Report: 16 teams supported Packers' tush push proposal
The Packers made a flawed proposal aimed at neutralizing the tush push. It nevertheless won support of half of the league.
Kalyn Kahler of ESPN.com reports that 16 teams supported Green Bay's submission, which would have banned players from 'immediately' pushing the player who receives the snap. While that number fell eight votes short of the minimum needed to change the rules, the 50-50 split confirms that the debate is very real — and that, when the owners gather again in May, it could go either way.
Still, at least half of the teams that weren't prepared to vote for the Packers' proposal will need to change their minds for the status quo to be altered.
The problem could very well be the formulation of Green Bay's proposal. That rule would have cracked open a separate can of worms for the league regarding the proper way to officiate the play, introducing subjectivity and potential inconsistency from crew to crew regarding whether a push was, or wasn't, immediate.
And if, for instance, a flag is thrown to nullify a key tush push touchdown when the shove arguably wasn't 'immediate,' the league would have to deal with criticism of the officials that could morph into claims from the tinfoil-hat crowd that the fix is in.
The question becomes whether it makes sense to rewind the clock to 2005 and prohibit all pushing of a ballcarrier. The rule changed because downfield shoving of a player who was fighting for more yardage was never called. No one realized 19 year ago that this would eventually morph into the dilemma with which the stewards of the sport are now wrestling.
A complete ban on pushing the player with the ball would become much easier and cleaner to officiate. And while there could be instances where an offensive lineman rumbles to the pile and gives a healthy shove without a flag being thrown, it would eliminate the strategic use of pushing and shoving as an affirmative strategy at the line of scrimmage.
It all comes down to whether 24 owners will get behind the idea of keeping teammates from getting behind the quarterback and ramming him past the line to gain or the goal line. A complete ban on pushing would more directly and conclusively solve the problem, with no need for the officials to determine whether or not a shove was 'immediate.'
An answer is coming before Memorial Day. Which, in the grand scheme of things, is about as immediate as it could happen.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
5 hours ago
- Yahoo
Former NFL Kicker and SMU Great Unexpectedly Dies at 65
Former NFL Kicker and SMU Great Unexpectedly Dies at 65 originally appeared on Athlon Sports. Former Green Bay Packers kicker Eddie Garcia passed away at his home in Poygan, Wisconsin last week. He was 65. Advertisement The tenth-round pick in the 1982 NFL Draft spent three seasons with the Packers. While at SMU, Garcia earned first-team All SWC honors in 1980 and was a second-team AP All-American in 1981 for the Mustangs. As of the 2024 season, Garcia ranks 5th all-time in career points for SMU with 262 (130 PATs and 44 field goals) Garcia kicked in 19 NFL games over the 1983 and '84 seasons, making three of nine field goal attempts. In his first season, he handled the kickoff duties while Jan Stenerud kicked field goals and extra points. In 1984, Garcia was the kicker for seven games until he injured his hamstring and was placed on injured reserve. He was waived following the season, according to the Packers. Related: SMU's Rhett Lashlee Admits the College Football Playoff Made an Error Garcia was elected to the Packers' board of directors in 2021 and served on the sales and marketing and Green Bay Packers Foundation committees. This story was originally reported by Athlon Sports on Jun 11, 2025, where it first appeared.
Yahoo
11 hours ago
- Yahoo
Jordan Love Taps Emerging Packers Weapon For Major 2025 Role
Jordan Love Taps Emerging Packers Weapon For Major 2025 Role originally appeared on Athlon Sports. The Green Bay Packers ranked as a top-10 offense last year in EPA per play, per pass, and rush, even though Jordan Love dealt with knee and groin injuries. Additionally, the receivers struggled to get open against man coverage and hold onto the ball, which did not help either. Still, the entire group needs to improve significantly if the Packers want a real shot at competing for a Super Bowl in 2025. Advertisement 'To me all those guys understand, they're competitive. As we've gone through, we have conversations about what we need to improve on,' Packers receiver coach Ryan Mahaffey said this offseason. "Those guys have an understanding that hey, when my number's called, I want to put myself in a position to be able to go out and help my team, they're naturally competitive. They take a lot of ownership in that, and I think we've got an intrinsically motivated group." Green Bay should be hopeful their receiving corps can bounce back from a disappointing 2024 season. Still, the passing game could soon have a new top target, as Jordan Love is eager to get his starting tight end more involved. Green Bay Packers TE Tucker Kraft (85) is tackled by Miami Dolphins LB Tyrel Dodson (11) after a short reception© Mark Hoffman / Milwaukee Journal Sentinel / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images While speaking to reporters on Tuesday, Love mentioned that Tucker Kraft will be a key focus of the offense moving forward. Advertisement "A big part of going into this season is finding ways to continue getting Tuck the ball. Get him as many touches as we can in a game," Love said, per the Packers Wire's Zach Kruse. "He's a dynamic playmaker. That's going to be a focus." Kraft caught 50 passes for 707 yards and seven touchdowns last season. He played 97% of the snaps in the Packers' 22-10 Wild Card loss to the Philadelphia Eagles, even though it was Luke Musgrave's fourth game back from injury. He was one of the most reliable playmakers in Green Bay's offense in 2024, and his workload should only increase going forward. The Packers have a sense of urgency to compete for a championship in 2025, and for Kraft, that means becoming the best version of himself to help elevate Jordan Love and the rest of the offense. If all goes to plan, he should see plenty of targets and let his talent take care of the rest. Advertisement Related: Former Packers $21 Million Star Named Potential Replacement For Jaire Alexander This story was originally reported by Athlon Sports on Jun 11, 2025, where it first appeared.
Yahoo
12 hours ago
- Yahoo
Packers Announce Sudden Death of Beloved Legend Eddie Garcia
Packers Announce Sudden Death of Beloved Legend Eddie Garcia originally appeared on Athlon Sports. He only played two seasons with the Green Bay Packers, but his impact has persevered well past his playing days. Advertisement Drafted by the Packers in the 10th round of the 1982 NFL Draft, kicker Eddie Garcia's career was cut short by a hamstring injury, prompting a transition into a career in marketing and sales that eventually brought him back to the Packers organization as a board member. On Tuesday, June 10, the Packers announced that Garcia had passed away on June 5. He was 65. The cause of death was not disclosed in Garcia's obituary, published originally by The Green Bay Gazette, but it did say his death was unexpected. "His sudden departure leaves a lasting void for his family, but they are comforted in knowing he is at peace in heaven with his loved ones who departed before him," the obituary states. Advertisement As the senior director of Oshkosh Corporation's Oshkosh Defense division, Garcia facilitated the Packers Military Appreciation Game sponsorship as a way to honor service members and veterans. "It was often joked that Eddie could sell ice to a penguin in relation to his sales talents, but at the end of the day he was most proud to build relationships with our country's active duty military, forming many lasting friendships along the way," the obituary states. Outside of work, Garcia "loved to travel the world, and then relax in Florida during the cold winters with his wife of 40 years and partner in adventure, Jill," the obituary said. Related: Packers Honor Mason Crosby With Powerful 8-Word Tribute Related: Packers Attempted To Trade Two-Time All-Pro To AFC Powerhouse This story was originally reported by Athlon Sports on Jun 11, 2025, where it first appeared.
