J&K High Court seeks MHA response on long-term visa status of deported Pakistan woman
The petitioner Rakshanda Rashid, a Pakistani citizen married to an Indian, had lived in Jammu for 38 years on an LTV, which was annually renewed. She had applied for citizenship in 1996 but the request has yet to be processed and at the time of deportation, her LTV application was pending with the Ministry.
Also read: Home Ministry appeals against J&K High Court order to repatriate woman deported to Pakistan
A Division Bench of Chief Justice Arun Palli and Justice Rajnesh Oswal orally asked the Ministry to furnish the reply on July 17, the next date of hearing.
The matter could not be argued on Thursday (July 10, 2025), as Solicitor General of India Tushar Mehta, who was to appear on behalf of the Ministry, was busy in another case in the Supreme Court.
The petitioner's counsel Ankur Sharma said they hoped a solution within the legal framework.
Also read: Bring back woman deported to Pakistan: J&K High Court
'The case could not be argued, but during oral discussion, we conveyed to the court that we want a solution and do not want to take an adversarial position against the government,' said Mr. Sharma.
On June 29, the MHA had appealed against a June 6 order by Justice Rahul Bharti, who directed the Union Home Secretary to bring back the petitioner from Pakistan in 10 days.
The Ministry said the 'judiciary should not override' the executive's decision to deport a foreign national, adding that the High Court order was constitutionally impermissible and unsustainable, as it directed the enforcement of a judicial writ beyond the sovereign territory of India in Pakistan, where she was deported to, and was thus ultra vires. The Ministry also said that the court's direction was 'legally unenforceable and diplomatically untenable'.
Also read | Cause and effect: On human rights, citizenship cases
After the April 22 Pahalgam terror attack in which 26 people were killed, the Ministry cancelled the visas of all Pakistani citizens and asked them to leave the country by April 29. The order exempted those with LTVs or Pakistani women married to Indian citizens. The woman was deported despite the Ministry's guidelines stating that Muslim women who are married to Indian citizens and have applied for LTVs are not required to leave the country.
Ms. Rashid's daughter Fatima Sheikh had told The Hindu earlier that her mother was taken to the Attari border in Punjab by the Jammu and Kashmir Police and expelled from the country on April 28.
She said her mother had applied for an LTV extension in January, yet the leave-India notice served by the police said the application was made on March 8. She said she got emails on April 26 and May 9 from the Foreigners Regional Registration Office (FRRO) that the LTV application was 'under process' and awaiting approval from higher authorities. Ms. Sheikh said her mother had no immediate relatives in Pakistan and was living alone in a hotel with little money.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
&w=3840&q=100)
First Post
22 minutes ago
- First Post
‘India vs Pakistan will not happen': Former CSK cricketer delivers bold verdict on upcoming Asia Cup 2025 match
With the Asia Cup 2025 approaching, a former India cricketer has contributed to the debate regarding the India vs Pakistan game, which is scheduled to take place on September 14, 2025 in Dubai. With the squad announcement nearing, the buzz around the Asia Cup 2025 is steadily intensifying. Focusing on the same, most of the experts are busy dwelling on the likelihood of the selection of players like . However, a former Indian cricketer has paid heed to another prominent aspect related to the tournament and in the process reignited the old burning question, whether India should play Pakistan in the tournament or not? STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD India and Pakistan are clubbed in Group A of the Asia Cup 2025, and hence an encounter has been scheduled to take place on September 14 in Dubai. However, given the tense relationship between the two nations in the aftermath of the Pahalgam terror attack, fans in India are calling for a complete boycott of Pakistan, and hence want the BCCI and the Indian team to pull out of the game against Pakistan. Kedar Jadhav confident Ind vs Pak will not happen Former India player and Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) leader, Kedar Jadhav, holds the same sentiment. According to Jadhav, the match against Pakistan should not proceed, and he confidently stated that it will not happen. Jadhav also commented on Operation Sindoor, the offensive military measure India undertook against Pakistan in response to the Pahalgam terror attack, and declared it a success. 'I think the Indian team should not play at all," Jadhav, who played for CSK in the IPL, told the reporters. 'As far as India is concerned, I think that wherever India plays, it will always win, but this match should not be played at all, and they will not play. I can say this with confidence … Operation Sindoor is a hit, it is successful…'. #WATCH | Pune: On India to face Pakistan in the Asia Cup 2025, Former Indian Cricketer and BJP leader Kedar Jadhav says, "I think the Indian team should not play at all. As far as India is concerned, I think that wherever India plays, it will always win, but this match should not… — ANI (@ANI) August 17, 2025 Jadhav is not the only one who carries this opinion. Earlier, former India bowler Harbhajan Singh had criticised the BCCI for entertaining the idea of playing against Pakistan, let alone approving it. The Asia Cup 2025 is scheduled to start on September 9 and will conclude on September 28.
Hans India
22 minutes ago
- Hans India
Cong should be ashamed of comparing RSS with Taliban
Hubballi: Congress should be ashamed of comparing the RSS with the Taliban. Earlier, the Congress had glorified Tipu Sultan as a hero and now, seeing them join hands with the SDPI for political purposes, it is evident that the Congress has in fact befriended the real Taliban, alleged former Chief Minister and MP Basavaraj Bommai. Speaking to media, he said that on the occasion of the RSS completing 100 years, Prime Minister Narendra Modi delivered a commendable speech at the Red Fort on August 15. The Congress, however, strongly opposed it out of sheer frustration. The Congress has always tried to claim the entire credit for the freedom struggle. But the reality is that many unnamed freedom fighters sacrificed their lives for independence. Farmers, laborers, and people from all sections of society came together and gave up everything for the country's freedom. It is well known that Congress is attempting to take credit for their sacrifices and pose as the sole beneficiaries of the freedom MP said even though Mahatma Gandhi had suggested that the Congress be dissolved after independence, the party continued for its own selfish interests and hunger for power. Over the last seventy-eight years, their governance has pushed the nation backward. Looking at the anti-national statements of Congress leaders today, one wonders if they truly belonged to the party of freedom fighters. The former CM said Congress should indeed be ashamed of comparing the RSS to the Taliban. The same Congress once glorified Tipu as a hero. Now, by allying with SDPI, they have made friends with the real Taliban. The CM',s criticism of the RSS is nothing but an attempt to send a message of loyalty to Rahul Gandhi. After all, he is not a 'core Congressman.' By making such statements, he is trying to prove that he is more loyal than the king himself, which is very clear. 'The RSS is engaged in the noble task of nation-building. Therefore, it is necessary for all of us to work together. I appeal to every Indian to join hands in this mission,' Bommai added.
NDTV
22 minutes ago
- NDTV
"India Like Mercedes": Pak Minister Doubles Down On Asim Munir's "Crude Analogy"
Islamabad: The Shehbaz Sharif government in Pakistan seems to be backing Army Chief Asim Munir's embarrassing admission of Islamabad's current standing vis-à-vis New Delhi. Pakistan's de facto military ruler, during his recent visit to the United States, compared India to a "shining Mercedes" and his own country to a "dump truck". Lauding Munir's leadership during the India-Pakistan military conflict, Pakistan's interior minister, Mohsin Naqvi, said that the Field Marshal used the same analogy to boast about Pakistan's prowess to a Saudi delegation that visited Pakistan in May amid war. "The Field Marshal told them, 'India is like a shining Mercedes, but we are like a dumper truck loaded with stones. Imagine the result if they collide.' The delegation remained silent," he said during a seminar in Lahore. Pakistan confirms Munir's "we are a dumper truck, India a Mercedes" statement "India is a shining Mercedes. We are a dumper truck full of gravel. If we collide, you know the impact on Mercedes. Our field Marshal Munir says", says Pakistan's interior minister Mohsin Naqvi — Sidhant Sibal (@sidhant) August 17, 2025 Contrary to publicly available proof, Naqvi claimed none of the Indian missiles landed on targets at any major military base in Pakistan. India had struck multiple Pakistani air bases during 'Operation Sindoor', damaging runways, hangars, and buildings, causing a massive blow to Pakistan. The evidence of it was visible in high-resolution satellite images released by Maxar Technologies Air Marshal AK Bharti, Director General of Air Operations, during a press briefing, said India hit selected military targets deep inside Pakistan and its response was "measured and calibrated." Munir's Crude Analogy Munir, speaking at a private dinner in Florida last week, used the unusual "crude analogy"-- as he himself called it-- to describe the two neighbours. "I am going to use a crude analogy to explain the situation... India is a shining Mercedes coming on a highway like a Ferrari, but we are a dump truck full of gravel. If the truck hits the car, who will be the loser?" Munir, who was on his second visit to the US in two months, reportedly said. His "analogy" about New Delhi drew peals of laughter on social media for its description of Pakistan, with internet users observing that even in his comparison, Munir made his own country look bad. "The only truth in Munir's statement is that India is the Mercedes, and his country is the dump truck. The rest is delusion," wrote a X user. Another user posted a picture of a missile-laden Mercedes and wrote, "India is a missile-packed beast that is straight-up deadly. It's gonna wreck you." "At least they know their are a dump truck and nothing marshal admitted that they are pathetic," posted a third user.
