logo
French Government Report Warns of Muslim Brotherhood Threat in France

French Government Report Warns of Muslim Brotherhood Threat in France

Yemen Online21-05-2025

YOL ( Exclusive) – Paris : A French government report warning of the threat posed by the Muslim Brotherhood in France was released on May 21, 2025, after being presented to President Emmanuel Macron during a high-level security meeting. Commissioned in May 2024, the report was prepared by two senior French officials to assess the impact of political Islam and the Muslim Brotherhood on French society.
The report describes the Muslim Brotherhood as a 'threat to national unity,' stating that the group seeks to undermine secular values and republican institutions through a long-term, non-violent strategy. It focuses on the Brotherhood's activities in schools, mosques, and non-governmental organizations, aiming to influence policies related to secularism and gender equality.
In response to the report's findings, President Macron instructed the government to draft proposals to counter the threat, with a Defense Council meeting scheduled for early June to discuss potential measures. While the report will not be fully published, some actions will be publicly announced, while others will remain classified.
Notably, the report draws a direct link between the 'Musulmans de France' (Muslims of France) association and the Muslim Brotherhood—an association that has repeatedly denied any formal ties to the organization. The report has sparked mixed reactions, with some praising it as a necessary move to safeguard republican values, while others warn against stigmatizing the broader Muslim community.
France in the Crosshairs of the Brotherhood: Silent Infiltration and a Challenge to the Republic:
Since its founding in the 1920s, the Muslim Brotherhood has never abandoned its global political ambitions — even while adopting the guise of 'social work' and 'religious outreach' in the West. This is the central finding of the French government report released on May 21, 2025, described as one of the most comprehensive investigations into the Brotherhood's structure, presence in France, and transformation into a long-term religious-political actor pursuing a subtle, patient strategy.
A Closed Circle, Broad Influence:
At the heart of the Brotherhood lies a tight-knit inner circle of ideologically committed elites — the organization's core leadership. Yet, its influence extends far beyond official membership. Thousands of sympathizers, NGOs, schools, and charities across France have absorbed, partially or wholly, the movement's ideological framework.
Academic Divergence… and Intelligence Concern:
The report outlines a divide in academic opinion: one camp views the Brotherhood as an evolving, decentered movement adapting to modern contexts, while another asserts that it remains a structured, hierarchical organization operating behind legal and social façades. The report endorses the latter view, warning of a 'soft infiltration strategy' that leverages victimhood narratives and religious legitimacy to advance its agenda.
Old Agenda, New Vocabulary:
Despite the death of founder Hassan al-Banna, his vision — along with that of ideologue Sayyid Qutb — remains central. Concepts like hakimiyya (divine sovereignty), sharia, and Islamic identity have been repackaged for Western audiences, but their essence remains intact.
Qaradawi and Ramadan: Soft Faces of a Hard Ideology:
• Yusuf al-Qaradawi: Rebranded Brotherhood thinking through 'Islamic centrism' and 'minority rights,' but frequently issued fatwas laced with anti-Western and antisemitic rhetoric.
• Tariq Ramadan: Advocate of a 'European Islam,' he maintained a conservative tone aligned with Brotherhood ideals, particularly on women's rights and interfaith issues.
From Preaching to Power: The French Experience:
France stands as a case study in the Brotherhood's methodical penetration of public space. Through the creation of the Union of Islamic Organizations of France (UOIF) — now known as Musulmans de France — the group expanded into education, civic activism, and local politics, influencing municipal councils and public discourse.
A Subtle Separatism, No Less Dangerous:
The report warns that the Brotherhood's danger does not lie in overt violence, but in a gradual and systematic reshaping of public legitimacy and civic identity. It operates through institutional integration, while ultimately seeking to rewrite the rules of the Republic — especially on secularism.
Legal Dimensions: How Europe Frames the Threat,
The report compares approaches across Europe:
• Belgium defines extremism as any political, religious, or philosophical ideology that contradicts democracy or human rights.
• The UK focuses on ideologies rooted in violence, hatred, or intolerance, even without formal legal codification.
• France legally defines separatism as an attempt to dismantle the national community — but the report stresses that this fails to capture the Brotherhood's subtle and stealthy approach.
Despite a seemingly moderate tone, the Brotherhood shares with Salafi and Tablighi movements several critical risk markers — notably communal isolationism and implicit rejection of republican values.
After the Report: What Should the State Do?
The report urges a two-pronged strategy:
• Firm, localized countermeasures against networks of influence;
• A renewed secular narrative that offers positive alternatives for French Muslims, especially in areas of funding, religious training, and institutional representation.
Conclusion
In this long-term battle, the Brotherhood's threat does not stem from weaponry — but from legitimacy. Its goal is not to destroy the state, but to reshape it from within.
And in that, it may have an edge over its adversaries: it moves slowly, infiltrates silently, and builds patiently over decades.
The question is no longer: Are they a threat?

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Dhamar city holds two cultural events to commemorate day of guardianship
Dhamar city holds two cultural events to commemorate day of guardianship

Saba Yemen

time5 hours ago

  • Saba Yemen

Dhamar city holds two cultural events to commemorate day of guardianship

Dhamar – Saba: The communities of al-Mahal and al-Kamb squares in Dhamar City on Wednesday organized two cultural events to commemorate the Day of Guardianship, under the slogan: "Whoever I am his Master, then this Ali is his Master." Attended by local and executive leaders, the events featured speeches emphasizing the occasion's importance in recalling the Prophet's message and the nation's roadmap. Speakers highlighted the nation's need for guardianship to restore its status and overcome challenges, urging a renewal of allegiance to Allah, His Messenger, Imam Ali, and the beacons of guidance. The speeches touched upon Imam Ali's status, morals, courage, and his role in supporting Islam and confronting Jews and Christians, urging attendees to follow his path and draw lessons from his life. They asserted that national victory and overcoming challenges depend on a sincere return to truth and rejection of tyrannical rule. The speakers also linked the Islamic nation's current "humiliation and subservience" to its failure to implement divine commands. The events underscored Yemen's supportive stance toward Palestinians in Gaza, attributing this leading position in confronting global hegemony to the Yemeni people's return to Allah, His Messenger, Imam Ali, and the "beacons of guidance." Whatsapp Telegram Email Print

Jordan condemns extremist Ben Gvir's al-Aqsa storming as "flagrant violation"
Jordan condemns extremist Ben Gvir's al-Aqsa storming as "flagrant violation"

Saba Yemen

time6 hours ago

  • Saba Yemen

Jordan condemns extremist Ben Gvir's al-Aqsa storming as "flagrant violation"

Amman – Saba: The Jordanian Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Expatriates on Wednesday strongly condemned the storming of al-Aqsa Mosque/al-Haram al-Sharif by Israeli extremist Criminal Minister Itamar Ben Gvir, under police protection. Jordan deemed it a "flagrant violation of international law," an "unacceptable escalation," and a provocation demanding immediate cessation. Ministry spokesperson Ambassador Sufian al-Qudah affirmed Jordan's absolute rejection of extremist Ben Gvir's continued incursions and the Israeli police's facilitation of repeated al-Aqsa breaches, alongside restrictions on Muslim worshippers. He stated this violates the historical and legal status quo and attempts temporal and spatial division, emphasizing that East al-Quds remains an occupied city without Israeli sovereignty. Ambassador al-Qudah warned of the consequences of these illegitimate violations against holy sites in al-Quds, urging Israeli enemy to halt all provocative practices by Ben Gvir, which continue the "dangerous escalation" in the occupied West Bank. He reiterated that the entire 144-dunam al-Aqsa Mosque area is exclusively for Muslim worship, with the Jordanian-affiliated al-Quds Endowments Department holding sole administrative jurisdiction. Whatsapp Telegram Email Print

Al-Mahabisha: 2,200 "Al-Aqsa Flood" graduates stage popular parade
Al-Mahabisha: 2,200 "Al-Aqsa Flood" graduates stage popular parade

Saba Yemen

timea day ago

  • Saba Yemen

Al-Mahabisha: 2,200 "Al-Aqsa Flood" graduates stage popular parade

Hajjah – Saba: The Mobilization Division in al-Mahabisha district in Hajjah governorate on Tuesday organized a popular parade involving 2,200 graduates from "Al-Aqsa Flood" open courses. Led by local and social figures, the participants chanted slogans of loyalty to Allah, the Prophet, and Imam Ali, and disavowal of enemies of Islam. Demonstrating acquired military skills, they affirmed their readiness to join the "promised victory and holy jihad" in support of Gaza's oppressed, defying the "usurping Zionist entity." Participants renewed their mandate to the leader of the revolution, Sayyed Abdulmalik Badr al-Din al-Houthi, to support Palestinian resistance and join the armed forces in the fateful and decisive battle. Whatsapp Telegram Email Print more of (Local)

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store