Tongaat Hulett's journey to recovery: new leadership and challenges ahead
Gavin Dalgleish was appointed as CEO with effect from 1 June 2025, marking a significant step in the final phase of implementing the approved Business Rescue Plan and setting the stage for a seamless transition of Tongaat Hulett's business, assets, and people to Vision, the consortium acquiring the group.
Image: Supplied
Tawanda Karombo
Tongaat Hulett, the beleaguered South African agro-processing firm, is poised to emerge from the shadow of its tumultuous past, thanks to new leadership and a significant restructuring initiative.
Gavin Dalgleish, the company's new CEO, has expressed optimism about the path towards stability following a protracted period marked by scandals and heavy debt that once threatened its existence.
Dalgleish was appointed as CEO with effect from 1 June 2025, marking a significant step in the final phase of implementing the approved Business Rescue Plan and setting the stage for a seamless transition of Tongaat Hulett's business, assets, and people to Vision, the consortium acquiring the group.
In a recent interview, Dalgleish detailed the pivotal changes occurring at Tongaat Hulett, which has been under business rescue since an accounting scandal left it with debts exceeding R8 billion.
Following the acquisition by the Vision Group Consortium, led by seasoned African investors Robert Gumede and Rutenhuro Moyo, the company is now focusing on debt recovery, having recently settled its obligations with creditors.
'We need to restore the faith of our employees, we need to restore the faith of our creditors and all our stakeholders that we're now functioning as a business again, and we're a good place and a reliable partner to do business with,' Dalgleish told Business Report in an interview on Thursday.
Tongaat Hulett, however, will still be up against headwinds buffeting the South African and regional economic landscape. For example, upon exiting business rescue, the company will be up against rising imports of cheap sugar and currency volatility.
For Dalgleish, the company's recovery will not be quick paced. In fact, he expects the rest of this year to be tougher for Tongaat Hulett.
'Like any other business, we're facing headwinds of a strengthening rand, reduced world market prices of sugar, and imports that flow from that. So for South Africa we're expecting this year to be a slightly tougher year,' he said.
Tongaat and the Vision Group principals recently went on a roadshow to meet stakeholders in KwaZulu Natal, Zimbabwe and Mozambique. During those trips, the company explained to stakeholders the new approach to doing business.
Dalgleish said together with the Vision principals, the company had sought to 'win back their (stakeholders) trust' and confidence as investors and as a business.
Tongaat employs 2 400 people and 25 000 others across the extended value chain.
Dalgleish said he felt overwhelmed by the responsibility he carries on behalf of the employees, value chain stakeholders and others linked to the company. He said sustaining jobs for those employed and impacted by the company was a top priority under his leadership.
'I'm excited by the challenge and the opportunity, as I said, I'm pleased with the the resilience of the people and the business that we found. And because of the social economic impact of the business, I have a great sense of responsibility.'
After fully settling outstanding obligations to the company's lenders as of 9 May 2025, the finalisation of the asset transfer to Vision Group 'is expected imminently,' the company said at the beginning of this month, underscoring 'Tongaat Hulett's progress toward financial and operational' recovery.
Last year, creditors in Tongaat voted in favour of a business rescue plan put forward by Gumede's investment consortium, Vision.
This was after an accounting scandal rocked Tongaat Hulett, with the company tail-spinning into a debt of R8.2 billion, prompting shareholders to adopt an amended business rescue plan.
Tongaat Hulett is envisioned to continue playing critical roles in the economic fabric of Southern Africa under its new ownership.
In South Africa, the business 'remains a cornerstone of the sugar industry, sourcing cane from 15 000 small-scale growers – thereby sustaining local farming communities, and underpinning numerous rural economies,' especially in the KwaZulu-Natal province.
In Zimbabwe, Tongaat Hulett owns two operating businesses, Triangle and separately listed Hippo Valley Estates. Triangle said recently that it was facing operational challenges that had forced it to retrench employees after cost cutting measures failed to yield a respite.
BUSINESS REPORT
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
an hour ago
- The Citizen
Are lay-by graves un-African? Cultural clash over burial solution
For residents considering lay-by grave services, existing consumer protection laws provide important safeguards. As Johannesburg grapples with a shortage of burial space, a new industry offering lay-by grave services has emerged – but cultural leaders are asking whether this modern solution fundamentally contradicts African traditions and values. The City of Johannesburg faces an escalating burial space crisis, with several cemeteries approaching or reaching full capacity despite earlier projections of adequate space for decades. This shortage, driven by population growth, urban migration, and cultural resistance to cremation, has forced the city to actively promote alternative burial methods, including cremation and reburials. In this gap, companies like Calgro M3 Memorial Parks, have stepped in. It offers what it calls 'dignified funerals and easy to afford burials' through lay-by monthly payment plans ranging from R500 to R1 625. The company operates cemeteries across Bloemfontein, Fourways, Nasrec, Durbanville, and Enokuthula Springs, with plans for a Randburg facility. When The Citizen attempted to contact Calgro M3 for comment, the company engaged in a week-long series of evasive responses, delaying any meaningful communication before stating on Thursday that their designated spokesperson was unavailable, with no timeline for a response. ALSO READ: Westpark Cemetery limits burials as it is set to reach capacity in four months The grave cultural resistance But the concept of purchasing burial services in advance has sparked fierce opposition from traditional leaders who question whether such practices align with African cultural values. Chief Mathupha Mokoena, President of Contralesa, has been particularly vocal in his criticism. 'Contralesa is aware of strange things that are contrary to our usual practices that relate to how we conduct funerals in our country, South Africa,' Mokoena stated. 'The question of memorial parks, including pre-paid burial sites, is foreign in our culture.' Mokoena argues that these services represent a fundamental departure from traditional practices, suggesting they transform burial customs into commercial enterprises. He contends that paying for burial arrangements in advance violates core African cultural principles. 'Paying for burial rites in advance, even buying a coffin in advance, is totally against our cultural norms and practice as Africans,' he explained. 'By doing this, we are directly inviting bad luck and curses that might follow those who are remaining behind.' The traditional leader warns that such practices could have severe spiritual consequences for families, describing potential 'strange things' that 'cannot be healed and will cause pain to members of the family.' His organisation has called upon communities to resist what they view as foreign influences on traditional burial practices. ALSO READ: Damaged graves: JPCZ urges residents to check resting places of loved ones Expert analysis on lay-by graves' cultural impact Cultural expert Isaac Muthethwa offers additional perspective on why these modern burial arrangements conflict with traditional African customs. However, he also states that such practices are not significantly different from paying for funeral cover, Muthethwa says Africans are not even supposed to be using coffins because of the belief that the body must go back to the soil. He explains that the practice of preparing graves in advance goes against fundamental beliefs about death and the afterlife. His concern extends beyond the spiritual realm to practical family dynamics. Muthethwa argues that investing in death-related expenses while alive diverts resources from living family members who might need support for education, healthcare, or other essential needs. He observes a troubling shift in community priorities, where people plan extensively for death while neglecting to celebrate life's milestones. 'When people are buying cars cash, you are bringing your best respected funeral cover so that everybody can see that 'this is how you buried your mom', but the following day the family is hungry because the money was meant for the burial and not for living,' he explained. City's regulatory framework Despite the cultural controversy, the City of Johannesburg recognises memorial parks as legitimate businesses operating within established regulatory frameworks. Jenny Moodley, spokesperson for Johannesburg City Parks and Zoo, confirms that private cemeteries must comply with municipal bylaws and national environmental regulations. 'Memorial parks that operate as private cemeteries within the City of Johannesburg are recognised and are required to comply with all applicable municipal bylaws and national regulations,' Moodley stated. The city requires proper zoning and adherence to health, environmental, and town planning regulations. Regarding Calgro M3 specifically, Moodley notes that the company has received necessary approvals and currently faces no formal complaints. 'The City is aware of Calgro M3 Memorial Parks as one of the private operators currently offering memorial park services within Johannesburg,' she confirmed. Officials emphasise that while these services are legal, consumers should conduct thorough research before committing to pre-paid burial arrangements. ALSO READ: Cemetery crisis: Burial space is shrinking Consumer protections and rights For residents considering these services, existing consumer protection laws provide important safeguards. The Consumer Protection Act ensures that lay-by payments remain the consumer's property until full payment is completed, with specific provisions for refunds and compensation if services cannot be delivered. Companies must maintain payment security and provide either equivalent alternatives or financial compensation if burial services become unavailable. In cases where unavailability results from supplier fault, consumers are entitled to double compensation. For residents considering pre-paid burial services, city officials recommend thorough research and due diligence. Moodley advised consumers to 'verify that the memorial park is legally zoned as a cemetery, compliant with City bylaws, and that the service provider is registered and transparent about its terms and conditions.' Under Section 62 of the Act, retailers must safeguard both consumer payments and reserved goods with appropriate care and diligence. If goods become unavailable, companies must offer consumers equivalent or superior alternatives or provide refunds with interest. In cases where unavailability results from the supplier's fault, consumers are entitled to double their payment amount as compensation. ALSO READ: Do you purchase goods on lay-by? These are your rights as a consumer A question of cultural evolution The debate over lay-by graves raises broader questions about cultural adaptation in modern urban environments. While practical pressures demand innovative solutions to genuine infrastructure challenges, the strong opposition from cultural leaders highlights the complex relationship between tradition and necessity. Some might argue that urban realities require pragmatic approaches to age-old challenges, while others contend that certain cultural principles should remain inviolate regardless of practical pressures. The question remains: can traditional burial practices evolve to meet contemporary urban needs while maintaining their essential cultural and spiritual significance? As Johannesburg continues to wrestle with its burial space crisis, the tension between modern solutions and traditional values reflects a broader challenge facing rapidly urbanising African communities. Muthethwa says whether lay-by graves represent a necessary adaptation or an unwelcome departure from cultural norms may ultimately depend on how communities themselves choose to balance practical needs with cultural preservation. READ NEXT: Criminals vandalise cemetery in search of valuables
Daily Maverick
3 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
Two-pot withdrawals reveal debt strain and the evolving role of employee benefits
Workplace financial stress is growing — and Two Pot withdrawal data may be the clearest indicator yet. Employers and HR professionals have typically relied on engagement surveys and exit interviews to gauge employee needs. However, the introduction of South Africa's Two-Pot retirement system offers a new, largely untapped source of insight: fund withdrawal patterns. According to Old Mutual Corporate's 2025 Two-pot Withdrawal Survey, nearly eight in ten employees who accessed the new 'savings pot' did so either to repay debt or to cover basic living costs. Of those surveyed, 45% used the funds to service loans, while 35% withdrew to cover essentials like groceries, school fees, and housing. 'The spike in early savings access is a window into the everyday struggles of the workforce,' said Blessing Utete, Managing Executive at Old Mutual Corporate Consultants. 'When employees are dipping into long-term savings just to make ends meet, it reflects how precarious their financial situations are. 'Two-Pot withdrawal rates present an opportunity to reassess employee support, recognising workers as individuals balancing financial, emotional, and family responsibilities — not just as salary earners.' Utete warns the risk isn't just that financially stressed employees will leave in search of better pay — it's that the ones who stay may be too overwhelmed to perform. 'Debt isn't just a personal issue. It's a performance issue,' he said. 'When employees are fighting just to get through the month, they often don't have the energy, focus, or capacity to deliver their best at work.' The Missing Conversation in the Workplace Despite widespread financial stress among South African workers, employers are still struggling to provide meaningful support. 'While employee benefits strategies often focus on long-term issues like retirement, many employees are grappling with immediate challenges, limited practical solutions, and inconsistent access to financial guidance,' he says. This was a key topic in Utete's podcast, where he discussed how integrated financial wellbeing is often overlooked in the workplace. 'People are expected to take charge of their financial stability — but when the only support they receive is geared towards distant outcomes, it sends the message that their day-to-day struggles don't matter,' says Utete. 'That kind of disconnect erodes trust. Employees start to feel like leadership is out of touch with their reality — and that's when engagement, loyalty, and performance begin to suffer.' Even when employers express an interest in financial wellbeing, workplace initiatives often fall short because they're too generic, too technical and clouded by a lack of cultural relevance — making it difficult for employees to act on what they're told. What a Modern Benefits Strategy Looks Like To address these challenges effectively, Utete says employers need to shift from compliance-based benefits to integrated, human-centred strategies that prioritise immediate financial resilience over abstract future promises. 'If we don't account for that in how we design support structures, we're ignoring the reality of modern working life,' he says. This means that, in addition to offering well-managed retirement and risk benefits, employers should also provide access to relevant, practical financial education and coaching, focused on budgeting, debt literacy, and everyday money management. Innovative debt assistance interventions, such as Old Mutual Corporate's Right Track solution, that helps employers uncover unlawful garnishee orders, unlawful deductions, and curb debt collector harassment. Flexible salary solutions, such as Smart Salary, offer early access to earned wages, allowing employees to responsibly manage their finances before payday and reducing reliance on credit or potentially expensive payday loans. Tools to help employees avoid debt review — which can restrict access to formal credit during the rehabilitation period — and resolve debt challenges without being excluded from the financial system. Integrated health and mental health support, integrated with financial wellbeing where appropriate to promote positive mindset and decision-making Creating a Supportive and Resilient Workforce By focusing on these immediate, practical solutions, employers can begin to address the underlying financial pressures that employees face. This shift goes beyond reactive measures, fostering a more supportive and resilient workforce and ensuring that employees have the tools they need to manage life and thrive both personally and professionally. While the Two-Pot system was introduced to improve long-term savings behaviour, it's now doing something more immediate: providing a window into workforce stress that traditional HR tools have missed. 'Withdrawal rates from long-term savings are a new kind of business intelligence — a signal that tells you who might be struggling and what kind of support your employees need,' concludes Utete. 'Employers who act on that intelligence — by building better, more relevant employee benefits strategy— are not just helping employees save for the future. They're improving focus, energy, and performance today.' our website. About Big Business Insights Big Business Insights is a thought-provoking podcast designed for business leaders, decision-makers, and industry professionals seeking a 360-degree perspective on leadership, employee benefits, and workplace transformation. Hosted by Blessing Utete, Managing Executive at Old Mutual Corporate Consultants, the podcast features expert guests, including Fatima Vawda, founder and CEO of 27Four and Director of the Association of Savings and Investments South Africa, and Mlamuli Mbambo, MD of Money Fundi, a financial education speaker, coach, and author. In the episode mentioned in the article, they discuss the challenges surrounding employee engagement with financial wellness programmes and how employers can address these issues to better support their workforce. DM
The Citizen
3 hours ago
- The Citizen
Industry leaders launch market surveillance code as Steinhoff fallout lingers
Aims to uphold integrity and prevent abuse, anti-competitive behaviour, and insider trading. FSCA investigators spend about 20% of their time assisting foreign regulators, including gathering trading records and financial data. Picture: Moneyweb The Financial Sector Conduct Authority (FSCA) has had to manage some of the most complex market abuse cases in the past eight years, including Steinhoff, regarded as the country's biggest corporate scandal to date. 'It's really been challenging,' says Alex Pascoe, head of market abuse at the FSCA. 'From December 2017, when Steinhoff announced accounting irregularities and its CEO Markus Jooste resigned, everything spiralled.' Pascoe was speaking at the launch of the South African Market Surveillance Code of Conduct in Cape Town on Tuesday, where he gave an account of the regulator's most prominent cases. The newly launched code of conduct is a joint initiative by South Africa's key financial institutions and regulators to align the country's market practices with global best standards. It aims to uphold market integrity and prevent abuse, anti-competitive behaviour, and insider trading. Although it does not replace existing regulations, it reinforces accountability from all market participants. ALSO READ: FSCA juggling high-profile cases with limited resources Case load Pascoe notes that the FSCA receives roughly 42 to 45 market abuse cases per year, but finalised 78 cases in its last financial year by implementing a World Bank-recommended case selection framework. Pascoe reflected on how the fallout from Steinhoff forced the FSCA to re-evaluate how it allocates investigative capacity. 'Everybody knew Jooste was Steinhoff, and Steinhoff was Jooste,' he says. 'From there on it spiralled – Viceroy and Tongaat [another accounting scandal], a mini-Steinhoff followed. It took a lot of resources to manage those cases, especially since they involved cross-border transactions.' (The Viceroy case refers to the FSCA's investigation into the US-based short-selling firm Viceroy Research, which was fined R50 million for publishing false and misleading statements about Capitec. The Tongaat accounting scandal involved the manipulation of financial statements by senior executives at sugar producer Tongaat Hulett to overstate the company's assets and profits.) ALSO READ: Secrecy surrounded Jooste's big FSCA fine and arrest warrant Jooste a 'brilliant' schemer The Steinhoff investigation is far from over. 'Last year we issued fines to Markus Jooste [of] R495 million. We are looking at his deceased estate and assets around the world,' said Pascoe. 'We won't just leave it at that. Ill-gotten gains – be [he] dead or alive – that's how serious we are. We are seeing this right through.' (Jooste, who faced multiple charges of fraud and racketeering and hefty fines from the JSE and the FSCA for financial misconduct, fatally shot himself in Hermanus in March 2024.) The South African Reserve Bank has already attached R1.4 billion in assets belonging to Jooste, but the global search continues. 'Most of his funds were hidden overseas,' says Pascoe. He adds that a second investigative report into Steinhoff is underway and has been shared with the commercial crimes court. 'Once preliminary findings are in, they [respondents] could make submissions.' Reflecting on lessons learned from Steinhoff, Pascoe says be on the lookout for a dominant CEO. The way Jooste set up the schemes was brilliant. ALSO READ: FSCA fines Markus Jooste R475 million, refers case to Hawks 'Only certain individuals knew what he wanted them to know. Nobody had the full picture.' He adds that Jooste's devices were wiped every two weeks, and hardly anything was documented. Steinhoff's complex global structure, multiple acquisitions, and lack of transparency made it difficult for stakeholders to understand the company's financial position. 'It was difficult to keep up and understand how everything fitted in,' says Pascoe. He also points to poor internal controls and captured auditors in Europe as contributing factors. 'The audits were not up to standard. And then, the culture of not questioning management.' FSCA investigators spend about 20% of their time assisting foreign regulators, including gathering trading records and financial data. 'We're getting requests from all over the world – Sweden, Belgium, even Pakistan,' said Pascoe. 'A lot of suspicious transactions are from overseas, and no longer from the JSE.' ALSO READ: Who will pay Markus Jooste's R510 million penalties now? Shadow trading The need for international collaboration was echoed by Tony Sio, head of regulatory strategy and innovation at Nasdaq's Anti-Financial Crime division, who also spoke at Tuesday's event. Sio shared developments in market abuse investigations, including a growing focus on shadow trading – a form of misconduct that remains largely unprosecuted but which are increasingly on the radar of regulators. 'Shadow trading is where insider traders don't trade in the companies themselves, but in economically-linked securities,' Sio explains. Although the practice started as a hypothetical scenario in an academic journal published in 2020, it is now being observed in market data. 'We found increases in volumes of linked securities before acquisitions.' He cites the 2021 case where the executive of a pharmaceutical company learned of an imminent takeover and used the information to buy options in a rival company likely to benefit from the news. 'His options doubled in value in one day. He thought he was smart by not buying in the company itself – but he was found liable.' ALSO READ: We can't afford another Jooste from Steinhoff Robust market surveillance attracts global investment Happy Shihau, head of compliance at Investec Corporate and Institutional Banking, who facilitated discussions at the launch event, stresses that the newly launched market surveillance conduct code complements – rather than replaces – regulatory rules and directives. Shihau says robust market surveillance is essential to attracting global investment. 'Investors worldwide seek to engage with trusted financial markets, and robust market surveillance is essential for upholding that trust.' She adds that the new code will help reinforce the regulatory environment and promote responsible behaviour across the industry. This article was republished from Moneyweb. Read the original here.
