Cubs' Carson Kelly, Added In Minor Move, Is Having Major Impact
CHICAGO, ILLINOIS - MAY 28: Carson Kelly #15 of the Chicago Cubs looks on before a game against the ... More Colorado Rockies at Wrigley Field on May 28, 2025 in Chicago, Illinois. (Photo by Matt Dirksen/)
Carson Kelly signed with the Cubs last December, only hours after Jed Hoyer had acquired Kyle Tucker from the Astros. Suffice it to say his addition didn't receive a lot of attention at the time.
Here's how the Athletic viewed Kelly, who was signed after the Cubs had seen their other targets, Travis d'Arnaud (Angels) and Danny Jansen (Rays) sign elsewhere:
'Kelly figures to be a co-starter with young catcher Miguel Amaya as the Cubs try to upgrade a position group that was among the worst in the game for parts of last season. Amaya made significant in-season adjustments, though, hitting .271 with a .761 OPS after the All-Star break while continuing to build trust with pitchers. Still, with their catching options dwindling, the Cubs had to make a move.''
Amaya was the Cubs' Opening Day starter but Kelly started the second game in that series against the Dodgers in Tokyo, then had a five-RBI game on March 31, in his third start. He followed that up with a three-run homer in his first start at Wrigley Field and steadily hit his way into the middle of the order.
The cost to add the 30-year-old Kelly was $11.5 million over two seasons, with a $7.5-million mutual option for 2027. That looks like one of the best bargains in last winter's free-agent market, especially with Amaya expected to miss four-six weeks with a strained left oblique.
Amaya, who was having a nice season himself (.280 with four homers, 25 RBI and an .818 OPS in 27 games), injured himself making a throw on May 24. The Cubs promoted veteran Reese McGuire to back up Kelly. McGuire was signed to a minor-league contract in January and was hitting .280 with an .827 OPS at Triple-A Iowa.
Kelly had accrued 5.9 fWAR in his first nine seasons. Fangraphs' calculations have him at 1.5 through 38 games this season. Despite being in a time-share with Amaya for most of the season, he ranks behind only the Dodgers' Will Smith among National League catchers in fWAR.
Look for Kelly to receive strong consideration for next month's All-Star Game. He is batting .268 with nine homers and a .913 OPS through Wednesday and, per Statcast, is doing an average job behind the plate (despite a -1 grade for framing).
Kelly's contract pays him $5 million in 2025 and '26, and includes a $1.5 million buyout for the '27 option. He will add $250,000 if he starts 81 games and another $250,000 for 91 starts.
With bat-first prospect Moises Ballesteros crushing the ball in Triple-A (.333 with six homers and an .886 OPS), the Cubs are positioned to possibly trade a catcher. But they're rightfully focused on the postseason after a 38-23 start, making the surplus most likely an issue for the off-season, not the mid-season trade deadline.
They're in the enviable position of having depth at the catcher's spot. That's a significant edge they picked up without having to spend heavily.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Newsweek
31 minutes ago
- Newsweek
Mavericks Trade Proposal Sees Team Move on From Anthony Davis
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. After a very long year, the Dallas Mavericks are entering the NBA offseason with a ton of momentum. Despite not making the playoffs, the Mavericks did win the 2025 NBA Draft lottery. More NBA news: Thunder Star Shai Gilgeous-Alexander Speaks Out Following NBA Finals Game 1 Collapse Dallas will now have a chance to draft Duke star Cooper Flagg, giving them an expected generational talent for years to come. But with the likelihood of them drafting Flagg, the Mavericks now have a logjam in the frontcourt. But one new trade proposal would help the Mavericks break up the frontcourt by moving on from star big man Anthony Davis. Andy Bailey of Bleacher Report put together trades for all teams and had Dallas land a strong package for the All-Star. Here is what the deal looks like: Hornets receive: Anthony Davis Mavericks receive: Miles Bridges, Jusuf Nurkić, a 2027 first-round pick, a 2029 first-round pick and a 2031 first-round pick MEMPHIS, TENNESSEE - APRIL 18: Anthony Davis #3 of the Dallas Mavericks reacts against the Memphis Grizzlies during the first half of the Play-In Tournament at FedExForum on April 18, 2025 in Memphis, Tennessee. MEMPHIS, TENNESSEE - APRIL 18: Anthony Davis #3 of the Dallas Mavericks reacts against the Memphis Grizzlies during the first half of the Play-In Tournament at FedExForum on April 18, 2025 in Memphis, Tennessee. Photo byTrading away Davis right after the team landed him for star guard Luka Doncic would certainly be an interesting decision. But the team didn't get enough value from the Doncic deal, and this could be a way to help rectify that. This trade would likely be about getting off the large contract of Davis, mostly due to his long injury history. Dallas could net some extra draft capital as well, giving them some ammo for a larger move down the line. Bridges could slot into the rotation as a solid wing player, offering athleticism and shooting. His contract is also team-friendly, with Bridges only making a little more than $20 million in each of the next two seasons. More NBA news: Shaquille O'Neal Shares Harsh Criticism for Thunder After NBA Finals Loss Nurkić could help replace Davis in the frontcourt, while giving the Mavericks a decent expiring contract. Dallas could look to move Nurkić at the trade deadline for more future assets. All in all, a deal like this could help Dallas in the future. But if the team wants to contend for a title next season, keeping Davis around helps in that regard. Davis is one of the better big men in the entire NBA, and the Mavericks targeted him for Doncic for a reason. The Mavericks aren't likely to move Davis anytime soon, unless a deal that the team can't turn down falls into their lap. More NBA news: Former NBA Lottery Pick Joining Rockets in Surprising Role: Report Jon Gruden Makes Shocking Pick in Pacers-Thunder NBA Finals Clippers Seen as Sleeper Team to Land Former NBA MVP: Report For more on Mavericks and general NBA news, head over to Newsweek Sports.
Yahoo
37 minutes ago
- Yahoo
MLB Insider Expects Cubs Might Land One or Two Starters in Coming Weeks
MLB Insider Expects Cubs Might Land One or Two Starters in Coming Weeks originally appeared on Athlon Sports. Rumors about Jed Hoyer's plans for the Chicago Cubs' rotation have been swirling in non-stop fashion, as for who and when, Hoyer hasn't given much indication except that he is scouring the market for starting pitching. However, Chicago MLB insider Bruce Levine thinks he knows when and, more importantly, how many. Advertisement In an appearance on 670 The Score, Levine offered his thoughts and insider knowledge. When talking about the Cubs' starting rotation situation, he had this to say: 'I will say that the Cubs are certainly out there trying to fortify their pitching right now. And over the next two to three weeks, I think they'll put a strong effort into trying to acquire a starting pitcher or two.' Jed Hoyer President of the Chicago Cubs prepares to throw balls to fans before a game against the San Diego Padres at Wrigley Banks-Imagn Images The timeline itself is a bit of a bombshell. With a first-place record, there really isn't any need to rush a trade, but, as the saying goes, the early bird gets the worm. However, the real bombshell here is the quantity. Depending on who they target, the Cubs might have a superb rotation in the next three weeks. As for Levine's reasoning behind his assumptions, he gave this argument: Advertisement 'Yeah, why would you wait for the trade deadline? You have dead teams out there. You have the Marlins, you have the Rockies, you have teams like Arizona that might be going the other way very soon in one of the more difficult divisions in baseball. So, there are teams that are going to want to improve and do it before the deadline if you mention the right players coming back. And the Cubs have good minor league players. That's where they're gonna go. They're not going to wait until the deadline to make a trade. They're going to be proactive and move towards these teams that are not in contention.' The hot stove is always burning as the trade deadline nears, but thanks to Levine, it just got a lot hotter. If Levine is right, we can expect to see a new ball game in Wrigleyville very soon. Related: Cubs Expected to Aggressively Pursue Justin Steele Replacement Before Trade Deadline This story was originally reported by Athlon Sports on Jun 5, 2025, where it first appeared.
Yahoo
38 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Cubs Land Former MVP from Yankees in Trade Idea
Cubs Land Former MVP from Yankees in Trade Idea originally appeared on Athlon Sports. The New York Yankees could soon be facing a roster dilemma—and the Chicago Cubs might be in prime position to capitalize. Advertisement With slugger Giancarlo Stanton nearing a return and top prospect Ben Rice pushing for more playing time, the Yankees may not have room to keep Paul Goldschmidt in the everyday lineup. Goldschmidt, who signed to a one-year deal, has been a standout performer this season, and his value on the trade market may be the highest among first basemen. 'New York will not be able to get Rice, Stanton, and Goldschmidt in the same lineup on a regular basis," wrote Newsweek's Andrew Wright. "The trade of a player on a one-year deal rather than a young, promising player could be the correct move for the Yankees to make." If the Yankees decide to move him, the Cubs are a logical trade partner. The Cubs, currently leading the National League Central, are locked in a tight race with the Milwaukee Brewers and St. Louis Cardinals. While their overall roster has held up well, first base remains a weakness. New York Yankees first base Paul Goldschmidt (48) looks on against the Pittsburgh Pirates at George M. Steinbrenner Klement Neitzel-Imagn Images Michael Busch has seen the bulk of the playing time at the position and is hitting .276 overall. However, his .148 average against left-handed pitching is a glaring issue. In 18 games at first base, Justin Turner has hit .250 against lefties but just .207 overall. Advertisement In Wright's eyes, that inconsistency makes Goldschmidt an ideal fit for the Cubs. Goldschmidt, a seven-time All-Star, four-time Gold Glove winner, and former National League MVP, is thriving in New York. Through 220 at-bats, he is slashing .327 with six home runs and a .859 OPS. More importantly for Chicago, Goldschmidt has been devastating against left-handed pitchers, slashing .520/.613/.900 in 50 at-bats. With Busch struggling against southpaws and Turner offering minimal upside, Wright believes the Cubs would gladly take Goldschmidt's production against left-handers over Turner's. The Cubs are in a win-now window, and the NL Central remains tightly contested. Meanwhile, the Yankees have an incentive to move a productive veteran they may not be able to keep in the lineup long-term. Advertisement Goldschmidt's trade value is surging, and if the Yankees are willing to deal, the Cubs could find their first base solution and a possible difference-maker for a postseason run. Related: MLB Insider Expects Cubs Might Land One or Two Starters in Coming Weeks This story was originally reported by Athlon Sports on Jun 5, 2025, where it first appeared.
