Tim Winton among 100 high-profile Australians calling for university fees that don't ‘punish' arts students
It was at the Western Australian Institute of Technology, studying arts, that he wrote his first novel, An Open Swimmer, launching a four-decade writing career.
This was the 1980s, when a Labor government temporarily made higher education free to all Australians.
'Earning a humanities degree was not only life changing, in terms of opening up a world of knowledge otherwise beyond my reach, it also turns out to have been enormously productive – for me and many, many people around me,' Winton said.
'My little arts degree has created jobs and cultural value for over 40 years.'
Flash forward to 2025, and arts degrees have ballooned to cost in excess of $50,000, thanks to the Coalition's Jobs-Ready Graduate (JRG) scheme, introduced in 2021 to incentivise students into certain disciplines such as Stem (Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics), education and health.
Sign up: AU Breaking News email
While strongly condemned by Labor at the time, the Albanese government has deferred any reform to tuition fees to a newly established independent tertiary commission.
Winton is among more than 100 high profile Australians who have signed an open letter by the Australian Historical Association (AHA) urging Anthony Albanese to abolish the JRG scheme and implement an equitable university fee system that 'does not punish students who choose to study the humanities and social sciences'.
'That any Australian government should seek to make getting a humanities degree more difficult is upsetting … but the idea that a Labor government would do nothing at all to right this wrong is utterly mystifying,' Winton said.
'If Labor won't act to defend equity in education, what is the point of them – I mean, what do they really stand for?'
The signatories of the letter speak to the diversity of arts degree outcomes: writers Helen Garner, Kate Grenville and Nam Le; professional cook Stephanie Alexander; former cabinet minister and representative to Unesco Barry Jones; and former Australian of the Year, scientist Tim Flannery have all signed on.
Grenville, who has authored 19 books, said her own studies in history and humanities were 'absolutely essential' to the writing of her books, many of which take place in the early years of colonisation.
'Without those opportunities to explore both widely and deeply, I would not have written the books that have now become one of the ways general readers learn about our past,' she said.
Implicit in the introduction of JRG was the assumption students would be deterred from arts courses because of their price point, and attract them to cheaper degrees for 'in-demand' courses.
But the Universities Accord report, released last year, said the JRG package had 'failed', finding only 1.5% of students applied to enrol in courses that they would not have under the prior contribution arrangements.
'The job ready graduates package needs urgent remediation,' the report said.
'It has left some students facing extremely high student contributions and large Help debts that do not reflect their future earning potential, and it has tilted the overall cost burden of higher education further on to students.'
In its place, the review recommended a student contribution system based on potential lifetime earnings – the higher the future wages, the greater the student contribution.
Higher education expert Prof Andrew Norton said ideally graduates working full-time should complete repayments within similar ranges of years, regardless of which course they took.
'That is far from what happens under the current system … many arts graduates will struggle to ever get their debt under control,' he wrote in The Conversation on Wednesday.
Convener of the letter, AHA president Prof Michelle Arrow, said four years after its implementation the effects of JRG were beginning to play out in the numbers of staff being cut in humanities disciplines across the country.
Australian National University (ANU) proposed cuts include the Humanities Research Centre, the European Studies Centre and the Australian National Dictionary Centre, as well as significant reductions in the Australian Dictionary of Biography.
'For a thriving humanities infrastructure, you need people in the community, but you also need academics,' Arrow said.
'We're going to risk losing a whole generation of academics … these kinds of job cuts will continue while these fees are in place.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
PETER VAN ONSELEN: UN climate boss makes LUDICROUS claim about daily habit Aussies will be forced to give up because of warming - turning off the very people he needs to win over
When Simon Stiell, the UN's top climate official, warns Australians that unless we lift our game on emissions, fruit and veggies will become 'a once-a-year treat', you know he's jumped the shark. That kind of rhetoric may stir applause from activists who are already won over to the climate cause, but it risks turning off the very people who weigh up what practical action should look like. You don't have to be a climate change denier to fall into that category. Climate change is real, most people accept that. The science is sound, people know that too. The dangers posed by a warming planet are therefore not to be underestimated. But packaging the argument in short term apocalyptic headlines doesn't strengthen the cause, it weakens it. It sounds like activism, not expert analysis, and that distinction matters. When the debate becomes saturated with worst case scenarios and doom-laden predictions, most people dismiss those who deliver inflated rhetoric as lacking credibility. Stiell might believe he's spurring governments into action, but for mainstream voters, the ones who decide elections, this sort of messaging can feel more like an old fashioned guilt trip. It becomes counterproductive to the cause. Australia is preparing to update its 2035 emissions reduction target right when the Labor government has ambitions to co-host a global climate summit. And the UN's climate tsar seems to think fresh alarmism will spur Labor into more action. But that will not be the case if his sensationalising makes the government look like its plans are rooted in activism. Younger voters tend to be more inclined to listen to the alarmism, but the electorate is broader than one generation still finding their feet in life. The case for serious emissions reduction is strong, but it must be made with rigour. Suggesting fresh produce will become a luxury good - or that living standards are set to collapse without dramatic policy shifts in Australia - makes for a good headline but is poor public engagement. It risks framing climate policy as a punitive exercise rather than an economic and technological opportunity. It also ignores the reality that Australia is a very small emitter on the global stage even if our per capita emissions are too high. What we do, or don't do, matters little if the likes of China and India don't do much more than they currently are. There are plenty of nations in greater need of lectures than we are. Australians aren't oblivious to climate risks, but they are wary of poor policies, broken promises and emissions targets that are often costly and don't get met anyway. Voters want action that's credible, not utopian and dreamy. They also want costed plans, not alarmist lectures, especially in the context of rising energy prices and concerns about reliability. The Coalition is already highlighting the economic burden of the government's major emissions reduction policy - known as the safeguard mechanism - and other net zero policies. The public will want proper answers to a problem - not simplistic fear mongering. The credibility of climate action depends on public trust. That means being transparent about costs and benefits, about timelines, trade-offs and targets. It means avoiding exaggerated claims that can't be sustained if the short-term doesn't mirror the long-term projection. Just because opponents of climate action use fear and verbosity is no reason for advocates who claim to be on the side of science to dash their credibility by returning fire. If the government wants to be taken seriously at home and abroad, it should focus less on emotionally charged appeals and more on policy design that builds confidence. There's merit in the idea of setting ambitious targets with built-in flexibility, allowing for adjustments as new technology develops and economic conditions change. That's the kind of thinking that builds consensus and keeps momentum going. Those urging rapid decarbonisation, net zero within a decade, or 65 per cent emissions cuts by 2035 need to ground their calls in practical pathways. Without them, they risk pushing the conversation to the fringes. There's nothing wrong with urgency, but it should be channelled into persuading the undecided rather than trying to pressure them. If Stiell wants Australia to lead, avoid the junk threats. After all, science is already on his side.
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Donald Trump flags huge tariff hike that will impact Australia
Australian exporters may be hit with tariffs of up to 20 per cent at the US border, after President Donald Trump flagged a hike in the baseline impost. On Monday, the US President suggested countries that do not negotiate separate trade deals would soon be hit with a new minimum tariff up to twice as high. 'We are going to be setting a tariff, for essentially the rest of the world, and that's what they're going to pay if you want to do business in the United States,' he told reports at a press conference at his luxury golf resort in Turnberry, Scotland. Asked what the new rate would be, he answered: 'I would say it'll be somewhere in the 15 to 20 per cent range.' 'Probably one of those two numbers'. Trump floated broad-sweeping tariffs as a key election promise last year which, he claimed, would encourage more manufacturing firms to set up shop in the US. Australia is among the roughly 200 countries expected to be hit with the new baseline tariff despite its bilateral free-trade agreement with the US. Shadow Finance Minister James Paterson said the update shed new light on the need for the Australian Prime Minister to meet with Trump. 'I think there is enough evidence now in the public realm that we do have a problem in the bilateral relationship between Australia and the United States,' he told Sky News. 'It's more than 260 days since the president was elected, Anthony Albanese has still not sat down and met with him.' Mr Albanese sought to discuss the tariffs with Trump during their attendance at the G7 summit in Canada last month before the US President cut his trip short. Mr Peterson added it remained 'unclear' whether Ambassador to the US Kevin Rudd had yet to meet with the White House administration since Trump was sworn in in January. 'I suspect we would know about it if he had, I suspect it would be all over social media if he had, so I think it's a reasonable inference now that there has been no meetings.' For its part, the Albanese government has restated its opposition to the tariffs but has downplayed what it says about the two country's relationships. 'We are a country that relies on trade, we are a country with a very high proportion of jobs that rely on trade,' Assistant Treasurer Dan Mulino told Sky News. 'That remains the position of this government. So, we would rather a situation in which the world doesn't go down the path of imposing tariffs. 'But what I can say is that Australia remains in a situation where we've got as good a deal as anybody, and we continue to engage with the US Government intensely on these matters.' A spokesperson for Trade Minister Don Farrell said Australia would continue to engage 'at all levels' to advocate for the removal of the tariffs. 'Our position is unchanged – any tariffs on Australian goods are unjustified and an act of economic self-harm,' they said. It comes only days after Australia lifted its ban on importing US beef - eliminating a key reason cited by the Trump administration for its tariff on Aussie goods. Mr Albanese insisted the move was the outcome of a review that had been underway for years, but Trump's officials have celebrated it as a win for the president.
The Guardian
5 hours ago
- The Guardian
Morning Mail: Clare pledges childcare action, Harbour Bridge Gaza protest row grows, questions over Adani's tax bill
Morning everyone. The education minister, Jason Clare, has told Guardian Australia exclusively how he plans to use new powers as soon as possible to shake up the childcare sector after the shocking reports of abuse in Victoria and New South Wales. In other news, pro-Palestine protesters are digging in over plans to stage a rally on the Sydney Harbour Bridge, while our Full Story podcast asks if the outcry over pictures of starving children in Gaza is a tipping point. Plus, we ask why Adani doesn't pay corporate tax in Australia despite billions in revenue from its huge Queensland coalmine. Discrimination claim | Mary Kostakidis has asked the federal court in Adelaide to strike out an 'embarrassing' Zionist Federation of Australia racial discrimination claim on the grounds it fails to identify which race, ethnicity or nationality was offended by the former SBS journalist's social media posts about Israel. Meanwhile the Sydney lord mayor, Clover Moore, has said a pro-Palestine protest involving a march across the Sydney Harbour Bridge would be a 'powerful symbol'. Childcare crisis | The use of CCTV in childcare centres, a national register of teachers and mandatory child safety training are top of the agenda for a meeting of state and federal ministers, as governments race to respond to abuse in the early childhood sector. 'Missing' $22bn | Consumer price figures released tomorrow may determine whether a cautious Reserve Bank of Australia will give millions of mortgaged Australians a rate cut next month. Union anger | The NSW government is facing strong pushback against workers compensation changes designed to curb claims for psychological injury, with educators and the peak union group criticising the bill's failure to address underlying issues. Gaming backlash | Payment companies such as Visa, Mastercard and Stripe are facing public backlash for pressuring online gaming platforms to remove hundreds of games in response to a campaign from an Australian anti-porn lobby group. 'Dark day' | The French prime minister, François Bayrou, said the EU had capitulated to Donald Trump's threats of ever-increasing tariffs, as he labelled the framework deal struck in Scotland on Sunday as a 'dark day' for the EU. Here's an explainer about what the EU has agreed to and analysis on why they chose a deal over a trade war. 'Real starvation' | Two leading human rights organisations based in Israel, B'Tselem and Physicians for Human Rights, say Israel is committing genocide against Palestinians in Gaza and the country's western allies have a legal and moral duty to stop it. For the first time, Donald Trump acknowledged that there is 'real starvation' in the region and told Benjamin Netanyahu to allow 'every ounce of food' into Gaza. Aeroflot hack | The Russian airline Aeroflot was forced to cancel dozens of flights after a pro-Ukraine hacking group with a track record of claiming responsibility for hacking targets in Russia said it had carried out a cyber-attack. Meanwhile Donald Trump has given Vladimir Putin a 12-day deadline to cut a peace deal with Ukraine. Gallagher charged | The older brother of Oasis's Noel and Liam Gallagher has been charged with rape and other sexual offences, Scotland Yard has said. Spidey senses | David Attenborough's new series, Parenthood – to be shown on Channel Ten – will feature footage of a 1,000-strong pack of young African social spiders hunting prey in a game of 'grandmother's footsteps' during which they freeze in unison then eat all their mothers and elderly relatives alive. Is this the tipping point in Gaza? Guardian Middle East correspondent William Christou speaks to Reged Ahmad from Jerusalem about whether this moment is a tipping point in the Israel-Gaza war. Sorry your browser does not support audio - but you can download here and listen $ More than three years after Adani started extracting coal from its Queensland mine, the Indian conglomerate has paid zero corporate tax from its Australian project – and tax experts say it may 'never pay a cent'. Our business correspondent, Jonathan Barrett, investigates how it has happened. A new Australian biography of the mythologiser of the American west, Zane Grey, has uncovered the unlikely tale of how the ageing writer and keen fisher spent his final years chasing his dream of catching a great white – and explains why a caravan park in southern NSW bears his name. Sign up to Morning Mail Our Australian morning briefing breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters after newsletter promotion Swimming | Alexandria Perkins (pictured on right) has taken a bronze medal for Australia on day two of the swimming world championships in Singapore, while Canadian superstar Summer McIntosh continued her winning ways. Football | As the world of women's football moves on after England's dramatic Euro win, the Matildas prepare for tonight's draw for the Asian Cup which will be held in Australia in March. Cricket | Kevin Pietersen has defended Ben Stokes after the England captain was criticised for his reaction to India's decision to bat on in the closing stages of the drawn fourth Test at Old Trafford. Rugby union | Our correspondent on the Lions tour, Gerard Meagher, explains why the 12-hour train journey between Melbourne and Sydney is an essential part of the experience. Victorian farmers are 'furious' about plans to hand VicGrid the power to access farmland to build transmission towers, according to the Australian Financial Review. In an editorial, the Courier Mail says sneering from Sydney and Melbourne won't stop Brisbane from having its moment. A couple whose baby was stillborn at Cowra hospital have thanked nurses for managing to make the experience 'deeply meaningful', the Central Western Daily reports. Energy | Australian Clean Energy Summit in Sydney. Courts | Interlocutory hearing at 10.15am for the racial discrimination case brought by the Zionist Federation of Australia against Mary Kostakidis. Perth | Case management hearing at 11.15am for Linda Reynolds v Commonwealth. If you would like to receive this Morning Mail update to your email inbox every weekday, sign up here, or finish your day with our Afternoon Update newsletter. You can follow the latest in US politics by signing up for This Week in Trumpland. And finally, here are the Guardian's crosswords to keep you entertained throughout the day. Until tomorrow. Quick crossword Cryptic crossword
