
The Source
St. Francis Area Schools, Education Minnesota, ACLU Minnesota
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
20-05-2025
- Yahoo
Minnesota Legislature approves pension changes for teachers
May 20—ROCHESTER — The Minnesota Legislature has passed legislation that will allow Minnesota teachers to retire a little earlier, if they so choose. While it still needs the signature of Gov. Tim Walz, the bill, among other things, includes reform for teacher pensions, lowering the age at which educators can expect to begin their retirement. "This is a big victory for Minnesota teachers," said Denise Specht, president of the statewide teachers union Education Minnesota. "What we're doing with this bill is an opportunity to retire at the age of 60 with 30 years of experience." According to the Teachers Retirement Association, educators become eligible to retire as early as age 55. However, the size of their pension would be reduced by a percentage for every year between the time of their early retirement and the normal retirement age of 65. The TRA, however, stipulated that the reduction to their pension would be smaller if they were at least 62 years old with 30 years of service. With the passage of Monday's legislation, teachers are now able to take advantage of that same benefit two years earlier at the age of 60. Although there's still a reduction in the pension for retiring early, the penalty for doing so has also been reduced from 6% to 5% for those who qualify with their age and years of experience. Teachers and their school districts contribute to teacher pensions. As part of the new legislation, $40 million was also dedicated to the Minnesota Teacher Retirement Association, which is the organization that manages teachers' pension accounts. Teachers across the state have been advocating for pension reform for years. In 2023, the Legislature lowered the normal retirement age from 66 to 65. Teachers hired before July 1, 1989, have a career "Rule of 90," which allowed teachers to retire once their age and their years of teaching experience equaled that number. There has been an effort to amend legislation surrounding teachers' pensions in recent years, since teachers who began teaching after the change to the rule in 1989 are now reaching retirement age. Rochester Education Association President Vince Wagner said that although the new legislation is progressing in the right direction, there are teachers who would like to see even more reform to the system. "By no means are we done talking about pensions," Wagner said. "It's a step forward." Monday's legislation is the end result of teachers advocating for pension reform for years. "This victory could not have happened without the tens of thousands of educators who came together in union to write, call and rally for a retirement benefit that's fair, flexible and sufficient," Specht said in a statement. "This is what educators can accomplish when we work together." In addition to teachers' pensions, the bill also impacts public safety personnel. According to a press release from the Minnesota House of Representatives, personnel represented by the Public Employees Retirement Association police and fire, there will be "a three-year cost-of-living adjustment delay once they retire. A year would be taken off in the bill. They would also get a one-time 3% cost-of-living increase in 2026 and 1% annually thereafter. These changes come with a $17.7 million cost in each fiscal year. "At a cost of $2.3 million per year, every state patrol retiree would get a 1.25% annual cost-of-living increase — up from 1%," the release said.
Yahoo
17-05-2025
- Yahoo
Where things stand with just over 48 hours left of the Minnesota legislative session
Hundreds of Education Minnesota members gather in the Capitol Rotunda on May 17, 2025, to rally in support of improved pensions, pay and health care. Photo by Andrew VonBank/House Public Information Services. With just over 48 hours prior to the Legislature's mandatory adjournment midnight Monday, lawmakers are still struggling to resolve a few key issues as they aim for a two-year budget to fund everything from roads to schools, parks, health and social services. Several large budget bills have yet to be negotiated between the 67-67 divided House and the Democratic-controlled Senate — health and human services, education, a potential infrastructure package and a tax bill — i.e., the most complex and contentious. The lack of movement on these bills makes a special session all the more likely. Legislative leaders say they anticipate a one-day special session prior to Memorial Day, though it could be longer. Lawmakers have to pass a budget by June 30 or the government will shut down. Among the major sticking points: cutting MinnesotaCare for undocumented immigrant adults. Some rank-and-file, progressive Democrats broke with their leaders and Gov. Tim Walz and protested the budget agreement over the proposal and harshly criticized Democratic leadership for acquiescing to one of the Republicans' top priorities. House DFL Caucus leader Melissa Hortman, DFL-Brooklyn Park, appearing Friday on TPT Almanac, said Democrats will need to compromise given the divided government. 'People need to bend. They need to understand they won't get everything they want,' Hortman said. Rep. Cedrick Frazier, DFL-New Hope, who is also co-chair of the progressive People of Color and Indigenous Caucus, told reporters Saturday that the POCI Caucus doesn't plan to shut down the government over cutting MinnesotaCare for undocumented adults. 'We care about all the Minnesotans, and we're not willing to shut the government down, but we're willing to make sure we work very hard to ensure the Minnesotans get what they need,' Frazier said. Other contentious debates include potential changes to the state's new paid leave and earned sick and safe time programs and cuts to taxpayer aid for private schools. Walz has proposed cutting $109 million in aid that helps private schools with transportation, counseling and textbooks. The state has allocated this funding to private schools for decades, but Walz and Democrats are proposing the cuts amid a projected multi-billion dollar budget deficit beginning in 2027. On Thursday, House Speaker Lisa Demuth, R-Cold Spring, gave reporters the impression that private school aid would not be touched and presented this as a win for Republicans. 'We also know that we have made great strides in protecting the funding for non-public education. We are protecting our schools,' Demuth said. 'We are protecting our students so they can learn in the best way forward.' But cuts to private school aid are still in play, as far as a key DFL senator is concerned. Sen. Mary Kunesh, DFL-New Brighton, said that funding for private school aid wasn't part of the global budget agreement, and protecting public education is a priority for Senate Democrats. 'I understand the uniqueness and the value of non-public schools, but as the chair of the Education Finance Committee in the state of Minnesota, my priority is to fund public schools at the best rate and in the best way possible,' Kunesh said in an interview with the Reformer. A source with the House Republican caucus told the Reformer that there's 'no scenario where we will agree to' any cuts. Kunesh, who also serves as an assistant majority leader, said that the cuts to private schools are part of her education budget, and she anticipates this issue to be a sticking point in budget negotiations between members of the House and Senate — also known as a conference committee. 'We just have to remind those members also that we have that obligation to public schools first,' Kunesh said. In between the Senate and House floor sessions, Rep. Dave Baker, R-Wilmar, and Sen. Judy Seeberger, DFL-Afton, held a small press gaggle near the Capitol rotunda to tell reporters that significant changes to the state's paid leave and earned sick and safe time programs are still on the table, despite their absence from the legislative leaders' budget agreement. Legislative leaders agreed to reduce the paid leave payroll tax cap that the Department of Employment and Economic Development could implement each year from 1.2% to 1.1%. But since paid leave will launch in January with a 0.88% payroll tax split between employers and workers, the reduction does nothing to change the program as currently constituted. Baker said Demuth has given him her blessing to keep trying to implement paid leave changes in conference committee, though he didn't say what he would specifically look to change. Throughout the session, Baker has attempted to exempt small employers from the paid leave requirement. 'We're just trying to get (paid leave) right-sized a little bit,' Baker told reporters.
CBS News
01-05-2025
- CBS News
Education uncertainty for new leader of the Minnesota teachers union
For the first time in 12 years, the 84,000-member Minnesota teachers union, Education Minnesota, will have a new president. Monica Byron will be MEA's first president of color at a time when the president of the United States, Donald Trump, is warning of funding cuts unless all DEI programs are banned. Byron says Minnesota teachers will fight to keep DEI-focused programs. "Right now, we have support at the local level and the state level to continue to make sure that when it comes to inclusion and it comes to those types of programs that we will have support," says Byron. She also takes the helm as schools across the country have come under fire for low test scores in the aftermath of the pandemic. The latest test scores show just under 50% of Minnesota students are proficient in reading, just over 45% are proficient in math. Only 31% of Black students are proficient in reading and 21% in math. While critics, especially Republicans, say the current education system is failing students and families. Byron and MEA feel the low test scores result from a critical statewide teacher shortage, and more students are choosing to opt out of tests. "What we are seeing there are fewer students taking the test and that actually impact the proficiency score," said Byron. Byron says those new test scores also don't reflect the impact of the $110M READ Act, which calls for schools statewide to go back to teaching reading through phonics. Byron says teachers are still being trained. "I think the best practices help all students, so I am hopeful that it will help reach all of our students and especially our children of color," said Byron.
