Historic trial begins into Google's internet search monopoly
By
Jody Godoy
, Reuters
Photo:
Unsplash
Alphabet's Google needs strong measures imposed on it to prevent it from using its artificial intelligence products to extend its dominance in online search, a US Department of Justice attorney said as a trial in the historic antitrust case began on Monday (US time).
The outcome of the case could fundamentally reshape the internet by unseating Google as the go-to portal for information online.
The Justice Department is seeking an order that would require Google to sell its Chrome browser and take other measures to end what a judge found was its monopoly in online search. Prosecutors have compared the lawsuit to past cases that resulted in the break up of AT&T and Standard Oil.
Now is the "time to tell Google and all other monopolists who are out there listening, and they are listening, that there are consequences when you break the antitrust laws," DOJ attorney David Dahlquist said during his opening statement.
The DOJ and a broad coalition of state attorneys general are pressing for remedies they believe will restore competition even as search evolves to overlap with generative AI products such as ChatGPT.
"This court's remedy should be forward-looking and not ignore what is on the horizon," Dahlquist said.
Google's search monopoly helps improve its AI products, which are also a way to lead users to its search engine, he said.
Google has agreed to pay Samsung monthly to install Google's Gemini AI app on devices such as smartphones, a deal that can be extended into 2028, according to documents shown at trial. The financial terms were not disclosed, but Dahlquist characterized the monthly amount as an "enormous sum."
US District Judge Amit Mehta previously ruled that Google's exclusive agreements with device makers to be the default search engine helped maintain its monopoly.
Nick Turley, OpenAI's product head for rival AI app ChatGPT, was expected to take the stand on Tuesday.
Google's lawyer, John Schmidtlein, said in his opening statement that the DOJ's proposals amount to "a wishlist for competitors looking to get the benefits of Google's extraordinary innovations."
AI competitors "would like handouts as well even though they are competing just fine," he said.
Google argues that its AI products are outside the scope of the case, which focused on search engines. Adopting the proposed remedies "would hold back American innovation at a critical juncture," Google executive Lee-Anne Mulholland said in a blog post on Sunday.
The company has said it will appeal once a final judgment is entered.
Antitrust enforcers have proposed far-reaching measures designed to quickly open the search market and give new competitors a leg up.
Their proposals include ending Google's exclusive agreements with tablet and smartphone makers like Apple to make Google the default search engine on their devices.
Google would also have to license search results to competitors, among other requirements. The DOJ has proposed that, if other remedies fail to restore competition, Google would be forced to sell its Android mobile operating system.
Google said the court should stick to making its default agreements non-exclusive.
Ending Google's payments to device makers and browser developers would raise the cost of smartphones and jeopardize the existence of companies like Mozilla, which rely on the revenue to operate, Google claims.
Google plans to call witnesses from Mozilla, Verizon and Apple, which launched a failed bid to intervene in the case.
The case is part of an antitrust crackdown on Big Tech started during the first Trump administration that shows no signs of slowing, despite overtures tech companies and their executives have made to the White House.
Assistant Attorney General Gail Slater and other DOJ antitrust officials were in the courtroom to show that the case, started under Trump and carried forward under former President Joe Biden, proposes "nonpartisan" remedies and has "the full support of the DOJ both past and present," Dahlquist said.
Slater celebrated a win in another antitrust case against Google on Thursday over advertising technology. The case was filed during Biden's term.
Meta Platforms is facing its own antitrust trial over the acquisitions of Instagram and WhatsApp.
- Reuters
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Techday NZ
29 minutes ago
- Techday NZ
How Norby the language robot is more than just a compaion
Norby, an AI-powered language companion, highlights the exciting evolution of language learning through interactive and adaptive technology. Adrian Mullan, Founder and CEO of Norby, led the demonstration at Dell Technologies World in Las Vegas, highlighting the robot's ability to engage in natural conversations across multiple languages and contexts. Norby supports more than 30 languages, with new additions and updates rolled out through over-the-air software updates. Mullan said his motivation for developing Norby was rooted in his own experiences. "A few years ago, while helping my daughter with her homework, I noticed something troubling - she was bored and struggling to stay focused. Conventional learning materials simply couldn't hold her attention. That realization sparked the idea for Norby," he explained. Norby is designed to be more than just another digital assistant or educational tool. "Humans have an innate desire to connect, even with the things we create. We give objects human-like traits, attribute emotions to our pets, and name our digital assistants - it's part of who we are," Mullan said. "I didn't want another device that demanded my attention. I wanted a companion - something that helps me stay focused, in flow, and truly engaged. A companion that adapts to my personality, interests, and goals." During the demonstration, Mullan illustrated Norby's capabilities by asking it to greet the audience in various languages and accents, as well as to generate stories on demand. "Hey, Norby, can you do me a favour? Can you say hello to the journalists in the room?" Mullan asked. Norby responded with, "Hello everyone. I'd be happy to extend a greeting to the journalists present. I'm sure, Adrian, you'd like me to make a good impression, so I'll make sure to be as charismatic as possible on various projects, including sound checks and helping with your work on interactive voice companions." The device's multilingual proficiency is underpinned by a flexible architecture that allows Norby to select the best available models for different languages. Mullan explained, "We plug into a bunch of different providers for the speech recognition as well as the large language model inference, and effectively what we do is we built an architecture where we can send the responses to the best model at the time." "So an example would be OpenAI, Google, Anthropic, all the big US providers will be great when it comes to English, Latin based languages and so on, but they'll tend to struggle with Asian character sets, so Chinese, Japanese, Korean and so on. In that case, we can spin it off to the DeepSeek, or to Qwen , or whoever, the best provider is," he said. The hardware is intentionally designed to be approachable and engaging, resembling a character rather than a device, and is equipped with high-performance processing, a full-colour HD touchscreen, high-quality speakers, and expressive RGB LED lighting. Norby's software supports a variety of large language models and is continually enhanced through regular updates. Norby's applications go beyond language learning. "Our problem at the moment is we have more requests from people than we can sort of deal with. I would say language and speech therapy is a really big one on the consumer side. The next area that we're moving into is much more the agentic productivity side," Mullan said. He described using Norby at home to manage daily tasks: "My Norby unit at home actually does things. I checks my email. It'll summarise my emails. I can ask Norby, okay, what's important for the day. And then what it'll do is, it's connected to my inbox, but also to my LinkedIn, to my social feeds, to my calendar. It'll take all of that stuff, create a summarisation." Addressing the broader technology landscape, Mullan compared Norby's form factor with other AI devices. "If you have something that's like projecting onto your hand, like, what happens when you walk out in daylight, right? So I think that's in their case, a big problem." "In the case of rabbit, I think they're doing some interesting stuff. Again, though my issue is, is that I think the moment you make a device that's very similar to a phoney form factor, you're effectively competing with the phone. And then in order to be able to move forward, what happens is, your expectation is that people have to carry this device and also carry the phone." "So we've made a deliberate decision not to do that. We've gone after a form factor that's a bit more anthropomorphised," he explained. Norby's adaptability is reflected in its ability to switch between personalities and modes depending on user needs. Parents, for example, can select predefined personas for their children, and the robot adapts its lessons to maintain engagement. "As the kids interact with Norby, it will course correct. So an example would be, okay, any kid that's learning a language, one of the challenges is engagement, right? Because they find it hard and boring. If it knows that, okay, there's an eight year old boy named Billy who's really into Roblox and Spider Man, it will then start to recreate those lessons in that context," Mullan said. Discussing privacy and security, Mullan stressed, "We take privacy and security seriously. Norby has been designed to be COPPA compliant. Our closed-system architecture means no access to third-party app stores or social media." Looking ahead, Mullan outlined the expansion of Norby's functionality, including the introduction of features such as singing, laughing, and emotional intelligence analysis. "There's a version that we're working on now that will sing, laugh, cry, whisper, yeah. I've had a chance to interact with that one. It's not production-ready yet, but it will happen," he said. "We're thrilled to be at this stage, and we're excited about the potential for Norby to make a difference in people's lives."
Techday NZ
29 minutes ago
- Techday NZ
Skymel launches ARIA to unite major AI models in one platform
Skymel has launched ARIA, an artificial intelligence assistant that coordinates multiple major AI models to provide unified responses to user queries. ARIA combines the capabilities of well-known AI models such as ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and Perplexity into a single platform, allowing users to receive answers that draw on the collective strengths of these systems without the need to operate each model separately. The service aims to address challenges that users encounter when attempting to source comprehensive answers from different AI models, including the need to create complex prompts, switch between services, or handle multiple subscriptions. Neetu Pathak, Chief Executive Officer and Co-Founder of Skymel, said, "ARIA is a fundamentally different kind of AI assistant. For too long, people have had to jump between ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and others, often feeding the output of one model into another, just to get a complete answer. With ARIA, you simply ask your question or upload your file, and our system instantly orchestrates a custom workflow across every leading AI model, delivering a unified, accurate result. No technical expertise is required and there is no more guesswork. It's just the best of AI, every time." At the core of ARIA is an orchestration engine that analyses the user's query, selects the most suitable AI models for each aspect of the task, and processes a sequence of outputs across different models in real time. The final result is a single response, synthesised from the work of each model involved. Key features include automatic model selection—where ARIA divides tasks and assigns individual steps to the model best aligned with that requirement. The platform then manages the process in sequence, validating and refining outputs in pursuit of more accurate results. ARIA also learns continually from user interactions to optimise its model selection and workflow logic over time. Users interact with a streamlined interface, receiving comprehensive answers without needing to know which AI models are at work behind the scenes. The service is being offered for a flat monthly rate, intended to remove the need for multiple logins or hidden costs often associated with access to several AI platforms. Expanding on Skymel's vision for AI accessibility, Pathak said, "AI should work for you, not the other way around. With ARIA, we're making advanced AI accessible to everyone, with no prompt engineering, no technical barriers, just effortless intelligence that adapts to your needs. This is the future of AI assistance." Skymel has opened a private beta for early adopters who wish to take part in shaping the assistant's ongoing development. In addition, the company plans to launch its Orchestrator Agent SDK and API, providing developers with tools to integrate ARIA's adaptive AI pipeline capabilities into their own applications.
1News
an hour ago
- 1News
Musk slams Trump's 'big, beautiful' bill as 'a disgusting abomination'
Elon Musk blasted President Donald Trump's "big, beautiful bill" of tax breaks and spending cuts as a "disgusting abomination," testing the limits of his political influence as he targeted the centerpiece of Republicans' legislative agenda. The broadside, which Musk issued on his social media platform X, came just days after the president gave him a celebratory Oval Office farewell that marked the end of his work for the administration, where he spearheaded the Department of Government Efficiency. "I'm sorry, but I just can't stand it anymore," Musk posted on X. "This massive, outrageous, pork-filled Congressional spending bill is a disgusting abomination. Shame on those who voted for it: you know you did wrong. You know it." The legislation, which has passed the House and is currently under debate in the Senate, would curtail subsidies that benefit Tesla, Musk's electric automaker. The tech billionaire followed his criticism with a threat aimed at Republicans. ADVERTISEMENT "In November next year, we fire all politicians who betrayed the American people," he wrote in another X post. It's a sharp shift for Musk, the world's richest person who spent at least US$250 million (NZ$416 million) supporting Trump's campaign last year. He previously pledged to help defeat Republican lawmakers deemed insufficiently loyal to Trump, but now he's suggesting voting them out if they advance the president's legislative priority. Winter's here, supermarket spying, and TikTok's new feature. (Source: 1News) However, it's unclear how Musk will follow through on his criticism. He recently said that he would spend "a lot less" on political campaigns, though he left the door open to political involvement "if I see a reason". The tech titan's missives could cause headaches for Republicans on Capitol Hill, who face conflicting demands from Trump and their party's wealthiest benefactor. Alex Conant, a Republican strategist, said "it's not helpful" to have Musk criticising the legislation, but he doesn't expect lawmakers to side with Musk over Trump. "Senate Republicans are not going to let the tax cuts expire," Conant said. "It just makes leadership's job that much harder to wrangle the holdouts." ADVERTISEMENT Trump can change the outcome in Republican primaries with his endorsements; Musk doesn't wield that level of influence, Conant said. "No matter what Elon Musk or anybody else says — and I don't want to diminish him because I don't think that's fair — it's still going to be second fiddle to President Trump," said Republican West Virginia Senator Shelley Moore Capito. Musk's business interests stand to take a hit if lawmakers approve Trump's bill, which would slash funding for electric vehicles and related technologies. Musk is the chief executive of Tesla, the nation's largest electric vehicle manufacturer, and SpaceX, which has massive defence contracts. Last month, Musk said he was "disappointed" by the spending bill, a much milder criticism than the broadside he leveled on Tuesday (local time). The budget package seeks to extend tax cuts approved in 2017, during Trump's first term at the White House, and add new ones he campaigned on. It also includes a massive build-up of US$350 billion (NZ$583 billion) for border security, deportations and national security. To defray some of the lost tax revenue to the government and limit piling onto the nation's US$36 trillion (NZ$60 trillion) debt load, Republicans want to reduce federal spending by imposing work requirements for some Americans who rely on government safety net services. Senate Majority Leader John Thune, R-S.D., strides from the chamber after speaking about the reconciliation process. (Source: Associated Press) ADVERTISEMENT Musk's post threw another hurdle in front of Senate Majority Leader John Thune's already complex task to pass a bill in time for Trump to achieve his goal of signing it by July 4. The South Dakota Republican has few votes to spare in the GOP's slim 53-seat majority. Two of the Senate's most fiscally hawkish Republicans quickly backed Musk. "We can and must do better," Kentucky Senator Rand Paul wrote on X. Utah Senator Mike Lee said, "federal spending has become excessive," adding that it causes inflation and "weaponises government". Still, Trump enjoys fierce loyalty among the GOP base, and in the end, his opinion may be the only one that matters. White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt played down Musk's criticism. "The president already knows where Elon Musk stood on this bill," Leavitt said, and Musk's post "doesn't change the president's opinion". The tension in the GOP delighted Democrats, who found themselves in the unlikely position of siding with Musk. Democrats are waging an all-out political assault on GOP proposals to cut Medicaid, food stamps and green energy investments to help pay for more than US$4.5 trillion (NZ$7.5 trillion) in tax cuts — with many lawmakers being hammered at boisterous town halls back home. ADVERTISEMENT House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries, D-N.Y., tells reporters he agrees with Elon Musk's criticism of President Donald Trump's spending and tax bill. (Source: Associated Press) "We're in complete agreement," House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries said of Musk. The New York Democratic lawmaker stood alongside a poster-sized printout of Musk's post during a Capitol news conference. The last time Musk weighed in significantly on legislation, the scenario was far different. His power was ascendant after the election, with Trump joining him for a rocket test in Texas and appointing him to spearhead the Department of Government Efficiency. During the transition period, Musk started whipping up opposition to legislation that would prevent a government shutdown, posting about it repeatedly on X, his social media platform. Trump soon weighed in, encouraging Republicans to back out of a bipartisan deal. Lawmakers eventually patched together a new agreement.
