Orange, Osceola boards rebuff Split Oak Forest defenders' last-ditch pleas
Defenders of Split Oak Forest tried but failed Tuesday to persuade Orange County government to take legal action to halt construction of a toll road through the public land's southern wedge.
Forest advocates insist Orange County has grounds to oppose the highway, even though it sits solely in the Osceola County portion of the preserve. County lawyers say they don't.
Without a lawsuit to stop it, the Central Florida Expressway Authority seems set on its preferred route to run a 1.3-mile leg of the Osceola County Parkway through the forest. CFX already has planted stakes outlining the path, and on Monday Osceola County commissioners approved the plan.
The Orange and Osceola meetings marked the apparent, anti-climactic conclusion of one of Central Florida's biggest environmental battles in recent years, one that pitted environmentalists against state road builders and the developers whose land will be served by the project.
The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission approved the highway cut-through in a closely-watched vote almost exactly a year ago, but the Save Split Oak contingent vowed not to give up the fight.
Toll road approved to cut through Split Oak Forest
Nearly two dozen supporters of the forest turned out Tuesday to plead with Orange County to intercede.
They argued that Osceola County's deal with CFX violates the original pact signed in the 1990's by Orange and Osceola counties to buy the 1,689-acre forest, now considered vital habitat for gopher tortoises and other endangered species.
But Orange County Attorney Jeff Newton says the county has no say because CFX will use land only in Osceola.
'This board and the citizens and voters of Orange County could not vote to restrict or regulate any lands in Osceola County,' he explained to a crowd in Orange County Commission chambers. 'They don't have the jurisdiction to do so.'
Orange County owns 1,004 acres of the forest. Osceola owns the other 685.
Orange County Commissioner Kelly Martinez Semrad wanted the county — either through Newton's office or outside counsel — to seek an injunction to stop the project, insisting the entire forest would be harmed by the intrusion across Osceola's segment.
'It's not just about what happens on Osceola's part of the forest,' she said.
Orange County Mayor Jerry Demings said the board has thoroughly vetted the issue through a series of meetings and agreements last year.
'I do believe Orange County has taken appropriate action to protect the portion of Split Oak that Orange County owns,' he said.
In their Monday meeting, Osceola County commissioners approved the agreement with CFX without discussion.
The 11-page document spells out Osceola's duty to release its conservation easement to the road builders.
Only a few people attended the meeting. Two held signs that read 'hands off our nature.'
'I just think this is horrible so I had to come,' said Linda Chastain, who sat in the second row of the commission chambers. 'I heard about this being on Osceola's agenda last minute so I had to rush over here.'
She attended Orange County's meeting, too, occasionally waving a multi-colored sign that read, 'PROTECT NATURE SERIOUSLY…IT'S UP TO YOU!'
But even Semrad — elected last year after promising to continue the fight — could muster little hope by the meeting's end. She listed possible legal issues the county could pursue but added, 'Or is it time for us to just say to the people, 'We've got no shot here. You've lost.' '
shudak@orlandosentinel.com
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
5 days ago
- Yahoo
Help curb boating accidents in Florida, Gov. Desantis. Sign the Lucy Law bill.
On Thanksgiving Day 2019, my life changed forever. A speeding boat struck me while I was snorkeling. My right arm was severed on impact, and I caught a glimpse of it sinking onto the reef below. Both of my legs were severely damaged by the propellers, and my left wrist was badly broken. After miraculously surviving this, one of the first things I said after waking up from my medically-induced coma was, "I can make a bigger difference now than I ever could before this happened." As a marine biologist who worked at Loggerhead Marinelife Center at the time of my accident, I frequently saw the devastating effects of boat strikes on sea turtles, not knowing that I would soon endure the same fate. I often snorkeled off the coast of Palm Beach County, enjoying the beauty of the area's diverse marine life. On that fateful day, I was snorkeling off of the coast when a 36-foot speedboat directly hit me. The driver did not see my divers-down flag, a required safety device that was floating just a few feet away from me. GPS data from the boat recorded their speed at about 45 miles per hour at the time of impact. I firmly believe that my faith was what saved me and that God had given me an opportunity to help others through this incident. When I heard about Lucy's Law, I knew I had to support it. The bill is comprehensive boater safety legislation named in honor of Lucy Fernandez, a Miami teenager who was killed in a tragic boating accident. She was just a few years younger than me at the time of my accident; she deserved to live a long, full, and joyful life. The legislation, which currently awaits the governor's signature, has three main components. It requires the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) to establish standards for online boating safety education courses. It also aligns boating under-the-influence with driving-under-the-influence penalties and creates harsher penalties for operators who leave the scene of an accident. Gov. DeSantis, we're counting on you to help prevent more of these life-changing accidents. I urge you to sign Lucy's Law. This legislation may not change what happened to me, but it can help protect others and potentially save lives. Florida is the boating capital of the world. We have pristine, blue waters filled with marine life, which my career is dedicated to preserving. Every resident and visitor has the opportunity to explore all that our coastal waters have to offer. But with that opportunity comes responsibility. According to the FWC, there were 659 boating accidents in 2023 alone and 59 of those were deadly. Education and training saves lives. Lucy's Law will save lives. Carter Viss founded the Carter Viss Foundation, a boating safety nonprofit based in Jupiter. This article originally appeared on Palm Beach Post: Florida bill could improve boat safety. Desantis must sign. | Opinion
Yahoo
23-05-2025
- Yahoo
Pride lights, and most other colors, no longer allowed on Florida bridges
No matter what the cause or its associated color, lighting a state bridge to recognize it is now against Florida policy — with, of course, a big patriotic exception. In a policy quietly adopted in February and playing out around the state this Memorial Day weekend, the Florida Department of Transportation says lighting on state-managed bridges 'shall be a default scheme of red, white and blue' and 'limited to the recognition, commemoration and or promotion of government holidays.' It effectively makes a standard practice out of the 'Freedom Summer' lighting rule declared by FDOT last year. And it squelches, without express state permission, options such as rainbow colors for LGBTQ+ Pride Month in June, or even orange for National Gun Violence Awareness Month, also in June, or red in September for Sickle Cell Awareness Month. Recent history suggests that special permission for some causes would be tough to get. Last year's freedom summer declaration came about after the state overruled a practice in Tampa of deploying rainbow lighting during Pride Month. For three years the Sunshine Skyway Bridge over Tampa Bay had sported such lighting, but in 2024 a Manatee County Commissioner objected. In prior years, creative bridge lighting had been fairly common in some locales. In 2016 the Central Florida Expressway Authority lit up the Lake Underhill Bridge on State Road 408 in Orlando with rainbow colors after the June 16 mass shooting at the Pulse nightclub. CFX — created by the state in 2014 — said by email that it follows the city of Orlando's specialty lighting schedule. However, the city has no bridges or roads that it lights up in color for special occasions. Orlando does illuminate the Lake Eola fountain, City Hall and public art displays. The city's specialty lighting schedule includes red, white and blue illumination for Memorial Day. Orlando also used specials colors for other occasions such as red on Nurse's Day (May 6) and pink, purple and yellow on Mothers Day (May 12). Tatiana Quiroga, executive director of Come out with Pride Orlando which is behind the city's LGTBQ + parade and the region's biggest celebration, said her organization has never made any special lighting requests of the state. Quiroga said the city uses rainbow lights at the Lake Eola fountain for the Pride celebration. She said Orange County and the city have a long history of supporting Pride. 'We have a great relationship with the city but it speaks volumes that we don't have one with the state,' Quiroga said. 'It illustrates a lack of support from the state for LGBTQ. 'They don't support pride but also what happens to the breast cancer community who want pink lights or showing support for the immigrant community or the Black community?' she asked. The holidays stipulated by the state are New Year's Day, Martin Luther King Jr. Day, Memorial Day, Independence Day, Labor Day, Veterans Day, Thanksgiving Day, the Friday after Thanksgiving and Christmas Day. The state has approved at least one exception to its policy so far: In the city of Sarasota, the community requested aqua blue as the default color on the Ringling Bridge when it isn't lit up in red, white and blue for the holidays observed by the state. With permission, those colors lit up the bridge earlier this month. FDOT said the policy is part of the Salute to America 250 Task Force, a group created by President Donald Trump that's planning a full year of festivities starting Memorial Day and running through July 4, 2026 — when the U.S. celebrates 250 years since the Declaration of Independence was signed. In a post on X, FDOT Secretary Jared Perdue said state bridges and highways will be lit with red, white and blue beginning Friday through 2026 'in commemoration of #America250.' 'Doing so reinforces how lucky we are to live in the Free State of Florida, USA,' Perdue said in the post. The Tampa Bay Times contributed to this report
Miami Herald
23-05-2025
- Miami Herald
Florida bears aren't 'game mammals' to be hunted with dogs
After a crucial vote on Wednesday, the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) is now barreling toward a final decision we feel defies science, disregards public trust and violates the agency's wildlife management plan. Following a three-hour public hearing in Ocala where more than 160 people spoke for and against bringing back Florida's first bear hunt since 2015 — a hunt so widely condemned it was abruptly shut down — the commission voted 4-1 to advance the proposal, called 'Alternative 2.' A final vote will be taken Aug. 13-14. If approved, a 23-day regulated hunting season would take place in December. We ask that at your next commission meeting, please vote to postpone this agenda item until updated science, effective safeguards and meaningful public input are in place. What we are talking about here is not just a policy disagreement. The new proposed rules the commission has drafted directly contradict Florida's Black Bear Management Plan (BBMP), which the agency carefully established as its bear conservation policy in 2019. The BBMP, developed with input from scientists, landowners, law enforcement and the public, lays out a clear conservation blueprint. It sets population goals: maintain at least 3,000 adult bears statewide, ensure at least one subpopulation exceeds 1,000 bears, bring all seven subpopulations above 200 and promote genetic connectivity across regions. Yet the new rules would allow hunts in any of Florida's Bear Management Units with a population estimate over 200 — setting the stage for hunts even if there are just over 1,400 adult bears statewide, that's less than half the BBMP's minimum goal. However, there's no requirement to verify if any bear population estimates are even current. So FWC is still relying on data that is nearly a decade old and the next population study isn't expected to be complete until 2029 or 2030. The contradictions don't stop there. The BBMP calls for meaningful public engagement through Bear Stakeholder and Technical Assistance Groups. Yet, these proposed rules were crafted largely out of public view with no comparable stakeholder process — fundamentally at odds with the agency's stated commitment to transparency and collaboration. The BBMP also supports private landowners as habitat stewards — not trophy hunt operators. But the new 'Private Lands Bear Harvest Program' contained in the new rules allows landowners with 5,000 or more acres to obtain up to three bear hunting permits per year. This is a shift in power — from public stewardship to privatized trophy hunting — unsupported by science or precedent. Even more disturbing is the plan to allow bear hunting with packs of hound dogs. The BBMP discusses dogs only as a deterrent — not as a hunting method. Yet under the proposed new rules, hunters may use packs of up to six hound dogs to chase down bears beginning in 2027. This isn't modern wildlife management — it's barbarism, codified. Symbolically, the proposed rules refer to black bears as 'game mammals' — a bureaucratic move that strips away the history of the Florida Black Bear as a treasured and iconic part of Florida's unique heritage. After years of being managed under special protection, bears are being rebranded as a recreational hunting resource. What's most revealing is what's missing. The proposed rules ignore the real causes of human-bear conflict: sprawl and unsecured garbage. Florida's bears aren't invading subdivisions — subdivisions are invading bear habitat. When food is left in reach — garbage, birdseed, pet food — bears do what any animal would: They take the easy meal. Southeast Florida Commissioners Chair Rodney Barreto, Albert Maury, Steven Hudson and Gary Nicklaus, you are stewards of the public trust. These rules rely on outdated data, ignore your agency's wildlife management plan and fail to address the true causes of conflict. Please vote to postpone this agenda item. Anything less will be remembered not as conservation — but as the moment FWC lost its credibility with the Floridians it serves. James C. Scott is campaign coordinator with Speak Up Wekiva. Chuck O'Neal is president of the organization.
